Torah · MussarMussar117. Lust vs. AngerTzidkat HaTzadikPart 117Rabbi Uri Nahum · October 28, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:46Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kof yud zayin.0:05In today's piece, it's a very nice, interesting piece about nature of people,0:10what they have and what they have to be on the lookout for.0:12I love those kind of pieces where you get a revelation into yourself,0:17and of course at the same time, it brings out some beautiful, beautiful explanations0:22and a new light to some familiar Gemarot. Let's begin.0:27Kol mi she'naki mechet'ei hataavah. A person who finds himself that he is clean from the sin of0:32taavah. Either he worked on himself to control himself, or by nature he's not so pulled after0:38taavah as you see other people are.0:41You know, there are people are born like that.0:43You know, everybody has their yetzer hara in some area.0:45And as a side point, I'd like to just point out, sometimes you may hear a class,0:49not necessarily this class, I'm talking about any class,0:51and, you know, the rabbi is speaking about a certain0:56yetzer hara, or you may read about a certain yetzer hara, and you say,0:58Baruch Hashem, I don't have it.1:00So you should just know, everybody's got a1:03yetzer hara. Everybody's got a yetzer hara somewhere.1:05In some areas it's stronger than others.1:07So this is what the Rav Tzadok is saying over here,1:11that if you find yourself that you're clean from this kind of yetzer hara, he says,1:21Tzarich shemirah yeteirah b'inyanei kaas v'rotzchah. Then you have to be careful with another yetzer hara, which is actually much stronger.1:27You need an extra protection for yourself by anger and by killing,1:33because shehu alul lahem, because you're more likely to be pushed towards that.1:40V'keyadua d'lo tirtzach v'lo tin'af hein shnei hafachim, v'hem yamin u'smol bara. As is known, on the Luchot there's commandments, the Ten Commandments.1:45On the right side, it's the commandment between one and five, that's between us and Hashem,1:50and on the left side, between numbers six to ten, it's between human beings to each other.1:56So number six is lo tirtzach, do not kill,1:59and number seven is lo tin'af, which is not to commit adultery.2:05So the Rav Tzadok explains that these two are actually— You know, anti each other.2:14So if you're clean from the lo tin'af, number seven, you probably are more likely,2:20you're more prone to the yetzer hara of2:25lo tirtzach, which is basically, you say, I'm not a murderer.2:28Yeah, I've killed cockroaches before, but I'm not a2:30murderer. Yeah, but the same yetzer hara of kaas and retzichah, that's all under the same thing.2:36He brings on the side point, he says,2:40we know Yeravam ben Nevat, which is called Ephrati. We know Yeravam ben Nevat was the first king to be2:44the ruler—excuse me—the first person to be the ruler of the ten tribes in the Northern Kingdom,2:47in Malchut Yisrael,2:49and he eventually became the example the Chazal use as a person who has led the Jewish people to do2:56aveirot. Now he came from Shevet Ephraim, which is from Yosef.2:59He was called Ephrati, pashut pshat, because he came from Ephraim.3:04No, רצה3:06לומר שלא עקרים מהם. Ephrati is also because he came from Yosef,3:10and Yosef was a person who exemplified the trait of3:16self-control and, you know, holding back on3:21ta'avot. And Chazal tell us, or3:23mefarshim explain, that he never saw3:24keri b'yamav. V'shem imo Tzeruah, and the pasuk mentions that his mother was called3:28Tzeruah. What does it mean?3:29היא שורש של לא כעס, which is from3:34kaas, tzaruah, anger that speaks lashon hara and all these things.3:36So he's bringing this point out to show you that, you see,3:40that when one is clean with one, he's got to be careful with the other one.3:43You know, the guy who's not tempted3:46with ta'avot, you know, but he loves money, he loves to steal from people3:50and, you know, rip off people or lie.3:51So you have to be careful in every and all areas.3:54But he's telling me more this, more right now.3:57What he's telling us is that we have to be extra vigilant4:01when we see we're clean from, what's it called,4:06from ta'avot, we have to be extra vigilant when it comes to anger.4:08By the way, it works the other way.4:10If you are a person that is very calm and chilled out,4:15you know, those people, it's very hard to get you angry,4:17then you got to be careful also from4:19taavot, because from taavot you can see yourself a little bit more,4:21you can discern it a little bit more.4:23Angry people justify, so that's why it's not so noticeable.4:31Ubaba Metzia, right, brings a story from Baba Metzia.4:33If we're not familiar, maybe I should say this story.4:36So I'm going to say this story even though he's not going to bring it immediately.4:40Let's start with the story.4:41The Gemara tells us about Rabbi Yochanan and4:45Reish Lakish. In short, Rabbi Yochanan, Reish Lakish we know used to be4:50listim. Listim is usually translated as a robber,4:53but listim could also be a murderer, a gangster,4:56a person who kills in order to rob,4:58and he kills people in order to get their items.5:01And Reish Lakish discovers Rabbi Yochanan.5:04Rabbi Yochanan discovers Reish Lakish. Either way,5:07and basically he brings him back5:10in teshuva, and he ends up marrying Rabbi Yochanan's sister.5:12And Rabbi Yochanan was a very, very good-looking person.5:15Now the Gemara tells us at the end of his life how Reish Lakish passed away.5:19The Gemara says that Reish Lakish and Rabbi Yochanan were actually5:22chavruta, they learned together for many years,5:24and they were able to really bring out so much, so much Torah.5:28Anybody who is familiar with the Gemara knows5:31how often Rabbi Yochanan and Reish Lakish are mentioned.5:34And the story is that at the end,5:38each one of them passed away.5:40They were once learning,5:40and they came across a machloket when it comes to a certain knife.5:45And Rabbi Yochanan makes a comment,5:46says, Of course you would know,5:47because you're a gangster.5:50So Reish Lakish gets offended.5:52He says, So what did I gain by being religious?5:55Over there they called me, you know, Rabbi, which is basically the leader,5:58and over here they call me Rabbi,5:59so what's the difference if I'm still considered a gangster?6:02Rabbi Yochanan understood that Reish Lakish is regretting6:05coming to the world of Torah,6:07and therefore he looks at him in a certain way,6:09and he ends up killing him.6:12Now, it seems to be as he's dying,6:14or just right there,6:17right, his sister, Rabbi Yochanan's sister,6:19who is the wife of6:20Reish Lakish, comes and begs her brother,6:23please forgive him.6:24We know that a talmid chacham who gets angry,6:26it means a lata Hashem,6:28and therefore Hashem does for him a lot of things.6:30So she said, Please forgive him,6:31and he refused to forgive him.6:33And then Reish Lakish is dead and he's buried.6:35But now Rabbi Yochanan was left without a6:37chevruta. It says he was left without a6:39chevruta; he was suffering tremendously.6:40And his students got him different people to learn with,6:43and they weren't even comparable to6:46Reish Lakish, not because they didn't know so much,6:47but Reish Lakish would argue everything out,6:49and that's how really Torah was developed.6:52And these other6:54chevrutot would actually be supporting Rabbi Yochanan,6:57and he didn't like that.6:58Eventually he suffered so much that his students had to pray7:01that Rabbi Yochanan himself should pass away7:03so he should stop suffering.7:06This was—this is the story that the Gemara brings about7:09Reish Lakish's first encounter with Rabbi Yochanan7:12and his final encounter.7:15Now, this story,7:16that's when Reish Lakish passes away,7:19is brought right after the following statement the Gemara.7:21The Gemara,7:23... brings and says over there7:25about the beauty of certain people,7:26and the Gemara says7:27some very beautiful people in the world.7:30If you want to know the beauty7:35of—listen to what it says.7:36It says the beauty7:43of Rabbi Yochanan is me'ein beauty of Yosef HaTzadik. The beauty of Rabbi Yochanan7:45is from the beauty of Yosef7:48HaTzadik. Simply, Rabbi Yochanan was a very good-looking person,7:50like Yosef7:52HaTzadik. He says over here,7:56Veyofi hatoar b'chol makom, mashma tebilit. Says the7:58Tzadok, when the Gemara describes somebody as beautiful.8:00We're not here to tell you, you know, it's not a GQ magazine to tell you who is more handsome and who should be on the front cover.8:06No. It's coming to tell you the yofi, the description of a person is beautiful in Chazal and the Torah refers to that the person is8:16shomer haberit. The person is careful in that area of8:18brit milah, like we explained above. If you remember in אות צד ו, Rav Sadok already discussed this when he talks about over there that anybody who is shomer haberit has the title of8:30yefe toar. That's why Yosef is described as a person who's yefe toar. As a side point,8:35the Chassidim bring down also that a person who is very careful with shmirat haberit doesn't wrinkle so easily.8:44It's an interesting idea.8:45In any case, so he says, now8:51that's Rabbi—what's called, that's Rabbi Yochanan.8:53V'achar kach, ne'emar alav d'atimizahadi Yosef,8:56and then the Gemara says actually Rabbi Yochanan himself actually is a descendant from Yosef9:01HaTzadik. V'achar kach,9:02ha'inyan she'ra'ah... Then the Gemara brings the story of who?9:06Of Reish Lakish and Rabbi Yochanan, how Reish Lakish ended up dying because he upset Rabbi Yochanan.9:11Why?9:16Because he didn't want to forgive.9:17Where did that come from?9:18Because of the anger.9:20How can a person not want to forgive?9:21When do you not forgive?9:22When you're very upset and he's very, very angry.9:25Where does that come from?9:26Well, we find something called9:31ritcha deoraita, Chazal talk about in Masechet Ta'anit, that a person, when a talmid chacham gets angry, it's the fire of the Torah that gets him all angry.9:36Now he explains9:39it's the same idea exactly as a proof of what we just said.9:42This is why Rav Tzadok is bringing it.9:44You see from here that a person who is careful9:47with shmirat haberit, like Rabbi Yochanan, who came from Yosef, who is described as beautiful,9:51which means he's shomer haberit. Who's careful, who's far from9:55ta'avot, is also a person that is more prone to anger,9:59and that's why the Gemara brings such a story to show you the flip side of it,10:04what a person has to be careful with.10:06And he goes into10:10this a little bit more. In fact, this is not only by10:12Reish Lakish. We find that Rabbi Yochanan did this to a few people.10:13We know Rabbi Yochanan, Gemara tells us, when he got very old, his eyelids were so heavy he couldn't see,10:18couldn't see.10:19So what they would do for him to see, they have to bring some silver spoons or forks to, like, lift up.10:24That's how heavy they were.10:26But when he taught, he's not blind, but they just, they covered and he couldn't see.10:30So the Gemara brings the story of Rabbi Yochanan and of Kahana.10:35For those who don't know, I'm not going to go through the entire story,10:37but I'm just going to tell you the details that we need to know.10:39Rav Kahana basically lived in Bavel, and Rabbi Yochanan lived in10:42Eretz Yisrael. Rav Kahana had to run away for whatever reason, and he ended up going to the shiur of Rabbi Yochanan.10:47Rav Kahana, along the way of running away, he scarred himself.10:52He cut himself by his lip, basically the edge of the lips,10:57and where the top and the bottom meet by the edge, by the corner of his mouth.11:02And the scar made it look like he's always smiling, he's always laughing.11:06So when he came to Rabbi Yochanan, he sat in the11:09shiur, and he was seated almost right in front of Rabbi Yochanan,11:12and he was challenging Rabbi Yochanan. And, you know, Rabbi Yochanan was very impressed,11:17wanted to see who this person was.11:18He never heard him before, and he was a newcomer, really.11:21He just came from Bavel.11:21When they lifted up his eyelids to see, he looked up, Kahana,11:25and he appeared to be like as if he's laughing at him,11:29like, Ha, ha, ha, I told you, you don't know what you're talking about.11:31And Rabbi Yochanan again gets upset and ends up also killing Rav Kahana in the same way.11:37Not that he actually meant to kill him, but he got upset and he got angry at him,11:40and he ended up dying.11:41So he says,11:46This is something that also, as Chazal tell us, this is, you're also punished and you kill.11:52That's a statement that Chazal make to somebody who, you know, because of him people get punished.11:58So that's... Rabbi Yochanan,12:00you see Rabbi Yochanan had this trait of killing, and it fits very well12:03because he was a person who was beautiful,12:05and beautiful is a description we give to12:11somebody which .... V'af al gav d'hadar banahu tab, bechol zot, ... now you can say, anger of the chachamim is a good thing.12:15It says in the Zohar, and like we just said in the Gemara also in12:19Masechet Taanit, it's the fire of the Torah.12:26De'oraita maratcha lei, as the Gemara says. But we see over there it wasn't such a good thing,12:29because at the end of the day, what did he gain from it?12:31Two talmidei chachamim passed away from the world, and he himself even suffered.12:35Rabbi Yochanan himself suffered because he didn't end up having12:38... that brought about his death.12:44Ufi shekara lReish Lakish listaa, d'hainu rotzeach. And why did this happen?12:45All started, why?12:46Because Rabbi Yochanan called Reish Lakish a listim, which means a rotzeach, a murderer.12:56And here's where Rabbi Yochanan made the mistake,13:01is that the halacha tells us, Masechet Bava Metzia itself, earlier13:05perakim, that you're not allowed to remind a baal teshuva of his earlier bad deeds.13:10And here you mentioned Reish Lakish, Oh, he used to be a gangster.13:20And being that he was at fault of mentioning that, it actually ended up actually harming him at the end.13:25He caused Reish Lakish to die, and actually that causes own passing away as well.13:33This is the piece that Rav Tzadok wants to say,13:36that a person who's careful, or who is naturally careful with the midah of13:42taavah, has to be more vigilant and more on top of the fact that he shouldn't get angry13:47or lose it because he's more prone to it.13:49But as we told you in the past,13:52the Psakim sometimes brings in brackets side points.13:54Now, this is a totally side point, not in the subject that he wanted to speak about in this letter,14:00but it's a nice idea. I'm going to say it outside; I'm not going to read it inside.14:03Rabbi Yochanan. The question is, why did Rabbi Yochanan not want to forgive?14:06Then it's his brother-in-law, and his sister is begging him,14:08and she told him, Please, please do for me. I don't want to be14:12an almanah. He didn't want to forgive.14:13Please do for the kids; they shouldn't be14:15yetomim. He didn't want to forgive.14:16How come?14:18So he brings out a very interesting idea.14:21He says Rabbi Yochanan must have felt that his end was coming,14:23which we see clearly that his end was coming.14:26He literally passed away within a year after that.14:30It probably was even a shorter time.14:32And because he felt his end was coming,14:34he didn't want to be14:36nidcheh. There's a rule that a person who's in the position of leadership,14:40if somebody else's turn is coming,14:42then that person has to step down.14:44How does he step down?14:45Either by lo aleinu passing away or something terrible else.14:48So Rabbi Yochanan was a big tzaddik.14:50The only other way that somebody else will take the leadership position is if he passes away.14:55So he was nervous that maybe Reish Lakish would be the next,14:58according to Psakim. He says this again.15:00He says that maybe Reish Lakish would be the next leader,15:05the next Rosh15:06Yeshiva, and therefore it's putting Rabbi Yochanan in danger.15:10So the fact that now it happened—of course he didn't plan15:13this—but the fact that this happened that way,15:15he didn't want to forgive because15:16it might be putting himself now in danger,15:18and the halacha is, chayecha kodmim.15:20If there's two lives to worry about,15:22you have to worry about your life first,15:25and you don't have to forgive.15:27We find the same thing by15:29Rabbi Chanina. The Gemara brings also another story by Rabbi15:31Chanina, another rabbi, where also, where, you know, somebody was going to rule.15:35So it's the same idea.15:36So that's an interesting approach to why Rabbi Yochanan didn't want to forgive,15:40and Rabbi Psakim adds as a bonus track at the end.