Torah · MussarMussar116. Mistakes in Torah From HashemTzidkat HaTzadikPart 116Rabbi Uri Nahum · December 9, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0017:19Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק). The exact recording day is unconfirmed. The displayed date comes from the shared file.Transcript0:01Tzaddik, ot kuf tet0:04zayin. Something that's been said, the idea has been said before, but now I guess he brings it up again0:09just to get a little bit more details about it, because it's talking about divrei Torah0:15and zeal batala and how the divrei Torah is metaken that. So he says like this:0:24על ידי הטעויות שיש בדברי תורה שטועה ואחר כך אומר על האמת. By a person who makes a0:26mistake in learning Torah, and then he fixes it by relearning the subject correctly0:34and correcting himself and understanding the Torah the way it's supposed to be,0:41שזה קרוי ישעיה מכשלה. This is what Yeshaya calls0:46מכשלה, כמו שאמרו בחגיגה. Like it says in the Gemara, what's a0:48מכשלה? It's a person who makes a mistake in the true kavanah and the true meaning of the0:55Torah, לרצונו לומר דברי תורה על ידי זה, right, which is the divrei Torah.1:00So it comes out that there's something called1:03a מכשלה, that what happens is a person stumbles, like a מכשול, like a stumbling block,1:09right? A person stumbles, a person makes a mistake in understanding the Torah,1:13and then by a person who fixes that mistake—how do you fix it?1:16Very simple. When you study it and you're honest with1:20yourself and you correct yourself and you say, Although I understood it this way,1:23I'm still gonna now learn it and see what the truth is,1:26and now you accept the truth and you see that you were wrong the whole time.1:32So what happens with that? So he explains now.1:35Now the reason why we talk about this, by the way, is because1:37this is all like a flow from beforehand. We talk about1:40zeh le'umat zeh, before we talk about the power of the Torah, the power that the Torah is able to pull out souls.1:45Now he says,1:47לרצונו לומר דברי תורה על ידי זה, when a person corrects— His mistakes in divrei Torah,1:58lokeach אותם נפשות דהוצאה זרע לבטלה, שבאים מצד יצר הרע, שכאילו יש היה מכשול. The person is able to extract the neshamot, the holy souls2:04that come through zera levatala. We already explained,2:06zera levatala produces souls;2:10they have no body, so they walk around, they are just roaming. The spirits are just roaming around earth.2:16But through the Torah, a person fixes his mistakes through the2:20Torah, then actually he takes those souls back.2:23And we find that the yetzer hara for this, for the2:28zera levatala, is also called2:32a michshol, כמו שאמרו בסוכה, ומפרק הסדיקה, בעד שנדרש על... We already explained this beforehand, that the michshol refers to this2:37yetzer hara that makes a person stumble in this area of2:42zera levatala. ומכשול היינו לפני עיוור, and the michshol is specifically talking about one area2:46where a person gets it, stumbles without saying.2:51We know the2:55pasuk, לפני עיוור לא תתן מכשול, right? The Torah says, don't put a stumbling block in front of a blind person.2:58Now, it could have said,3:01לפני עיוור לא תתן אבן, because in front of a blind person, if you put a stone, he also3:04stumbled. What's3:05a michshol? Michshol refers to specifically when a person stumbles about something3:10without realization.3:12So you made a mistake, like, lemashal, I'll give you an example.3:15Let's show you an example in Torah, in the halachot, in the learning,3:20and let's show you an example also in a regular case. We'll see in a second.3:26Let's take the halacha in learning, for example.3:29A person may study a halacha, may study a subject,3:32let's say the subject of Shabbat. He studies it,3:34he studies all the melachot, he probably knows them very well,3:37but he happens to skip over the melacha of borer.3:40Now, because he didn't study the melacha of borer,3:42people ask him, Are you allowed to, like, look, I have a plate mixed with, you know, a salad,3:47all different pieces, it's all mixed together.3:49Can I just separate, you know, what I don't like? I don't like the tomatoes.3:51Can I take it out?3:52He says, Well, I know the halachot of Shabbat.3:54Of course, what's the problem with that?3:56Now he doesn't realize that there's a halachot3:58boreh; he never actually learned those halachot.4:00And one day he's opening up the sefer and he's like, Oh my gosh,4:03that's asur.4:05Maybe let me look at other books.4:06He looks at everybody. Everybody seems to agree that you can't separate4:09what you don't like, which is the tomatoes, out of the salad.4:13So that's a4:14michshol. That's specifically, that's called a machshalah or4:17michshol, because it's4:18lifnei iver. It was something that was completely concealed from you;4:21you never knew about it,4:22and you're breaking it the whole time.4:23This is a4:24michshol. The same idea of a person,4:26let's say like we gave the4:30mashal, the Torah says lifnei iver lo titen michshol, and that's referring to giving somebody advice4:33that he's unaware of.4:35For example,4:36did you know that if a person asks you for4:40a—let's give you another,4:41it's also4:43in halacha—but if you speak to somebody4:45lashon hara,4:46and that person believes your lashon hara,4:49you are4:50over, besides the speaking of lashon hara,4:53there are a whole bunch of4:57issurim that a person is over. One of them is lifnei iver lo titen michshol, because the person who heard the lashon hara from you,5:00you made him now believe it,5:01so you're the cause of somebody else stumbling.5:03He thought to trust you that you're not giving him anything5:06taref,5:07and therefore you cause another5:09Jew to sin.5:13You're over on lifnei iver lo titen michshol. So you see again,5:15michshol is specific in the case where a person is unaware.5:19Vechen zeh, and so what does that have to do with us now?5:21What does that have to do with the5:23michshol that we're talking about, zera batala? The answer is,5:25same thing over here,5:28that bechalom layla, a person who gets5:29the zera batala in his dream,5:32that's also a5:33michshol. It's without his awareness.5:40Uvadai Hashem yitbarach, al lifnei iver lo titen michshol, and says the Rav Tzadok, it can't5:41be Hashem caused this person to have this.5:43It can't be that Hashem should stumble you,5:45should put the stumbling block in front of you5:47and make you5:49over an aveirah. We know from many places,5:51Chazal, Hashem keeps the Torah.5:53Hashem puts on tefillin, in one place5:55in Chazal it says, and in another place it says,5:58the Gemara asks, if Hashem is a Kohen,5:59how is He able to bury Moshe Rabbeinu?6:01I mean to say,6:04the Gemara, Chazal, trying to portray to us that Hashem keeps the rules6:06that are mentioned in His Torah.6:08So what's the6:10pshat? How is it that this person6:11is getting this6:12michshol through his dream6:17of zeh l'vatala? Rak hu k'dei la'amod b'Torah, l'hotzi yakar mi'zolel, and the answer is,6:19it's not a stumbling block,6:20it's actually a building block.6:21It's in a way that a6:23person is able to correct himself6:25by learning Torah now6:26and correcting himself from the misunderstanding6:28of the Torah that he had.6:29He's able to now pull6:32out—he actually now has special access6:33to the world of the6:35yetzer hara, and he can pull out from there6:37a soul6:41from the world of the6:44yetzer hara, the souls that he6:45has snatched,6:46and you can pull them out.6:56And now,6:58through the learning of7:00the Torah, which is the feminine part of the7:02michshol, and7:07through the7:08zeh l'vatala that came through this dream,7:10together the combination7:12of these two now actually,7:14male and female, produce7:15a new soul that brings this soul7:18back to the7:20kedushah. And this7:22soul that has been there,7:23it also came7:25from7:29zeh l'vatala, v'hamada'a la'emet, and the reason why it came back7:31is because you corrected yourself7:34in the understanding of the Torah.7:40In other words, basically he's saying,7:43as Chazal tell us,7:44a person is unable to really7:46understand the Torah7:49until he stumbles on it.7:51Again, the terminology is used the same word,7:53nichshal, to tell you7:55that really this is the way that a person7:57is able to come out of7:59the stumbling.8:00It's by pulling, by bringing the Torah through that, basically learning the Torah and getting8:06an understanding of the right way, and pulling out those souls that unfortunately have been8:11taken away by the8:12yetzer hara. Now he goes and he explains a little bit connection why, you know, this concept is8:18totas by Yeshayahu8:19Hanavi. V'daika Yeshayahu karo kach, ken8:24mitnabeh harbeh muchshol bein ami. And davka Yeshayahu was one who gave this nevuah, and he prophesies and he says,8:29Remove the stumbling block.8:31As we know that he himself actually stumbled upon this,8:36as is known, the Brit HaLashon, Brit HaMaor Mechuvanim. Another time maybe we'll talk8:40about it a little bit more, but there are two places in the body that are considered8:45a brit.8:46There's, till now what we're talking about, which is the area of the brit milah, which8:49is known as brit8:51hamaor, and there's another one that's called brit halashon, which is the mouth,8:56the tongue, literally, but it means the mouth, the speaking.8:58And they're actually very mechuvan each other.9:01In fact, when a person is lined up and he kind of just like stands with his legs a little9:04bit split and his arms a little bit split to the sides, spread to the sides,9:09so you see that the five fingers on the arm and the five fingers on the feet, which is9:16the toes, what we call the toes, are lined up to each other, and the five and the five9:19on the left side is also lined up,9:21and then what's exactly lined up is the person's mouth and the yesod, which we call the9:28brit hamaor and brit milah.9:30They're actually lined up to each other,9:31and they're all connected.9:32They're all very, very connected.9:33That's why you could probably understand a little bit what we're saying till now, is that9:37we see that the brit milah, the tikkun for it is coming through the brit halashon, through9:42the learning of the Torah.9:43In any case, he says over here, we know that. Yeshayah actually stumbled in the lashon.9:50Where do we see this?9:51Because Yeshayah says that, I live amongst a nation that's tameh.9:57I forget exact words of the pasuk. And Chazal tell us that Yeshayah died.10:01You know how he died?10:02A very interesting way how Yeshayah died.10:05Yeshayah was actually killed because he gave a nevuah to the king at the time, who was Menashe,10:14the son of Chizkiyahu Melech.10:15And Menashe was not such a good king at that time, to put it mildly.10:19He actually executed many, many people, and he wasn't happy with what Yeshayah said, and10:24therefore he ordered his execution. And Yeshayah ran away, and they were chasing him. They went10:29to a forest, and Yeshayah said a certain name, and he changed himself into a tree.10:36So now they're in the forest, they just see trees. They don't know where Yeshayah is.10:39So he must be hiding in one of those big trees somewhere.10:41They took an axe, and they started chopping trees, and they came to the tree which was10:46actually Yeshayah, and they snatched at it, they hit it, and actually they ended up killing10:52him.10:52And where did the axe hit?10:54Right by his mouth.10:56Why?10:57Because of the words that he said.10:58So we know that Yeshayah actually stumbled with his words. And what happened afterwards, like we said, the brit11:05halashon is exactly lined up and corresponds to the brit11:12hame'or. Like that's what we explained now, and we explained beforehand, that through Torah you can be11:17metaken the brit milah.11:27Now we find places in the Chazal where they talk about a person ended up getting hurt11:33in the brit milah area. And Chazal say it was because of his mouth.11:38He brings two cases. I'm just going to tell you one of them, okay? And that is Bar11:43Deromah. Bar Deromah was this unbelievable warrior, this, like, this soldier amongst the Jewish people during11:50the Churban Bayit Sheini, as the Second Beit HaMikdash was being captured by the Romans, and he was11:56killing out the Romans like crazy, to the point that the commanding general, or the Caesar12:02actually, takes off his crown and puts it on the ground. He tells Hashem, If you don't12:05want me to do this, take my crown. I can't handle it. This Bar Deromah was a powerful12:09person.12:10He was a one-man show.12:12In any case, the Gemara says Bar Deromah, one time he says, Now come on, Hashem, why12:16don't you help us out?12:18And the Gemara says that was his downfall, when he said this word to Hashem, like, Hey,12:23help us out. Why'd you leave us alone?12:26So what happened?12:27It says one time he was going to the bathroom, and a snake came and hit him exactly where12:31he was going to the bathroom, by the brit milah area.12:34So you see it was his mouth that said it, and he was hurt through the brit milah area.12:40So again, you see that's all there. So you see it's called the mechshol, ki hu, meHashem yitbarach. It's all from12:50Hashem yitbarach, כמו שנאמר, ומיהשם מענה לשון, ומזמין לו בפה מה שאינו רוצה לדבר כלל, כי נודע בכמה מקומות. What does it mean, meHashem מענה לשון? From Hashem is the words of the tongue, as that sometimes a person13:05is deserving of something, and Hashem sets him up to say something that actually brings13:11him down.13:13Don't think that a tzaddik will get this stumble. No.13:16It's when a person is not a tzaddik and does not deserve it, and he is deserving actually of13:21a punishment, that Hashem will set him up to say something which will eventually be his13:27downfall.13:30ומהשם מענה לשון. And we know that sometimes people say things that they probably weren't mechaven to,13:34but actually that was just what brings on the downfall.13:37Just a very quick thing we find by Datan and Aviram, when they ganged up with Korach against13:45Moshe Rabbeinu, and Moshe Rabbeinu tries to make peace with them. He tells them, Come, come,13:49let's make peace. And they said, Lo na'aleh, we will not get up. And Rashi points out, they said, We13:53will not go up, because they were going down, and therefore they said, We're not going to13:56go up. And their mouth actually brought about the stumbling block.14:01That's their14:03mechshol. U'vezeh nichshal Yeshayahu, and this is exactly what happened to Yeshayahu, who was nichshal in the same thing. Shene'emar, Ki ish tameh sefatayim anochi, right? Here, what we should have said14:14right now, basically just bring it out over here. He says, I'm a person who's tameh sefatayim, and I'm sinning amongst a nation that's also14:22tameh sefatayim.14:22And Chazal tell us that when they killed him, they killed the axe hit him by the mouth, bishvil shediber ra b'nei Yisrael, because14:30he spoke bad about the Jewish people. V'nafsho tzan him etzem haTorah, because the Jewish people themselves are the Torah,14:36as we know, Kutsha Brich Hu v'Orayta v'Yisrael chad hu. The souls of the Torah are the 613 commands, I mean 600,000 letters.14:45We know, Chazal tells us that there's 600,000 letters in the Torah, and although there's14:50actually much less than 600,000, and all the mefarshim try to explain it, but we know there are 600,000 Jewish people, and that the14:59Torah always speaks about. And even though we know that there were also ladies and there were kids15:02that were younger than 20, people that were older than 60, it doesn't make a difference.15:06Still, the Torah, 600,000, you see that the Torah and the Jewish people are one and the15:11same.15:14Nimtza hu ta'ut b'deTorah. It comes out that when he spoke against the Jewish people. He said that15:18their am tamei v'ta'eh, you're really actually making a mistake in the Torah itself.15:23V'umdan be'emet hu chashv shelo nikshar rak leshaa. This is yesha'ah we're talking about over here; we got to be careful. It was15:28only a short time. However, his one-time mistake, his momentary mistake, actually was set in15:37a book, v'im divrei Noach mipi Hashem yitbarach, and it was actually divrei Noach from Hashem. That's why, even though his mistake15:47was only to the eye, because deep down he knew afterwards, obviously he knew that the Jewish15:52people are not really tamei, but it was a mistake, and his punishment came through15:57menasheh. Now why is it that he came through Menasheh?16:00Because that was Menashe's whole thing.16:05Adin Menashe, now, Menashe has to justify his killing.16:07It's like, you know, the early Reform and Conservative movements.16:11You know, when they were matir all the types of16:14issurim, they had to justify through, you know, something that, you know,16:18like they wrote teshuvot to justify the twistedness, right?16:21So Menashe also had to justify. What did he say?16:24He says he calls upon Yeshayahu, and he tells him,16:28You said this and this and that, and you're mistaken.16:30You're going against the Torah.16:33This is where you're accusing16:34Yeshayahu. You, Menashe, you were a king that slaughtered people.16:38You were a king that was not such a good king,16:40and you're coming against Yeshayahu, and you're telling him this?16:43And obviously, it's mida keneged16:46mida. That was the taanah against Yeshayahu, that Yeshayahu should hear16:50that he made a mistake.16:51He made a mistake in the Divrei Torah,16:53even though it wasn't the mistake that Menashe was talking about,16:56but that was his justification, or his excuse to kill17:00Yeshayahu, and that's the taanah of the Divrei Torah.17:02And that's why it says up, Tzadok,17:03this whole concept of bichshon ha-machshalah that Yeshayahu warns us about,17:07it came dafka from him because he's a person who experienced it and knew about it,17:11and it was from him that we learned this concept a little bit.17:15So that's why he's the one who warned us about it.