Torah · MussarMussar121. Why the Sin of ז״ל Is Not Mentioned in TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 121Rabbi Uri Nahum · October 30, 2022−15Play+30Position0:009:18Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzedkat HaTzadik, ot kuf chaf alef, 121.0:04A little bit of a shorter piece.0:07Says the Rav Tzadok,0:07Bechol haTorah kulah lo nizkar befeirush avon dehotzaat zera0:12levatala. In the whole entire Torah, there's no mention of the sin of0:17hotzaat zera0:19levatala. Rak nizkar0:23shena'enshu Dor HaMabul ve'Er veOnan. The only thing that was mentioned is that0:25Dor HaMabul was punished0:27and Er and Onan.0:28Happens to be when we're recording this,0:30it happens to be it's right after Parashat Noach,0:32so we know we're fresh from Dor0:36HaMabul. And in Dor HaMabul, although it says that0:37they were punished, but it says their punishment.0:40Why? Because0:42they were0:43the0:46aretz vatimaleh ha'aretz chamas. But it doesn't say actually what the Gemara says in0:49Niddah, that the punishment of0:51Dor0:52HaMabul was because of zera0:55levatala. Er and Onan, they married Tamar,0:56or they both married Tamar.0:59One did it lechatchila, one did it as a yibum, it seems like,1:02and they were killed.1:04But why? Just because1:05they were ra b'einei Hashem.1:07But it doesn't actually say it.1:09Now, in the brackets he brings a side point.1:10He says, Veyadua de'Ein hu nitzotz Mashiach.1:13He says it's known,1:15I didn't know this, but now we know it,1:17that Er, the son of1:20Yehuda, the one who, you know,1:21Er and Onan were the two kids of Yehuda that married Tamar1:23and they died, like it says in1:25Parashat Vayeshev, Er was actually a spark of Mashiach.1:28She'paam rishon la'olam, that this is the first time that actually Mashiach soul came to the world.1:34Ba letaken avon deDor HaMabul, le'ayein ma1:36shekatavti le'Er, and he came to fix1:37the sin of Dor1:39HaMabul. I'm actually realizing that I might have said the word1:41Dor HaMidbar. I meant to1:42say Dor HaMabul till now.1:44So it's an interesting thing1:46that he says that really1:48we know Dor HaMabul's sin1:50was zera1:51levatala, and Er actually came—1:53To redeem that generation,1:55he came, I guess it seems to be like a soul,1:57but he was the first time that Mashiach appeared in the world2:00was2:01Aher, right? Interesting idea.2:03But anyway, it seems like he messed up specifically in that.2:06And even though it seems to be like a light sin,2:08but he was killed for it.2:09But I guess now we can understand,2:11with his lofty soul,2:12he was held on a higher, higher level.2:16Anyway, he comes to explain2:18now why does the Torah not mention2:20the sin.2:23He says he couldn't2:24expressively,2:26he couldn't express and write the sin2:28straight out,2:34because since Hashem put it part of nature,2:37is that this could happen to a2:40person even b'ones, even against his will,2:42like we know that2:43a person could get this in his sleep.2:49And if so,2:50if there would be such a terrible sin2:52that would be straight out written in the2:54Torah and how bad it is,2:56people will flip out, basically.2:58Oh, hey, what's going on?2:59It's like you're trapped.3:01It has to happen, and it's going to happen3:04inevitably,3:05and it could happen even without your control,3:08and it will cause basically3:10a big uproar. People can't handle it.3:18The Torah left it for people3:20to understand it on their own.3:22When the Torah says that the command3:24was given to all humanity3:25that a person has to attach to his wife,3:30as opposed to,3:33with the ... and3:37Chazal tells, v'lo b'eshet chaveiro, right? You have to be with your3:38wife, and that's it, only with your3:39wife and nobody else.3:42You should understand from it3:44that if a person is together3:46not with his wife,3:47which we already saw clearly3:50that's an aveirah. Any time that you're3:52together with anybody or anything without your wife,3:54that'll be3:55a problem.3:59And we know about the4:02mitzvot of Bnei Noach. Let's just go quickly over the4:04mitzvot Bnei Noach, and not everybody's familiar with it.4:06When Hashem created the world,4:07He gives Adam six commandments.4:09People are not familiar with4:10that, but the Gemara says in4:13Masechet Sanhedrin, I believe daf nun-tet, it says over4:15there—you can look it4:16up—and it's doresh on the pasuk,4:17Vayetzav Elokim et4:20ha'adam, right? And over there, the Gemara discusses4:22exactly the six4:24mitzvot. Once the world was destroyed through the mabul4:27and Noach emerged from the4:29teivah, Hashem reviews the mitzvot with him,4:31and He adds one more4:33mitzvah, and that is4:34ever min hachai. What are the seven4:36mitzvot Bnei Noach? The easiest way to remember them is4:40the famous three4:41that every Jew has to give up4:43his life on:4:43giluy arayot, shefichut damim,4:46and avodah zarah—basically adultery,4:49idolatry, and murder.4:51And then4:52alef, bet, gimel, dalet.4:54That's how you remember the other four4:56mitzvot. Alef is4:58ever min hachai. Bet is—which means you cannot take a5:01limb, you cannot eat from a limb of an animal5:04while the animal is still alive.5:06You have to wait until the animal completely dies5:07to be able to eat a limb from the animal.5:10This is even from5:11Bnei Noach. Bet is birkat Hashem.5:13No human is allowed to do the opposite5:16of blessing Hashem. That's why we use5:18this language, birkat Hashem;5:19it really means the opposite.5:21Gimel is gezel, stealing.5:24All forms of stealing are forbidden to all5:26humanity, even if you live in New York City5:27and you're stealing under a thousand dollars, it's still5:30assur. And dalet is5:32dinin, judgments,5:33which means you have to set up courts.5:35It has to be a judicial system5:37in the world for all5:39humanity. These are the seven5:43mitzvot Bnei Noach. The Torah itself has5:45613 mitzvot, yet these seven mitzvot came5:47to all humanity beforehand.5:49Chazal tell us a concept5:51in Pirkei Avot,5:52derech eretz5:55kadmah laTorah. Okay, simply means that before you come to5:57even do the mitzvot of Torah, you need to have5:59a little bit of decency and6:01manners. That's a simple understanding.6:02But Rav Tzadok applies it also over here6:05to the seven6:06mitzvot Bnei Noach. Seven mitzvot Bnei Noach are more like derech eretz.6:08It's a common rule of all humanity6:10across the board. Everybody has to6:13follow these rules, but not just6:14because God said so,6:16but really this is a logical6:19thing that everybody should follow, just like6:21manners. It's decency that everybody6:23accepts.6:26V'chein davar zeh gam ken miderech eretz. So too,6:27zeh habattalah is actually part6:29of derech eretz as well.6:33Deyeda me'atzmo she'eino miderech eretz laasot ken. If you think about it,6:35even though a person gets enjoyment6:37from such a sin,6:39but not every enjoyment is mutar.6:41It's much easier for me6:43to steal from someone than to6:45work hard for something, and I enjoy it6:47much more. Does that give me the permission to steal?6:49Absolutely not.6:51So now6:52logic tells me that6:55if I really use my logic6:57and I'm fair, is that I cannot6:59steal from any person.7:01Any person. You don't have to be a7:02Jew to know that. You don't have to be7:05a learned person to know that. It's a logical7:07thing. Derech eretz7:08means the way of the land. Every person7:11will acknowledge and recognize7:13and admit that this7:15is the way a person7:17should live. You should not be stealing7:19from anybody else. And that's7:21what he says over here, that these mitzvot really7:23are considered like derech eretz, and so7:25is7:28zeh habattalah. Yes, it's7:29enjoyable, but who cares if it's enjoyable?7:31At the end of the day, it's not proper.7:34Not proper.7:35It's a wrong thing to do. And in fact,7:38people who7:41really are7:42honest with themselves will recognize7:43that it's really not proper.7:45Again, it's basically saying7:47you could figure it out.7:49You see, animals don't do such a thing.7:51Even animals, like I said,7:52gashmiyut and materialistic7:54don't do such a thing.7:57And therefore, to do7:58such a thing, you're—8:00Really, going out of the normal way.8:03Now, normal is not based on what people do, normal of what the goal and the purpose of life is.8:09Now, he says over here an interesting thing.8:13He says that's why we find8:16a halacha in Masechet Berachot, it's a side point, one of those bracket things.8:19He says that Baal Keri is not allowed to learn Torah in the times when Chazal made a8:23takanah, it was called tevilat Ezra until he dips in the8:27mikveh. A Baal Keri was allowed to learn, though, derech eretz.8:30Why? Because this is something that he needs a little bit of derech eretz. Interesting side point.8:34Hinei derech eretz kadma laTorah, and we know derech eretz8:37kadma laTorah, and it says in8:42Tanah d'Vei Eliyahu, נקרא דרך ארץ, דרך ארץ החיים, עיין שם, ושאין בו דרך ארץ אי אפשר להגיע. If you don't have this basic decency,8:46basically what he's saying is that you could recognize this thing on your own,8:49basic decency that this is not how a person is supposed to live.8:54A person is supposed to live with, like we said, derech eretz,8:58that's the way of the land, what's proper, and to recognize that this is not the way9:02Hashem wants the world. Even animals don't do such a thing.9:07And with that recognition, he could figure it out.9:10And that's why the Torah doesn't mention it. You could figure it out. You can learn it on your own.9:14If you think about it, you'll know that it's wrong.