Torah · MussarMussar106A. Stumbling in TorahTzidkat HaTzadikPart 106Rabbi Uri Nahum · September 23, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:32Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf vav.0:02If you're wondering what happened to 105, to kuf0:06hei, kuf hei is also missing, as we explained in the end of kuf dalet.0:10It's not in the sefer kuf0:12hei. So let's begin with kuf vav.0:14Before we begin, actually,0:16I have to tell you that it's a little bit of a hard piece,0:19and it's a long piece.0:20I was debating if I should divide it into two parts.0:23I'm going to try to start going, and I'm going to see where I'm up to,0:26because it's a hard piece.0:28Therefore, we have to slow down to explain certain things.0:31He literally over here brings so much into a few words,0:35and, you know, like this, like this, like that,0:37and like each one is another whole thing to explain.0:40So in order to get it clear,0:42we might have to go a little bit—not off tangent;0:44it's really on the0:45subject—but we have to clarify and bring background.0:48So I'm telling you that this might be kuf vav part0:52one, and we'll send another clip for kuf vav part0:54two. And just now that we're on the subject,0:57let me spend another few seconds to give you the introduction1:00that the next couple of pieces all deal with1:03the zeh l'umat zeh. We mentioned this in the past,1:06that there's going to be a lot,1:07a lot of this stuff that's going to come up1:09in the next couple of paragraphs.1:11It's mainly for men,1:13so if a woman is listening to this,1:14it's not really such a good thing to listen1:16to—not for her.1:17And another thing is that1:19the pieces start to get bigger and bigger now.1:21Each ot now has a few things,1:23and expect that there will be part one, part1:26two, and we'll mention it right in the beginning of the audio,1:28so this way you'll know that you're still part of it.1:30And if you're listening to a1:31clip and it says part1:32two, then you missed part1:33one. Go back to make sure you get part1:36one. Okay, let's begin kuf vav.1:41אין אדם עומד על דברי תורה אלא אם כן נכשל. Gemara tells us in Masechet Gittin, a person does not... fully grasp the concept of1:49Torah unless he stumbles upon it first.1:51That seems to be a rule.1:52As we know in1:54life, that we learn best from our mistakes.1:56If you're a good learner,1:58when you make a mistake,1:59let's say, for example,2:00you're driving in Israel2:02and you said, you know,2:04you're deciding to take a shortcut,2:05and you went off the path that GPS is telling you,2:07and all of a sudden you ended up2:09in a very dangerous territory,2:11right?2:12You're going to learn2:13that next time you come,2:13oh, I remember this place.2:15You don't make a right turn here.2:16You learn from your mistakes.2:18So similarly, the Gemara seems to be saying2:20on a pashut pshat, on a simple level,2:21that the Bnei Torah is the same thing.2:23And when you make that mistake,2:24you're like, oh my gosh,2:25you know,2:26I can't believe what I, how I learned2:27it was so wrong.2:28And then you're going to be able to2:30stand,2:31you're going to be able to grasp2:32the full understanding of2:34the Torah, or you're going to be able to really,2:36the Bnei Torah will stick with you,2:38but only once you make a mistake first.2:41So he's going to go a little bit2:43and focus on this point, basically.2:46It seems from here2:47there's a formula,2:48and that's what he's going to focus on.2:50Even though we said this concept2:51a little bit before,2:51but he brings it out2:52a little bit more over here.2:53And the formula is2:55that from bad, good results,2:58right?2:59I don't know if you got my English3:01clear that way.3:02Meaning to say,3:02you see that good things3:04come out from bad.3:05It's because you got this3:07machshelah, because you stumbled upon the Bnei Torah,3:11you're zocheh to be עומד על דברי תורה. That's what it seems like.3:12So keep that formula in mind3:14as he's going to come back to it3:17and discuss it more,3:17and that's going to be the focus3:19of this3:20אות. So he says,3:23ומכשלה דדברי תורה מביאה לידי קנין. A person who stumbles upon the Bnei Torah3:25actually brings him to keri,3:29כמו שכתבתי במקום אחר, that he says somewhere else.3:30Where do we see this?3:32He says, look earlier3:33in3:36אות ע״ו. Seventy-six. I don't know if the clips are numbered;3:38they're not numbered,3:49but if you go back to Ot Ayin Vav, there he speaks about a very interesting—he talks about Dor Hamabul, and he says that Moshe Rabbeinu was supposed to be part of that generation. And in fact, that generation,3:51which got forty days of flood3:53and destruction of the world,3:55was really the generation3:57that was supposed to bring the3:59Torah, which came also in forty days,4:01and the Torah also that came4:05and basically upheld the world.4:07As we know, Chazal tell us,4:12al shlosha devarim ha'olam עומד; al haTorah is one of them.4:12Torah is what keeps the world4:15standing; it's what upholds the world.4:16And being that that generation4:18of the Mabul was one4:20that was fit to bring Torah4:22and didn't use it properly,4:24so therefore, it's like we said,4:25if you don't use it, you abuse it.4:27You lose it,4:28actually—not just lose it, but you destroy it4:30in that same way,4:31and therefore it brought destruction.4:33So it comes out4:34that that generation of4:36Dor Hamabul, had they done what they were supposed to be doing,4:40then they would have had4:42a Moshe Rabbeinu,4:43because Moshe Rabbeinu's neshama was there,4:45as Chazal tell us.4:46Where is Moshe in the4:47Torah? As it says,4:49b'shagam hu basar, right?4:51And Moshe Rabbeinu4:52was—you see a lot of similarities4:54between Dor Hamedbar and4:56Dor Hamabul: forty and4:57forty, forty years in the desert,4:58forty days of Matan Torah.5:00Over here also,5:00they used to plant only once in forty years,5:03and they got forty days of flooding,5:05which destroyed them.5:06A lot of similarities.5:07And they also had the neshama of Moshe Rabbeinu,5:10b'shagam hu basar. And Moshe Rabbeinu5:11is called Moshe,5:12even though he had ten names,5:17because it says in the pasuk, Ki min hamayim meshitihu—I pulled him out of the water.5:18Which water?5:19As Rav Sadok explained earlier,5:20from the waters of5:22Dor Hamabul. This is the soul that came5:23from the waters of5:24Dor Hamabul. In any case.5:26What you see, the very interesting thing5:27what Rav Tzadok is saying over here,5:30that the generation was supposed to be5:31the generation of5:32the Torah ended up being5:33Dor Hamabul. What was the main sin of5:35Dor Hamabul? The Gemara says,5:37Masechet Niddah, daf yud-gimmel, that the sin of5:39Dor Hamabul was5:41zera levatala. There's no way around it.5:43It's going to have to say it the way it is:5:45zera levatala. So you see that a person5:48who basically messes up with the Torah,5:51it leads to5:52keri. That's what he's saying.5:56Ein adam omer divrei Torah ela im kein nichshal aleha, and nichshal is stumbling upon it,5:58making a mistake with it.5:59The mistake of the divrei Torah6:01brings to6:02keri, just like we found6:03that an entire generation6:04who made such a mistake in Torah6:06brought them to6:08keri. Okay?6:09So he says6:11another proof from6:14the Masechet Berachot. I'll tell you,6:16Avdahna Masechet Berachot very pretty well,6:18and this is in a6:19gemara that comes up in6:20Hok LeYisrael, which Baruch Hashem for the last6:22over ten years,6:23Bnei Anara have been doing Hok LeYisrael every day,6:25and it comes up.6:26That means at least once a6:27year I'm going over this Gemara again and6:29again, and I never understood,6:30never thought about it this way.6:31The Gemara says like this:6:36Ve'savea yalin, ba'yipaked ra. A person who sleeps full6:39will not be given something bad,6:43says the Gemara.6:46Kol hamasbia atzmo midivrei Torah, a person who makes himself satiated6:49from the words of Torah,6:54velan, and then says, and he goes to6:55sleep, and basically he's learning a6:56lot right before he goes to sleep,6:59eino מקבל בשורות רעות. He won't get bad news.7:01Now we know the word ra already,7:03as by now we explained it,7:04refers to7:06zera levatala. So that's what he's saying:7:09hamasbia atzmo midivrei Torah, a person who satiates himself7:10with divrei Torah.7:11Satiating means you're full,7:12you're not overstuffed,7:13you're not hungry,7:14it's perfect,7:15exactly the way it's supposed to be,7:16which basically,7:17if you have taken in7:20the divrei Torah7:20in the way it's supposed to be,7:22you are protected from ra.7:24As Rav Tzadok explained a number of times,7:26ra refers to7:28zera levatala. Therefore, says7:30Rav Tzadok, mina lehefech, so it works also backwards.7:32That means7:33a person who's not7:35savea from divrei Torah—you might have learned Torah,7:36but you're7:37nichshal in7:38divrei Torah—then there is ra,7:39and the ra is7:41zera levatala. Now,7:44that's two points7:45that he wanted to prove,7:47that7:47machshela, that a person who stumbles,7:49it can lead him to7:51zera. Vachakach, however,7:53after,7:53what happens the next step7:54after a person is7:57nichshal, after a person has7:58the zera levatala by mistake?8:00What happens?8:06וכך על ידי זה חפץ השם בידו יצליח, כמו שביאר לעיל, ועומד על דברי תורה. But now that you're nichshal, there's a next step.8:09The next step is you zocheh to actually be8:12עומד בתורה. You zocheh to get the true grasp of the Torah,8:17כמו שביאר במקום אחר, like we explained above already,8:22וכמו שאמרו, דעבונות נעשו זכויות. And it's the same idea that we mentioned in the past of sins that turn8:33into זכויות. וממים הזדונים נהפך למי הדעת, and waters which were, you know, like we find by Elisha, waters which were killing people,8:38all of a sudden they turn to waters that give life to people.8:43ונפש השוקעה נכנסת לקדושה, and the soul that was actually captured by the hands of the sitra achra is taken out8:49and entering kedusha. All this again are different examples of now what was bad gets fixed.8:56העבירות, and not just erased, they actually get fixed. They become into mitzvot.9:00We explained that concept a number of times, a deeper concept.9:03And some people ask, Oh, I could plan an aveirah, and I want to mention this point, and that9:08is, the Gemara says,9:13כל האומר אחטא ואשוב, אין מספיקין בידו לעשות תשובה. Everybody says, I am gonna sin, but I'll do teshuvah afterwards.9:18It says they don't allow him to do teshuvah.9:21You could try to do teshuvah, but they won't allow you to do teshuvah.9:24What the Gemara is teaching us is that when you, of course, the real level of9:29teshuvah is to realize that that was all from HaKadosh Baruch Hu.9:31That's the real, real level.9:32But if it was planned, they'll never let you get to the real level of teshuvah.9:36Only when it's not planned, Hashem will let the person get to that level of teshuvah.9:42Okay? So that's what he's saying over here, that now that a person went through the9:48machshelah, then9:50he zocheh to be עומד בתורה. Now he's zocheh al9:52דברי תורה. One second, we're dealing again, זרע לבטלה is the result that comes out of it.9:56What happens to that זרע that went to the batalah?9:58That soul that's created when a person is mazria automatically brings down a soul.10:02If it's done b'kedushah and heter, the soul gets more of a10:11kedushah. Or there's more kedushah to the soul, basically.10:14If it's done lo aleinu not b'heter, and it's going l'batala, it creates demons,10:19creates all terrible things.10:20But now that we said the next step after the zeh l'batala is that you fix it.10:23How do you fix it?10:24And the answer is, you take it from the sitra achra and you bring it, you enter it into the10:29kedushah, v'na'aseh mimenu divrei Torah. And what do you create from that10:34zeh l'batala? Zeh l'batala should create souls, humans.10:37No, you create actually eino chiddushin Torah. Ki hadua shenefeshot Yisrael hem atzman divrei Torah,10:42as is known, that the souls of the Jewish people are actually the words of the Torah.10:48Where do we see this?10:49Well, one place Chazal tell us,10:54Kudsha Brich Hu v'Orayta v'Yisrael chad hu. Hashem, the Torah, and the Jewish people are all one.10:56As we know, the souls of the Jewish people, not all humans, only the Jewish people,11:01come from Hashem,11:03v'yipach b'apav ruach chayim, and we took that role on of Adam Harishon,11:07b'tzelem Elokim. All these different11:09terminology Chazal use is that because we are mamash HaKadosh Baruch Hu.11:13But that's also what Torah is.11:14As we know,11:15Yisrael, the Dorshei Reshumot said,11:24yesh shishim ribo otiyot laTorah. And Chazal tell us numerous times,11:26not numerous, but masechet Kiddushin it says11:28that there are 600,000 letters in the Torah.11:31Now even though that's not true, that's not even close to being true.11:35I think it's around half of that even.11:37But Chazal said that, that 600,000 letters in the Torah,11:41and we know that 600,000 Jewish people,11:43when they came out of11:44Mitzrayim, even though that's also not exactly accurate if you look in Parashat11:48Bamidbar, but still you got the idea.11:49There's a connection here,11:50because the souls of the Jewish people are the words of the Torah. V'tachdush d'bei Torah11:59hu holadat nefashot kedoshot. And therefore, when a person is mechadesh in the Torah,12:02that's the same concept as actually giving birth to holy souls.12:08V'chein amru. And that's why you can understand now the Gemara.12:10We mentioned this Gemara in the past12:16about Maaseh b'Hahu Hasid about that Rabbi... Rabbi Yehuda ben ... I think it was,12:19what we explained in the Gemara Masechet Shabbat12:21about one of the rabbis, maaseh12:24b'toch chasid, b'vad a chasid, that goes to do pidyon shevuyim on a girl.12:29We're going to see who this girl is later,12:31be'ezrat Hashem. But anyway, he goes to do the mitzvah of pidyon12:35shevuyim, and afterwards, the Gemara, just to refresh your memory,12:37the Gemara tells us that he went, he took her and he put her in a room.12:40He let her sleep, you know, not in his bed, obviously,12:44but, you know, basically he closed his bed12:46and he basically closed himself off from the students.12:49And in the morning he went to the12:51mikveh because it seems like he had keri.12:52So he asked them, Rabotai, what did you suspect me of?12:55And they said, honestly, we were dan l'chaf zechut.12:58How?12:59He says, because we thought that, you know what,13:03what did you think when I put the girl?13:04He said, maybe one of us is not baduk.13:07Maybe you suspected one of us,13:09okay? And what did you suspect?13:11He tells them. And when I went to the13:13mikveh, what did you think?13:14He says, we thought that from the exertion of the road,13:17you had zera levatala, and that's why you had to go to the13:20mikveh. He tells them, chazak u'baruch, that's exactly what I did.13:22And now the Gemara mentions over there,13:24shanah letalmidav, which is really not part of the story.13:26He taught his students.13:28A good case if he said in the shiur, not13:30said in the shiur. This is the conversation that went on.13:32Says Rav Tzadok,13:33nah,13:34what happened to this rabbi?13:36He got13:37zera levatala. But that's a michshol that he got,13:40right? Now he is13:41metaken it. How is he13:43metaken it? By getting the chiddush in Torah.13:45That's what he says.13:46Shanah letalmidav hu ma shetichadesh lo daika,13:48chashatavan b'kodem shehu13:50hateshuvah v'tikun. Not that he reached that level of13:52teshuvah; he got another level of understanding,13:55a chiddush, and therefore was able to do it,13:57as he was able to bring out that part of the Torah.14:00That's exactly what he's saying,14:01that the zera levatala and the chiddushim in divrei Torah14:04are actually very connected.14:06Now I'm looking at the time here,14:07and I still have another huge paragraph,14:12and it's still connected to Kuf Vav,14:14so I'm going to keep it as Kuf Vav. Part14:18one, be'ezrat Hashem, the next clip will be kuf vav, part14:23two, and there, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll explain14:25and we'll give a little refresher14:27and, you know, review of what we just did,14:29and then go on to the next part.14:30So stay tuned.