Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 7Sefer Even ShelemaPart 127Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:53Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:05Even shelema, perek chet, ot hei. Nu, piece, although we left a few pieces on the side we didn't do, but we got the point from0:11ot dalet. Let's go to0:15ot hei. Mi she'omer peshatim udrushim mefo'arim. A person who says beautiful explanations and beautiful derashot,0:20mefo'arim, like really unbelievable, she'einam le'amitah shel Torah. But really, it's not le'amitah shel Torah. It's not according to what the Torah really means.0:30בכדי, in order to sound good, onsho gadol me'od. His punishment is very, very, very big.0:37When I was in yeshiva, one of my rabbis used to say—I think he got it from his rabbi,0:42I don't want to say his name because maybe he didn't get it from his rabbi—it's very nice,0:45I think he did get it from him. He's the same,0:47Moshe Shapira, alav hashalom, that's all. Moshe Shapira was known to be sharp.0:50He says, you know, like somebody would say something very nice and, ah, beautiful, sounds very good.0:55He says, you know, in the morning we say,0:57Emet,1:08veyatziv, venachon, vekayam, veyashar, vene'eman, ve'ahuv, vechaviv, venechmad, vena'im, venora, ve'adir, metukan, vetov, veyafeh, umkubal, veyafeh. Okay?1:08Sixteen things we say praising about Hashem.1:11Haddavar za1:12aleinu. We say about Hashem's Torah,1:13good?1:14He says, if you count, there's sixteen things. The first one is emet,1:19right?1:21Then veyatziv, venachon, right?1:21It's true and it's proper and it's good and it's1:23praiseworthy, etc. The last one is1:25yafeh. He says something might be very, very beautiful, yafeh, but it's very far from emet.1:29Okay?1:32So people can sometimes say things like, Why not?1:36It sounds good.1:37Sounds good means nothing.1:39If, you know, and if you make a video with music in the background also,1:42and that also means nothing.1:45But people get so impressed by those external things.1:47Nobody bothers if it's emet or not emet.1:50And really, unless you learn halacha be'iyun and you see, it's unbelievable.1:56Like, for any halacha to go through—I was just telling the rabbis in the shul,2:00I was talking, I said I opened up a Musar sefer,2:03mamash Gedolei Hador, not our generation, last generation,2:07right?2:08And he wanted to bring a certain point in2:10Musar. He brought a2:13Chazal. He said, We see from here this point.2:15As I'm so used to learning, you know, the sefarim and the2:19poskim, like you reopen up the shut and they bring2:21one—especially if you read the Yabia Omer, it's unbelievable.2:24So, and like, you know, for every single idea, a2:28chidush that somebody wants to suggest, if it's2:31in halacha, you have, poof, all the sefarim. Every angle is analyzed and, you know,2:37dissected, and it's yes or no,2:41and, you know, nothing could just—you can't just say a2:44chidush. Look at the Gemara.2:45One rabbi comes up and says—well, he's2:48a2:49nobody—Amar Rava. Rava, Rava is a nobody?2:50Rava is a major2:51talmid chacham, he's one of the Amoraim.2:53He says something, all of a sudden the Gemara says,2:54Ah, v'ha tanya, what about this, da-da-da-da, right?2:57So you can't say something unless you have a really, really solid proof,3:01and even to make it there, before you get the challenges,3:04good?3:04So, but unfortunately, you know, people who don't learn in such a way,3:09you can say anything you want,3:11as long as it sounds good,3:12as long as you appeal to people's hearts,3:14and you talk about a subject that they feel3:17they have a strong feeling about,3:20ta'aseh mah she'ata rotzeh. Say whatever you want and stick it into wherever you want,3:23because it doesn't make a difference anymore,3:25because people don't know how to analyze it anymore.3:27So if it's really an emetah shel Torah, right?3:31If it's mamash, that's the emet, that's the pshat of the Torah3:34based on this and that and that,3:35okay, that's great.3:36But if it's not and it just sounds good,3:39and if you—listen, there's two types of people.3:41I want to be very careful how I say this.3:44There are two types of people:3:45the people who really believe that their pshatim3:47are emet. I'm not talking about those guys,3:49because they're not trying to be bad, right?3:51They're just maybe they're lacking the proper3:54analysis, but they really believe their pshat is3:55emet, and that's okay.3:56Then you have the3:57Ohr HaChaim. The Ohr HaChaim says you can say any pshat, right?4:01My favorite,4:02that was the Shevim panim laTorah, right?4:05Shevim panim laTorah. We're up to number 200 already with this pshat, right?4:08Shevim is shevim. Where'd you get 200?4:10Anyway, but there's the Ohr HaChaim that says4:13that you could say as long as it's a Torah idea, you could say it.4:18You know, if it fits, you could say it,4:19but it has to fit.4:21It has to be also Torah idea.4:22If it's not a Torah idea, that's very dangerous to say.4:25That's very, very, very dangerous to say4:27if it's not a Torah idea.4:29And again, this is talking about a guy who believes that he's right.4:33Maybe he's lacking the skills of how to prove that he's right from the Torah.4:37Then there's another guy who just wants to sound good.4:40You know, it just sounds very good,4:42it sounds beautiful,4:43you know. That is what the guy is talking about over here,4:46because he's saying peshatim and derushim, explanations4:49that sound beautiful, but they're not l'amitah shel Torah.4:52And just to, you know, impress people,4:55that is a very, very—4:56that's4:58lo aleinu, his punishment is very, very big. It's a small piece.4:59Let's just see it in the5:06Gra himself. Pasuk says in Mishlei, Arev la'ish lechem shaker. For a person, it's so pleasurable5:12bread that's false.5:15But afterwards, his mouth gets filled with cuts.5:19Okay? Pashut pshat, people lie, but then they end up with cuts,5:23which means that you will bear the responsibility of your lies,5:28right? I'll give you an example.5:29I'm trying to sell you a service.5:30I'm a man who deals with services.5:33I'm trying to sell you a service.5:34Why? Because let's say Chaim and Isaac,5:36they both provide different services.5:38Chaim provides services that have to do with roofing,5:42and Isaac provides services that have to do with5:46stucco. Good?5:47So now you come, you need stucco, and you need—5:50so I work with Chaim.5:51I get whatever customer I send him, he gives me 10%.5:54And same thing with5:56Isaac, I get 10% also, right?5:57So you come5:58now, I know that you're not so good.6:00Good?6:01So what do I say?6:02I say, Yeah, use Chaim and use Isaac.6:04Chaim I send you,6:05don't worry, Isaac, they give you...6:06Okay?6:07That's a sign,6:08you know, which is fine,6:09not to do that,6:09no problem.6:10But I know that Chaim and Isaac... I’m really not good.6:13I know that.6:14And I know that6:16as soon as you build, right,6:17the stock is going to fade,6:19the roof is going to start having leaks,6:21because I know that, right?6:23So what’s going to happen after a while?6:25So for me, it’s a lie.6:27It’s an easy buck money, and it’s easy6:29good prices because, you know, right?6:31But after a while, people are not going to trust me anymore.6:33So who ends up getting the cuts from the lies?6:37Me.6:38Okay,6:38that’s a6:39pashut pshat of the pasuk that Shlomo HaMelech is saying,6:42pashut pshat. Comes the Gra and explains6:43that, like we said, we see already the pattern of how the Gra explains.6:47The Gra is always taking it and applying it in the spiritual world,6:50you know, more in the spiritual world.6:51He says,6:58הלחם שבא לידי אדם ברוב עמלותיו וברמאות, ערבו מתוק לו מאוד. Any bread, right,7:00which means bread is like, you know, I have to work to earn bread to put on the table,7:03which means the goal, right,7:05of what you’re trying to work for.7:07Anything that comes out of trickery is very pleasant to a person.7:10A person enjoys it a lot.7:12Think about it.7:13We all love bargains.7:15Bargains are,7:16according to halacha, is mutar, but in a way it’s like a form of tricking the other guy, right?7:20He wanted to sell it to me for7:22a hundred, I brought him down to7:24seventy, right?7:24And then that guy tells7:25me, I was trying to sell it for7:27fifty, you settled on7:30seventy, right?7:31It’s in a way, I got him.7:35In a way, it’s a form of I got him.7:38Again, it’s mutar.7:39You’re allowed to bargain.7:39I’m not saying you’re not allowed to bargain.7:41But why we love bargaining is it’s in a way, I got him.7:46Yes,7:46my way, I got the guy.7:48He wanted7:49a hundred, I got him down to7:50seventy. Good?7:51I did something, but it’s also like I beat the system.7:54So that’s why, actually on the side point, somebody was telling me.8:00I know a man who works in real estate. He says, You know what? The prices, the houses go up like8:03crazy.8:04He says, that's what a guy told me. He says, his house, he knows his house is worth8:101.1. What does he do?8:11He says, If I put a 5.1, I know all these people in this community are going to come8:16and they're going to bargain me down.8:17So I say8:181.5. They bargain me down to8:191.1. They feel they got a deal,8:20they take it,8:21right?8:21But what happens when two guys say, You know, 1.5, we'll take it, and they're not bargaining?8:25All of a sudden the prices jump up in the market.8:27So we did it to ourselves,8:30right?8:31We bargain them down, but we don't realize that when we bargain, so the guy is not going8:34to lose money.8:35Nobody wants to lose money.8:37You didn't bargain anything.8:38So next time, all the prices will go up because they know we mark it up, because then8:42you can bargain down. If you don't mark it,8:43and then not only that, we get stuck on those prices.8:45So that's lechem shaker, the chatzatz. You end up with the cuts.8:50Okay,8:50so he says, But afterwards, eventually you get cuts in your mouth from the bread because it's not8:57really good bread.8:58So he says,8:59V'ha'inyan, apply it to us:9:07שמטוק לאיש לומר חוקים אשר לא טובים, ופשטים שקריים ודוחים מפוארים, וחלוקים בכדי לפאר את הנשיא. It's so pleasant for a person to say chiddush. People always love to come up with9:12chiddushim. It's unbelievable,9:13because I don't want to say something everybody else says,9:16right?9:16I don't want to say something everybody else9:17says. It's interesting,9:18I'm going to tell you a story about Gedolim in a second, how they looked at it.9:20I don't want to say something that everybody else says.9:21I want to say9:23a chiddush. You want to hear my9:24chiddush? My9:25chiddush? You want to hear it?9:26And then when you tell the guy, Oh, beautiful,9:28you know, Rav Chaim says that.9:29Oh yeah?9:31Rav Chaim telling you9:32this? Oh, Rav Chaim? It's unbelievable.9:34Oh, I thought I said it.9:35What do you mean?9:36Okay,9:36people love their own9:38chiddush, so they like it.9:39Okay,9:39they want to feel like they did something.9:41It comes from a good source.9:42But sometimes also, you know what?9:44You have to lie, because how much chiddushim can you really come up with9:47that haven't been discovered, really?9:49So he says— Because he gives them9:53the שכר מעלה, but אחר כך, he’s going to be held responsible for it,9:58and he’s going to be punished for it.10:00The story about10:02of חכם עזאתיה. He had a book of his own חידושים that he wrote on the10:05... He went to one of his10:06talmidim, he told him, Do me a favor,10:08go look in the other sefarim,10:11right? I don’t, you know,10:12there’s certain gedolim that, you know, like חכם עובדיה, who look in every10:16sefer. Before they write, they look in every10:17sefer. And then there’s gedolim like Rav Moshe Feinstein, who look at just the basics,10:21two, three אחרונים, and that’s it.10:22Never looked at anybody else.10:24And that’s different.10:26Rav Ben Ish Chai talks about two different types of poskim,10:28how to always wrote.10:29Okay, different10:30mahalach. Clearly, if you see a Gra, you read teshuva from a10:33Gra, you read a teshuva from a10:34רבי עמרם, two different worlds,10:36completely,10:37completely different styles.10:38In any case, it’s fine.10:39חכם עזאתיה had his own thing.10:41He doesn’t want10:42the talmidim, I want to put out my10:44חידושים. Go see if there’s somebody who brought it down10:45already, wants to put me saying the same thing.10:47Okay,10:48somebody already said it.10:49So he went, he looked,10:52found כמעט almost all the חידושים of חכם עזאתיה were already brought by10:57other sefarim. He’s disappointed, you know, like he went to10:59his rebbe. He says,10:59Rebbe, almost everything you said is brought down already somewhere else.11:03He was so excited.11:05He11:05says, Why are you excited?11:07He11:07goes, Let me explain to you.11:08If you’re driving somewhere,11:09right, and you’re not sure where you’re going,11:11so if you’re traveling and there’s nobody driving on the road,11:13you get nervous,11:14like, Where am I going?11:15But if you’re traveling11:16and you see people who know what they’re talking about,11:18and they’re driving the same way,11:20you know you’re on the right road,11:22right?11:22And that’s really a11:24חידוש, right?11:25That11:25I was11:26מכוון, you know the concept,11:29אני מכוון לדעת של, right?11:29You’re מכוון to the11:30דור החיים. That’s an unbelievable thing.11:31Don’t feel disappointed that דור החיים brought it.11:35You should be excited,11:36jump for joy that the דור החיים brought it,11:38that somebody,11:39that means you’re going in the right path.11:40That’s an unbelievable thing.11:41And it doesn’t only have to be11:43a ראשון. If there’s another גדול that brings it down,11:45you should also feel very excited about it.11:48Okay,11:48with that we’ll stop over here.