Torah · MussarMussar120. The Downside of KiruvTzidkat HaTzadikPart 120Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 2, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:45Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:02Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf chaf. I would like to preface the piece of Rav Tzadok today by telling you an important concept0:12that we find in the Torah, we find in a lot of places, and especially in the Chafar world0:18of kiruv today, that Baruch Hashem there are a lot of people that are far from Torah and0:23a lot of great people that work to bring them closer to the Torah.0:28So, I've heard this from many people, and they said a beautiful idea. They said that0:33kiruv is like the kohen who is busy with the0:38parah adumah. What's the story there?0:40Parah adumah, we know, is you take basically a red cow, completely red cow. I'm not going0:45into the details of what kind of cow it has to be, and you take it and you burn it, and0:50from its ashes you mix it with water, and then with that water mixed with the ashes, you0:53sprinkle it on a person who's tameh met, a person who's come in contact with a dead0:59body, in the same room as a dead body. Move the dead body doesn't make a difference,1:02and that way he becomes tahor.1:06Okay?1:07Now, the thing is, the kohen who's dealing with this, he himself becomes tameh. Not as1:12tameh as the person who's tameh met. That means the person1:15who's tameh met is tameh for seven days, and he has to undergo a whole process of, you know, taharah through the1:21parah adumah. The person who's, or second parah adumah, the person who mixes the water with ashes on1:26parah adumah, that kohen becomes tameh, but only for one day, and he just has to dip,1:31and he's already back to being tahor.1:34So, I've heard this statement in the past, a very true statement, and Rav Tzadok is1:39going to reiterate it over here in his own style, with his own proofs, is that kiruv1:47is like the kohen1:50who's— The people are working kiruv. That means, in order to make somebody else tahor, you have1:55to become tamei to become tahor. It's impossible. You have to become tamei. Even1:59though you're osek, your whole business is to try to make somebody else pure and tahor,2:04but inevitably you're going to get some sort of2:07tumah. Same thing, kiruv. You have to understand, if you're working kiruv, it's inevitable that2:12you will get a little bit of the other guy, right?2:15Sometimes it's scary. Some people get lost. They're working kiruv, and then instead of them2:20bringing the people far closer, the people far bring them further, right?2:25But we're not talking about that extreme. We're talking about anybody. It's just a reality.2:31I mean, I've been involved a little bit in the past, and I'll tell you that, you2:34know, you sit there with certain people, and they're very far, and they're telling you stories2:38of what they're doing, and, you know, you're not used to hearing this kind of garbage, and you're2:43not used to hearing about this kind of things, and they're telling you their sins, and, like,2:46it contaminates the soul.2:50So that's the kiruv.2:51Kiruv, you become like the para adumah, the kohen working the2:55para adumah. Rav Tzadok, like we said in this piece, says the same idea.2:59I'm prefacing this because, remember I told you in the past that brackets, we try to do3:05them if we could, but if we can't do them, it's because, you know, sometimes it's a little bit3:10out of, you know, a little bit off the subject, a little bit the same idea but a little bit3:13on a different point.3:14So there's a few brackets over here within brackets, believe it or not.3:18So we're going to skip that, for those who are following in the book.3:21That's only because it's going to throw us off a little bit.3:24So, but we try to focus on the subject.3:26He says like this:3:31Mi shemezakeh lechayavaya, אי אפשר שלא יידבק בו מאומה. A person who is mezakeh harabim... Mizakeh, not just the rabim, excuse me. He's3:38mizakeh people that have aveirot. That means a person who's basically working kiruv.3:43It's impossible that none of the stuff of the aveirot or the tumah of the other guy is3:49gonna, you know, not get stuck3:54to him. Okay, ... someone should go to be bin. Like the mashal that Chazal give about a person who cleans pipes.4:00Bibin is pipes, right? Pipes.4:02So what happens if you're cleaning the pipes under your sink, or if you're cleaning the4:08sewer? You're gonna smell.4:10Hold on,4:11I am the cleaning guy.4:13I've been called here to clean the pipes.4:16Yeah, but you're gonna smell.4:17That's the way it works.4:19You're just around dirt, you're gonna smell.4:21So that's the same thing.4:23You're cleaning up this person's neshama.4:25That's what I'm saying, but you're gonna smell.4:27That's the reality.4:29So it's impossible.4:30That's what he's saying.4:30It's impossible.4:31And he says, how does that affect the person?4:36That connection actually could actually bring the person to seeing Keri,4:41כמו שאמרו, like Chazal tell us about that story that we mentioned in the past,4:45about this certain4:46chassid. Remember that story with that certain chassid, that he went to redeem this girl, and when4:51he came back, he went to sleep and basically he saw tumat Keri, and he had to go to4:57the mikveh the next day.4:58So it says over there, when he's telling his students the story, he says,5:05מפני טורח הדרך, לסדות אותה ריבה. He actually, the reason why he got Keri is because of the exertion or the tiredness that5:11he experienced when he had to go do redemption, to redeem this girl, to buy her back from5:17the goyim that kidnapped her.5:21Now, this is a Gemara in Masechet Shabbat. Bat Abot Rabina Tan, which is a kind of Midrash,5:28you could call it, a Tosefta. It brings the story, and it sheds more light on the story.5:35It tells us more details.5:36It says in Abot5:40Rabina Tan, Perek Chet, shehidbil la-ribah. He actually took this girl and he made her dip also.5:45Why? Because this girl was living amongst the goyim.5:48She was kidnapped by the goyim,5:50and she was doing averot like the goyim.5:53And there is a certain halacha that a person goes off the derech, when he comes back5:56he has to5:56dip. So he actually was mezakeh this girl, was trying to help this girl purifying her.6:02And what happened?6:05He himself, it kind of clung on to him.6:09It attached to him.6:10And because her averot, he was trying to help her clean her6:14averot, so a little bit came on him, and that led him to6:17carry. Rav Tzadok says a beautiful explanation for those who, you know, are knowledgeable in this area of6:23Shas, will appreciate much more.6:26Ma she'ein ken Elisha.6:27But we find a person that actually it says about him he was a kadosh,6:31and that was the student of Eliyahu Hanavi, Elisha.6:34And it says about him that he himself did not6:39carry. The Gemara actually points out that when Elisha used to visit that lady that he used to stay by6:46in the name of a special hotel,6:48the lady of the house tells her husband that6:51I know this man that comes to our house is a holy man.6:54And the Gemara says, How in the world does she know that he is holy?6:56So the Gemara explains that she never—there were a few different opinions.7:00According to one opinion, she never saw carry on his7:05bed sheet. Now why would she see carry on his7:06bed sheet? In those days, they didn't have pajamas.7:08They would sleep actually without any clothing.7:10So if a person who travels, normally she would, you know, guests come in,7:14she has to change the bedsheet.7:15She sees carry is on the bedsheet.7:18But for Elisha, she never saw carry on his bedsheet.7:21She says, This guy must be a holy man.7:22They didn't know it was Elisha, who was, who as we know him today,7:25who was a big tzaddik, the son of Eliyahu7:27Hanavi. But she knew one thing:7:28he is a holy man.7:31She didn't see it on his7:32bedsheets. Now that connects, he says, very well with what we're saying,7:37with what Rav Tzadok has been saying till now.7:39We told you that if you're osek b'kiruv, if you're trying to be mezakeh the sinners,7:43some of it will cling on to you, and it will eventually lead you to7:48carry. So if Elisha never saw carry, even by accident,7:53it's because it must be he wasn't involved in it,7:55and the Chazal tell us actually, a little bit of a criticism on Elisha, shemadcheh b'stein yadayim.8:00It says about Elisha, actually, when Gehazi, who was his shamash, you could say,8:06when Elisha discovered what Gehazi was doing, he pushed him away with two8:11yadayim, criticizing Elisha that, you know, look, when certain times you have to distance a person,8:17do with your left arm, but the right arm should bring him closer.8:20But don't push him away completely. Elisha pushed him away completely.8:24So he didn't want to deal with sinners, and that's why for him it says about8:28him, he never saw Keri in his life.8:35But Chazal do tell us, don't be like Elisha in that matter.8:39Don't be like Elisha, and focus only on your holiness only, and not try to be mezakeh others.8:51As we just told you, Chazal say in their own words,8:57if you have to push away somebody, at times you have to. You know,9:01if some person is out of line, you have to put him in his place.9:04So the left represents gevurah, push him. It's also the weak hand,9:07but the right hand, which is stronger, represents chesed. That should bring him closer.9:13That's basically put more emphasis on bringing people closer than pushing people away.9:17Now, and Chazal tell us, not like Elisha who pushed away Gehazi.9:25And right afterwards, Chazal tells the same thing of how to deal with the9:29yetzer hara. Very interesting, right? And that's what Rav Tzadok wants to connect,9:33that it's not just two random statements. These two statements that Chazal put,9:37that come after each other, actually connected to each other.9:40And it says also, when it comes to dealing with the yetzer hara also,9:47you should... Pushu, with the yetzer, but you left him, but make him closer to you.9:54Work with him to utilize his kochot, his energies, in a positive way.10:01Whereas in Elisha, Elisha היה גם כן ימין דוחה. Elisha was different. Elisha actually, even his right hand, he pushed away.10:08Ve'af she'amru, טוב מאוד זה יצר הרע. And even though Chazal tell us—now one second—when Hashem created the world,10:12it says every time He created something, it says,10:15Vayar Hashem ki tov. Whatever He created, He saw that was good. At the conclusion of the creation of the world,10:22it says, Vayar Hashem et kol asher asah, vehineh tov me'od. Chazal tell us on these words, when it says in the Torah10:25that Hashem saw everything He did and it was very good, what was very good?10:30Chazal say, Ze yetzer hara. This is referring to yetzer hara. Yetzer hara is very good. What's going on over here?10:35Told me, push him away a little bit on the side. What's going on?10:40It depends. It depends on the person.10:44That's what he's telling you. Sometimes you have to embrace the10:46yetzer hara. Sometimes you have to push it away. You have to push it with the left hand,10:49but you have to push it away.10:54So he says, ויש בדעתו להכניע, ולהיות דוחה לגמרי, ויש בדעתו להפכה. It all depends on the person. Some people, they know how to work with the11:01yetzer hara, and some people will have to destroy it. They can't work with11:04them. I'm going to give you two examples from11:07Chazal, and then hopefully we'll try to make it a little bit more practical.11:11Example number one from11:16Chazal. The two examples, actually, let me compare them:11:18Abraham Avinu versus11:21David HaMelech. Chazal tell us that Abraham Avinu worked with the11:26yetzer hara. He actually used the yetzer hara in a positive way.11:34Like it says, Ve'ahavta et Hashem Elokecha bechol levavcha, bishnei yetzarecha. If to love Hashem with all your heart,11:36it doesn't say with your heart, levavcha, the way it's supposed to be spelled.11:39It says levavcha, double bet.11:41Chazal tell us because you have to love Hashem not only with the11:44yetzer hatov, which is naturally tending to love Hashem,11:48but you also have to11:51love Hashem. With the11:52yetzer hara. I'd like to use one of my rabbeim in yeshiva, Rabbi Berger,11:55who told me a beautiful example.11:57He says if Avraham got the urge to play pool,12:00because at the time, you know, as a young12:04bachur, you know, sometimes you want to go play pool, the billiards,12:06right? She says if Avraham wanted to play billiards,12:09this is not the best place for a yeshiva bachur to be,12:11you know, with the TV screens all around.12:13What would he do? He would go to the billiards and be mekarev people.12:16If he got the urge to eat, he would invite people and teach them about Birkat Hamazon.12:21Right? Understand? He uses the yetzer hara to love Hashem.12:26The Gemara says in12:28Zevachim that David HaMelech had a different trait.12:30David HaMelech, in Tehillim, says about himself,12:32V'libi chalal b'kirbi. He completely destroyed the12:36yetzer hara, completely destroyed the12:38yetzer hara. Nothing. He says, My heart is hollow. Nothing. I completely killed him.12:42So that's what Rabbi Tzadok is saying. He says it depends on the person.12:44Some people, like Avraham, will work together with the12:48yetzer hara, will embrace the12:49yetzer hara, will bring him closer. Like we said,12:52small is docha, you have to know, you can't completely follow the12:55yetzer hara, but you have to be12:56mekarev him, and, you know, work with him.12:58And then others that say, One second, we're not working together.13:03You understand? The yetzer hara, you and I are not buddies.13:05Avraham will call you yetzer, you're buddies with him.13:07Me and you don't get along, and we'll destroy the13:11yetzer hara. You have to completely go against him. Two different natures.13:14We find this also by Yehoshua and13:17Kalev, with the way they dealt with the whole story of the spies and the13:21meraglim. Yehoshua went head on against the13:24meraglim, and Kalev says, No, guys, come on, it's not so bad.13:29You know, he worked on it. He tried to work with them at least.13:31So how does this apply to us?13:32So you have to know your nature. You have to know yourself.13:34There's some people that actually could use those powers of the13:40yetzer hara in a positive way.13:42There are people who— You know, may not love such Jewish ideas.13:48There are people that could twist them.13:50You know, sometimes I listen to certain music.13:51I know exactly where it came from. It came from garbage.13:54It came from total garbage songs.13:57But for some people, that's what they need.13:58They can take that song and kind of turn it around.14:01Other people, if there's no good music to listen to,14:05I will listen to any music. It all depends on the person.14:07It all depends on your nature,14:08where you could handle. And by the way, it's not like that for the rest of your life.14:12It could be you could handle it now. You can't handle it now, and you need to work with it.14:15And then when you get to a certain level, you say, you know, I don't need this anymore.14:19And everybody has to know themselves.14:21And you have to know that some people that just stay away from every bad person.14:25And there's other people that say, no,14:28let me bring them closer.14:30Let me take those bad people and be mekarev them.14:32You have to know yourself and your nature, and you have to know how to work with it14:36and use your energies and talents that Hashem has given you14:39to serve HaKadosh Baruch Hu in the best way.