Torah · MussarMussar122. Teshuvah for One Sin Drags Other Sins AlongTzidkat HaTzadikPart 122Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 3, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:44Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat Tzadik, ot kuf chaf bet. Says0:14our tzaddik, כאמר להם בשבת שחטאת הבא לכפרה חטא, גורר אותו חטא גם פעם אחר שעשהו יו״ד שם. What he's basically saying, I'm not going to bother translating because I have to0:17explain it anyway, what he's basically saying is that we know that there's certain0:21aveirot that a person has to bring a korban chatat on. There's actually 36 aveirot a person0:26is obligated, when there was a Beit HaMikdash, to bring a korban chatat. One of the famous0:29ones is a person who is mechalel Shabbat beshogeg, meaning to say he was not aware0:35that it was Shabbat and he did a melachah. Let's say a person put on a fire.0:40He wakes up at 6 a.m. Shabbat morning, completely, like, spaced out, not realizing it's Shabbat, and he puts0:46on a fire and he makes himself a cup of coffee. As he's drinking his cup of coffee, looks0:51out the window and his neighbor says, Hey, Shabbat shalom, neighbor, and he remembers,0:55Oh, I can't believe it's today Shabbat. I can't believe I did not realize that when I put0:59on the fire. So that's called an aveirah bishogeg on Shabbat. He's obligated to1:04bring a korban chatat to the Beit HaMikdash.1:06Now, the halachah is that when you bring this korban chatat, it also will include other1:15aveirot also. Other aveirot that he did together will be also included in this. That means even1:19if there was aveirot in the past, will be packed into this korban or will be dragged by this1:26korban, and it will forgive as well.1:29This is the halachah. What do we learn from that? Also we can learn from this, says Rav Tzadok,1:36to do teshuvah. When a person does teshuvah in which he gets the zechut that he's able1:44to get kaparah, to get cleansed from his aveirah, it also not only cleans him for this particular1:54sin that he's doing teshuvah for, but it'll also clean him for other sins as well,2:01because the chet— That's coming to get cleaned. The sin that's coming to get cleansed drags2:07along with it other sins. V'sham ita belo noda d'chayav asham talui. And the Gemara says over2:13there, there's another korban known as asham talui. What's asham talui? A very interesting thing.2:21Asham talui is a korban. Let's learn about not—very, very important subject to learn about, and not too2:27many people get to learn about it.2:28So let's take a little bit of time off to learn about2:31korbanot. One of the korbanot is known as an asham talui, not to be confused with an asham2:36vadai. Asham talui means—and asham, a korban with a Torah prescribed as an asham talui means—korban that2:41comes when there was a safek aveirah, not any2:45safek aveirah. Basically, we told you that there are 36 aveirot that a person will bring a2:51korban chatat. The Torah says also there are certain aveirot that a person will bring a korban asham. For example,2:55a person who steals, and when he's taken to court he swears that he didn't steal,2:59and then we have witnesses that testify that the guy really actually stole. In that case,3:05he will be chayav to bring an asham vadai, vadai from the word certain. Asham talui3:10is when a person is not sure if he did an aveirah which would require him to bring a3:19korban chatat. Let's give another example, ready? Here's a person who had—there's a certain fat on3:25an animal known as chelev. The animal, every animal is full of fat. Fat is a white stuff3:30that you see on the meat when you buy it. So fat is not assur, right? That's what gives3:35the deliciousness of the meat. But there's certain fats that are located in certain3:40parts of the animal. The Torah warns us very clearly to stay away from it. You don't have3:43to worry about it. Your butcher, hopefully, if he's a kosher butcher, is not selling3:48it to you, because from the slaughterhouse already they take it out.3:51In any case, if a person has in front of him two pieces of fat. He eats one of them.3:56He's not sure, though. Afterwards, he's told, by the way, I don't know which piece it was,3:59but one of those fats was actually chelev, which was asur to eat and the punishment was4:04karet. He doesn't know which one he ate. He can't verify which one. The other one he4:09ate one, the other one was thrown out. So in that case, he would bring a korban known4:13as a asham talui. Asham talui means an asham that's suspended. What does that mean? It suspends4:18the punishment until he could verify if he sinned or not. Sometimes a person may live his entire4:23life and never really figure out if he did this sin or not. But let's say in this case4:26that we gave that he ate one of the fats, it becomes later, it becomes discovered later on that he never4:32actually ate the fat, the forbidden fat. He never actually ate the chelev. He only ate4:35the forbidden fat. Okay, the korban was brought already, that's fine. But if he4:40discovers he actually did eat the forbidden fat, the chelev, then he has to bring a4:45korban chatat. I hope that wasn't too confusing. Anyways, an asham talui, Chazal tell us in the Gemara,4:51comes when a person doesn't know if he did this sin or not. V'hainu, what does that represent?4:57he says, she'efshar lekaper bachatat al zeh. Sometimes a person does an aveirah and he can bring a korban chatat to clean5:07himself out from this aveirah. Kemo sheamru Chachamim, when it's ... can, b'talmidei Rabbeinu ... ki yachmirah Torah b'safek. Because this concept is interesting. You would think that if a5:20person did an aveirah for sure, then he should be forgiven. But if he did a safek aveirah, then5:26kavachomer he should be forgiven when he brings a korban. We find that no. An asham talui doesn't5:31forgive you for the sin. Proof: if you discover later on that you actually did the5:35aveirah, you have to bring a korban chatat. So then what happens? What ends up happening? So5:42what comes out is that what comes out is that asham talui doesn't forgive5:47for anything. So it comes out that the safek aveirah, a person who is not sure if he did5:52an aveirah, is actually worse than a regular aveirah, because a regular aveirah, when a5:56person knows he did an aveirah, you bring a korban chatat and it cleanses you. If you're not sure if6:01you did the aveirah, you bring a korban and it still doesn't clean you. When you discover6:04that you actually did the aveirah, you still have to bring a korban. So this is actually6:10pointed out by Rabbeinu Yonah. The Rabbeinu Yonah, Talmidei Rabbeinu Yonah, this is a6:15commentary that we find in the back of Masechet Berachot, on the Rif, and he says over there,6:20he explains over there why6:24the asham talui is more severe. In a simple way, simple understanding of Rabbeinu Yonah,6:32he explains, you know, why it's more stringent. Because when a person knows he did an aveirah, he feels6:37regret and he's going to do teshuvah. A person is not teshuvah, he always6:43has in the back of mind, Did I really do anything? Come on, what did I do wrong?6:47I didn't do anything wrong. So he never really fully regrets his actions, and he never will6:52really come to do true teshuvah. And he brings this down over here, Rav Tzadok, and he says,6:58Hataam, what's the reason why a safek aveirah is worse than a vadai aveirah? He says,7:08Ki hayediah shenivla lo mechaperet miktzat, mipnei shehayediah zeh hu mitcharet. The knowledge that a person has when he knows that he did something wrong is a little bit7:13part of the teshuvah process, because it makes him feel bad and he starts to7:18regret the7:23aveirah. V'afilu hachi, bigrera nitkapera, vhu hadin lchol kaparat hata'im bteshuvah. It still, just the kaparah comes, it gets dragged along. That means with a little bit of knowledge7:32of knowing that you did an aveirah and you bring a chet, it's able to be mechaper for many7:37hata'im, for many sins. Excuse me, you bring a korban chatat, it's able to be mechaper for many sins7:43together.7:45Now, that was an introduction to what Rav Tzadok wants to say. Now he connects it to what he7:49wants to say, and like we said many, many pieces ago, there's a lot of discussion of7:55zera levatalah in these twenty or thirty paragraphs or so.8:00Rav Tzadok talks about, it goes on and off in and out from the subject. He says,8:04V'lachen, hotza'ah zera levatala, ein mo'il teshuvah,8:07kemo shemuva b'Zohar. We already mentioned the Zohar that says you can't do teshuvah for8:15zera levatala. Im sham al avon keri, u'mitkaper u'motzi otan tipinah ashukim. He says if a person really does teshuvah, like we said,8:21teshuvah is in the heart, and that's where you can do teshuvah. Rav Tzadok explains early in a different piece.8:25But Torah, Torah is a way for a person to cleanse himself for this sin of8:32zera levatala. He says if a person really is able to do teshuvah, right, through Torah or whatever prescription is given to us,8:39then he actually saves those drops that came out. He kind of saves them; he pulls them out, right?8:46If you are zocheh to the true teshuvah for this aveirah, what's the rule?8:52The aveirah that you get forgiven for, that you fix, is able to pull along other similar aveirot that you've done in the past and fix them along the way.9:02She says, motzi gam9:06ken tipot hotza'at zera levatala b'hakitz. So powerful is the teshuvah that a person can do that on zera levatala comes out in a dream, which where you're anus,9:13and if you really feel bad, like, Wow, what did I do wrong?9:16it's actually able to be mechaper even for the zera levatala that came out when you're awake, which was actually more in your control than the one when you were sleeping.9:26V'al kach gam ken yasad Hashem yitbarach9:29ענין הקרי בטבע. Wow, listen, amazing idea. He says that's why it's part of nature.9:34You know, it's part of nature. Men see this in their dream.9:37When they're sleeping, it's not in their control necessarily.9:39Again, we're not talking about resha'im that are watching and looking at things that leads them to this at night.9:45We're talking about tzaddikim that get this at night.9:47He says it's part of nature, that the keri is part of nature,9:52because it's part of Hashem's grand plan to be able to save, actually, the other drops that came out. On purpose,10:02the drops that are really harmful.10:04V'al yedei zeh yitukan. When a person gets bit oness and he fixes it, he could actually fix the ones that came out,10:15biratzon, u'mi shechata b'atzad zeh la'batala shemitbarach mazmin lo, gam ken mikrim k'dei lashuv aleihem. And Hashem kind of sets him up,10:20a person who has sinned with zera levatala and he really feels regret and he really wants to fix himself,10:25Hashem actually sets him up in the situation where he's able to fix those drops by getting it into a dream.10:35He has brackets, which I'm skipping right now.10:38So he says,10:41Ve'af mi shelo chata b'zeh b'hakitz. And don't think this is only for people who actually sinned when they were awake,10:46which means b'ratzon, on purpose,10:49b'mezid. He says even a person who didn't do it on purpose when he was awake,10:52HaKadosh Baruch Hu mazmin lo b'oness gam ul'taken oto haba10:57al yedei hirhur bayom. Even a person didn't actually take10:59out the zera levatala, but sometimes, like we said, a person could get it in a dream.11:02Why? Because he was thinking.11:03He was thinking in the day, and therefore he was thinking about it in the day,11:07he saw it in the night in his dream, and that brought it out.11:10So he says, so too, a person who did such a thing,11:16in a way, when it came out of his dream, sometimes it could be his11:19fault. Even when it's his fault, Hashem also brings it to him sometimes in oness to be mechaper for this.11:27V'chen yitaken acherim chot'im. And not only that, sometimes11:29a person אומר, Look, I never had this,11:31Baruch Hashem, I'm a tzaddik since I was born.11:34I never had this issue in my life.11:35I never had such a thing, and yet he sees it in11:38oness. He says, yet sometimes you, or the person who gets this oness of zera levatala in a dream,11:43when it's mamash oness, it could be also not only for himself, to be fixing himself,11:48but to fix other people as well.11:51As is known, שיחיד ששב מוחלין לו בכל העולם כולו. There's a famous Gemara, Masechet, I believe it's Masechet Kiddushin,12:00but it's probably Masechet Yoma, more likely,12:01and I see over here that they're putting the note it's Masechet12:03Yoma. In any case, the Gemara, Masechet Yoma says that12:07יחיד ששב, if an individual does teshuva, they're not only forgiven, but they forgive the whole world.12:12Which, on a simple level, on simple understanding, really it's hard to12:17understand. What does that mean? I did teshuva, why should they forgive the world?12:20And so there's some people that don't have the ability to do12:23teshuva; they're not on the level.12:24Yet when you do teshuva and you're a tzaddik, and you are sincere in your12:29teshuva, it has the power to save also other people as well from, or to fix other people's sins as well.12:37That's the meaning of Chazal, that your teshuva could actually influence other people's teshuva as well.