Torah · MussarMussar115. Torah Lishma vs. Torah שלא לשמהTzidkat HaTzadikPart 115Rabbi Uri Nahum · December 9, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:27Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק). The exact recording day is unconfirmed. The displayed date comes from the shared file.Transcript0:05Tzidkat haTzadik, ot kuf tet vav. We're talking about actually learning Torah.0:08This is the last couple of letters, and we continue0:11in the power that a person has when he learns Torah.0:14He says over here a beautiful idea:0:16Ki shemechadesh davar Torah.0:18A person could sometimes come up with a0:20chiddush. What's a0:21chiddush? It's a novel idea. It's a new idea,0:24a new concept that has not been brought about,0:26and everybody has really a share of his.0:29Obviously, the more you learn Torah,0:30the more you're able to connect and see how things connect0:33and come up with an idea.0:36But even if a person doesn't learn,0:38but he learns not as much, actually,0:41there's a, you know, everybody has his chelek in Torah.0:43We pray, v'ten chelkeinu b'Toratecha.0:46Let us bring our share to be able to,0:49that we should receive our share in the Torah.0:51So he says, Ki shemechadesh davar Torah,0:53when a person comes up with a chiddush in davar Torah,0:56tzarich shelo yihyeh mitzad shum1:00negi'ah balev sherotzeh kach.1:01It has to be purely for the sake of understanding Torah.1:05It cannot be for any biased reason,1:10because let's say, for example,1:11the person wants it that way.1:12Let's say it's a halacha, so he's looking for a1:15heter. Or let's say he wants to say a certain1:17chiddush because the chiddush comes out that,1:21you know, in explaining a certain concept in1:23Midot or something, that he can learn a lesson1:25that he wants to impose upon somebody else,1:28or lehitpa'erut, or to show off,1:30look how much I know,1:31or1:34lechalok al divrei zulato yotze, or other people sometimes have intention to be1:36mechadesh in order that1:37they should argue with others.1:38It cannot be from that.1:42Rak mitzad hateshukah lada'at ha'emet. It has to be purely for the desire for a1:45person to know the truth.1:46What does Hashem want?1:47What is Hashem trying to teach me here?1:51Then even if you make a1:53mistake and you really misunderstood it,1:57it's still called divrei Torah,1:58v'divrei Elokim chayim,1:59and it's the word of God.2:01And what's the proof?2:04Sheniskabel Talmud divrei haTana'im v'shent chumah halacha, shegam hava amina hu divrei Torah.2:06We see in the Gemara that sometimes we see the Gemara saying something2:11and— The Gemara knocks on, says it's incorrect thinking.2:14So why are we bringing it?2:16And yet, if a person comes and spends an entire day learning2:18just that, this is what we call the hava amina,2:20the initial stage in the Gemara of trying to find an explanation to something2:25or an answer to something.2:27And although it may eventually be knocked out through logic or through other proofs2:32or maybe even a pasuk or perhaps a2:34beraita, we bring it in the Gemara.2:36If a person just learns that alone, it's considered he learned Torah.2:38So you see that even the hava amina,2:41even the mistake in understanding the Torah,2:44is still considered divrei Torah2:46and is considered divrei Elokim Chayim.2:49Why is that so?2:54שכך יסד השם יתברך, מושכל ראשון ואחר כך הגעלה. That's how Hashem set it up.2:56There is what we call2:58מושכל ראשון. There's the original thought that a person thinks about,3:02the original idea that a person tries to get to,3:05and then the person gets to the emet.3:10וגם המושכל ראשון הוא מאשם יתברך, מדברי אלוקים חיים. And even that original thought, what we call the hava amina,3:13even the original, you know, thinking, what we thought to be correct,3:21it's also from HaKadosh Baruch Hu to get to that point.3:26אבל כשהוא מצד הנגיעה. However, that's only when your true desire is to understand Hashem's words.3:30Hashem is giving you a hava amina.3:32Hashem is letting you understand it in the wrong way. However,3:34if a person is not learning Torah for that sake,3:39a person is learning Torah for the sake of his own personal, you know, reasons,3:47he's trying to come out, he's trying to basically squeeze the Torah3:50what he wants to say,3:54אז אין לו כדברי תורה כלל, כמו שנאמר בירבעם. Right? This is not called divrei Torah,3:55like we find the pasuk applying to3:58Yeravam. Who is3:59Yeravam? Yeravam is the first king by the... Ten kingdoms.4:03This is very quickly.4:04After the death of4:05Shlomo HaMelech, his son Rechavam took over,4:07and at that point there was a person called4:11Yeravam who, whatever the incident was,4:14together with ten shevatim decided to split the Jewish kingdom,4:18and now they were divided into basically two kingdoms:4:21the kingdom of Rechavam and the kingdom of4:25Yeravam. The kingdom of Yeravam went to the north.4:29They made their capital Shomron,4:31and from there, Yeravam eventually, unfortunately,4:34although he started as a tzaddik,4:35he eventually turned into a very, very evil person,4:38to the point that he became the primary example4:42whenever Chazal or the Torah or the pasuk, excuse me,4:46in Nevi'im want to speak about a person who is a sinner4:48and makes other people sin,4:50it's always going to use4:53Yeravam ben Nevat. So it says about him in a pasuk,4:57Hachodesh asher bada milibo. He made up basically his own holiday on the fifteenth of5:01Cheshvan. The reason why he made up this5:02holiday is only that the Jewish people under his5:07kingdom should not go to Yerushalayim,5:08because he was scared if they go to Yerushalayim5:10during the real actual three mo'adim, three holidays,5:13what's going to end up happening is that5:15they might actually leave his kingdom and stay there.5:17This is the original Reform movement, basically.5:20Yeravam made up his own month and made up his own holiday.5:23The pasuk says,5:26Hachodesh asher bada milibo, the month that he made up from his own heart.5:30Uvadai, now what are you going to say?5:44Okay. Uvadai, says the Gemara, ... Uvadai hu darash להם איזה דרש ולימוד, שחג האסיף הוא בחשוון. And don't think Yeravam just told5:46them there's a holiday, that's it.5:48Look, this is at the beginning,5:50before he completely went off.5:52And certainly Yeravam was known to be a tzaddik,5:55came up with some sort of derashah and explanation5:57why the holiday of what he called Sukkot6:02actually had to be pushed to6:07Cheshvan. However, but his intention was not6:10l'shem shamayim. His intention was clear:6:12he wanted to go against... The Beit Din that was in Yerushalayim,6:16he wanted to go against the malchut of6:22Rechavam. Therefore, נקרא שבאדם לבו. It's not called a ahavah mina; it's not a mistake they did in6:25Torah. Because remember, mistakes in learning Torah6:28is also from HaKadosh Baruch Hu sometimes.6:30However, in this case, he made it up6:32because he had his personal interest.6:35And we don't say, Okay, it's machloket, right? Think about it.6:39Everyone always wonders,6:40Ah, come on, somebody's got to be right,6:42or somebody's got to be wrong.6:44This rabbi says this, Rambam says this,6:46Rashi says this,6:48and then those are people that don't know much.6:50But there's really6:5220 Rishonim, and it's possible to have 17 opinions,6:5410 opinions, right?6:56And you have sometimes6:57machlokot. You don't really have so many different ways6:59of understanding7:00again, but you have so many different opinions.7:02Who are you supposed to follow?7:03How are you supposed to do anything?7:04And it says,7:07אלו ואלו דברי אלוקים חיים. That's also—even let that be a mistake.7:09It's a7:10havah amina. They're all doing it l'shem shamayim,7:12and since they're all l'shem shamayim,7:14it's min HaKadosh Baruch Hu,7:15and it's called divrei Torah.7:17And therefore, even those who follow7:18it, it's divrei Torah.7:19Why don't we say over here that7:21the holiday that Yeravam made up7:23is also7:26אלו ואלו דברי אלוקים חיים? And says7:26Rav Tzadok, the answer is because the holiday7:28that he made up7:30was a made-up thing to go against7:34the Beit Din.7:35It was not l'shem shamayim.7:36It was done for his own selfish reasons7:40to keep his kingdom a kingdom.7:44We find somebody else like that in Tanach,7:46v'chein Doeg.7:46Who's Doeg?7:47Doeg is Doeg7:48HaEdomi, who was the head of the Sanhedrin7:50in the time of Shaul HaMelech7:51when he was chasing David,7:54and David gave him curses7:56and Tehillim left and right.7:58Anyway, but Doeg was called Doeg.8:00Because he came from Edom, another explanation, because he,8:04Edom means red. Whoever got into a debate with him,8:07Doeg was such a genius that he was able to make everybody turn red from embarrassment after the discussion,8:12like they didn't know how to answer him.8:14Doeg asah kol al pi haTorah beda'ato. Doeg, whatever he did, he felt that he did al pi halacha.8:19Now, by the way, keep in mind, Doeg HaEdomi is also responsible for the execution of the entire city of Nov, the city of the Kohanim.8:27That was Doeg. This is the same man who was posek halacha8:32that the people in Nov,8:35ir haKohanim, are chayavei mitah, and now he carried out the executions.8:38He says,8:43Kiryosas and Nim hayavu hu hora amoni ve'afilu amonit al pi halacha, beda'ato, right? And he came out and he said,8:47What do you mean?8:48When they were trying to debate if David is a kosher person8:52to be considered a Jew, basically, or8:54not, because he came from Ruth8:56haMoabiyah, and Ruth—we know that Ruth herself was from Moab,9:01and the Torah says clearly we don't accept, or we're not allowed to marry into people from the nation of9:09Moav. So they told him, Yeah, but that's only the men are not allowed to marry.9:14That means the men from Moab are not allowed to marry Jewish ladies.9:17So his response was, Are you kidding me?9:20Amoni v'lo Amonit?9:21What about Amoni v'lo Amonit?9:22You tell me also men and not women?9:27The Torah says everybody,9:29it makes no difference.9:31Nobody was able to answer him, really.9:34Nobody was able to answer when he said this line.9:36Everybody was silent because Doeg's proof was very strong.9:42And if so, David is not fit to become the king,9:47and therefore he is considered one of the people who are pasul amongst the Jewish people,9:55v'danu lemored b'malchut, v'chen lAchimelech. And therefore. Lefi his p'sak, David is not qualified to be a king.10:01If he's not qualified to be a king, the fact that he's acting in a way like he's acting,10:06running away from the king, or thinking that he has his own rights to be a king,10:10then he's moreid b'malchut.10:11If he's moreid b'malchut,10:14it's chayav mitah. And if Achimelech, who was the Kohen Gadol living in the city of10:19Nov, ir haKohanim, was assisting David, he's assisting a moreid b'malchut,10:23and he's chayav mitah. You see how far it goes?10:31Doeg is not the only one who made the mistake.10:34Shaul was actually chasing David.10:36He believed this as well,10:38but there's a difference.10:39Doeg had a personal thing against David.10:43David was also sharp in learning,10:46and Doeg was jealous of that.10:47He saw the halacha kemoto b'chol makom,10:50and that bothered Doeg.10:51So the reason why Doeg was disqualifying David from becoming a member of the Jewish nation,10:57although he's Jewish but not a member,10:59meaning to say he's from the11:01psulei kahal, why was he looking for that?11:03Because of personal interest.11:04He wanted to knock out the competition.11:07Not so Shaul.11:09Shaul was actually, yes, he had a ruach11:12ra'ah, but he didn't have something personal against David.11:15Once he found out, or he believed, the p'sak of Doeg11:20haEdomi. Then he carried it out,11:22but he didn't have that personal interest.11:25He thought this was the11:26emet, and therefore we find that even Shaul, at the end of his life11:30when he was11:31chayav mita, he was still called bechir Hashem,11:34the chosen one from Hashem.11:35That's why David didn't even,11:37you know, although David had the chance to kill Shaul a few times,11:40he didn't, because he was bechir Hashem.11:46However, Doeg's11:48mistake—where did it come from?11:49Doeg's mistake came from his jealousy11:53and was not11:55l'shem shamayim. So his mistake, because it wasn't11:58l'shem shamayim, was considered a made-up halacha,12:00and if it's a made-up halacha, it's not called12:02divrei Torah.12:05This is where Chazal say that sometimes12:08a person's Torah can become poison for him.12:11Where is that12:12so? That's when a person is learning12:14Torah like the way Doeg HaEdomi was,12:16or a person has a personal interest.12:18A person learns Torah with that way,12:21right?12:21The Gemara says,12:23naasit lo sam hamavet—it becomes actually poison to him.12:25Look at what happened to Doeg over here.12:26It was poison to him,12:27it actually ruined him,12:28because now he's justified12:30in his head. He thinks he's doing the will of God.12:34And this12:36is—Doeg is one of the people that's mentioned in Mishnah12:39in12:41Maseches Sanhedrin, ein lo chelek l'olam haba, because this is not called divrei Torah12:45באמת, כלל, רק למראית עין. This is not called divrei Torah at all.12:47This is just divrei Torah to the eyes of the people,12:51that people should look and say,12:52Wow, look, he's learning Torah,12:53but really that's not called the words of Torah whatsoever.12:56Here, up to here really the piece is done,12:59but here has in brackets13:00connecting back to the other concepts13:03that we said in the last two letters,13:04and that is13:05that when a person learns Torah,13:06he's able to extract neshamot.13:07From the evil13:10and take them out and save them,13:11like it says in the pasuk,13:12Lokeach nefashot13:14chacham. So now it says,13:20Rav Tzadok, This kind of Torah, though,13:22like that of doeg13:24ha-Edomi and the one that a person is doing13:25out of personal interest,13:26doesn't have the ability13:28to save any of the souls.13:31Kinyan el13:34acheris velo amid perin, right? Like the Zohar says,13:36it's like a person is a mesuras;13:38it's the inability to have children13:40and cannot produce fruits.13:42Such Torah is not called13:44etz chayim; it's a dead tree.13:49Like13:50Chazal say the opposite way,13:51that Hashem wants the heart of a person.13:52Here, there's no heart in it;13:54it's a personal interest.13:56Okay, now he gets into a little bit of Kabbalah,13:59but you just got the point, basically.14:01The point is that14:03basically14:04such Torah is not a real Torah14:08that we refer to14:09that brings life.14:10It's called14:12elu d'... Yet14:12Torah that is stemming from knowing the truth,14:15even if it's a mistake,14:16like we said,14:18still14:18it's mitzad14:20knowing the truth,14:21and that's a Torah that's eternal14:23and14:24produces peirot.