Torah · MussarMussar123. Killing Yourself Over Torah for LifeTzidkat HaTzadikPart 123Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 3, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:21Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00So, Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf chaf gimel.0:04In a way, kuf chaf gimel is connected to kuf chaf bet,0:07because in kuf chaf bet we spoke about0:09teshuvah for0:12zera levatalah, and in kuf chaf gimel it talks about how to fix it.0:15Although it was mentioned in other pieces earlier0:18that Torah is the way for a person to fix0:22zera levatalah, here he elaborates on this point and he says,0:30על ידי לימוד תורה ביגיעה נתקן עוון הוצאת זרע לבטלה. A person who learns Torah, but not just regular learning Torah,0:34with0:35yegiah. You know, yegiah means with effort and hard work.0:40There's a way to learn Torah where you can listen and just, yalla, let's go,0:43I understand, yeah, you just nod your head.0:45There's a way where0:49you are me'ayen, you look deeper into it.0:51You don't accept it for face value.0:53If you don't understand it, you go back and you repeat,0:55and you go back and you keep asking0:57and you keep trying to figure out until you get to the clarity of1:01what the Torah is trying to tell you.1:02That's called1:03yegiah. He says that kind of learning,1:05a person could fix the avon of1:09הוצאת זרע לבטלה. Why?1:10He brings an unbelievable idea.1:12Listen to this.1:13Let's start with the1:15Gemara, Masechet Niddah. Chazal tell us1:17that חייא מיתה. Chazal tell us a person who is1:22משחית זרע לבטלה is חייב מיתה. We learn it from1:23Dor Hamabul, we learn it from Er and Onan,1:25the children of Yehudah who married Tamar.1:27Hashem killed them.1:29So the Gemara learns from there anybody who does this sin is1:32חייב מיתה. Look in Shulchan Aruch,1:34in Even HaEzer, it talks very, very harshly about1:37this thing. Chas v'shalom, it's חייב מיתה, right?1:39So it says,1:43וודאי כל דברי חכמים רחמים על בריותם, להמשיך טובה וחיים לעולם. So when Chazal tell us something,1:46their intention is to bring life to the world1:48and to have mercy on people.1:50They're not here to just punish people1:52and they say, Oh, you did this,1:53you're going to get punishment of death.1:54It's not their intention.1:56Yet, when a person reads that Gemara,1:59really it shakes you up.2:01Chazal speak very harshly about it,2:03and in a way, like we said,2:04it's a very, very difficult thing2:07for a person to really2:08control himself on it,2:10or at least in his past2:11when he's single, at least.2:12So what's going on?2:14So he explains,2:16The kavanah b'makom she'amru chayav ones al adam, he says,2:19Rav Tzadok, beautiful understanding2:20and beautiful way of to look at2:22when Chazal speak in such a strong language.2:24He says,2:24The kavanah of2:26Chazal when they say that a2:28person's chayav punishment,2:29a person who is chayav punishment,2:32hainu sheba'ones zeh mitkaper. Their intention is2:34that through this punishment2:36he gets cleansed from his sin.2:39Like Chazal tell us,2:41chayavei mitat Beit Din mitatan kaparatam. Chazal tell us when a person2:44is subject to the death penalty,2:47the death penalty is not just a2:50punishment like we understand it.2:51We understand punishment is,2:52I'm going to take out my anger on you.2:55When we punish our children,2:57what do we do?2:58In a way, we're really angry,3:00right?3:01But really,3:02punishment is supposed to be3:03cleansing a sin.3:04That's how it's supposed to be.3:05So when a person3:07has committed one of the worst crimes3:09in the Torah,3:10where he's subject to death,3:12he's supposed to3:13die, he has one of the3:16arba mitot Beit Din, mitatam3:16is3:17kaparatam. The death actually cleanses them3:19from the sin.3:20Ki3:23ra'u shekashe limtzo kaparah, right?3:24When Chazal saw that3:26it's hard to find a way3:27for a person to get cleansed,3:31and they found3:33a person who3:34commits whatever sin it is,3:36he's subject to3:37whatever punishment it is,3:38and in the case where a person3:39is subject to the death penalty,3:41it's in the Torah,3:42clearly3:43that that's only3:44where he could get cleansed.3:48So clearly,3:49when3:50Chazal tell us a person is— Punishment is3:52subject to a certain punishment3:54for the action that he does.3:55It means that it's3:57through this punishment3:57that he gets cleansed,4:00because otherwise,4:01why is Hashem punishing him?4:03Why in4:03the world is he getting punished?4:05It's very clear4:06that the punishment is only4:07to cleanse a person.4:09Let's bring you a proof.4:10Chazal tell us4:12that a4:13person who commits certain4:15aveirot, that the punishment4:17is malkut,4:18lashes,4:19he's called a rasha.4:20This actually has4:25practical4:26halachot to it when it comes to4:27the halachot of4:28edim. A person who4:30commits certain4:30aveirot that he's chayav malkut4:32is called a4:33rasha. For example,4:34a person who eats4:35treif, if he has not done teshuvah,4:36he's called a rasha.4:38Now,4:39when he gets malkut,4:40if Beit Din gives him4:41the lashes for his4:43aveirah, the Gemara says clearly4:45he becomes now4:46achicha, your brother.4:46He's the same level as you,4:47and that's it.4:48He's completely4:49cleansed of his4:50sin. So you see that4:51the punishment a person4:52receives for his action4:54of sinning4:56cleanses his4:57aveirah. It makes his4:58aveirah go away.4:59So same thing5:00we're saying over here also.5:01A person who5:02is chayav any punishment,5:03whether it be death,5:04whatever it may be5:05that the Torah prescribes,5:06the punishment is only there5:08to take away the sin.5:19V'lekach, says Rav Tzadok, and that's why, pe'amim nigzar al adam, bishvil hotza'at zera levatalah, sheyihyu lo banim. Sometimes a person5:22who wastes5:23and5:25he's motzi zera levatalah, chas v'shalom, there's a gezeirah upon him sometimes5:27that he should not have kids.5:29Now again,5:30you can't go around5:30and start becoming5:32a5:33navi and knowing Hashem's ways5:34and say anybody5:34who doesn't have5:35kids is because5:36he is motzi zera levatalah. We don't know.5:37He's just telling you5:38at times.5:40This could be5:41the punishment of a person.5:44V'kiotzei shumarba d'bnei shekra mita. Why this punishment?5:46Well,5:47Chazal tell us there are four things5:49that are considered like death.5:51One of them5:51is a person who doesn't have5:52any children.5:54So,5:55a person5:58who's motzi zera levatala, his punishment is5:59that he should die, right?6:00So6:01by not having kids,6:02it's considered like he died.6:03But it's not only that.6:04An ani also6:06is6:06nechshav k'meit. A blind person6:07is also6:09nechshav k'meit, right?6:09And a metzora is6:10nechshav k'meit. There are three other people6:12that are considered like6:12they're dead people:6:13a blind person,6:14a poor person,6:16and a person6:18who has6:19tzaraat is considered like6:20he is a dead person.6:21So6:22sometimes there's a6:23gezeirah on a person6:24that he should be poor,6:24that he should be blind,6:25that he should be6:28metzora. And that6:29is6:30the reason for that6:31is because6:32he's haya really mita6:33for6:35hotzaat zera levatala. So he explains6:36over here6:36unbelievable things.6:38He6:38says, One second.6:39That punishment6:40of not having kids,6:43let's just take that6:43as an example,6:45it's because6:46of6:48hotzaat zera levatala, v'haidei divrei Torah shemit atzmoa, divrei Torah. But6:50when a person6:51kills himself6:53over Torah,6:55shezen nikra gam ken mita. We find6:56that6:57a person6:57who works6:58very hard6:59to learn7:00Torah,7:00to understand7:01Torah,7:02it's also considered7:03death.7:04Where do we see this?7:05Well, it says7:06in the Gemara7:07on the pasuk7:08that says,7:09Adam7:13ki yamut b'ohel. The pasuk7:14in Parashat Chukat says,7:15Zot7:16haTorah, adam7:18ki yamut b'ohel. Amar Reish Lakish, ein divrei Torah7:20mitkayemim ela b'mi shememit atzmo aleha.7:21A person who7:23dies in the7:23tent, and the Gemara7:23says,7:24What's tent?7:25That's7:26ohalah shel Torah, the tent of the Torah.7:27A person who7:29kills himself7:29over the Torah,7:30that's the person7:31who is able7:31to really acquire7:32Torah.7:33So you see7:35that learning7:35Torah7:36is considered7:36a form of death.7:38So therefore,7:39if a person7:40was motzi zera...7:41And there's7:41a punishment,7:42he should die,7:43and Hashem7:43says,7:44okay, as a result7:45he won't have7:45any kids. Says the Tzadok, when he toils in Torah, as nitkaper lo b'zeh, then he's carrying out his own punishment by killing himself. So he's already punishing himself, killing.8:00himself, but he's killing himself over Torah,8:02then he gets cleansed for his8:06... lebatala, gam ken dugmat mita,8:07similar to, like dying.8:11And in fact, the Gemara even uses the term,8:13Ma ya'aseh adam8:15v'yichyeh? Yamit atzmo. Or if you want a person to live, let him kill himself,8:17meaning kill himself over Torah, you get to live8:19because of this gezeirah that you should die, then you get to live.8:22And guess what?8:23That way it's mekaper for him and he's able to have kids.8:30Divrei Torah nikra etz chayim. Divrei Torah, we find another beautiful8:33explanation he brings over here, same idea.8:35So we find that Torah is called8:38also etz chayim, right?8:38Kemo she'amru חזל, like it says in the Midrash many places,8:41the Torah is known as the tree of life.8:44Etz chayim hi lamachazikim bah.8:46It's the tree of life for those who hold on to it, who support it.8:50So in many places we find Torah referred to as8:53etz chayim. Not going to get into all different places,8:56but if you're familiar, familiar; if not, you take my word for it for now.9:00You take Reb Tzadok's word for it.9:02U'mita nikra derech eretz.9:03And we find that the way of the land, the derech of the land,9:08the derech of this world, is that people die.9:10And we found that the word derech eretz refers to death.9:13Where do we find this?9:14Well, if you look in Sefer9:18Melachim, in the beginning of Sefer Melachim, when David is about to9:21die, we read this as a haftarah for Parashat9:26... Chayei Sarah. He calls over his son, and he tells his son9:29Shlomo, Anochi holech b'derech kol9:32ha'aretz. I'm going in the ways of all the land,9:34basically telling him, David's saying, look, my end is near.9:38I'm going like the way everybody else goes, which is they all die.9:42So therefore we find that derech eretz is also referred to,9:45or alludes to, death.9:47So he explains something beautiful here.9:49V'kach mita hu derech l'hagia... On l'chayei olam9:54comes out that the death is actually the road9:58which a person needs to take in order to get to the eternal world.10:03We're here living in this world.10:04We all know that this is only temporary10:05in order our goal is to get to Olam10:08Haba. That's the world, Olam and Nefashot.10:11That's the real chayei olam.10:13That's a real life over there.10:15But the way to get there is only one way,10:17and that is through10:19dying. So he says, if death is a way to get there,10:22shederech eretz hu derech Eretz10:24HaChayim. Comes out that derech eretz10:26is actually the way to the Eretz10:30HaChayim. Dying is only the only path a person can take10:33to get to that tree of life,10:35like we explained above.10:39So it comes out it's also the same way.10:42If a person toils and works hard to learn and understand Torah,10:46and working hard, by the way, includes not only how much you10:50understand, but how much you have to sacrifice to learn.10:53It could be taking away from precious time,10:56or taking away from things that you know are very difficult.10:59Everybody's going somewhere to an11:01event, and you really want to go, and you don't.11:04You go and you commit to what you committed to,11:07and everybody's talking random things,11:10and you stick to what you're doing and you're learning.11:13That's also killing yourself for it.11:15So it comes out that when you kill yourself11:19through Torah,11:22זהו הדרך לארץ החיים. That's also the path to the tree of life.11:27ותקן בזה מה שגם בדרך ארץ, and that can be metaken what you did with the derech eretz,11:30because we find that derech eretz is also the terminology.11:34It refers to not only death,11:36like we just saw before.11:37Derech eretz also tells us.11:39We find that the term derech eretz11:41is also for people that have marital relations.11:46We find that's also called derech eretz.11:47So derech eretz is also another terminology11:51that we use for relations,11:55which is, you know, when not used properly,11:58it's also12:01considered zera levatala. So it comes out that derech eretz, which is12:04a mitzvah, can be mekayem the derech eretz, and that's a derech to get to12:07the Eretz Chaim. And you can do that.12:08You can skip the line.12:09You can skip the punishment.12:11You can avoid all the problems12:12by putting your effort in killing yourself12:15in the study of Torah,12:17which gives us chayei olam.