Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 6Sefer Even ShelemaPart 126Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:13Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:03אמצע הלימוד, פרק ח' אות ד'. We are continuing what we said from yesterday,0:08is that learning in itself, even not the understanding,0:13even not the bottom line, and even not the keeping it,0:16we have to look at learning in itself as a goal, as an accomplished goal.0:20So we read from the Gra himself, and we saw some major insights.0:25I would like to go now to another two pieces, still in the same piece,0:30it will be called ד' 2, and read another piece from the Gaon Mevilna.0:35He quotes a Gemara, Masechet Berachot,0:37and this is from a peirush in Shenot Eliyahu on Masechet Berachot.0:45It says, אמר רבי חייא בר אמי, גדול הנהנה מיגיעו יותר מירא שמים. Greater is a person who benefits from his own toil, from his own work,0:50greater than the yirei shamayim.0:52Pashut pshat, everybody learns this Gemara and says,0:54Oh, you see, if you go to work, you're greater than the yirei shamayim.0:58For some reason, the people who explain this Gemara,1:01which obviously is not the right way of explaining it, I'll tell you why,1:04right, they're explaining that a person who goes to work is not yirei shamayim,1:10because, right, it says,1:13גדול הנהנה מיגיעו יותר מירא שמים. Greater is a person who benefits from his own toil, from his own hard work, than a yirei shamayim.1:18What are you saying? That a guy who goes to work is not yirei shamayim?1:21What does yirei shamayim have to do?1:22Yirei shamayim is how you approach the mitzvot and the word of Hashem.1:28Are you scared of the word of Hashem that you make sure to keep it or you're not?1:31So you could go to work also be yirei shamayim,1:34right? What does it have to do with1:37a guy who learns in kollel, right? And also, what's the sevara1:41also here to say that if you're neheneh, what do you mean? What does that mean, you benefit from your own work?1:46Here we go, the question that we just said.1:49If a guy is neheneh from—if you go work and you earn your own parnasa... You're not asking for a handout, right?1:57You could also be yarei Shamayim. Peshita, dafei yarei Shamayim.1:59Of course, if you're a person that doesn't have to ask for a handout and you're yarei Shamayim,2:04of course you're going to be better than a regular yarei Shamayim who has to ask for a handout.2:08So, like, what's the question?2:11And if you tell me, a guy who doesn't have enough parnassah has to ask for a handout.2:16He is a yarei Shamayim and the other guy is not.2:19So what do you mean? Yarei Shamayim is the bottom line.2:21So what's the difference what you do,2:30right? ותראה הרמבם גאון, רבינו זצל, שאותיות טעם הוא טוב, ערב ומועיל. So the Gaon Mivilna explains that we know the Rashi teivot taam is2:36טוב, ערב ומועיל, and we explained that yesterday already.2:37טוב is what's good now.2:40ערב, it may not be good, but it's going to2:43be—excuse me—ערב is physical enjoyment, pleasures of the physical body,2:49and מועיל is it may not be enjoyable now, but it's going to benefit you in the future, like we said, like medicine.2:54Okay, so I'm going to skip all this.2:56And he says,3:02ויש בדברי תורה גם כן אותיות טעם, טוב, ערב ומועיל. And also in learning Torah, it's the same way.3:05How? ערב is when a person learns3:08שלא לשם שמים, because he enjoys the external parts of the Torah,3:12which means it's a stimulus.3:15It's, you know, lemaaseh, when you hear a good drush, don't you love a good3:17drush? It makes you think, right?3:19And when you discover, like, ah, nice, right?3:22You discovered a3:24chochmah, or you learn something new.3:25It doesn't have to be Torah,3:26but it makes you right away, it makes you feel good.3:29So he says also that there's some people who learn Torah3:34שלא לשם שמים. What is3:35שלא לשם שמים? It means for the wisdom of it.3:37It's very, very, you know, it's very interesting.3:39Some people, you know, just like they're what they call bookworms or geeks.3:43They love learning.3:44They love, love, love, love learning.3:45So that's called שלא לשם שמים if it's only for that purpose.3:48And then there's3:50מועיל. A person is learning it that he should be baki in Torah, and he should know it,3:54but he doesn't really enjoy his learning.3:56It's like, you know, it's killing him,3:57but he's doing it because he knows that it's going to help him.4:00He needs to know halachot.4:02He needs to be posek halacha,4:03so he's going to do it.4:05He doesn't enjoy it, right?4:06And then there's the person who's learning Torah4:10b'tov, and that is that he enjoys the learning right now.4:15Why?4:15Because he understands that this is what I'm supposed to be doing right now,4:21not just for the benefit of it.4:22It's not the goal of it.4:24This is the goal in itself.4:26It's not a step to the goal.4:27This is the goal in itself.4:29He says that's the meaning of the Gemara.4:34You know what neheneh means over here?4:37It means you're benefiting from your4:40yegia. Yegia means from your toil in your Torah.4:42A person who is toiling in Torah and he's enjoying his toil in Torah,4:46he's enjoying the hard work that he's putting into Torah,4:50hu yoter meyirei Shamayim.4:51He has a greater benefit.4:53He's a greater level, excuse me, than4:56yirei Shamayim.5:00That's better than the person who knows that this is the right thing.5:03He knows he's going to end up, he's going to enjoy Torah later on.5:07That's even greater.5:08So we can explain now5:09over here, a lot of people that come5:12to—sometimes some people, I've heard some people have this misconception.5:14I want to be able to, based on the Gra, to clarify it.5:17Some people will say, Look at this guy,5:20baal teshuva. He doesn't know what he's learning, and he's struggling.5:23He's not enjoying his learning, but he's pushing himself.5:25He's greater than the guy who enjoys his learning.5:26No, that's not true.5:28That is not true.5:30The guy who enjoys his learning is greater.5:34Both of them because the guy who's enjoying his learning.5:36Again, why is he enjoying his learning?5:37If he's enjoying his learning because of the stimulus,5:40because of that excitement of learning something new,5:43and he'll get the same even when he hears a nice joke5:45or he hears a nice story, right?5:47So that's not,5:49okay, that's not what we're talking about.5:50But if he's enjoying his learning because this is,5:52he knows, I'm doing a Ratzon Hashem,5:55right?5:56Imagine Hashem tells you you're going to have a hard day tomorrow.5:59Go with a smile because in Shamayim,6:01I told the malachim you're going to pass6:02and there's a tremendous reward.6:04As you go through the hard day, you're smiling.6:07This is part of the movie.6:08You're loving it.6:09So when you're learning and it's hard6:11and you're still there and you're enjoying,6:13you understand,6:14lefum tzaara agra, and you enjoy learning6:17and you get a geshmak from your learning,6:19and you know you're doing it for that purpose,6:21for the right reason,6:22that's great in the guy who doesn't enjoy his learning.6:24You're supposed to enjoy your learning.6:26So in fact, a guy who starts may find it very, very difficult.6:30I just want to point out also another6:32point. Some people, they come and they say,6:35Ah, I can't learn6:36Gemara. It's too hard,6:37very, very dry.6:38It's too boring.6:39I can't,6:40right?6:40You're not going to enjoy it right away.6:42You need to work very, very hard in the beginning,6:45and it's going to be dry.6:46It doesn't mean that tov comes right away.6:48We're saying that you have to enjoy learning.6:50It doesn't usually come right away.6:51It comes after commitment to it6:54and after putting a lot of things, you6:56know, effort into it.6:56It's like, you know, we all know babies when they're born,7:01they're cute, but they create a lot of problems7:04really in the first three months.7:06They're always crying, they're always making,7:07they're not really so much fun to play with.7:08You can't throw them up and down.7:10Babies, when they start turning close to one year,7:13start crawling, they start giggling,7:15start smiling at you,7:16they start saying words,7:17they start saying funny things.7:18As they get older, those stages,7:21so enjoyable.7:22But you have to go through the first three months7:24till you get used to it.7:26And then they get to the next stage in their life.7:28They become also tantruming7:29and making problems and everything else.7:31And then they get to the rebellious stage.7:33But you know, you're going to enjoy them later on7:36when they get married and they bring you, and they bring children7:38and their grandchildren, right?7:40So it's always a stage.7:41So it's always difficult in the beginning,7:42but it will be enjoyable later on.7:44So those who are starting out, they're learning,7:46or who started out and they fell out7:48and they said they don't enjoy it,7:49understand, enjoyment will eventually come.7:52If you, you know, the lowest level is7:55ariv, that, you know, physical enjoyment.7:58It has to be something exciting.8:00Friends are coming. There's good food in the class. That's a person learning for external reasons.8:05That's a low level, because he's learning at the end of the day.8:07It's better than going to a movie or going to dinner in a non-kosher restaurant and doing, you know, enjoying himself.8:11Baruch Hashem, he's learning. But that's the lowest level.8:14The next level is mo'il, where he's learning. He doesn't enjoy it, but he knows it's going to benefit him later on,8:21because at the end of the day he knows what Hashem wants from him.8:24And then the highest level is that he enjoys also what he's learning, and it's mo'il. That's a tov.8:28But that doesn't come right away.8:33So he says, at the end he says, anybody who tries to finish right away, tries to finish things without really going and working through it,8:40he says, ein bo siman berachah. He brings over here from a famous pasuk in8:49Mishlei, Nachalah mebohelet b'rishonah, v'acharitah lo tevorach. The pasuk says in Mishlei, an inheritance that's mebohelet, that's very quick in the beginning, at the end has no blessing.8:57כלומר, שהוא בהול במלאכתו, ואחריתה לא תברך. It means to say that a person is so overwhelmed with this melachah, there's no blessing for it.9:08כי הדרך הבהול שבתחילתה רוצה שיתגמרים, וכשבא לסופה אז הוא עצמה מאוד. A person who is in a rush to do things, right,9:11does not think; he just wants to get the job over with.9:15לכן ואחריתה לא תברך. That's why he has no blessing in the end.9:19וכן בתורה. It's the same thing in the Torah.9:23הלומד... Person who comes to learn something, his whole purpose right now is what? I want to finish the book.9:28I want to finish. I want to make my siyum.9:30Therefore he tries to speed up the process.9:34לא יהיה ברך. He does not get9:37blessing. שבאחריתה לא ידע אף התחלתה, because at the end of the day he won't even remember the beginning.9:42ומגודל בהלתו לא יברך. And because of this whole confusion, his whole rush, he does not get the blessing.9:46I'll give you an example. I'll give you an example.9:48Take this book that we're learning, right?9:54Even Shlema. I mean, for those who are following it, they love it.9:56I know there's a lot of people in the shiur, and not everybody is able to hear every day,9:59but even those who listen most of the time, they love it, right?10:03What if I tell you we're going to finish in a month?10:05No! We don't want to finish, because each one, it's an unbelievable thing.10:08We're not rushing to make a siyum.10:11Actually, each piece, it's amazing.10:14But somehow, when it comes to Gemara, everybody's always looking,10:15When is the siyum, Rabbi?10:18If you're really enjoying it, you should not10:21want—I don't want this masechta to finish.10:23But we have this thing. We've created it,10:26you know, shelo lishma, b'al lishma. We wanted it to come10:29lishma, but really, we've created this thing of, like, you know, the excitement or the challenge10:34or, you know, that people should have goals in learning sefarim and finishing them.10:39But the negative part of it is that everybody's always looking for a siyum.10:43They want the party, they want that celebration.10:45Okay, it's good, I'm not saying it,10:46but that's not really what your purpose is.10:49You're supposed to look at the way we're learning10:50Even Shlema. Each piece is beautiful, and we want to understand it more and more.10:54We don't want this book to finish.10:56Yes, we'd like to finish the whole Shas, but you kind of, like, not want it to finish in a way.11:00And he's telling you that attitude of just trying to finish doesn't have beracha in it.11:07I think that's enough. We got the point from this.11:10Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll move on to the next piece already by tomorrow.