Torah · MussarMussar125. Giving Charity Can Fix the Sin of ז״לTzidkat HaTzadikPart 125Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 9, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0010:25Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat ha-tzadik, ot kuf0:04chaf hei. In this piece, like we said earlier,0:06Rav Tzadok continues in another way,0:08or other areas where a person can do tikkun0:12for the0:14aveirah of zera levatala. Here's another form,0:15and it's a very, very nice connection.0:16It's a beautiful way how he connects it.0:17He says,0:22Tzedakah la'aniyim gam ken me'aletetaken avon hotzaat zera levatala. Giving charity to poor people is another form,0:24is another way, excuse me,0:27for a person to be able to0:29fix the sin of0:34zera levatala. Uvichlal lekol ma she'amru, zal, chayav mita. In fact,0:36anytime the Chazal said that a0:37person is chayav mita for a certain action,0:38and Chazal say it in a lot of places.0:40For example,0:41it says a person who's over al divrei chachamim is chayav mita, as it says0:45in the pasuk, Poretz geder yishchenu nachash. A person who breaks a fence0:50should be bit by a snake.0:52Now, simple meaning is,0:54in the olden0:55days, people had fences between each other,0:57and that's where snakes used to like to hide.0:59And if a person breaks1:00the fence because he wants to expand his territory,1:02he'll come across snakes1:04and chash will bite him.1:06So,1:07Mishmuel HaMelech says this pasuk,1:09and Chazal use it also1:10for a person who breaks the fence of the rabbis.1:15Whoever is over on divrei chachamim is chayav mita. So says Rav Tzadok,1:16you should know,1:18and we know, of course,1:19there's a lot of1:19areas where the Torah says itself1:20that a person's1:22chayav mita. So he says,1:25giving charity to poor people actually is another form1:26that helps a person,1:27that protects a person from death.1:32Kemo she'ne'emar, Utzedakah tatzil mimavet, as it says,1:34tzedakah saves a person from death.1:38Kemo she'amru, perek kama d'Bava Batra, as Chazal themselves1:39bring stories and stories1:40upon how tzedakah actually1:43helps save people1:44from certain death.1:50And there it says in the Gemara also about this,1:53that1:54whoever1:56makes one Jewish person survive,1:59whoever supports2:00financially or anything2:02one Jewish person,2:03it's like you actually2:06kept an entire world alive.2:12And he should know,2:14when you're2:15mechayeh tzedakah by supporting somebody financially2:18who was2:18basically a2:20person—imagine a2:20person who's really on his way down,2:21he is real poor.2:22It's hard to imagine2:23real poverty nowadays2:25because, you know,2:26inflation2:27everybody is flipping out,2:29the prices are crazy,2:30the stocks are going down2:32and the interest is high.2:33Everybody has problems.2:34Okay, fine,2:36whatever, okay?2:37That's not poverty.2:38Nobody is walking around2:39losing weight.2:40We hear stories2:42from the Holocaust,2:43that was poverty,2:44you understand?2:45People literally2:46didn't have what to eat,2:47and you give the person2:49tzedakah, you give the person charity,2:51you give him food,2:52you give him money2:53to be able to buy food.2:54You literally have2:56pumped life into this person.2:58So2:59Chazal tell us,3:00when you give life3:02to one Jewish person,3:04you are actually giving life3:06to an entire world.3:08Part of that entire world3:10includes also those spirits3:12that have also been created3:14by the3:17זרע לבטלה. But on a condition3:19that you give charity3:20to a worthy poor person.3:24Otherwise,3:25if you don't give3:25it to a worthy poor person,3:27it doesn't help.3:31Why? Because if you think about it,3:32giving charity to the wrong person3:33is kind of—3:34You know,3:35it's kind of like repeating3:36the sin of3:38zera levatala. Why?3:40Shemashpia chayim l'mi she'eino ra'ui. You're giving life,3:42basically,3:43giving3:44zera to a person,3:45while there's no person there.3:47It's3:48levatala. Remember,3:49zeh levatala is wasting,3:52but included in3:53wasting is also when a person,3:55lo aleinu,3:56is having relations3:56with the wrong people.3:58A person has relations3:59with4:00a goya or something,4:01that's also4:02zeh levatala, besides the other4:03averot that are also included in it.4:05So you mashpia,4:06you give from your energy4:08to the wrong person.4:10Same thing when you give charity4:12to the wrong person,4:14you're mashpia,4:16you give from your energy4:17to the wrong person.4:18So that's why,4:19in order to fix4:21the zeh levatala, it has to be that you give it4:22to the right person,4:23a person who is worthy.4:25We're not talking about just fakers,4:27right?4:28We're talking about also people4:30that deserve charity.4:32Go read the4:32Gemara, Masechet Bava Batra,4:33that says clearly over there4:34there would be4:35one time there were times of hunger,4:36and Bi opened4:38up—Rabbi Yehuda Nasi, that4:39is—he was very, very wealthy,4:39and he opened up warehouses of food,4:42and he says,4:43If you're4:44a talmid chacham, you could come online4:45and get food.4:46If you're4:46am haaretz, get out of here.4:48You're not getting.4:49Right?4:50What's going on over here?4:51What do you mean?4:52A poor person also deserves.4:53Well,4:54if he's not learning Torah,4:55am haaretz who doesn't care about Torah,4:57so what am I feeding?4:59What am I supporting him?5:00So it has to be a person,5:01again,5:01not just that he's financially5:02not doing well.5:03It has to be a person also5:05who cares about Torah.5:08Not just,5:08okay,5:09I'll go join a class5:11because I know I'm going to get money.5:12No,5:12he gets his money5:13and we don't see him again.5:14A person who cares about5:15Torah, a person who tries to come5:16to learn,5:17has to be5:20mamash a barich, a chamer, a barich who needs money.5:21What an unbelievable5:22zechut it is.5:23You're not only supporting5:25a poor person,5:26you're supporting5:26also Torah as well.5:29Back to Rav5:30Tzadok, and he says,5:31on a condition5:31that it has to be a proper5:42ani. The pasuk says that5:43Yirmiyah cursed5:44the people,5:45the fake prophets.5:48How did he curse them?5:49He says,5:50Hashem,5:50make them stumble5:52when it's time5:53of your anger.5:53We know it's5:54a time of5:54anger of Hashem,5:55lo aleinu,5:55the terrible decrees.5:57But,5:57like we said,5:58tzedakah5:59tatzil mimavet. Giving charity6:00actually saves6:01a person from6:02these terrible decrees.6:03So Hashem says,6:04when you have that anger,6:06make them stumble.6:10How do you make them stumble?6:11Hashem doesn't give6:13aveirot to people,6:13and it says,6:14no.6:19It means that,6:20oh, they want to give charity?6:21Don't give them6:22the privilege6:23of giving charity6:24to people.6:25Send them people6:26that don't deserve6:27charity,6:30because6:32really6:33they6:34made6:36Yirmiyah sin6:37with6:39zera levatala. He says,6:40kenoda as is known.6:41I'm going to bring you6:41what he means to6:42say over here,6:43or what6:44they bring in parentheses he means6:45to say,6:46and then6:47we'll connect. We'll6:50explain it6:50and tell you6:51certain issues6:52with it.6:52In any case,6:53so that's what he says6:54over here.6:55They made him6:56be6:57motzi zera levatala, so that's why,6:58same6:59midah keneged midah, let them also get,7:00כביכול, stumble7:01in the same way,7:03to be7:03mashpia to the wrong people.7:05Now,7:05what's the story7:06that7:08Yirmiyah was zera levatala? And it says, coming7:09out of a7:10person—remember, coming out of a person,7:11even if it's not in his control,7:12it's called7:15zera levatala. Chazal tell us that Yirmiyah had a7:15son called Ben Sira.7:17How was he born?7:18He was actually7:18born from7:20Yirmiyah's daughter.7:22Yirmiyah did not go with his7:23daughter, but7:23it says that7:25Yirmiyah, when he went7:26into the mikveh...7:28And that7:29Zera stayed in the water,7:30and when his daughter7:31used the same mikveh,7:32it came into her7:33body and she got pregnant7:34from it.7:34And that child7:35was called Ben Sira,7:37quoted in7:39Chazal a few times7:40in the Gemara,7:40where we7:41learn some important7:41lessons from him.7:42There was even7:46an idea,7:46there was even7:47contemplation7:48that maybe7:48we would use7:49Ben Sira's book7:50as one of the books7:52of7:53Tanach, but it wasn't used7:53at the end.7:54Okay,7:55now he has over here7:57some idea7:58in brackets,7:59which we're skipping.8:00We're going to go to the end now. He says,8:06וְקִלְלָם שֶׁקִּשְּׁלוּ בְּמִדַּת הַנְּדָבָה, וְלֹא רָצָה לְקַלְלָם שֶׁכָּשְׁלוּ בְּחַטְאוֹ. And he cursed them.8:08Why did he curse them? Look, they made8:09you be8:11motzi zera levatala. Curse them that should also be8:14motzi zera levatala. No, he says they didn't want to do that.8:18דְּזֶה גּוֹרֵם רַע לַכֹּל, כְּמוֹ שֶׁנִּתְבָּאֵר בְּזֹהַר מִשְׁפָּטִים. As we said in the previous recording,8:22that zeh al8:23levatala causes problems for the entire world,8:25so he's also going to suffer from it.8:27The whole world is going to suffer from it.8:28So he didn't want to curse them for such a thing,8:30but he cursed them with something that's very identical,8:33and that is giving tzedakah to the wrong people.8:39וְהַיְנוּ דְבַר זֶה אֵין בְּיַד אָדָם לְדַעַת כְּלָל. And this is something that nobody,8:42nobody could know.8:43Nobody could know8:46if your charity is going to the right place or not.8:49Like, for example,8:49he says,8:59אֲנִי בְּקִדּוּשִׁין... וְכֵן אָמְרוּ שֶׁמָּא תֹאמַר כָּל הַבָּא לִקְפֹץ קוֹפֵץ, וּמִי לֹא אָמַר, מַה יָּקַח הַזֶּה... וּבְרֵישִׁית בָּדְרוּ שׁוּב פָּסוּק... וְלַעֲרֵב... Right, nobody could really know, you know,9:01his actions, where they're going to lead to.9:03In fact, he even says9:05nobody could even know where his kids,9:07which kids will actually be the good kids,9:09which kids will not be the good kids.9:11Nobody knows all these things.9:12We do our effort and we hope that9:15Hashem completes it.9:16Same thing if you think about it also,9:18a person is together with his wife,9:19nobody could guarantee that there's going to be a child,9:22right? It's from Hashem.9:23We do our effort and we hope Hashem does it the right way.9:26So that's the same thing he says,9:29הַנִּתְנָה צְדָקָה שֶׁנּוֹדֵעַ אֵיזֶה כָּשֵׁר. We don't... Also when we give tzedakah to people,9:33we don't really know9:34which person actually deserves it9:36and uses it properly.9:42רַק מִי שֶׁשָּׂם כְּרָאוּי, מְבַקֵּשׁ רַחֲמֵי שָׁמַיִם שֶׁיִּתּוֹקַן חֶטְאוֹ. But what could you do then?9:44If you tell me the way to fix the sin of9:46zera levatala is by giving charity, but now you're telling me9:48we never know if you're really giving charity to the right person.9:50We never know who the real right person is.9:53So he says, however,9:55a person who does teshuvah properly,9:58and he begs Hashem that he wants to fix himself,10:01and he wants to fix his sin,10:06then Hashem, what He'll do10:09is He'll make sure10:11that the people he comes across,10:13that he comes to help,10:14will be people proper and10:18befitting10:19his charity or his giving charity10:21so he could fix his sin.