Torah · MussarMussar102. The Definition of a חסידTzidkat HaTzadikPart 102Rabbi Uri Nahum · September 18, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0019:52Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot kuf bet.0:02An amazing piece today.0:05Please pay attention and try to understand the depth of these words.0:08We find terminologies in0:12Chazal, and sometimes in Torah as well, but mainly in0:15Chazal, of people on, let's call them, three different levels,0:18three good levels:0:20tzaddik, chassid, and kadosh.0:23So tzaddik we've discussed a little bit here and there,0:26and we kind of like hinted to a chassid a little bit last time.0:28In this piece, Rav Tzadok focuses on the term chassid when it's used.0:34So just in short, tzaddik is a person usually0:38who's mitgaber, who does more good than bad.0:40That's the usual understanding that we have.0:41Chassid, a person goes0:43lifnim mishurat hadin, goes beyond the letter of the law.0:46As we explained last time,0:48resha'im are more שייך being a chassid than a tzaddik,0:51because resha'im really also go off the path,0:54just go to the other side of the path,0:55where a chassid goes to the good side of the, you know, off the path.1:00So in this piece, he defines more the terminology that we find as1:04chassid, and it's a little bit deep.1:06We'll try to simplify it as much as we can,1:09but at the end he just writes,1:13Ein kamaqom l'haarich yoter ka'ait. It's not the time to write more at length about it,1:17which means it's for us to think about it a little deeper.1:19So let's begin.1:25Mi shemitnaheg afilu b'chol divrei hareshut v'tzocheh gufanim b'kedushah. A person who conducts himself with everything that he does,1:29even things where there's no command for it,1:31what we call1:33devar hareshut. Devar hareshut is mundane things that Torah permitted you to do.1:36You have no mitzvah; it's not an1:39aveirah. So I'll give you a little background.1:41It's brought down in the sefarim, especially in sefer Musar,1:43Chovot HaLevavot as well,1:45is that every action a person does1:47could be divided into three possibilities what they are.1:50It's either a mitzvah, an aveirah, or1:54devar hareshut. A mitzvah is where the Torah commands you, you must do it.1:56For example, building a sukkah, sitting in the sukkah.1:59What are you doing1:59that? You're actually doing a mitzvah,2:01living in the land of Eretz Yisrael. It's a mitzvah.2:05Then there's2:05aveirah. Torah says, for example,2:07don't speak lashon hara.2:08It's an action that you're doing2:10that is asur, speaking lashon hara.2:13Can't just, you know,2:14no, you're doing an2:16aveirah. And then there is2:18devar hareshut. Well, let's say, for example,2:20you choose to talk about the sports game.2:23You're not—what are you doing?2:23You talk about the sports game.2:25Now, if you're happy to talk about the sports game2:26in the middle of chazara, that's an2:28aveirah. And if you talk about it in the middle of learning Torah,2:31so that's also an2:33aveirah. But if regular time, when you're speaking,2:36regular talking to your friend,2:37and you talk about the sports game,2:38there's no aveirah in what you're saying.2:40It's not a mitzvah either2:41to talk about the sports,2:43but it's called2:45devar hareshut. No problem,2:46devar hareshut. You're permitted.2:47There's a lot of what we call2:48middle area, gray area,2:50that there's no—you know, it's optional.2:52You can do it.2:53You don't have to do it.2:54Says Rav2:55Tzadok, if in this area2:57where there is no mitzvah to do what it is,2:59you actually conduct yourself with kedushah.3:02In the times when you have the option to speak,3:03in the times when you have the option to eat3:05whatever you like,3:06you do it with kedushah.3:08Rav Tzadok, what does it mean with kedushah?3:13Shekol ma'asav l'shem shamayim, that everything they do is for the sake of Hashem.3:15What does Hashem want me to do?3:18I have a chiyuv right now to build a sukkah.3:19I have a chiyuv to do a certain mitzvah,3:22but I want to3:23do—what would Hashem want me to do?3:27U'machnis bahen avodat v'ratzon Hashem yitbarach, and in your action,3:29you infuse in them3:31the service of Hashem.3:33You want to hear an example?3:34He brings an example over here:3:37kederech she'amru zeh b'Hallel Shamayim. Like the way Chazal told us3:39about Hallel Shamayim. What does the Gemara say,3:42Masechet Beitzah, daf tet-zayin amud aleph, about Hallel Shamayim? The Gemara says3:43about Hallel Shamayim—I'm not going to read it inside,3:45maybe a line or3:46two—the Gemara says3:48about Hallel Shamayim that all their whole day,3:50the whole week,3:52revolved around Shabbat.3:54But they did it in two different ways.3:57Shammai would go every single day,3:59every time he would see something,4:02says the Gemara,4:03that his whole life,4:04whatever he did was l'kavod Shabbat.4:05If he would find an animal,4:07he'd say,4:07This animal is for Shabbat.4:08Next day,4:09he found a better animal,4:11he says,4:11No, this is going to be for Shabbat.4:13And then if he found a better animal,4:15this will be Shabbat.4:16So whatever he did was always for Shabbat.4:18And Hillel,4:19zakein, has a different trait,4:20which was all4:22l'shem Shamayim, as says the Gemara,4:23Baruch4:24Hashem, yom yom.4:25Everything they did was for the sake of4:27Shamayim, which means4:28that they both had ways of serving Hashem4:32l'shem Shamayim, each one in his own way.4:33That means Hillel said,4:35I'm going to find whatever I need on Friday;4:37every other day4:37had his other kavanot4:39for how to serve HaKadosh Baruch Hu with it.4:41One who conducts his4:45devar harishut, his mundane actions,4:46his mundane words,4:47his mundane time4:49in such a manner,4:50he says,4:52Zehu nikra chasid. This is who we call a4:56chasid. This is not a guy4:58who's medakdek to do everything precisely as halacha says.5:01If you're that guy5:01that's5:02medakdek exactly what5:03does halacha say, mutar, asur,5:05you're a tzaddik.5:06But a guy who is not5:08medakdek, he goes beyond what his obligation is,5:11right?5:11He's not really doing what his obligation is,5:13doing beyond,5:14that is a5:16chasid. And he says,5:19V'ze nikra b'chol levavecha. And when the Torah says,5:25V'ahavta et Hashem Elokecha b'chol levavcha, b'chol nafshecha, uv'chol me'odecha, you have to love Hashem with all your heart.5:29And the Gemara says,5:30Why levavcha? There's two bets that are written in this word.5:34It's supposed to be5:35libecha. And the Gemara says,5:39Bishnei yetzrecha, with your two yetzarim. There's yetzer hara and yetzer tov. You have to love Hashem also with the yetzer tov.5:42It sounds great,5:44but what does that mean,5:44you love Hashem with5:45yetzer hara? I mean, with the5:46yetzer hara. I understand how you love Him with5:48yetzer hatov, but with the5:49yetzer hara? Yetzer hara is not a good guy.5:50We're supposed to ignore that guy5:51and beat him up5:51and run away from him.5:53How do you love Hashem with the5:55yetzer hara? So he explains,5:56that's what we mean.5:57And the yetzer hara means,5:59in the area where the yetzer hara has permission,6:03כביכול, to, you know, run free.6:04He has free time,6:05free play,6:07and he's, you know, it's6:10דבר הרשות. And even there, in6:12דבר הרשות, you take it and you pull it towards6:14service of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.6:18Why? שצדיק הוא הכובש את יצרו. A regular tzaddik is a guy who suppresses the6:26yetzer hara. אבל זה מכניס קדושה גם בכל חמדות היצר. But this guy, what he does is,6:28is that even where the yetzer hara craves food,6:33lust,6:34desires,6:35not forbidden ones,6:37right?6:38What's the problem?6:38The guy eats a good steak.6:40Where does it say it's6:41assur? We're not talking about a guy who is6:43always running after that good steak,6:45not checking6:46hishgachot and putting himself at risk,6:47and the guy6:48who's naval birshut haTorah, like the Ramban says.6:50No, we're not talking about that guy.6:51Once in a while,6:52a guy enjoys steak.6:52What is the problem with that?6:54According to6:55halacha, there's no problem.6:56It's still,6:57you can't take away from the fact that6:59that's the area of the7:00yetzer hara that could, of course,7:01pull a person.7:02It's a little dangerous,7:03and we see people that could get7:05too pulled after7:07yetzer hara. But this guy7:08who, in that arena,7:10uses7:12it for HaKadosh Baruch Hu, says, Yeah,7:13I love steak.7:14I'm going to use7:16that love of steak7:17to have steak דווקא on Rosh Chodesh,7:22דווקא on Yamim Tovim, דווקא on Shabbat,7:24special days.7:24That's when I eat my steak.7:27And I have this desire.7:28I'm going to use7:29it דווקא. You know, it's a good thing, by the way,7:30to train kids.7:31To get them those special things,7:35don't get them anytime.7:36It's Rosh Chodesh,7:37we get a special treat.7:38You know,7:39in my family, for example,7:40they love sushi,7:41so we tell them,7:42sushi, Rosh Chodesh.7:43Now,7:44it shouldn't become a7:46chok v'lo ya'avor, because then it becomes a little too much again also.7:48But7:49there's something special for Rosh Chodesh.7:51We reserve those special things.7:53Try to do it for Rosh Chodesh.7:55Now, that's a very small level,7:57a level of shamayim and things, but it's—8:00It's the same idea that we're trying to explain,8:02that a person should infuse, even in the areas where it's divrei reshut, make it for8:08avodat HaKadosh Baruch Hu.8:10Ve'az Hashem yitbarach. So what does Hashem do then?8:14Midah keneged midah. You are putting kedushah in8:17the davar hareshut. You are infusing holiness in the arena where the yetzer hara is taking over.8:22Hashem will also8:25now take kedushah. Bechol ma sheya'aseh, Hashem also is mezakeh you that you should put kedushah in everything that you do.8:29Vezocheh lehotzi kedushah harbeh min hayetzer hara, daika.8:34Then you're zocheh to actually remove a lot of kedushah from the8:38yetzer hara. Yetzer hara is holding to a lot of kedushah, we should know.8:41That kedushah is taken from many people who don't use their8:46kedushah. Hashem supplies the world with a tremendous amount of8:50kedushah, and many people waste that opportunity.8:53It goes in the hands of the8:54yetzer hara. We could pull it out.8:56You know, there are a lot of holy souls, the sefarim bring down,9:00that go to the sitra9:03achra. If you want to see it in real life,9:06there are a lot of evil people that look like evil,9:09but their neshamot are very high9:12neshama. And if they would do teshuvah and they would be tzaddikim,9:16they would be probably one of the greatest tzaddikim.9:18I'll show you a few examples in history, and you can turn back and see.9:22We could show you a few examples.9:23For example, let's take a person who did not use it properly,9:28Achab. Achab was a man who could have been unbelievably great.9:32Hashem was so patient with him.9:34Hashem kept on sending him and sending him things upon things,9:38people, and Eliyahu Navi, and trying to, you know, be patient and to help him.9:42He didn't use it properly.9:44He didn't use his powers properly,9:46and he became Achab, the king that the Gemara says,9:49that the Mishnah says,9:51ein lo chelek l'olam haba. And then you have somebody like Rabbi Akiva.9:54Who was the epitome of9:58Am Haaretz before he became a Rabbi Akiva.10:00Yet, when he woke up and he realized what he, you know, what he should be doing,10:06look what he became.10:08Can you imagine Rabbi Akiva10:10stayed an Am Haaretz? Imagine seeing those water drops and just saying,10:13Yeah, it's a nice idea, and continuing with his own life.10:16Wow.10:18That, that would have been a tremendous loss10:21for the entire Jewish people throughout all of history.10:24But here's again,10:25and neshama that was by the10:27Sitra Achra, the Baruch Hashem was utilized.10:29How many Rabbi Akivas do you think are out there?10:32Huh?10:32How many people are there?10:33How much inside of us could have been a Rabbi Akiva,10:37what we could have done?10:38So the yetzer hara is holding on to a lot of those things.10:42When we zocheh to pull kedusha in his arena, we get to pull out of him10:45a lot of the kedusha that he has in his bank account,10:49and that's what's called10:52nikra tov me'od. We know that Hashem, when He created the world,10:55He calls a lot of things10:56tov, and at the end He calls it10:58tov me'od, and the Gemara says, What's tov10:59me'od? That's mita.11:00Now, mita is given over to the11:02yetzer hara, who is also known as malach11:04ha-mavet. What's going on?11:05What does that mean?11:08So yoter mi-tov stam. Tov me'od is better than a regular tov.11:09A tov me'od is11:12that you're able to take,11:13even within the area of evil,11:14you're able to pull out and extract the good.11:21And that's the explanation also11:23when Chazal11:24say that the place of the baalei teshuva11:26is where they stand,11:27even great tzaddikim don't stand there.11:29What does that mean,11:30even great tzaddikim don't stand there?11:31And the answer is because11:34baalei teshuva,11:35a tzaddik is so careful11:36he doesn't go off the path.11:40The rasha11:42who goes off the path11:43and then he decides to do teshuva,11:45so technically11:46he could take that part.11:48Remember, like we learned in earlier pieces,11:50you could take the11:51aveirot, turn them to11:52mitzvot. You could take that part from the evil side11:54and make it kadosh,11:57which a tzaddik can never do.11:59Therefore, they could stand in a place12:00that even the tzaddikim cannot stand.12:03Hamashal to this:12:04who's the best,12:05best, best cop12:08in law enforcement,12:12an ex-criminal. We all know that,12:13because he knows.12:14He knows exactly how criminals think.12:17A regular guy that grew up in a law enforcement family,12:21has never, you know, done anything wrong.12:23He never drives above 55 miles an hour12:27anywhere, you know, on any highway.12:29So this guy doesn't know what it's like to be bad,12:33right? He just looks for the bad guys12:35where he thinks he can find them.12:36But the guy who was the bad guy12:39knows exactly what the bad guy is thinking,12:41and he knows how to stop them.12:43That is, in a way, a mashal12:44that we can understand what a tzaddik,12:47what the difference between a tzaddik and this12:49chassid. The chassid is the12:51baal teshuva, because the baal teshuva could go to the area of the12:54yetzer hara and mamash pull out from there.12:56So what does Hashem do to this12:58chassid who brings in a lot of kedusha?12:59You might say,13:00a great reward,13:01yeah? We just said kedusha,13:02but guess what it says over here?13:03A little shocking.13:04Hashem actually brings him stumbling blocks,13:11and he trips on them.13:15And then he needs to do teshuva on these sins.13:22And through this, he could take out those precious things13:24from very lowly areas.13:27Who do you know?13:29In amongst the great Jewish people,13:31that was called a13:39chasid. דְּפִלָּא לְדָוִד. שָׁמְרָה נַפְשִׁי כִּי חָסִיד אָנִי. Hashem, guard myself because I'm a13:41chasid. David was a13:42chasid. He wasn't called a tzaddik;13:43he was called a13:45chasid. And he is the greatest example13:47of a person who goes beyond the letter of the law,13:51and yet Hashem put him in situations13:54where he was13:56nichshal. The whole story with13:57Bat Sheva, which came as an accident,13:59and although technically it wasn't14:02an aveirah, but on his level it was14:03an aveirah, and he did teshuvah his whole life.14:05And from that we have many perakim in Sefer Tehillim,14:08and to the point the Chazal say14:10that the reason why he sinned14:11is only to teach future baalei14:14teshuvah, or future people that sin,14:16the ways of14:17teshuvah. That's a14:19chasid. The chasid, Hashem puts him in situations14:24that are, ay, that seem like,14:25oh my gosh,14:26what a terrible sin,14:26and then he has to get himself out.14:28And by getting himself out of it14:31through teshuvah, of course,14:32not through avoiding consequences,14:34but through14:36teshuvah, he is14:38zocheh to be motzi yakar mizolel. But a tzaddik she'eino yotzei mishurat hadin. But a tzaddik who's so careful,14:42he stays on the path,14:43do what's right,14:44never go off.14:46Meaning to say,14:48chas v'shalom, don't think that the chasid is trying to do14:50aveirah. No.14:50The tzaddik who's very on the path,14:52he doesn't even do14:58lifnim mishurat hadin. And Hashem is also careful with the tzaddik.15:00As the pasuk says,15:01there is no evil that could come upon the tzaddik.15:05That means, you know,15:06twistedness,15:06any bad things,15:08any bad actions.15:09It says of tzaddik,15:12Kol latzaddik daika. The pasuk says15:13davka for the tzaddik, not the15:15chasid. The tzaddik who's so careful,15:16everything he does is15:19al pi hadin. According to the letter of the law,15:21doesn't stray left and right,15:23doesn't do beyond what he's supposed to do,15:26and should make sure that no slippery things should come his way.15:31V'lachen amru. That's why you can understand now another story.15:34Before we get to15:37Rav Tzadok, so I wanted to give you the background,15:39which is the story in the Gemara.15:39The Gemara says15:43in Masechet Shabbat, daf kuf chav-zayin amud bet, there there's a whole entire page that deals with the concept of dan l'chaf zechut.15:48A person should judge other people favorably.15:50Even when things15:51don't, you could interpret a person's actions to mean bad or good,15:57interpret them to mean good.15:59Okay, so the Gemara brings this.16:00Story of maaseh16:02b'chasid echad. And Rashi on the spot says,16:04whenever it says maaseh16:06b'chasid echad, whenever the Gemara anywhere in Shas says16:08there's a story about a16:10certain chasid, it's referring to either16:12Rabbi16:13Yehuda ben Bava or Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi16:16Elai. Good? So a story with one of these rabbis,16:18maaseh16:19b'chasid echad, where one time there was a16:20mezonot pidyon shvuyim. He went and he, you know, there was a girl, Jewish girl,16:24that was taken to captivity,16:25and he redeemed her.16:27When he came back,16:29he put her in his room16:30and he locked the16:32door, and his talmidim all slept outside.16:34In the morning he woke up16:36and he went to the mikveh.16:38Now, usually go to the mikveh16:40if you saw keri at night.16:43So he comes back to his students,16:45he says,16:47Rabotai, what did you suspect me of16:49when I took the girl16:50and I locked her up from everybody else?16:52So they all replied,16:53Rabbi, we honestly, we thought16:55that maybe you don't trust us with any of the girls,16:58right? In 2022 everybody would say,17:00What do you think the rabbis are doing,17:02right? But back then there17:04were tzaddikim. So he says, No, we suspect17:06that maybe we are17:07not—you didn't trust one of us.17:10And he says, And when in the morning17:12I woke up and I went to the17:13mikveh, what did you suspect me of?17:15You know, that sounds a little more fishy.17:16He says, Well, we thought that maybe17:20from traveling17:21it could cause a person to see17:23keri in his dreams.17:25He says, You're right.17:26I swear to you that that's exactly what happened,17:28and just like you judged me favorably, Hashem should judge you favorably.17:31That's the story in the Gemara.17:33Good? Now he says over here,17:35why does the Gemara17:37mention17:39maaseh d'raah keri oto chasid? Why does the Gemara mention17:40that he was a17:42chasid, and it brings the story that he happened to see17:45keri? So he explains,17:51ולא בחינם נקרא שם בשמו אותו החסיד. And that Gemara didn't just happen17:52to call him a chassid randomly.17:55No, that is a17:57chassid. A chassid is a guy who goes beyond17:59what he's expected to do,18:00and Hashem could sometimes put him in this situation18:03where, you know, like this guy,18:04he's so caring. It wasn't his fault.18:07He didn't bring himself to18:08להיות caring, but he's so caring. But now he has to do teshuvah for it,18:10but by doing that teshuvah, he's able18:13to bring out that18:14kedushah that the yetzer hara is holding on to.18:17We find another example.18:18The Gemara Masechet Eruvin18:19talks about Adam HaRishon. It says he was a chassid gadol,18:22Adam HaRishon.18:23Yet it says that for 130 years he saw18:28kari b'ones. Again, he says,18:30Daika l'chassid, Hashem yitbarach masbin zeh l'hotzi yakar mizolel. דווקא for such a person,18:35the chassid, Hashem18:37puts him in the situation where he has to bring out18:40the18:40yakar, the special thing from zolel.18:43Yakar is the letters18:45kari, as known from the Arizal. He says,18:50כי נפשות שפרטי הקרי הם יותר גנאי יוצאים מזיווג. The Arizal says the souls that come out from18:54the kari that comes out of a18:55person are actually greater than the ones that are18:58born from husband and wife.18:59Now, you can't do that on purpose19:01because it's such a tremendous19:02aveirah, but if it happens to a person,19:04and a person who's trying very, very hard19:07to be a tzaddik and a19:09chassid, then it's a sign that19:11that person has the ability19:12to be metaken, to mend this amount of19:15neshamot.19:16Again, it's not the time to speak about it, but19:18we should strive to be19:20tzaddikim and chassidim in a good way.19:22We shouldn't put ourselves in19:24a situation, chas v'shalom, that we should sin. Then we're called19:26resha'im. A rasha is a person who even19:28puts himself in the possibility of sinning.19:31But when it does19:32happen, we should understand19:34that perhaps Hashem holds of us19:36something great,19:38and if there's what looks like an19:40aveirah, it means that we could do19:42teshuvah, and we19:44could bring,19:46you know, tremendous fixing19:48to the sin and the mistake that we've done.