Torah · MussarMussar106B. Stumbling in TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 106Rabbi Uri Nahum · September 23, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:15Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, Ot Kuvav, part0:04two. As we mentioned, that as the pieces start to get longer and longer,0:08we're going to divide it up into different parts.0:11Sometimes it'll be two parts, maybe sometimes a little bit longer.0:14But now the pieces are getting longer, but not necessarily all the time,0:17but for the next couple of pieces. You'll hear right in the beginning.0:20A little recap of what we did in part0:22one. Part one, Rav Tzadok focused on the words in the Gemara in Gittin,0:26that Ein adam omed al divrei Torah ela im ken0:30nichshal. A person does not understand the concepts of Torah unless he stumbles,0:33and he explained there that the stumbling leads to0:39keiri, but that, meaning to say, remember, there's like what seems to be from the Gemara,0:43there's like steps.0:44First a person stumbles, and then he grasps the concept of Torah.0:47So he explains that the stumbling actually leads to0:53keiri, zera levatala, and from the zera levatala a person then gets the next step, which is understanding.0:57That chiddush, that concept of being able to understand,1:01the ability to be able to understand Torah, says1:05Rav Tzadok, is, you know, that's like giving birth to new souls.1:10And he starts to connect it to different ideas that he said in the past.1:13And one of the things is a story in Masechet Shabbat,1:17Maaseh b'oto chasid, about that chasid that did the mitzvah of pidyon1:22shvuyim, and he got carried that night.1:24He was zocheh that he was able to teach his talmidim the next day from that1:28chiddush because of the stumbling that he had.1:31Now the Gemara is actually—I mean, Rav Tzadok is actually going to focus on the story1:35and show us exactly what was that chiddush of Torah that came from the1:40machshalah in that story in Masechet Shabbat. So he says,1:43Vena'eh, shezeh atzmo hayah ma she'amru achar kach me'inyan ladun lechaf zechut, afilu be'ofen zeh shehamaaseh lechora moreh birur lechov. V'lo yada ze mikodem. Says, you know what the1:56chidush—okay, so what was the1:57chidush? You remember every chidush Torah,1:58every time there's a zeh l'vatala, that person does a tikkun on,2:01he's zocheh that he's mechadesh Torah.2:04What is that chidush that came from this story?2:07And the answer is exactly what the Gemara is trying to teach us on that page.2:10On that page in the Gemara,2:12remember we said this in the past,2:14that that entire page is filled with the concept of the rule called dan2:20l'chaf zechut, judging other people favorably.2:22How far does it go?2:23You have to judge other people favorably.2:25And the Gemara brings such a story over there to tell you2:28that look how far the students judged their rabbi favorably.2:33Even though everything looked like the way it looked, right?2:38Everything seemed to spell out that there was an aveirah that was done over here.2:43You know, the rabbi went,2:44he took this girl,2:45he hid her,2:46and he kept her in the room.2:47Then he went to do2:48tevilah, he didn't let anybody come in.2:49That's what it looked like.2:50But at the end, we came out with actually a big2:53chidush. We came out with2:54a chidush that actually even in such a scenario,2:56you have to be dan2:57l'chaf zechut. And that's, he says, the2:59chidush. Before this story, we never knew that.3:02And the fact that the rabbi got the3:05zeh l'vatala, that the tikkun that he did3:08was able to bring to light a new chidush in Torah.3:13כמו שאמרו שם, like it says,3:18בית המי' שאינו בדוק בדברי תורה, לשון נקייה. Like it says over there,3:20one of the things that he asked them, he says,3:22when I took that girl and I put her in the room privately,3:24within, I didn't let anybody come in,3:26why do you think I did that?3:27And the students told him,3:28because maybe one of us is not baduk.3:30So he explains, it's a nice way of talking.3:35היינו שהיה חשוד את זו הזנות. What the Gemara is trying to say,3:37what do you mean3:38אינו בדוק? It means that the rabbi actually suspected3:39one of those students with zenut.3:45That's when, דאמר שאינו בדוק, משמע דמתכשר הוה, אך שלא דנו לכף זכות. Now, the Gemara doesn't say there was a person,3:50there was actually a student that was,3:53you know, there was real reason to suspect him3:55that he was a person3:57who might do this aveirah with this girl.3:59But it just says that4:02אינו בדוק, which means that the4:03rabbi—this is the stumbling of the rabbi.4:06The stumbling of the4:07rabbi is when he went to do the mezuzah pidyon4:09shevuyim. It's an unbelievable thing if you think about it now.4:11When the rabbi went to do the mezuzah pidyon4:13shevuyim, he took and he put her in the room.4:15Why?4:16Because he really suspected one of those students,4:20and that's a mistake, no?4:22That's a mistake,4:23because really he was innocent.4:25You suspected him, and that means4:26there was something wrong in the4:28rabbi thinking that the other guy did it,4:29but really there was nothing wrong with the guy.4:31And the rabbi should have done,4:33should have judged him favorably,4:35should have judged the student favorably.4:37That was his mistake,4:38and that's why he got the4:40zera levatalah. But then he did teshuvah.4:42He came and he asked them,4:43and when they taught him4:44the concept4:46of dan4:48l'chaf zechut, ah, that's the chiddush that came out of this whole story.4:51So he says over here,4:56because the rabbi didn't judge his student favorably,5:00the consequence was5:03that he should get5:05keri. That's his stumbling.5:08However, it didn't come exactly,5:10chas v'shalom, in an aveirah form.5:12It came as it usually comes in a natural way,5:15but like we're learning,5:16and we know that even5:18nature has its reasons behind it,5:20in a natural way,5:21which is the exertion from the travel.5:25But it doesn't make sense.5:26If it came from exertion of the travel,5:29the travel was for what?5:30For the mitzvah of pidyon5:32shevuyim. We have a rule,5:33shomer5:33mitzvah lo yeda davar ra,5:34and we know ra is5:36keri. So how could the rabbi get this5:38keri? True, people who travel5:40usually they lose,5:41you know, their strength5:43and they feel weak,5:44and therefore they're not controlling5:45so much of their body,5:46and it could let out5:48keri. But how could it be that this rabbi,5:49it should happen to him?5:50Didn't he go to do5:52a mitzvah? And the answer is,5:54shomer5:55mitzvah lo yeda davar ra.5:55And he explains,5:57ah,6:01rak shekol davar nedon al shem sofo. Really,6:02that's the problem here.6:04Really, it should not have happened to6:06him, but because he was negligent in6:07the Torah,6:08that he didn't do the mitzvah of the Torah6:11of dan l'chaf zechut,6:13therefore such a thing happened to him.6:14Now, everything is usually judged6:16how it comes out at the end.6:17As everybody knows in business,6:19you have your good days and bad days.6:22When you look back and say,6:23was my business successful or not?6:25He'll tell you, Well,6:25I remember that year,6:26you were losing money.6:28Yeah, but that's part of business.6:28When you open a business,6:29you lose a lot of money.6:30You invest,6:32you buy a lot of things,6:33you borrow money to,6:34you know,6:35to be able to do what you have to do,6:37and eventually you get back6:38and you make more money6:38and you build on it.6:39And there are days where you have,6:41you know,6:42basal6:42and there are asan, which means days that are great6:45and days are not so great.6:46That's everything in life.6:47And how do you judge something?6:48You look at the end.6:50At the end,6:51at the bottom line, what was it?6:51What did it produce?6:53Now, this story also,6:55we look at the end.6:56The end was that6:57there was a chiddush in6:59Torah that we didn't have beforehand.7:04And being that the end result7:05was that he should be able7:07to understand the Torah,7:09this whole stumbling was7:10that he should be omed al divrei Torah.7:11Remember,7:12that's the order.7:13When the person is7:15nichshal, he has to be omed on it,7:16or if he tries.7:23זכה לזה רק על ידי תורה, אותו דרך פדיון שבויים. That's why7:25this rabbi was only7:26zocheh to this7:27chiddush by actually doing7:29the mitzvah. I mean to say, it's not random.7:31It's not that a person says,7:32Okay, can we do teshuvah now?7:33It's not random, not at all.7:35It's kind of like7:36from the beginning7:36it was planned that way,7:38because he took the initiative,7:41this rabbi took the initiative7:42to do the mitzvah pidyon7:43shvuyim, to go save that girl.7:47Now,7:47okay, isn't everybody supposed to go7:49save another Jew?7:50Mitzvah pidyon7:51shvuyim is to save a Jew from being7:53captured by7:55goyim. A Jew is captive, it's a big7:57mitzvah. Well. Let me tell you7:58a little bit about this girl, says.8:00Tzadok. You know who this girl was?8:06The otah riba hitnahagah b'darkhei goyim, kemo she'amru b'Avot d'Rabbi Natan. The same story is brought down in Avot d'Rabbi Natan. It's a midrash.8:11We all know the—it's braitot, really,8:14a set of braitot. And we know Pirkei Avot. There's also Pirkei Avot d'Rabbi Natan.8:18It's a little bit longer and elaborates on a lot of stories that we know from Gemara,8:21and also elaborates on the regular Pirkei Avot.8:24And then the end of Perek 8 says that that girl actually8:28was a girl who was basically off the derech completely.8:31She was living with the goyim, acting like goyim.8:34Now really, he didn't have to save her. She chose to be like the goyim.8:37The rabbi didn't have to go and save her all the way.8:40Yet what happened? The rabbi went out of his way.8:47V'hu mitdatek chasidut levakesh zechut gam l'resha'im. It's a8:49chasidut that a person should try to be dan l'chaf zechut even8:54for the resha'im. The halacha is clear about dan8:57l'chaf zechut. Halacha says that if the guy is an average guy,9:00when it looks not so kosher, you have to judge him favorably.9:03But a guy who is a rasha, not at all.9:06And if a guy is a rasha doing his own thing, you don't have to have an obligation to go save him.9:10But the rabbi went out of his way,9:12and he was9:15mitnaheg b'chasidut. And because he took the initiative to go try to save the girl,9:18now along the way he made the mistake of not judging people favorably,9:21which is interesting because he actually was involved in trying to save this girl9:25in a way that's like judging people favorably beyond the letter of the law,9:30right? That's how chasidut is in this9:32halacha. But he didn't judge one of his students favorably,9:34therefore he was nichshal in that area of the Torah.9:37And because he was nichshal, but what saved him was the fact that he started the mitzvah9:42of trying to save this girl.9:44And even though keri came out and it seemed to be bad,9:46but— It brought about a chidush in Torah.9:49That's the proof to his9:51teshuva, that he was able to mechadesh Torah in this ענין as well.9:55Now, how do we know that that's called9:58chasidut? How do we know that when you try to save even the rashaim that don't deserve it,10:03it's also called10:05chasidut? He brings a proof from Gemara Masechet Sanhedrin10:09that says about Rabbi Akiva that he used to be doresh10:14that the children of the reshaim have a10:17chelek l'olam haba, even though other rabbis disagreed, other Tannaim disagreed with him, Rabbi Akiva was doresh that.10:23Now, somewhere else, another place, Rabbi Akiva says that10:26dor hamabul ein lahem chelek l'olam haba. The generation of mabul don't have a10:30chelek l'olam haba. And there also there was Tannaim that disagreed with him.10:33They said10:36they יש להם חלק לעולם הבא. And the Amoraim, one of the Amoraim points out and he says,10:42שבקי רבי עקיבא לחסידותיה. What happened to Rabbi10:44Akiva's chasidut? Why did he leave it when it comes to10:47dor hamidbar? So you see that Rabbi Akiva, who came out of his way to be doresh10:53that we should find some sort of zechut for the10:58reshaim, that's called10:59chasidut. Now the Gemara answers the difference if it's goyim or11:01Jews, but basically you got the idea that when you try to be melamed11:07zechut and try to help the reshaim, you're called a11:12chasid, and that's the same idea of11:15הוי מעשה באותו חסיד. Why is he a chasid? Because he went out of his way,11:17even though this girl was acting like the ways of the goyim,11:19he went out of his way to try to save her.11:23Now that's the next paragraph that he says,11:25Rav Tzadok, and this is the last paragraph.11:26He says,11:29ולכך נקרא באותו מעשה חסיד אחד. This is why he's called11:32a11:35chasid. He says, לפנים משורת הדין, ועינו עולה עיניהם כי גם בכל רע גנוז טוב. This is why he's called a11:36chasid. A regular person judges based on what he sees.11:39The chasid sees also the evil, but he looks beyond the11:43evil, says the evil is only on the surface.11:46Looks deeper than anything he sees.11:48There's something really, a big soul over here,11:52and there's something really good that's beyond the surface of the11:57rasha. And that's why he's a chassid, because he looks beyond the surface,12:01as other people just look at the surface.12:09וכך זכה אז לאמור, הדבר הזה, תורה לדון לכף זכות, שהוא גם כן כנזכר טוב במעשה הרע, לעין. That's why he was zocheh to this12:12chiddush, because of what he started.12:14What did he start?12:15This rabbi started the mitzvah12:17by what he saw, that there was a Jewish girl that was in captivity by the goyim.12:21And when he found out about her, he Googled her, he checked her profile,12:26and he saw she's acting like a goy, she's living like the goyim.12:29What are you trying to save her for?12:31What are you trying?12:31She's living like the goyim, doing whatever they're doing,12:34okay?12:35Yet he said, you know, I'm going to look deeper than that,12:38because deep within the evil, there's something good.12:42So what was his reward?12:44His reward, that he was zocheh to be mechadesh forever,12:47and he was given the title12:50מעשה בתלמיד חסיד, and he is the one who taught us in Masechet Shabbat12:52that when things on the outside look evil, look bad,12:57there's something good that's hidden inside of them.13:00That's what—think about it—that's what judging favorably is.13:02On the surface it looks bad,13:04but deep within there's really something good,13:06and you have to look beyond the evil on the outside.13:11וזמינו השם יתברך אותו מכשול. And Hashem made it that he should be13:15nichshal with this zera, right,13:17like we said, which came as a result of him not judging favorably,13:20and through that, לעמוד בתורה, he was zocheh13:24to be able to get this new13:27chiddush. He says in parentheses13:31over here that mechshol, שלידת נפש בלא רצונו ודעתו. That mechshol is really creating the soul without his will,13:35without his intention.13:40וחומר עד בית תורה, רצון, כמו שאמרנו, מזומן על אותו דבר בלי דעתו. And that's what עומר עד בית תורה is.13:42It's a13:43chiddush. How do you zocheh to such a13:45chidush? You never thought about it.13:46You didn't try to think about it. It13:47all of a sudden came to13:52you. And now that he was mechadesh the13:54Divrei Torah through this shiur by giving teaching everybody,13:56this is what the mezalv done l'chazek zchut is.13:59That's why, that's how we see that he was metaken14:03that soul that was created by accident14:06through this14:10zera levatala was taken out of its captivity14:11and brought into kedusha.