Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 9, Lesson 7Sefer Even ShelemaPart 160Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:42Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04Even shelema, perek tet, ot chet. Again, a small line, but it has some deep stuff into it.0:09Let's see what he says.0:13Haikar hatefilah tzarich lihyot al klal Yisrael. The main part of tefilah has to be on Klal Yisrael.0:18Very interesting. Now, where does the Gra get this from?0:22So again, we come back to the Mishnah0:27in Berachot. The Mishnah says that we know already the chasidim harishonim used to pray one hour and delay an hour before and an hour afterwards.0:35We explained why that is, but now the reason why they took so long,0:39it says in order that they should be mechaven their hearts to Hashem.0:43Comes the Gra and comments on that in Shenot Eliyahu, and he says,0:47פירוש, אסור לכוון בתפילה לצורך עצמו. You're not allowed to be mechaven in tefilah—listen to this—it's asur to be mechaven tefilah just for yourself.0:56אך להתפלל שיכנס יצאי בתכלית השלמות. However, you have to pray for the perfection of the entire Jewish nation.1:03ויהיה נשמת כנסת ישראל למעלה, and in the spiritual worlds that the level of Klal Yisrael should be perfect.1:10אבל לא לצורך עצמו. You cannot pray just for yourself.1:12That means, you know, I'll give you a mashal.1:15Let's say you have a big building,1:19and the building, you have many, many, many windows and many, many doors,1:22and you have also a lot of lines, pipelines, and you have a lot of also electrical lines,1:27as we know, a lot of complicated things that run into the building.1:30If there's something that's wrong in the building, the building is not a good building.1:34So let's say, for example, a pipe burst in one of the apartments that you own in the apartment building.1:39So in that apartment building specifically, and in that room specifically, in the kitchen,1:46there's a certain pipe that's leaking. It makes your building less in value,1:50so you work on that.1:51But why are you fixing that pipe? So this way the whole building is still in good condition.1:57So too in Klal Yisrael, in the Jewish people, there's a lot of Jews, but we make up one unit.2:02We are the Jewish nation.2:04Amongst this Jewish nation, there is one specific family, and that's your family.2:07Amongst that specific family, you may have an issue with one of the members of the family.2:11It could be yourself, it could be one of your children, it could be one of your cousins, aunts, whatever.2:16Within your family, there's somebody that needs rachmei Shamayim.2:20And you're praying for that person,2:23whether it's a refuah sheleimah, whether they need parnassah, whether they need shidduchim, whatever they need,2:27they need2:29siyata dishmaya. You cannot pray just for yourself,2:31because just for yourself, you're asur according to the2:35Gra. But when you're praying for that person, it could be just yourself or that specific person,2:42then your praying is that when he becomes perfect, when he gets his2:46refuah sheleimah, he makes the entire Jewish nation also whole.2:50He makes the whole people also, what's it called, more perfect.2:56So that's what the Gra is saying:2:58asur to be mechaven only for one specific person.3:01You have to pray for the perfection of the entire Jewish nation,3:04right?3:05And how do you do that?3:06What do you mean,3:07I need it for myself?3:07And the answer is, I'm that broken pipe in that big building called the Jewish people.3:12And he says,3:16that's in3:17derech ha'amidah. But you want something specific just for you, then you do it in3:24Elokai Netzor. In the middle of the tefillah, in the middle of the berachot3:28d'amidah, by Refuah, by Barechenu, don't pray for yourself.3:34This is, look what the pasuk says:3:36in order that they should be mechaven their hearts to their Father in Shamayim,3:40not that they should be mechaven3:42b'dibur, not their words,3:44their hearts.3:44What's the difference between their hearts and their words?3:47So he's explaining, the Gra is explaining,3:50the difference is like this,3:52is that their words... Right?3:56They're mechaven their words to3:57Hashem, but their heart, which means their4:01kavanah, and the kavanah, which means the hearts of the entire Jewish people,4:05that's what they did it for.4:06They took so long to do that.4:08But the dibbur has to be, like we said, in the middle of the Amidah,4:11it has to be in all the Jewish people.4:13You have a personal request,4:15wait for4:17Elokai netzor. It's a very, very interesting thing4:19and a very important thing also,4:21mamash real practical advice in how we should pray.4:24Then he brings another source,4:27two more sources4:28from the Gra's commentary on4:31Tikkunei Zohar. Let's first quote the4:32Tikkunei Zohar. The Zohar says,4:34ועלו לבני נשא דינון אטימין לבא ועיינין. Woe to the people whose hearts are sealed and whose eyes are sealed,4:39and they cannot see, they cannot feel.4:46דלא משתדלי למנדע בקרא דמאריהון, לרצויא ליה לבשכינתיה בכמה תחנונים פיוסים, לנחתא ליה לגבי שכינתא. They don't know how to appease their master,4:51HaKadosh Baruch Hu, that he should join together with the Shechinah. We quoted the Zohar4:55beforehand, and he says,4:58כל שכן להתערא ברחימו לגביה, and even more so to arouse the rachamim, the love towards him.5:03כמא דתקינו הבוחר בעמו ישראל באהבה, like the way5:07Chazal מתקן, הבוחר, Hashem who chooses his nation, the Jewish people, with love.5:14The Gra writes,5:16what does it mean,5:20בכמה תחנונים? דכל הבקשות דסלותא הוא הכל על כלל ישראל. All the requests, that when we pray,5:23has to be for Am Yisrael.5:27דהוא בשכינתא שהיא כלל ישראל. That's the meaning,5:30that you bring closer to Shechinah. The Shechinah represents the Jewish people,5:33and that's why when Chazal talk about5:35השראת השכינה, they say, אין השכינה שורה אלא אם יש 22,000 people,5:39right? It's always, Shechinah is always5:43שורה על כלל ישראל. It's always represented by5:49כלל ישראל. וזה שנאמר, כמא דתקינו הבוחר בעמו ישראל באהבה, כו' עליה, כמו שכתוב בשערי... Everything has to be regarding the Jewish people.5:52One more place, one more Zohar.6:09The Shechinah, the ... andaya. I know this guy here, aniyah begaluta, rechukah miba'alah, v'kara lah b'chol yoma shema Yisrael, d'hen nachit legaba, v'dai alei etmar kol anot anochi shomea. And every person that feels the pain of the6:14Shechinah, right, which is poor in the galut,6:17the Shechinah is far from its husband,6:19which is represented by Kudsha Berich Hu,6:21and every day he calls out Shema Yisrael6:23in order that he should join it together,6:25Hashem says, Oh, I hear the kol anot.6:27The Gra writes,6:30she'im tiflato bishvil Shechinah, az ne'eneh. If you pray for the sake of the6:32Shechinah, then you get answered.6:33This is a famous thing.6:34I'm sure you've seen in many sefarim,6:36especially by the Arizal and the Mekubalim,6:39that a person who's praying6:41has to pray for the sake of the6:42Shechinah, not for me, for You, Hashem.6:44So that's how usually people.6:45Now we're seeing something very interesting,6:47how the Gra is saying it,6:48that when you pray for the6:50Shechinah, it's not that you're praying for Hashem;6:51you're praying for Klal Yisrael.6:54They're represented by the6:56Shechinah. It has to be for the sake of Klal Yisrael.6:58It makes it a little easier,7:00right? Because I personally, at least for me,7:02it makes it a little easier,7:03because I always7:04understood, you know, when they say you got to pray for the sake of the7:06Shechinah, I had a very, very difficult time relating to that,7:09because I am really selfish.7:10I really want it for myself,7:11and I know how much Hashem,7:13of course, wants us to have good also,7:15but it's very, very hard to really convince myself that7:17I'm really—I'm asking for more parnassah for You, Hashem.7:20I am really, in essence,7:21but again, it's just so I can learn better,7:24so I can do better,7:25I can be more comfortable in life.7:27But now it makes a lot more sense when you say to pray for all the Jewish people.7:32And it's easier to have ahavat Yisrael7:33than to have ahavat hamakom,7:34just as much easier,7:35as the Rav Tzadok HaKohen brings down,7:37that by the7:39amei haaretz, ahavat Hashem is more than7:41ahavat Yisrael is more than ahavat Hashem,7:44because they don't have the Torah,7:45so they don't have that ahavat Torah,7:46but they all have7:48ahavah, and Jewish people come from a holy place,7:49so they have a natural ahavat Yisrael.7:52That's why you see people are not in Torah,7:53therefore they7:54have— The only problem is when that—8:00Love blinds them from the real8:02truth. The greatest love is to have love for HaKadosh Baruch Hu and the love for the Torah.8:05But they get blinded by8:07ahavat ... ahavat ... and they forget about also8:11ahavat Hashem, and that's why8:14everything ... They kind of8:16... but, you know, ahavat ... as we know.8:17In any case, the Torah shechinah. Now we're understanding a nice understanding from the8:23Gra, is to pray for the sake of the whole entire Jewish people.8:26Like we said, it's easy to do that,8:28even though I need it for myself.8:30And again, we all fix pipes in our house,8:33but we fix the pipe not for the pipe, for the entire house to function normally.8:37Did you ever have a sewer backup?8:40Ooh, right? A sewer backup means some kids put, you know, toilet paper that's not supposed to go in there,8:44or baby wipes, and backed it up,8:46and what happens? Everything comes back into your house, right?8:49So it's fixing the pipe not for the pipe.8:52I mean, for the pipe, but for your whole house8:54not to stink from all the backup that comes in.8:55So when we have personal issues,8:58whether it's financial, whether it's physical, or even spiritual,9:02Klal Yisrael is on a lower level.9:05And really it's an unbelievable idea9:06because it really makes us now understand,9:09and it makes it easy to pray for somebody else.9:12There's no competition; we're all part of that big building,9:14and we all become better in value.9:17When you become,9:18you know, it's kind of like, look at a shul, right?9:20When another person in our shul gets better9:24parnassah, the shul gains, because9:26... then he'll be able to give more to the shul,9:28and we will all gain from that.9:31When all of Klal Yisrael gains financially, right?9:35Yes, even in competition, everybody else,9:37it makes it better.9:38The Gemara says you have to stand up for ashirim,9:41give kavod to ashirim.9:43It's a very hard Gemara.9:44Rabbi used to give kavod to ashirim.9:45When ashirim would come, he would give them kavod.9:48So you might say, yeah, because, you know,9:50rabbis, they need the money, you know what I'm saying?9:53But someone, Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi in the Gemara says there was no person that was,9:56from the time of Moshe Rabbeinu9:57to Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, that was such a great talmid chacham and at the same time so rich.10:00He was the richest person. He didn't need anybody's10:04money,10:06right? Yet he still was10:08mechabed talmidei chachamim. In fact, the fact that he was so rich10:10makes us understand why he was10:12mechabed—excuse me—that why he was mechabed the ashirim.10:16Because, because if any other rabbi would have done it,10:18he'd say, Yeah, he needs money for his yeshiva.10:20Rabbi supported the10:22whole—he supported the whole Klal Yisrael.10:23The Gemara says, Lo paska mishulchano, right?10:26The rarest fruits and vegetables10:29that were not around in the kayitz and in the winter,10:32never came—you know, he always had on his table.10:36Yeah?10:36So why would Rabbi be mechabed the ashirim?10:39Must be there's something there.10:40Rav Henkin,10:41alav hashalom, Rav Henkin used to be one of the gedolei Yisrael in America.10:44He was even Rav Moshe Feinstein,10:46like, you know, would give so much kavod to Rav Henkin.10:48It was older than Rav Moshe Feinstein,10:50one of the big10:51poskim. I saw in his sefer a beautiful explanation.10:54He says because ashirim,10:56they know how to make money,10:59and because they know how to make money,11:01they will always make more business11:03that makes more people have11:05parnassah, that they should have money.11:08People who really know businesses,11:10they always give benefits to the rich.11:12And who's the one who complains?11:15That's the poor people, right?11:17The people who are happy with their hundred dollars a day,11:21and after they get their hundred dollars a day,11:22you won't see them for a week.11:24These are the guys that ruin,11:26actually, parnassah. Because when there's more ashirim,11:28there's more money,11:29they make it more factories,11:30that gives more jobs to people,11:31that gives more competition,11:33that makes it more available.11:35Think about it.11:35You have a business,11:36you want to expand,11:37you need more workers.11:38Who are you going to hire?11:38You're going to hire more people.11:40They're going to have parnassah to eat,11:41and then in turn, when they have11:42parnassah, they're going to be able to buy more,11:44and when they buy more,11:45it produces more,11:45and it creates more and more and more and more.11:49The guy who does not want to become a,11:52the guy who does not want to become a ashir, right? He's always taking and saving,11:54he doesn't want to invest.11:55That guy is not doing anything for anybody.11:56It's just for himself.11:57The ashir is the opposite.11:58Yes, ultimately it's for himself,12:00but at the end of the day12:01it helps everybody else.12:03So that's what Rav Henkin explains.12:05This is Rav Henkin, I'm telling you12:06about 80 years ago, right?12:07That's how he explains that the Gemara12:09and how Rabbi was giving money to the ashirim, right?12:12So we have to understand that12:13this applies not only to12:14the ashir, to everybody.12:16To everybody.12:16When everybody in Klal Yisrael does better,12:19it makes us all better on the same level,12:22it makes us all better.12:23I want to read one more piece12:25over here on the bottom in the quote12:26from12:27Rav Chaim Volozhin, the main student of the Gra.12:29He says,12:38Rabbeinu Chaim Volozhin, he wrote at length12:39that the main part of the tefillah12:41of a person,12:42even when he prays for materialistic things,12:44I need12:45parnassah, I need food,12:46I need, you know, hatzlachah in my job12:48and everything else,12:50right? It should always, it should be that12:52Hashem should get12:53nachat ruach,12:54to give more power12:58in the spiritual13:00worlds and to get rid13:01of the ruach13:41tumah. And the Gra,13:42clearly,13:43the way he's explaining, it13:44sounds like13:45that when you pray13:46for the whole Jewish people,13:47it sounds like the Jewish people13:48are already on a high level.13:50But you know what happens13:51when all the Jewish people13:51are on a high level?13:53Hashem is our Father.13:54Right?13:55Which father13:57who has kids13:58wants to see the success14:00of one and not the other?14:03We might be a little young14:04because our kids are still young,14:06but can you imagine14:07your own father14:08and your own siblings,14:09right?14:10Imagine everybody's doing well14:11except for one.14:12Oh, one is doing well14:13and the rest are not.14:14Father's happy?14:15Completely? No.14:16He always has in his heart,14:17Hazit,14:18what's going to be with that kid?14:20What's going to be with him?14:21He's, I don't know.14:22Imagine everybody's healthy14:24except for one.14:25How does a father feel?14:27Baruch Hashem,14:28four out of14:30five. Okay, right?14:32That's not shenei mot. Hashem is the father14:33of the Jewish people.14:34He wants the good14:36for everybody,14:37right?14:42Because then14:43when we're all physically,14:44right,14:45doing okay,14:46it makes it much easier14:47to become more spiritually14:49attached.14:49Yes, there's the risk14:50of the other things,14:52right? But when it comes14:53with the bracha from Hashem,14:53it just makes it a lot easier.14:55It makes it easier now14:56to give to yeshivot14:58and to makes it easier now14:59to take more time off15:00from work15:01and to learn.15:03It comes out,15:06shedivrei hagaon Rav Chaim Mashlimim b'divrei haGra. So it comes out15:07that15:07Rav Chaim Volozhin is15:09explaining the Gra on the next level.15:10What do you mean15:11you're praying for Hashem?15:11Well, when15:12I'm praying for Klal Yisrael,15:13it makes Klal Yisrael better,15:14makes it better15:15for the15:16Shechinah, because now15:16it gives more15:17koach. It says in15:19pasuk, Tenu oz15:20l'Elohim, right?15:20And Chazal say15:21the more we do mitzvot,15:24that כביכול gives more power15:24to the15:26Shechinah. So that's the meaning.15:31And that's why15:32when we pray for Klal Yisrael,15:33it gives more15:34koach to the spiritual15:35worlds, and that's15:37the perfection15:38of the Jewish people.