Torah · MussarMussar128. The Need for כפרה for All Types of TeshuvahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 128Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:31Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:07Tzedkat HaTzadik, ot kuf chaf chet. Ki sheha'adam oseh aveirah k'inyan et la'asot laShem. So let's explain this concept first0:09before we come to the0:11Rav Tzadok. There's something called et la'asot laShem. The Gemara talks in0:15Masechet Berachot about Torah0:17sheba'al peh. Torah sheba'al peh is, as it's called, it's supposed to be ba'al peh.0:20It's supposed to be oral. It's not supposed to be written down.0:23Yet today we have Mishnayot and we have Gemara.0:26The person who decided to put the Torah sheba'al peh in writing0:31was Rabbeinu HaKadosh,0:34Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi.0:36But really, the Gemara explains0:38it's asur min haTorah to write Torah sheba'al peh down.0:42But he saw that there was a time0:44that, or he foresaw, that Torah sheba'al peh would have been forgotten,0:48based on whatever the Gemara explains over there.0:50So he says, based on the pasuk,0:52the pasuk says,0:56Et la'asot laShem, heferu Toratecha. When we see that the Torah0:59is going to be,1:04chas v'shalom, forgotten, or something is going to end up actually causing1:07harm to the Torah, so then1:11et la'asot laShem, you're allowed to1:13kind of break the Torah to save the Torah.1:16That's, in a way, we could say it and summarize it in short.1:19This is known as1:22et la'asot laShem. It's a sin, but a sin to save the1:25Torah, because otherwise it would have been a greater sin.1:28So we are not one to make such decisions.1:31It was the fact that Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, he can make such a1:34decision. In any case, he says over here,1:36if a person does an aveirah of that category,1:38where he feels he has to do the sin because just to save him from a bigger sin,1:42he says,1:45... he kaparah la'aveirah. And even though you prevented yourself from a much bigger sin,1:49still you need kaparah for1:51that aveirah she'asa. Like we find, here's a proof.1:53We find in the Gemara, the Gemara talks about1:55if a person has a real dream that scares him,2:01that he needs to fast on.2:03And there's halachot of when to fast for a dream and when not to2:06fast. And there's halachot on those halachot, meaning to say,2:09a person shouldn't just say, Oh, I saw this, brought down halachah. There's a2:15lot of commentaries. Make sure you ask a competent rav. In any case, that there are cases where a person is supposed to fast for a certain dream.2:19What about if a person has that dream on Friday night?2:23The halachah says that the2:25ta'anit, the fast a person has to do for a dream, has to be immediately2:28that next morning. That's the way2:30the ta'anit has the effect to cancel out2:34the dream. What if that dream2:37was on Friday night, and now a person2:40is confronted with fasting on Shabbat?2:42Fasting on Shabbat is asur. So what do you do?2:45So the halachah is that a person can be2:48mit'aneh. A person could do ta'anit chalom on Shabbat.2:51However,2:54v'tzarich lemita'ev ta'anitah leta'anitah. A person has to fast another day of the week2:58to be mechaper for the fasting3:00that he did on Shabbat. So you see, you're allowed to fast on Shabbat3:03for ta'anit chalom, but you need to also3:06fast for that. What do you mean? I thought I'm allowed to.3:08So you see that even though you're allowed to, but being that3:10itself in itself is an aveirah, you need a kaparah for that as well.3:17וכן בית דין סנהדרין סרבו מזבח כעבדים, מקום מקום צריכה כפרה. Where people thought they were doing3:20a mitzvah, the Gemara brings over there, but still3:22it wasn't a mitzvah, and therefore it needs3:25kaparah. Moshe Rabbeinu3:28עלה בשכרה הלוחות, וגרם על ידי זה שכחת התורה. So too, Hashem tells Moshe Rabbeinu when he broke3:31the3:34luchot, יישר כוחך ששיברת. Chazak u'baruch that you broke the luchot. In fact, he's praised for it at the end of his life,3:39at the end of the Torah. Parashat Vezot HaBerachah says,3:43וְכֹל הַיָּד הַגְּדוֹלָה. What's this yad hagedolah? Chazal tell us is that he broke the3:47luchot to the eyes of the Jewish people. Our nekudah says that he broke the3:50luchot to the eyes of the Jewish people.3:53You see that even though Moshe Rabbeinu did a3:56wonderful thing, still it caused the3:59Torah to be forgotten,4:01kemo she'amru zal. If it wasn't for the fact that people brought it back4:04from the limud, the Torah was forgotten after the breaking of the4:10luchot. Even though Hashem agreed to that, like we just brought you proof,4:13still it's called an4:15aveirah lishmah. It's not a sin for the sake of sin; it's an aveirah l'shem Shamayim, to try to fix it.4:24And even Moshe himself suffered from it,4:26because breaking the luchot caused forgetting of the Torah,4:30and Moshe was the cause of that.4:33Therefore, says the4:37Gemara—I mean, says Rav Tzadok—we find that he himself,4:39Moshe Rabbeinu himself, forgot4:41Torah. When, at the end of his life, when Yehoshua was about to be appointed,4:45Hashem took away from him momentarily4:48the wisdom of the Torah, and He said to4:51him, Yehoshua, not knowing what's going on.4:57We find Esther also got punished4:59for something that she did that was an5:02aveirah lishmah. What was Esther's5:06aveirah lishmah? Because she went and she told5:09Mordechai, It's a time of5:10sakanah. We need to get the Jewish people to fast.5:14But that timing, if you look at the dating,5:18was going to be—the three-day fast was going to be on Pesach.5:22People will not eat on Pesach.5:25It's asur to fast on a holiday. Number two, you're not going to eat matzah that year.5:27You're not going to eat maror. What's going on?5:30No, it's a three-day fast. We must fast. I'm going in5:33sakanah. I have to go in, and they all have to fast,5:35and only then they should do their own teshuvah.5:37Okay. The pasuk says,5:41Vaya'avor Mordechai. Mordechai went to go carry the message of Esther to all the Jewish people in Shushan,5:47chazal tell us, vaya'avor from the lashon of aveirah. He didn't sin.5:49He didn't sin to go, but it's a sin. It's called5:53an aveirah lishmah. No, but it's not a sin like our sin. It's an aveirah l'shem shamayim.5:58And therefore,6:01says6:03Rav Tzadok, you find that Esther was also punished for that.6:05How was Esther punished for that?6:07And the answer is, when she walked into Achashverosh on that third day,6:12she herself also fasted, and she stood there,6:15right? It says that6:17when she got to the place where the avodah zarah was6:20outside the room of6:22Achashverosh, ruach kodesh went away from her,6:26right? So,6:28v'likach ba'ah teshuvah. Therefore, come back now to ba'ah teshuvah.6:34After this note, na'asu zechuyot. Even though6:36ba'ah teshuvah is saying a major chiddush over here,6:38and ba'ah teshuvah,6:42who does an aveirah, חזתא לה, the aveirot which she did on purpose6:43actually turned into mitzvot.6:45They turned into zechuyot for him.6:48It says even though that's true,6:54still he needs6:56to put himself through some sort of suffering6:59because it's not any worse7:01from7:03aveirah lishmah. Now, although this is Rav Tzadok is saying,7:05this is Rav Tzadok, this is a class on7:07Rav Tzadok, and we're way, way too far to really argue,7:12but I do have a question myself personally,7:14because the Gemara says that7:17when a person does teshuvah,7:20so then if it's teshuvah7:22me'ahavah, if it's teshuvah out of fear,7:24what happens is, his aveirot is considered like7:28shgagot, like a shogeg. He needs7:32kaparah, it seems like, pashut pshat, it seems like he needs kaparah. And a person who does teshuvah7:34me'ahavah turns7:35it to zechuyot. It doesn't sound like over there7:39that there's some sort of need for7:42kaparah. Right? It sounds like, you know, the opposite.7:44Turns7:46it to zechuyot. So I'm not sure exactly what does it7:48mean that he needs to go through some suffering.7:50But I can bring you a proof7:52to Rav Tzadok, no. And the proof is from the Gemara,7:55a very interesting Gemara.7:56The Gemara says that a person who's—8:00Born on a certain day of the week will be certain things.8:02If you're born, for example, on a Sunday, since Sunday is the first day of the week, it's the leader,8:07so that person has natural tendencies of leadership.8:11A person who's born on, let's say, for example, Friday,8:14since Friday is the day that everybody's running after, you know, to get ready for Shabbat,8:17he's going to be a person who runs after mitzvot.8:19The Gemara says something interesting.8:20What if a person is born on Shabbat?8:23My answer is he will die on Shabbat, because they had to be mechalel Shabbat for him to be born.8:27Therefore, he needs a kaparah to die on Shabbat.8:30One second,8:30that's a clear halacha8:32from the areas that's very, very clear,8:34that when there's a choleh sheyesh bo sakanah, we're mechalelin Shabbat.8:39We have to be mechalel Shabbat.8:40Kol hazariz, right,8:42a person who is zariz and mechalel Shabbat gets more reward.8:47So what's going on?8:48The guy is born on Shabbat,8:49it's his fault.8:50That's when it was decreed upon him,8:52and we have to be mechalel Shabbat because that's what is supposed to be done.8:57And you see from here that there's some sort of sin, כביכול, that took place,9:03and it needs a certain kaparah, even though it was done with 100%9:06heter and it's a mitzvah to do it.9:07Perhaps that's a proof also9:10to Rav Tzadok HaKohen. In any case, we continue,9:11and he says,9:14ועל זה אמרו כל האומר הקדוש ברוך הוא ותרן. On this9:15Chazal tell us, and maybe says Hashem is9:18vatran. You know, Hashem doesn't care.9:19It's okay, Hashem easily, you know, lets go of things.9:25ותרן לא חייב, the Gemara says.9:29Now, כל מעשה האדם נפעל בעונש הכתוב. Every single action a person does is recorded and it's important,9:33and a person will have consequences on it.9:39However, now it sounds scary:9:43I'm a baal teshuvah, and I know what I've done in the past,9:45and you tell me now, even though I thought I did9:49a teshuvah, and even though I got a certificate from Shamayim that told me,9:52You are9:53a baal teshuvah meahavah, I still need9:54kaparah? He says, Yes, but you should just know,9:57there's a lot of loopholes, as we could say.10:00This is good loopholes.10:01There's a lot of— Advice that comes from the10:06Rachamim HaKadosh Baruch Hu of how to circumvent,10:07and not avoid, but to kind of substitute the punishment.10:12Right, for example,10:14he brings an example. He doesn't fully speak about it,10:16but the Gemara talks about Masechet Rosh Hashanah.10:19If Hashem said in the beginning of the year10:22that a certain city does not deserve to have so much rain,10:25they're going to have only a small amount of rain.10:27Let's use tons for a second.10:29The normal rain that they need is ten tons.10:32Hashem says at the beginning of the year,10:33the city, they don't deserve it.10:35They're only getting three tons of water.10:37So what's going to10:38happen? Three tons of water will only rain.10:40What if they become tzaddikim in the middle of the year?10:42It's now Chanukah, they're inspired to become10:45tzaddikim, they did teshuvah.10:46Doesn't make a difference.10:48It was decreed upon them that they should have only three tons.10:51However, what does Hashem do?10:52He brings the three tons of rain10:55in the time and the place that they need it,10:57exactly. Because we know10:59a lot of the rain that falls11:01gets kind of could be wasted,11:04right? It falls on things that are not necessary.11:05It falls on the concrete.11:06What does that do for it,11:08right? So Hashem says, I'll bring it exactly where they need.11:10I'll bring it in the areas where they need11:12the reservoirs to be filled.11:13I'll bring it in the fields.11:14I'll bring it exactly as they need it.11:17So you see the same idea also,11:18that when a person has a certain punishment,11:21Hashem has a way,11:21don't worry, to kind of circumvent it,11:25to turn it into a good thing for him.11:30Sometimes Hashem gives him the11:32yisurim when it's actually good for him.11:33We also know there's something called substitute.11:39Yeah, you might get, as you're playing basketball,11:41so you lose a game.11:43That's part of the fun.11:44You're playing basketball,11:45you're losing a game,11:46okay. You get bumped a little bit in playing basketball.11:48Part of the pain.11:50No pain, no11:50game. Everybody knows that. But why are you getting it then?11:52That's part of the11:53kaparah. So Hashem has a way.11:55Besides that, also you could substitute11:58it, until you get to the actual12:00yisurim that they need to pay for,12:02He'll give it to you. But again,12:04it's all12:05b'rachmei Shamayim. But it's going to come.12:08Sometimes a person even gets,12:12you know, punished12:13without even realizing he got punished.12:15As Chazal tell us in Perek Avot,12:19Nifra'in me'adam mi'da'ato v'shelo mi'da'ato. They pay when the person gets consequences;12:21he gets it with realizing, without realizing it,12:25and He brings him brackets.12:29Because shelo b'hargashato mishum ones mikrei shelo mi'da'ato. A person who doesn't feel12:31the punishment,12:32that's called12:37shelo mi'da'ato. Because sometimes a person12:38goes through suffering12:39and he's working on himself.12:40He says,12:42Kol meda'avid Rachmana l'tav avid. After he is happy,12:44he says,12:45Sameach b'chelko, happy with this.12:46Other people look at him and they say,12:50Ah, chazit, nebach, poor guy, look at him,12:51going through so much suffering.12:53Meanwhile he says, No, this is part of my12:54nisayon. He loves it because this is part of the challenge.12:57And that's also,12:59perhaps, yes,13:00he's feeling it, that that's part of Hashem testing me.13:03It could be also a punishment, but guess what?13:06Shelo mi'da'ato, b'da'at he doesn't think it's a punishment,13:09and he thinks it's wonderful13:10and it's great, because that's how they punish him13:13in Shamayim, they clean up his slate.13:18Also the pain a person feels13:20for his sins that he's done in the past,13:22that's also13:23from a sample of the suffering13:26in Gehinam.