Torah · MussarMussar113. Polishing the Dirt Off of the NeshamaTzidkat HaTzadikPart 113Rabbi Uri Nahum · December 9, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:04Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק). The exact recording day is unconfirmed. The displayed date comes from the shared file.Transcript0:00Tzedkat Tzadik, אות קוף י״ג, 113. In order to understand the next piece,0:06we need background. We need to know the Gemara, Masechet Bava Metzia, daf peh ה, amud0:10alef, and I have to go through the details in the Gemara. It's a nice story,0:15an interesting story, and0:17from there we'll go back to the piece and see how Rav Sadok analyzes it. So the Gemara says, talks about Rabbi Yehuda Nasi.0:25He was0:26friendly with the son of Rabbi0:29Yishmael bar Yochai. We know Rabbi Yishmael bar Yochai went to the cave together with the son of Rabbi0:33Elazar, and Rabbi Yehuda Nasi was actually a contemporary. They were the same age, actually; they were friends when they were younger.0:38And the Gemara says one time, after the passing of Rabbi0:44Elazar, the son of Rabbi Yishmael bar Yochai, Rabbi went to where Rabbi Elazar used to live, and he asked the people in0:49town, says, Hey, does he have any kids? Does he have0:54any—Rabbi Elazar, does he have any kids? I want to meet them. They told him, Yeah, he does have one son,0:58and you should just know, every zona, every prostitute that people hire for two coins,1:03which sounds like, you know, like the expensive ones, she actually hires him for four coins. Some say even eight coins.1:11So, which means that basically this kid is way off the derech, right?1:14He's going with zonot. The zonot are hiring him. In any case, Rabbi now decides that, as the Gemara brings a few stories about Rabbi doing this,1:23he decides to be mekarev. He wants to bring him back in teshuvah. What does he do?1:27He comes, he takes this kid, whose name was Yose, and he tells him, Look, I'm going to give you1:34semichah. He brings him, and he actually gives him semichah, and he gives him over to his uncle from his mother's side,1:40that is, Rabbi Shimon ben Isi ben Lekunya. As this child, or this young man, is learning with his uncle,1:49he keeps on telling him every day, Ah, I want to go to the city. I want to go back to my old things.1:54So the uncle tells him, Come on, they made you a rabbi.2:00They put you a crown of gold on you, and they, you know, basically they're calling you a rabbi, and you want to go back to your old city?2:10What's the comparison? So he says, You're right. You know what? That's it.2:15I'm not going to ask for this anymore. I'm going to become—I'm going to stay here. I'm going to stay in yeshiva, basically.2:21When this Rabbi Yosei gets older, he comes to the shiur of Rabbi Yehuda Nasi, the first person who was mekarev him originally.2:29So I guess in the shiur back and forth, he hears the voice of this child.2:32Now he doesn't know who he was because it's been many years since then.2:35He says, Wow, this person sounds like my old friend, Rabbi Elazar, the son of Rabbi2:41Shimon bar Yochai. So they tell him, Yes, actually, Rabbi, this is his son.2:45Wow. Rabbi Yehuda Nasi hears this. Obviously super excited,2:48but then he says the following pasuk, and that's important to know.2:51He says a pasuk. It says,2:58פרי צדיק עץ חיים, ולוקח נפשות חכם. The fruits of the tzaddik is a tree of life,3:03and one who takes souls is considered a3:06chacham. And Rabbi explains why he said this pasuk.3:08The first part of the pasuk,3:10פרי צדיק עץ חיים, a fruit of the tzaddik is a tree of life.3:14Who is that? That's Rabbi Yosei, the son of Rabbi Elazar, the son of Rabbi3:18Shimon bar Yochai, right? He is the fruit of a tzaddik,3:21and one who takes the nefashot is considered a3:23chacham. Who is that? That's Rabbi Shimon ben Isi ben Lakunya, his uncle, who took care of him.3:29He was the one who took his soul and he basically brought it back.3:32In any case, the Gemara fast forwards that when this child of Rabbi Elazar ben Shimon eventually passes away,3:40he's taken to be buried,3:42and they wanted to actually bury him right next to Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, his grandfather, and his father, Rabbi3:47Elazar. But there was a big snake that prevented them from going into the cave.3:51And they weren't able to get in.3:54In other stories in the Gemara, it brings actually around the same pages,3:57it says that there were snakes and they were able to go through, but in this case they wouldn't let him4:03in. And no matter what they tried, they wouldn't let him in.4:05And they thought, you know, it must be because, you know, look,4:09the kid actually went off the derech, and that's why he couldn't get in.4:12And all of a sudden a heavenly voice comes out and declares and says,4:16It's not because the father was greater than the son.4:21That's not why we're not letting him in.4:23It's only because the son didn't go through the experiences of the father.4:29The father went through 13 years of4:34tzaar me'ara. It's, you know, the story of Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi Shimon, how they hid in the cave for 13 years.4:38That the father went through, but the son never experienced that.4:43And because he never experienced that and never went through that4:46tzaar, therefore he's not zocheh to be buried next to his father and grandfather.4:50This is the story that we need to know.4:52And now we'll get to Rav Tzadok, a beautiful analysis and a lesson for us.5:02Pri tzaddik, hu etz chayim. The fruit of a tzaddik is5:04etz chayim. That's how he starts out with the pasuk,5:05which is, as we just saw, we conclude the Gemara with that.5:09He says,5:15Kemo she'amru gabei Berei d'Rabbi Elazar b'Rebbi Shimon, af shehein ra'ui lo, ken. The tzaddik's fruit, basically the children of a tzaddik, is actually a tree of life.5:20And they said this pasuk in the Gemara,5:22Masechet Bava Metzia, like we just saw about the grandson of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, the son of Rabbi Elazar, Rabbi5:28Yose. Even though at first it didn't appear so, but it is that way.5:35Vadai ha-tzaddik molid nefashot yekarot. Certainly, a tzaddik who knows the proper hashgachah and everything else,5:39his offspring will also be special neshamot.5:44And the same thing we find, the Darizal says the same idea5:51about, Ruchin, neshadin, v'linin shalita d'am rishon haya dor shabud Mitzrayim. It's a result of the person.5:54And if the spirits that the Gemara tells us in Masechet5:59Arvin, that— Adam HaRishon brought to the world, in his 130 years of6:05teshuva, he was motzi zera levatala, and he created all these spirits.6:08Now, Riza says those spirits came into the bodies of the people who were in6:14Egypt and were enslaved in Egypt.6:17Now, what's the connection here?6:20He's explaining6:21it's based on the father.6:24They didn't come into, you know, basically bodies of6:27goyim; they came into the bodies of people who were6:31tzaddikim, because Adam HaRishon was also a6:37tzaddik. So too, the ten drops that came out of Yosef, we know,6:40were eventually these are the souls of the ten special rabbis that were killed6:44by the Romans after the Churban Bayit Sheni,6:47which are known as the Asarah Harugei Malchut.6:50Again, from Yosef they were able to be such holy rabbis.6:57Rak shetzarich lazeh Eloki, nefashot chacham. The only thing is, you have to know how to pull them out of the, you know,7:03the trap of the7:06yetzer hara, and you need a chacham to do that,7:09because it can only be done with wisdom to separate them from the evil that’s surrounding them.7:14That’s like we saw, Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi was a7:18chacham. He knew how to be able to pull out the special neshama,7:22the son of Rabbi Elazar, and to bring him back.7:25He knew how to—he said, if he’s the son of Rabbi Elazar, Rabbi Shimon,7:28there’s a special neshama here, and he had to do it with7:36chochma. And sometimes it doesn’t have to be that the father himself does it;7:40it could be somebody else, another talmid chacham who is the7:44chacham, could do that, could bring him out.7:47And sometimes Hashem Himself is the one who brings the person back.7:52Again, doesn’t force him, but He puts him in a situation that allows him to bring back.8:00We find that this terminology of lokeach nefashot, which over here in the pasuk is saying is a8:05chacham, we find the terminology of lokeach nefashot also attributed to Hashem.8:11In the abelim, it says lokeach nefashot8:16bemishpat, referring to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.8:17So that means when the pasuk says lokeach nefashot chacham, which we explained is talking about8:22a person who is basically mekarev, who pulls out the neshamot from the evil and brings8:27them back b’teshuvah, that could also be through al yedei HaKadosh Baruch Hu.8:36And when the father passes away, HaKadosh Baruch Hu, who took away that nefashot, also8:42takes other nefashot, and these are nefashot that are entrapped in the net of the8:50yetzer hara. Hashem saves them,8:52va’oseh mimenu etz chayim, and from those nefashot He produces a tree of life.8:58Sometimes it’s the way the Gemara brings out over there.9:02Dekari lei Rebbi. He calls him a9:04rebbi. What does that mean,9:04he calls him a rabbi?9:05So in this story, all of a sudden they gave him a9:08semichah. The guy was nowhere near9:11semichah. How in the world did you give him9:13semichah? The answer is that basically made him live up to the title that they gave him,9:16right?9:17So he says over here, by giving him the status of a great person, right away the person had9:30to live up to it.9:32That also, he says, that’s what happens to a person sometimes also from Hashem.9:37Hashem gives him this boost of spirituality that makes him feel like, I’m so great.9:42What am I doing?9:44What am I doing here?9:45What am I doing amongst this terrible, terrible9:49tumah? And he lives up to it.9:51And we find that somebody did the same thing.9:53Happens to be, as I'm recording this,9:56today is the fifth day of Chol Hamoed of the holiday of Sukkot.9:59We know the holiday of Sukkot is in the zechut of Aharon10:03HaKohen, because ענני כבוד is in the zechut of Aharon10:06HaKohen, and Sukkot is10:08זכר לענני כבוד. And today, which is the fifth day, is also the Ushpizin of Aharon HaKohen, according to our counting.10:14Now, why am I bringing this up?10:16Because it's mamash connected over here.10:18Chazal tell us in Mishnah, in Pirkei Avot,10:29הוי מתלמידיו של אהרן הכהן, אוהב הבריות, אוהב שלום, רודף שלום, אוהב את הבריות ומקרבן לתורה. Love peace and run after peace10:32and love people10:34and be mekarev them to Torah. Chazal tell us, how did Aharon HaKohen, how was he mekarev people to Torah?10:38When he would see a person who was not really a tzaddik, he would tell him, Tzaddik!10:42He would call him a tzaddik.10:43The person would say, Ah, if Aharon thinks I'm a tzaddik, I have to live up to it.10:47Mamash the same thing.10:48Aharon HaKohen was the same10:52לוקח נפשות. He brought them closer, how?10:55By making them live up to their title.10:59So, back to11:05Rav Tzadok. ואז גם רבי, שקראו לו אז ודאי לא לשווא. When they called Rabbi Yosei, Rabbi, when he was first starting his journey of teshuvah,11:11it wasn't for no reason,11:14כי כשנתגלה האמת. Because later on, when he really lived up to it and he became a rabbi,11:19אז גם תחלה היה כן. So it comes out that really he was there the whole time.11:21He was that person, he was that great person that could have been there the whole time.11:27רק שהיה בהעלם, כי מלא בושה גריעתא מה לא נפיק. It was all concealed.11:30The greatness was actually concealed.11:32Why?11:33Because something bad cannot come out from something good.11:37It's not going to come out of something good.11:39If it's bad, it's not going to come out of something good.11:41It just happens11:43to be that I took hold of it.11:45He lured this neshama in,11:48but we had to get it out,11:49v'teida, and I'll prove it to you.11:50He says, The Gemara says at the end of his life, when they came to bury him,11:56a voice came out and11:58says, The reason why he's not zocheh to be buried next to his father is not because12:01Rabbi Elazar is greater than him.12:03You hear that?12:04That means he's as great as his father.12:06What do you mean?12:08Rabbi Yose himself, when he was a young man,12:10it clearly says in Gemara he was ra'uy zonot. He was always a ra'uy zonot.12:16But because of his12:18teshuva, and that he brought himself back to where he really was,12:21his great neshama, the earlier sins are not mentioned12:29anymore. He was actually good from the beginning.12:32Only thing is, like we said, it's covered up.12:34A diamond is a diamond.12:36Oh, you look at a diamond, it's all dirty.12:38It's a diamond.12:39It's covered up with bad things.12:41You know, we mentioned we're in the holiday of Sukkot.12:44You know, right before Sukkot,12:45we look at many, many etrogim,12:47and like every year I look at perhaps hundreds of etrogim,12:51and a lot of times I see people pick up an etrog,12:53they put it down,12:55and they feel like it's a bad etrog.12:56I look at it, and sometimes I could see that12:59although it has spots on it,13:00a lot of these spots are external.13:02If you just know how to rub those spots off in a very, very delicate way,13:07it'll come off right away,13:08and you have a beautiful, beautiful etrog under it.13:10So what looks to some people as a mum and a psul13:13and a, you know, blemish,13:17it's actually, you just have to know how to get rid of that dirt,13:19and you see on the inside it's actually something beautiful.13:22And that's what we're saying over here.13:24The beauty of the person, which is his neshama,13:27sometimes is concealed with a lot of external things.13:30Sometimes you see people, like you think they're way off.13:34Just find out, especially if you find out they come from special families,13:37something special there.13:38You just have to know how to get rid of that13:40dirt. Not everybody could get off the blemishes from the etrog,13:43because, you know, some people may scratch it13:45and they don't know what they're doing.13:46You have to know how to do it.13:47And not everybody could do, necessarily, kiruv in the right way.13:51Some people think, I'm going to yell at them.13:53I am. What are you doing? No.13:54Look at Rebbe.13:55This is over 2,000 years ago.13:57Look, in my days when I was a kid, we got hit and I was normal.14:00In Rebbe's days, special people got hit14:02and it was normal.14:03But he didn't go and hit and yell.14:06The opposite.14:06He lifted him up.14:07He took him.14:08He says, You're going to become Rebbe.14:09People think that, oh, we're a weak generation.14:12We're14:14chazikeses. Ah, we have to talk so nicely to everybody14:16because they can't handle the hitting like we grew up.14:20I don't know if that's so true.14:21Look,14:22I can show you from the Gra from 300 years ago,14:25who says in mefurash, you know, that hitting is not the way.14:28And the klal from this14:31Gemara, it's closer to 2,000 years.14:32It's not exactly 2,000 years.14:34It's closer to 2,000 years,14:35where Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi didn't yell at him,14:37didn't give him14:38mussar, didn't put him down,14:39didn't knock him.14:41The opposite. He lifted him up.14:42He lifted him up.14:43That is what Chazal are teaching us.14:45You have to lift up the person.14:47You have to know how to do it.14:48Again, maybe perhaps some people may need a hit,14:49I don't know.14:51But understand that lifting up the person is not because of weakness.14:55The opposite.14:55You make the person live up to it.14:57You bring out the diamond.14:59You polish the diamond and you get rid of that dirt15:00to bring out his true beautiful neshama.