Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 9, Lesson 9Sefer Even ShelemaPart 162Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0010:56Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Even Shelema, perek tet, ot yud. So ot yud looks very, very small. It's very, very possible that we could actually do today two pieces. Let's see,0:13because yud aleph is also very small. Bechol yom hamusaf yesh lo l'adam neshama0:20yetera. Every day that there's musaf, a person has an extra soul. Interesting,0:24because we know on Shabbat you have an extra soul, but he's saying anytime that there's musaf, like Rosh Chodesh and Yom Tov, there's an extra neshama.0:33Vehu tosfot ruach hakodesh, and that is an additional spiritual ruach hakodesh.0:41So, you know, I don't know how you're going to translate ruach hakodesh, but, you know, you know, you know, ruach hakodesh.0:46To translate, I think I'm going to lose the meaning, but I will translate a Holy Spirit, right?0:52And I don't mean it in like the Christian way, obviously. So ruach hakodesh is ruach hakodesh.0:58That's what I'm going to stick to that. Let's come back, and before we see the source of the Gra, I would like to take you to the bottom over here1:06where they quote. You know, they're being different from different places, not necessarily from the Gra, but to kind of support the idea.1:13Look what he says. Ita b'Gemara, it says1:21in the Gemara, neshama yetera noten HaKadosh Baruch Hu l'adam me'erev Shabbat, motzaei Shabbat notlin otah mimenu. Famous Gemara: on Shabbat, Hashem gives, on Erev Shabbat, right when Shabbat comes in, Hashem gives a person an extra soul.1:28Motzaei Shabbat, they take it away from him, and that's why the pasuk says,1:37Vayechulu... vayechalu hashamayim... No, no, sorry.1:39Vayinafash. That's the word.1:41Vayinafash. Vayinafesh. What does vayinafesh mean? Vayinafesh is the word,1:47Oy, uli... says the Gemara, what's vayinafash? Why are you breaking it up into two words?1:49It says, Vai nefesh, woe to the soul,1:51woe, the soul that came extra on Shabbat and then left him motzaei Shabbat.1:58Okay. On the commentary on Mesachet Pesachim, he writes,2:02Shegam b'Yom Tov yesh neshama yetera k'Shabbat. Also on Yom Tov,2:04the Gemara, Shabbat.2:05So the Rashbam says, right, he could write that.2:07Even though there's an extra soul on Shabbat.2:14Da, the Rashbam explains, because the Gemara over there in Masechet Beitzah deals with havdalah, all the difalah and everything else.2:18Why is it that, like we just had, why is it when we have Yom Tov,2:22we don't make2:24Birkat Besamim? We make Birkat Motzaei Shabbat because the soul leaves us.2:27The Rashbam says that's why on Yom Tov the neshama doesn't leave.2:31We have2:32also neshama yetera on Yom Tov. We don't need to take Birkat Besamim Motzaei Shabbat.2:36That's when there's Yom Tov,2:37and that's the holiday coming up2:39also, Shabbat is going to be the same idea.2:41Tosafot asks the question,2:45Im kein b'Motzaei Yom Tov hayah tzarich birkat besamim. If you tell me that the2:47neshama—to ask a question on2:49the Rashbam—if you tell me the reason why we don't make besamim is because there's neshama also on Yom Tov,2:54so I have a question2:55for you, Rashbam. What happens on Motzaei Shabbat? We make2:58besamim. Why? Because the soul leaves us.3:01So why don't we make also, bechat besamim, on Motzaei Yom Tov?3:05Right? Because we have an extra one,3:08right?3:09Therefore, they said,3:13Lekach nehagu bYom Tov, lekanes neshamah yeteirah. They disagree with3:15him. They disagree with the3:16Rashbam. They hold that on Yom Tov there's no neshamah3:19yeteirah, and that's why we don't make a bracha on besamim on Motzaei Yom Tov.3:23Chachamim do not institute it. That's the machloket between Tosafot versus the3:28Rashbam in Masechet Pesachim. Comes the sefer3:31over here, אבל כדברי הרשבם הוא ... קדוש. However, if you look in the Zohar, it sounds like the3:34Rashbam, right?3:36It says in the Zohar,3:38he writes, There's always a neshamah3:41yeteirah. Now I'm going to jump again,3:43for those who are following with me in the book,3:45go on top to the source that the Emet Shlomo himself brings from the3:49Gra, which comes from Tikunei Zohar.3:52Look what it says in4:00Tikunim, Tikun chaf aleph in Tikunei Zohar: אבל נשמתא יתירה בשבת וביומין טבין ובכל מוספין, היא אימא עילאה, תוספת רוח הקודש. The Zohar says4:04the neshamah yeteirah on Shabbat and on Yom Tov and any time that there's Musaf,4:07it comes from the Ima4:09Ilaa. Ima Ilaa represents the level of4:14sefirat bina, whatever it is, תוספת רוח הקודש. Good?4:15That's the Zohar.4:16And on that, the Gra writes,4:21כאן מפורש בכל יום המוסף יש לו לאדם נשמה יתירה. Here you see clearly from the Zohar telling you4:23that any time there's Musaf, there's a neshamah4:28yeteirah. והיא המוסף תוספת נשמה. That's why for the word musaf, which means additional,4:30and that's the additional neshamah4:33yeteirah. Where does it come from?4:34The Zohar says,4:37Ima Ilaa, which we said it comes from bina, דבחומשכינתא תתאה, from the weak, it comes from the lower part of the4:41Shechinah. That's why it's called4:46Ima, there's Ima Ilaa, Ima Tataa. Okay,4:48וכלל כי הנשמה לפי התפילה, והנשמה יתירה שתוספת רוח הקודש. And the rule is, the general rule is,4:50the neshamah is based on the4:52tefillah. The kind of levels of souls that we would get4:55is based on the prayer that we pray.4:56The fact that we're praying in Musaf,4:57it means there's got to be an additional thing that we have.5:01That's why we have to pray it.5:02Good?5:04Now we come back down to the bottom over here.5:08We come back to the machloket between Rashbam versus Tosafot.5:11According to the Rashbam,5:13there's5:16a neshama yetera even on Yom Tov.5:17Tosafot says no, there isn't.5:18This all clearly sounds like the Rashbam,5:22right?5:22Okay.5:23The Rama writes5:31in Hilchot of Sukkah, דבהושענא רבה אין אומרים נשמת כל חי. The minhag in the Rama's time, we do say5:33it—I mean, we don't say it,5:35right? Hoshana Rabbah is the last day of Sukkot5:36right before Shemini Atzeret,5:37when we stay up the whole night.5:39The minhag is, he says, that5:42they don't say Nishmat Kol Chai on Hoshana Rabbah.5:44Now the5:46Gra writes—why does the Rama have to tell me5:48we don't say Nishmat Kol5:50Chai, right?5:51He writes the words,5:52he refers to the words of the Rashbam.5:55What is that? The Rashbam—now, the Gra doesn't tell us what he means to say.5:58He says,5:59the Mesek Le'eizer, which is a book that was written6:01as a commentary on the Gra's words,6:02he writes,6:09the kavanah of what the Gra is trying to tell us is, if Hoshana Rabbah,6:11Shemini Atzeret, we do make6:12Birkat Beisamim. According to6:14the Rashbam, he says there's no6:16neshama yetera, and nishmat tefilat of nishmat kol6:18חי is only said in days that we have6:22neshama yetera, right? Yeah?6:23So it sounds like what he's trying to tell you6:24is that based6:26on—right, that's what the Rama is trying to tell you.6:27It sounds like the Rama is going like the Rashbam,6:30that today there's no6:32neshama yetera, that's why we don't say Nishmat Kol6:34Chai. Good?6:36But then there's a question,6:38because according to that,6:40why is it the Gra brings from the Zohar?6:42According to the Zohar,6:42it doesn't make a difference.6:43As long as you say Musaf,6:44even on Chol Hamoed we say Musaf.6:46And according to the Zohar,6:47anytime there's Musaf,6:48there's also6:50neshama yetera. So that's a big question,6:52right? So you have to say,6:54he is forced over here to say6:55that there's different levels6:56of a common neshama that we get.7:00ויש לציין מה שכתב מעשה רב. Now, there's a book called Maaseh Rav.7:01This book is a very important book7:03to understand the7:04Gra. He brings a lot of minhagim7:06that the Gra himself used to do,7:08and he brings over there:7:14רבינו הנהג ללבוש בראש חודש כובע של שבת, וכן היה עומד להתפלל בבית מדרשו לכבוד ראש חודש. Says the Gra used to,7:16on Rosh Chodesh,7:18when we do have Musaf7:19and it's even lighter than7:22Chol Hamoed, he would wear the special hat7:23that he would wear also on Shabbat.7:25Rosh Chodesh was a special day like Shabbat.7:27That's how the Gra treated it.7:29And even in his7:30beit midrash, the special candles7:31that they would light for Shabbat,7:32they would light it also on Rosh Chodesh.7:36So sounds like the Gra held like the Zohar all the way.7:40Of course, there might be different levels,7:41because we are permitted to do7:44melachot, but still, that's what he did,7:46right?7:47Okay.7:48So now we said also that7:50whenever you pray,7:51whenever you pray Musaf,7:53there's a neshama7:54yetera, and that's the Tosef.8:00That's the extra ruach hakodesh.8:01He brings from the Ramban8:04on the Torah. He writes in the name of the Ibn8:06Ezra that in Shabbat,8:07what's that mean, that there's a tosefet neshama8:09yetera? What does that mean?8:11Different opinions, how to understand8:12it. The Ibn Ezra understands it that there's a tosefet chochma benefesh, a binah yoter,8:16that you have an extra8:19spiritual8:20boost8:21in understanding the Torah better,8:24in understanding8:25things better,8:26because that's the8:28extra neshama8:30that comes to help you understand things better.8:32That's how the Gra explains it.8:33The others want to explain8:35it connects to food, whatever it is,8:36but it's definitely an extra spiritual boost,8:40and how it affects you,8:41already there's different opinions.8:42We'll read the recording of Ibn8:44Ezra. Okay, that's yud,8:46a little bit more, I guess,8:48lomdish. We did it a little bit more8:51halacha-oriented. We move on to8:54yud aleph.8:57The majority of our prayer8:58is not talking in first person.9:01It's actually talking in third person,9:03right? We say,9:06chonen hadaat. We don't say,9:08atta chonen. We do say9:11atta noten... right?9:14Atta chonen ha-daat, but when we say Baruch atta Hashem, chonen ha-daat. The one who gives9:16chonen ha-daat. Rofe cholim, the one who9:18heals the sick.9:20Rofe chole amo Yisrael, the one who heals9:21the Jewish people.9:22That's called lashon nistar, which we call in English9:25third person, not directly,9:27but the third person.9:28Why is that so?9:30And the reason is, you talk to9:33Hashem, you talk to the King. You don't talk directly to the King.9:35You know, like people who,9:37you know, you see people who talk like9:39when they talk to a big rabbi,9:40they don't say, Hey, you coming to us?9:43Is the rabbi coming today?9:45They're talking in lashon... that's called lashon nistar.9:46That's called third person.9:48It's more respectful,9:50right? So look over here.9:52Where did this come from?9:53Where did this idea come from, from9:55the Gra? He quotes it from the9:57Gra in Sefer Iyov. He says,10:02lachen tiknu Chazal... lashon nistar, she-ein le-daber le-melech lashon nokach. Why did Chazal institute10:04that when we pray, we should not10:06speak directly;10:07we should say in third person?10:10Because to give you the understanding10:13that10:14we are talking10:16to a King,10:17and you don't talk that way to a King.10:18You don't talk in a direct way,10:21right? So10:23they bring also over here10:24different nusachim in the10:26Sefardim. We say,10:28mekadesh et shemo, right?10:30And as opposed to Ashkenazim,10:31they say,10:33mekadesh et shimcha. So he says the Sefardi one10:36is more correct because, you know,10:39like the same idea:10:40you talk to a King, it has to be in third person.10:42Okay, that's a side point about tefillah,10:44just a collection of different ideas10:46of the Gra on the tefillah.10:48Tomorrow, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll move to10:50the next piece, a little bit longer,10:52and,10:53be'ezrat Hashem, like always, it will always be interesting.