Torah · MussarMussar130. Changing a Person’s EssenceTzidkat HaTzadikPart 130Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 25, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0017:34Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf0:04lamed. In this piece, it's again one of those deep pieces, and I hope with the time we're able to explain it properly.0:11New concept, a very, very deep concept,0:14really, really nice concept. It says like this:0:19Af al pi shebechirah netunah la'adam. Even though one of the fundamentals of Judaism is that a person has freedom of choice,0:23as the Rambam brings down, those people that claim that a person doesn't have freedom of choice,0:29there's no point of anybody doing any mitzvot, or doing any0:33aveirot, because why should I get punished for an aveirah? It's not my choice. Hashem made me choose it.0:36Why should I get rewarded for a mitzvah?0:39I didn't do anything. Hashem made me do it,0:41right? And that's why he explains: you're not born as a rasha and a tzadik, and the midrashim0:45that speak about when a person is about to be created,0:49Hashem says how he's going to be: tall, small, short, rich, poor, popular, not so popular.0:55All those things are decided in Shamayim.0:58But tzadik and rasha, it's not decided,1:00because otherwise the whole Torah goes down the drain.1:03Why should a person get rewarded or get punished?1:06Now. We're going to touch upon that point.1:09It's a very, very sensitive subject,1:11as the Rambam dedicated a few times in his main,1:15main halachot, whether it's Hilchot Teshuvah, where he dedicates a lot about, you know, talks about this.1:20He talks about1:21in Shemoneh Perakim. It's a fundamental thing for people to say,1:24I have no choice.1:25Don't blame me. That's the way I am, man.1:28So it's not that way.1:30But now we're touching this very, very sensitive subject,1:33and we hope, b'ezrat Hashem, we're able to give it over in the intention that Rav Tzadok wanted to say,1:39because, again, it can be very sensitive.1:42If you feel that there's a question, please don't hesitate to contact me and let me know.1:47Okay, let's begin.1:48It says, although a person's, the choice to choose good or bad is not l'adam; it's given in a person's hand.1:58In makom makom, ein adam yachol l'hishtanot mishorso shebara. But to change your root and your source, you can't change that.2:03Like Chazal tell us in Masechet Sanhedrin,2:09Af al pi shechata, Yisrael hu. Chazal tell us that, talks about over there,2:13people who are חייב מיתה, the worst punishment in Judaism.2:16And not only that, to the point that Chazal tell us that a beit din that kills anybody,2:21it's very rare, once in seven years,2:23according to other opinions, once in seven years a person is חייב מיתה, right,2:28that's what the perek is dealing with.2:30And still it says,2:31חטא ישראל. You know, Hashem tells Yehoshua, Jewish people have sinned.2:35What do you mean?2:35They're2:36Yisrael. How can you say2:37חטא? If they sinned, they don't belong part of us.2:39And the Gemara points out, even when a Jew sins, he still retains his name Shem Yisrael.2:46So even the biggest rasha, he's still basically, he's not changing who his root is,2:52where his source comes from.2:56Bishum dehu mishorshav vigza kedisha, because the Yisrael in this specific example, he's from a root and a source of holiness.3:03V'chen amru, and Chazal tell us,3:07tov alav habisha. A good cannot become bad.3:10Something that's in its root, you know, just covered up as bad for a moment,3:14but it cannot turn itself to something bad,3:18im lo beramei karoha, unless we find sometimes that people at the source are really evil.3:26V'chen amru, tinah haita blibam, as Chazal tell us, about certain people that went off the3:30derech because deep down they had this tina, they had this hate, they had this thing against religion.3:40V'chen lehefech, bisha lo hava taba. Likewise, we find that bisha lo hava taba, bad also cannot be good,3:46right? There will not be something that's bad at the source, that's rotten at the source,3:50that's just a3:58cover-up. Now, we don't find this in Chazal anywhere telling us this.4:02Seems like a person can always turn himself from good to bad and bad to good,4:07but he's telling you deep in the source4:09they don't. The Gemara doesn't say it like that.4:12It says true, Chazal didn't want to reveal to us, but they alluded to it,4:16and they put it only in secret for those who really understand.4:24V'azei amru, botzina mkatfei yadua, and you can see this in their words that they hinted,4:28although there it seems to be a regular agricultural facts,4:32that the botzina referring to, like, I guess you could say, like a gourd or a pumpkin,4:39you could see from when you pick it from its source, you could see if it's good or not.4:43And here he's saying like the same thing also.4:46A person, based on his shoresh and his ikar, that's how you could see if it's good or not.4:52Now, the thing is, rak hashoresh hazeh neelam mikol haberuim. Nobody, nobody could figure this out.4:58Nobody could figure out what's their shoresh, what's their source.5:02And you might be thinking the source is based on his parents. Absolutely not.5:06The source is not based on the person's parents,5:08but the source is based on that person's neshama, that person's5:12soul, as we'll see soon, that it's something that really deep down, really also,5:17it's something that a person can affect.5:19Zeh besod... okay,5:23ki liba lefuma. Lo galya. Again, a remez in the words of5:26Chazal: the heart does not reveal to the mouth.5:28It means that nobody really knows the true source of what his neshama.5:33I'll give you an example.5:36Mekubalim say that we're all gilgulim.5:37Does anybody here know which gilgul they came from?5:41If you do, I would like to get classes from you.5:44I'm not saying anything.5:45You know, I'm sure that there are holy people that may be able to tell a little bit what they have to fix.5:50Can anybody really say, I came from this gilgul?5:53Absolutely not.5:54We don't know.5:55Ah, but that's my source.5:56That's where I really came from.5:58Imagine we were to discover we're some famous figure in history, in6:02Tanach. Wow.6:03So, but none of us will know that.6:05None of us will know that,6:07right?6:07So,6:12v'lakach matzinu gam ken chot'im she'amru al she'ein lahem chelek l'olam haba. It says that's why we could find,6:14even though we said earlier Chazal tell us,6:19afilu shechata Yisrael hu, yet we find that people could do a6:21chet, people could sin, and they have no6:24chelek l'olam haba. I don't understand.6:25The Mishnah says clearly,6:28Kol Yisrael yesh lahem chelek l'olam haba. Every Jewish person has a6:30chelek l'olam haba. How could it be that there are certain people that lose their6:34chelek l'olam haba? And the same Mishnah, by the way, that says6:38Kol Yisrael yesh lahem chelek l'olam haba, there mentions the fact that there are exceptions.6:46There are apikorsim, and there are kofrim baTorah, kofer b'tchiyat hameitim, and then it lists certain people, shlosha melachim v'arba hedyotot, ein lahem chelek l'olam haba. There are three kings and four regular people that don't have a6:54chelek l'olam haba. How could that be?6:58I told you, I said everybody is considered Yisrael, and if you're a Yisrael, you automatically7:00qualify. And it says no, because a person's source could be something different.7:03Now what does it mean,7:06ein lo chelek l'olam haba? It explains,7:10v'lo chelek l'olam haba hainu sheha'ikar chasimat hasefer shehu shorash. It means that the root has become evil.7:14Says now you can understand,7:14there's a discussion in the Gemara.7:15He puts this in brackets.7:17He just puts it on the side.7:18There's a discussion in the Gemara about Menashe.7:21He's listed in the Mishnah as7:23ein lo chelek l'olam haba. Just to give you a little background of who Menashe was.7:25Menashe was the son of7:28Chizkiyahu Melech, who happened to have ruled for the longest than any other king.7:32He ruled for 55 years.7:34In these 55 years, for 22 years he did evil,7:38and 33 years he was7:42chozer b'tshuva. So the majority of his life, you could say he was7:44chozer b'tshuva. Now the way he was chozer b'tshuva was a very interesting way.7:47In any case, it's a surprising thing, and it's a puzzling thing, really,7:51that the Mishnah lists Menashe as one of the people that7:54ein lo chelek l'olam haba, and we know he did terrible sins.7:56The Gemara details some of the sins that—8:00Meaning to say that one of them is he executed his own grandfather,8:04Yoshayahu HaNavi. So we know he did terrible things. But one second, he also did teshuva. If he did8:10teshuva, and his father, by the way, was Chizkiyahu HaMelech, one of the greatest tzaddikim that we've had in history, and8:17what's going on over here?8:22How can it be ein lo chelek l'Olam Haba? He did teshuva. So that's why he says, explains, because his teshuva didn't help him.8:26Why? Because the ikar, the source of him, was really rasha, was really evil.8:32Ah, but one second, the Gemara says, no, you can't say that, because if you say that,8:36then you're gonna, you know, people who are baalei teshuva are gonna be disappointed. You're gonna8:42end up harming the people who could be baalei teshuva. But Rav Tzadok points out, the Gemara says8:49if you say that, only you're gonna make people who are baalei teshuva disappointed. They're gonna say,8:53Oh my gosh, what's my teshuva? You're gonna give them ye'ush. They're not gonna be8:58encouraged to do teshuva. But otherwise, it sounds like really the Gemara doesn't disagree9:03that ein lo chelek l'Olam Haba; he is listed at the end of the day as one of the people that9:09ein להם חלק לעולם הבא. So he explains the reason for this is exactly what he's saying9:15over here: ונעשה על ידי פעולתו בחירתו לרע. It's because of his actions and his choice to become evil. He could turn himself.9:23וכן להפך על ידי תשובה מעשיו טובים יכול להתקרב. So too, a person who is deep down inherently evil could choose to change himself and to make himself9:31closer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, even if he's not Jewish. Even if he's not Jewish and evil, he could turn himself around.9:38Where do we see this from? חזל tells us,9:41אפילו עכו״ם ועוסק בתורה הרי הוא ככהן גדול. The Gemara says on the pasuk, יקרה היא מפנינים, the Torah is more precious than peninim, simple meaning than the jewels. And the Gemara explains9:53peninim could also mean the word inside, penim. Kohen Gadol goes on the deepest part10:00of the Beit HaMikdash, and the Kodesh Kodashim, that no Jew is allowed to enter. Kohen Gadol has10:06permission to enter there once a year, not one time a year, on Yom Kippur, one day a year. He enters there five times.10:13No Jew has permission to enter there, right? And yet the Kohen Gadol goes and enters there.10:18And how special is the Kohen Gadol? Yet,10:22yekarah hi mipeninim. A person, a goy who learns Torah, the Torah is more precious than even the Kohen Gadol goes10:27inside, because if the Kohen is an am haaretz and a goy learns Torah, he's like the Kohen Gadol. Not10:33as am haaretz, obviously, but he can be at such a high level. V'chol haTorah maleim zeh. You find full of this. So you see that10:39even a goy whose root is really evil can actually turn himself into something very good.10:46It's his choice. V'chol haTorah maleim zeh. And we know that the word10:53beri'ah hu yesh me'ayin. There is such a thing. That means although a person is really, in his root, is evil or good,11:00and the change may be only external, but there's a way that a person can turn the roots11:06into something bad, and that's the concept of beri'ah. Beri'ah, we find different11:12languages or expressions when it comes to making something. There's asiyah, there's11:20yetzirah. All these different expressions mean that you're taking something and working with it and just11:25making it into something, you know, of a different form. Not so when it comes to beri'ah. Beri'ah is also11:30making something, but it's a creation, which means you take something from nothing. You make something11:34from nothing. That's beri'ah, good? So that's the same over here in the pasuk: Le tahor bera li Elokim, David HaMelech prays for. Create for me, even though11:47I don't have it, create, change it completely. And therefore there's such an option for a person to11:51do, but it can be done either way. It can be done from bad to good.11:56That's liftahor. He could create literally a new pure heart, and la'ani, a person can do it the12:01other way. He could take what's already tahor, like we find by Menashe, make it into bad.12:10And he says that being that it's in the person's hand, that's why you could pray and you could12:18beg Hashem to help you in what we call the teshuvah process. But again, it's a teshuvah12:24where a person goes deep inside and changes that root inside. But as long as he doesn't12:29change that root on the inside, it then doesn't change, and goes again12:35both ways. Sometimes a person's root is really good, just the outside, like the case of12:42Chata Yisrael. He now brings a midrash that he brings it in just like, you know, like12:49he alludes—not alludes to—he writes only a few words on the midrash, but he doesn't tell us the full midrash. I would like to read you12:53the full midrash. The midrash is found in Yalkut Shimoni, in Sefer12:58Yechezkel, ot shinun hei. It says13:01that nefesh hachote'et, titamud. Hashem tells—I mean, the navi Yechezkel says in the name of Hashem to the people, You know, your ways are all twisted. I don't13:11know what you guys are saying. At times, Yechezkel and the people were saying, Oh, what are you talking about? There is people that will not die because they're—you know, basically how people say till13:17today, they say that if you have connections, you'll be okay. So he comes and criticizes them. He says,13:22Are you kidding me? You think that a person who is a tzaddik and that said he's a tzaddik for the13:28rest of his life? No way. He's a tzaddik, but if he becomes a rasha, he'll die13:34for his sins. He writes over here on the midrash from Eichah Rabbati, it says,13:41Sha'alu lachochmah, choteh mahu עונשו? They asked the wisdom. What would be the punishment for a sinner?13:47Amar lahem, so the Chachma replied,13:51Hata'im tedofra'a. The sinners will be chased by evil.13:55Sha'alu nevuah, what's the punishment? They asked the prophecy, what is the punishment for a person who is a14:01sinner? Amra lahem, the nevuah told them,14:09Hanefesh hachotet, hi tamut. It's the person that sins will die.14:14Sha'alu Torah, what's the punishment? They asked the Torah, what is the punishment for a sinner?14:18Amar lahem, yavi'u asham v'yitkaper lo. Let him bring a korban and he gets14:23kaparah. Sha'alu HaKadosh Baruch Hu, what's the punishment? They asked Hashem, what's the punishment of a sinner?14:31Amar lahem, ya'aseh teshuvah, Hashem says to us, let him do teshuvah, yitkaper lo, and he will get kaparah without anything else. That's the Midrash concludes by saying, that's the meaning of14:40Tov v'yashar Hashem, al ken yoreh chata'im baderech. Hashem is good and He is straight, and that's why He guides the sinners on the right path.14:46This is the Midrash. Comes the Tzadok and explains,14:55right, Metzad kulam bisha lo hava taba, right? Everybody seems to agree that if you're really evil in the source,14:59you cannot become good.15:02This is what the people were telling actually Hezekiah by saying, look, when the person,15:07you know, in the source he could be, he's something, you know,15:16the pasuk says, Beshuv tzaddik mitzidkato, v'asa avel umet alehem, b'avlo asher asa yamut. When a person does, when the guy who used to be a rasha—excuse me,15:22reading again—Beshuv tzaddik mitzidkato, when a person used to be a tzaddik,15:26and then he ends up, you know, going off the derech and he does evil,15:34b'avlo asher asa yamut, because of his wickedness he shall die. What are the people telling Hezekiah? That he had to answer this.15:40The people, if you look at the pesukim beforehand, the people were claiming to15:44Hezekiah, No, forget about the tzaddik, he does aveirot. Okay, no, he'll be okay. He did already15:50his teshuvah, kind of like, you know, he checked in already. He's okay. Says Hezekiah, No way, not at all. When a person is evil, that's, he's gonna, I mean, when a person...16:32So it's a tzaddik and he does evil, he's going to get punished for it. Now, they were claiming otherwise. He says over here, why in the world is the pasuk relating to us what these people are saying? It sounds ridiculous. The guy was a tzaddik. He ended up going over to the derech and doing aveirot. No, nothing's going to happen to him. Certainly, the pasuk is not going to mention the opinion of fools. If the pasuk is mentioning the opinion of these people, they were not foolish people. They were not talking about what we think, a regular guy. They're talking about in the root.16:37In the root of a person, if he's really a me'ikaro tov, it can't be that he'll get punished,16:44that he'll die from it. And they understood, and they thought that they really understood this concept that we're talking about,16:50that it's all based on what a person is at the root.16:52That's why he tells them, no, your ways are twisted.17:00It's only when a person does teshuvah and Hashem accepts him, only when Hashem accepts him, then we could come back retroactively and understand and see what his real source is.17:13So again, it's a very deep concept what the Tzaddok is saying over17:16here, that a guy is based on who he is in the ikar, that cannot change. But that cannot change on a regular basis.17:23But a person who could go to extremes and do crazy things on a regular basis, that could actually change his17:31ikar from good to bad or from bad to good.