Torah · MussarMussar100. How תשובה Can Turn Sins Into זכויותTzidkat HaTzadikPart 100Rabbi Uri Nahum · September 14, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0019:58Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, Ot Kof. This piece is reminiscent of an earlier piece that we did, Ot0:09Mem. And so if you have the tracks, you can go back to track 40. I would recommend to go back and to0:15see. It's a very, very deep concept. It's a concept that kind of challenges the way we understand0:22freedom of choice, because we know, as Chazal tell us, that kol bidei Shamayim chutz miyirat Shamayim. Everything is in the control of0:32Hashem except for yirat Shamayim. And we also know that Hashem doesn't decide if a person is going to be0:41a tzaddik or rasha. Hashem decides everything else, but not if it's tzaddik or rasha. Freedom of0:46choice is in our control. We control everything. We already discussed such a concept0:52where we find that really through teshuvah, a person kind of reverts his averot and actually they1:01turn out to be mitzvot. And Rav Tzadok earlier explained in Ot Mem how that works. It's a very1:07similar concept over here in Ot Kof, and he quotes also Midrash that supports it. It's a very deep idea1:13because, like I told you, it challenges the foundations that we all, you know, grew up on. And it's1:22not that it challenges; we're going to hopefully, be'ezrat Hashem, today show you that it's not really a challenge, but how it1:26actually works. Again, it's a deep idea. It needs much thinking, and we have to know and, you know, make sure1:36that's established in our heads that freedom of choice is completely in the hands of a person.1:41Even after we read this, be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully, if it's not clear, you'll make sure you contact me,1:47and we hope to clarify it a little bit more. So let's begin with Ot Kof.1:55Teshuvah. What is the concept of2:00teshuvah? היינו שמשיב אותו דבר להשם יתברך. The simple meaning of teshuvah that we always understood is that we return to Hashem, i.e., I was2:07close to Hashem, I was keeping a certain mitzvah, I stopped keeping the mitzvah, or I started doing2:13aveirah, and therefore I distanced myself to Hashem. I go back to my olden ways. When I do2:18teshuvah, I go back to my olden ways, and now I'm a good boy again. I fixed what I did. I'm back to being2:24close to Hashem. So that is true. And Rav Tzadok now gives another aspect of teshuvah, and he says2:34that teshuvah means that you take that item, whatever it was, and you bring it back to Hashem.2:40What does it mean, bring it back to Hashem? רצה לומר שמכיר שהכל פועל השם יתברך. You come to the recognition that everything2:49is from HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Everything is being made; Hashem controlled everything.2:58וכוחו, and the person's ability to do anything,3:04אפילו המחשבה טרם נוצרה בלבו של אדם, that includes even the thought before it came to my mind, even before it came to be that I thought3:10about such an idea, that also is from HaKadosh Baruch Hu. כמו שאמרו זל, like it says in the Midrash,3:22Bereshit Rabbah, נפצה השם יתברך נתן לו כוח. Hashem is the one who gives you all the koach. So if that's so, if all my abilities,3:29all my energies, all my powers, all my thoughts are all from HaKadosh Baruch Hu, He's the one who3:35gives me everything, as גמבאבירא, so if that's true, then also... Through a sin. How was I able to do a sin?3:44It was only because I thought about it, I planned it, or I didn't plan to, you know, push away the3:52yetzer hara, and then I had the ability and the power to do it. But where'd that all come from? That all came from HaKadosh Baruch Hu. That all3:58came from Hashem. So then, so then by recognizing afterwards, and I come back and I said, I really4:06feel terrible about what I did, and I fix my ways. That's number one. And then I think about4:12and I say, Whoa, where did everything come from? I realize that it all came from HaKadosh Baruch Hu.4:16That's called teshuvah, bringing back the action to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. He says,4:23And then when you do such a complete teshuvah, again, it starts with first stopping the bleeding,4:30means stop the aveirah, then go back and fix it, and then in machshavah bring back the thoughts4:37and recognize that everything comes from HaKadosh Baruch Hu, then you zocheh, shezedonot na'asot kizchuyot. And then you zocheh to what the Gemara4:51says, what we call teshuvah me'ahavah, where your sins actually end up being a mitzvah. Why? What's the logic? We've always heard that if you do teshuvah me'ahavah, then your aveirot turn into4:59mitzvot. How could that be? What is the logic with that? I understand if I don't get punished,5:04but I should get rewarded for it. To give you a mashal, just to make this, you know,5:09a little bit more realistic. You run a red light, you drive into a red light, and there's a cop right5:13there, a cop pulls you over, he says, Sir, did you not see the red light? And you tell him, Of5:17course I saw it, but I didn't see you. You get a ticket for running into a red light, and for being so5:24chutzpahdik, he gives you another ticket for aggressive driving. Okay? You come to court, you plead not5:30guilty, you show up to court, or if you're in Jersey where you have to come to court anyway,5:33you stand in court and the judge says, Sir, did you do this? And now... You realize, you know,5:39you were a terrible thing you did. You're a wise guy, and the cop is right there testifying against you,5:43or the prosecutor is right there testifying. You say, Dear judge, I have to tell you, I did it,5:50and I feel terrible. I really feel horrible about what I did. I sort of thought about it. It was5:54so silly of me to do it, and it was really not nice the way I spoke to the cop. And you start to5:59shed tears and you cry, and the cop sees that—I mean, the judge sees that you're very sincere. In fact, even the6:04prosecutor feels bad. Says, Look, Mr. Judge, you know, you see me here for years. I've been prosecuting6:09people for years, but I really feel bad for this guy. I can't really drop the charges because I6:13work for the city, but, like, I'm asking to please, you know, I see this guy is very sincere.6:21So the judge says, You know what? You're forgiven. Don't worry about it. You have two tickets. Each6:26one is going to cost you $500. I'm dropping the charges, and I understand you have a family to6:31feed, and it's not so easy for you how to make ends meet, and I see that you really feel bad for what6:35you did. We're dropping the charges. That makes sense, right? It makes sense to a certain extent.6:41Is it possible? It's possible. But I can't understand the next step. The judge says, I see6:46how terribly you feel, and therefore those $500 tickets each that you have, instead of you having6:54to pay it, we're not going to give you $1,000. Right? That's what we're saying when your7:00aveirot turn into a mitzvot. How could that be? Why? So explains the Tzadok, כי גם זה היה רצון השם יתברך כך. Because, let's—the mashal is not exactly7:13accurate. We gave the mashal to a regular human being, but let's think about it for a second.7:18There's something called sachar. There's something called reward. Why do we get reward? You know7:22why we get rewarded? Because when we do a mitzvah. Okay, why is it that when we do a mitzvah, we get reward?7:28Simple, because that's what Hashem wants. You know, sometimes people think it's a mitzvah and they do something.7:34Really, it's not a mitzvah. They don't get rewarded for that. For example, we all know the mitzvah of honoring7:39one's parents. And if your parents tell you to do something, you're supposed to do it. So if your father says,7:44Can you please get me a cup of water? Even though you're, like, sitting there, relaxed on the couch, reading your book,7:48and you're up to a very exciting part, you're supposed to put the book down, go up, and get him the cup of water right away.7:52Good? So you get rewarded for listening to your father. But if your father tells you on Shabbat, Please, it's—8:00You're wasting money with this electricity. Shut it off. Shut off the AC.8:04It's asur to listen to your father.8:06And if you think you're doing a mitzvah by listening to your father, you're not,8:09because Hashem said, Don't listen to your father when he tells you to do something against the Torah.8:14And if you do put on the AC, it's not like, oh, you get a sin for breaking Shabbat,8:20but you also get a reward for listening to your father.8:23No, you don't get any reward. You didn't listen to your father.8:25I mean, you didn't listen to Hashem.8:27You only get rewarded for a mitzvah because that's what Hashem wants.8:31Hashem doesn't want you to listen to your father when he tells you to break the8:36Torah and to be mechalel Shabbat,8:38and that's why you don't get rewarded.8:39But when we do get rewarded, it's because we listen to Hashem, and that's what Hashem wants.8:44So it comes out that when I take my aveirah and I think about it and I see that the8:51power or the ability or even the thought of doing the aveirah was what Hashem wanted,8:57because how else would I have gotten the energy?9:00But this could only happen after I actually stopped doing the aveirah and when it wasn't planned.9:07And I actually come back and I say, How in the world was I able to do such a thing9:10if it wasn't for Hashem wanting me to do it?9:12It comes out that my aveirah was really ratzon Hashem, and if it's ratzon Hashem,9:17if that's the will of God, just like on a mitzvah you get rewarded because that's the will of Hashem,9:22so too on a sin. When you've made it the will of Hashem,9:27when you've come to realize it's the will of Hashem, you also turn it into a9:39zechuyot. Ki gam zeh hayah retzon Hashem yitbarach kach, kemo she'amru, like Chazal tell us on the pasuk, Im yechata'echem ka-shanim ka-sheleg yalbinu. Hashem says, Come, I'm going to whiten your sins.9:42If they were like red wool, I'm going to make them pure as snow.9:46What is that? How could that be?9:48And it says, when we come to realize that it's all from You, Hashem,9:51Hashem is the one who's going to come and cleanse it and turn it around.9:53Now, he brings the Midrash.9:57U'le'inyan she'amru zal al ha-pasuk, Nora alilah al bnei adam.10:01Like Chazal tell us in the Midrash.10:02I'm telling you this source of the Midrash.10:05I don't know how much I'm going to be able to bring out in this recording10:08because I'm limited also on time,10:11but I want you to please check out this Midrash.10:13It's a Midrash in Tanhuma, Parashat Vayeshev,10:17ot dalet. Unbelievable Midrash.10:19The pasuk says, Nora... nora alilah bnei adam.10:22Nora is wondrous things.10:25Alilah—alilah means like an excuse, or, yeah, an excuse to bring it on a person.10:31Then the Midrash gives a mashal, but it gives a few examples of this mashal,10:34where we see in history where Hashem kind of like wanted something to happen,10:38and He was waiting for an opportunity for it to happen.10:42I'm not going to give the mashal, actually; it's going to take too long.10:44I'm looking at the recording right now,10:46but I'm going to tell you what the Midrash says over there.10:48The Midrash says over there,10:50you know, we seem to blame Adam HaRishon for the sin of eating from10:55etz hadaat, but there the Midrash says, Nora alilah bnei adam.10:57You're the one who Hashem planned this.10:59We know the Torah was written11:04almost 2,000 generations before the world was created,11:08and in the Torah it says—the Midrash11:10says—in the Torah it says already,11:14Adam ki yamut... Zot haTorah: adam ki yamut ba'ohel. The Torah already describes the laws of tumah and taharah of a person11:18who comes in contact with a dead body.11:20That means the concept of death existed beforehand.11:23Yet we find Hashem telling Adam HaRishon,11:25You should know, when you eat from11:28the etz hadaat, you'll bring death to the world.11:29I don't understand. Death was bound to come.11:32Because you wrote in the Torah,11:34you're just waiting for the opportunity for Adam to do it.11:38And that's, I mean, the Midrash sort of blames, כביכול, HaKadosh Baruch Hu11:43for the actions of certain people.11:46Adam HaRishon, Midrash talks about the brothers of Yosef11:49because of Yosef, bringing them down to Egypt,11:51Moshe Rabbeinu. It's a very, very interesting Midrash.11:55After you hear this recording, go back to the Midrash11:56and you see how amazing it is.11:58So you see that the ability that I was able to do it12:02was really planned out from HaKadosh Baruch Hu.12:04Like David HaMelech, he continues here,12:06Rav Sadok says,12:12ודרך שאמר דוד המלך עליו השלום, למען תצדק בדברך. In order that You should become, Hashem, that You should become righteous in Your words.12:20This is why we find that at certain times12:23Hashem takes away His assistance from certain people,12:25that they should kind of end up in the hole.12:29If so, that should be like12:33his זכות. That when you come to that realization,12:35again, not when it's planned,12:37like David HaMelech,12:39after he recognizes his mistake with Bat Sheva12:41and he did this all his life,12:42then that was really the plan of HaKadosh Baruch Hu,12:45right?12:47כביכול, that's when the12:49mitzvah—that's, excuse me, that's when the aveirah actually turns into mitzvah,12:51because at the end of the day12:53it was all one and the same.12:54It was planned by HaKadosh Baruch Hu,12:58was the ratzon of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.13:04וזה שנאמר, וחסידיך ירננו. Now you can understand another Midrash13:06on the pasuk in Tehillim that says,13:09Your13:10chasidim, Hashem, Your chasidim will rejoice.13:16אמרו חזל, אלו רשעי ישראל. You would never think to hear such a Midrash.13:18Midrash says, Who are the13:20chasidim? Again, not to mix with the13:22modern-day chasidim. Chasidim is a person who does13:25beyond the letter of the law.13:26The Gemara says those are the resha'ei Yisrael.13:30V'chen ha-pasuk also, another pasuk says,13:36Isfu li chasidai, koretei briti alei zevach, gather for Me My13:38chasidim, says HaKadosh Baruch Hu.13:39And again, the Gemara says, I mean the Midrash says,13:45those are resha'ei Yisrael.13:46You want to know where the Midrash is?13:48It's13:49Yalkut Shimoni, in Sefer13:51Yeshayahu, remez13:52reish tzadi-vav. Look it up.13:53Now it says, what is a13:58chasid? A person is supposed to be a tzaddik.13:59What's this concept of14:00chasid? Tzaddik is, there's a path,14:02the correct path that a person is supposed to do.14:04You do correct things, you're a tzaddik.14:06Chasid, you go beyond the tzaddik.14:09You go off the path.14:10You're off the derech,14:11כביכול, but in a positive way.14:13So he says,14:17פירוש כי חסיד הוא הנוטה משורת הדין את חסד. A chasid is really a person14:19who goes off the path14:21to do more and better things14:24for HaKadosh Baruch Hu.14:26And rasha, if you think about it,14:27is also the same thing,14:28except to the other side of the path.14:30The path is in the middle.14:32That's a tzaddik.14:33The chasid goes off the path to the right,14:35and the rasha also goes off the path.14:37He also goes off the derech,14:38but to the left.14:42וכן רשע נוטה משורת הדין לרשעה, goes off the path to do evil.14:48And in the future, when a person decides,14:50when that rasha decides,14:51I want to do14:52teshuva. I want to fix my ways.14:53I want to go back on that path,14:57right? And when he decides,14:57and at that point14:58Hashem opens up the gates of15:00teshuva, and a person is able to really do proper15:04teshuva, ויקירה כל כוח מחותו. And in the future,15:06Hashem, everybody's going to come to recognize15:15the15:16power of Hashem's kingdom. נפסע זה דונו שהיו נטייה משורת הדין, היו חסידות, כיוון שהיו נוטים מהמידות רצון, השם יתברך. לעולם ה' opens up the gates of15:18teshuva. It means that He is waiting for us to do15:22teshuva. So I could open up those gates.15:23It comes out that that's Ratzon Hashem.15:25Hashem is waiting for that15:27teshuvah. That means15:28this is all part of Ratzon Hashem,15:30that we have to go kind of15:31in the hole to get out of it.15:35In the words of the Gemara,15:36Yeridah l'tzorech aliyah.15:37It's going down15:39for the sake of going up.15:40So it comes out in the future,15:42when we come to recognize that we went off the path,15:44we are really like15:46chassidim who also went off the path.15:47But15:48when we did it on our own will15:51to do bad things,15:54we're considered reshaim. When we realize that15:57it's from HaKadosh Baruch Hu, we're like the15:58chassidim that also went off the path,15:59but for the good one.16:00Now he says, look at the diyuk also in the words.16:04The two pesukim that the Midrash works with,16:07one says, Vachasidecha yiranenu, Hashem, Your chassidim will rejoice.16:11Another pasuk says,16:15Isfu li chasidei. Says Rav Tzadok, how come it doesn't say the generic term16:18chassidim? Why does it say16:22chasidei, chasidecha? He says, you know why?16:26Rak shees Hashem yitbarach hem keruyim chassidim, because only Hashem can really call them16:29chassidim. As human beings, those are reshaim that went off the path.16:32We can't imagine that they should be16:35chassidim; they're off the path.16:36But only Hashem will recognize that really that was His ratzon.16:39He could testify and say, These are My16:46chassidim. Vetzaddik vachasidim sheteihem derech kol bnei adam, uvetolada. There are two levels in the person.16:49There's completely two different levels.16:50There's a tzaddik and there's a16:52chasid. There are two different levels in how a person acts,16:54also how a person is born.16:58Val ze amru, Barata tzaddikim, barata reshaim, and that's why we can understand now.17:00Gemara says, Hashem, You create tzaddikim and You17:03create reshaim. What do you mean?17:06It doesn't say tzaddik and17:09rasha; it says tzaddikim and reshaim. Like it says in the Gemara, there's a tzaddik and there's a17:12rasha. They make the kid promise, Be a tzaddik and don't be17:18a rasha. And you understand, it's not a choice;17:20it's the ability.17:21Hashem gave the ability for a person to be a tzaddik or17:26a rasha. That's the meaning that Hashem created17:29reshaim. That's the meaning that there's a ratzon of Hashem that should be17:33a rasha, not that He wants you to do that evil act.17:37It means that once the act has been done17:39and you recognize that that ability came from HaKadosh Baruch Hu,17:43then it works.17:47Like the word rasha, hu shem chasid, kenizkar le'eil. Instead of a tzaddik, it's really a17:51chasid, supposed to be. Instead of17:52rasha, that's the other level that we're mentioning.17:54There's a tzaddik and a17:55chasid. The rasha and the chasid is kind of the same idea. In concept, but not in action.18:02ושני כוחות מרובים בכל אדם, and these two powers are in every single person:18:05the ability to do the right thing and to do beyond the right thing,18:09going off the18:11derech, but off the derech in a positive way, to be a18:13chassid; off the derech, להבדיל, in a negative way, to be a rasha in a certain area.18:16רק אינם שווים באחד זה גובר ובאחד זה גובר. But even though every person has this ability inside of him,18:24everybody has this ability to be a18:25tzaddik or not a18:28tzaddik. For some people, one overpowers the other.18:30ואין כאן מקום להאריך, it's not the place to speak at length.18:34So what we want to bring out is that18:36the real teshuvah is18:39to recognize all the abilities in the world really come from Hashem,18:42even our ability to do18:43aveirah. And if so, that comes out that that is the ratzon of Hashem,18:47and if that's the ratzon Hashem,18:48then it comes out that my aveirah was really a mitzvah.18:51But you can only be zocheh to such a thing18:54if you already did your18:55teshuvah, if you already started doing your teshuvah process,18:58which means you stopped the19:00aveirah, you started fixing your ways,19:02and now, thinking back of what was,19:05then you can say such a thing.19:06But you can't come and plan the19:08aveirah. You can't come and say,19:09Look, I want to do this19:11aveirah. If I want to do it,19:12it must be that's Hashem's ratzon, and I'm going to do it.19:14That doesn't work that way.19:16Only once it happens, then you could turn back.19:19That's what Chazal tell us:19:22כל19:27האומר אחטא ואשוב, אין מספיקין בידו לעשות תשובה. Anybody who says, I'm going to plan a sin,19:29they're not allowed to do19:30teshuvah, because that's not called19:32teshuvah. That's—you're not.19:33The whole idea of teshuvah is19:35I'm taking that action19:37and bringing it back to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,19:39where I'm saying it's Hashem, really,19:42but it's not my responsibility;19:43it's Hashem, really, that gave us the ability.19:46But when I come and plan it,19:47then I'm taking full responsibility for my action.19:49It's not Hashem anymore.19:50I'm saying right now I want to do it.19:53Therefore, we— It could only work, as we say, b'diavad.