Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 5Sefer Even ShelemaPart 125Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:54Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01בן שלמה, פרק0:04ח', אות ד'. החכם נהנה בעת לימודו במה שמקיים מצוות0:39בוראו. A chacham, a wise man, at the time when he is learning, he's enjoying the fact that his learning is itself an end of a goal, which what? Which his learning itself is the fact that he's mekayem, he's doing what Hashem wants him to do, to learn Torah. אף על פי שאינו יודע. Even though he doesn't really understand, he understands that the learning itself is what Hashem wants me to do, even though he doesn't yet grasp the concept. וחוזר תמיד ומוצא בו טעם.0:49And he comes back to the same concept again and again. He always finds another layer of understanding, another meaning, another thing to it. אבל הכסיל אינו נהנה עד0:52שיסיים הספר.1:36But a fool doesn't get hana'ah until he finishes the book, he finishes the concept. ועץ ומהר לסיימו. And he wants to go quick and finish the book already. ועכן אין בו סימן ברכה. That's why that speed that he does in his learning will not have a siman berachah. He just wants to finish the book. He wants to feel that accomplishment of finishing. He doesn't want to, you know, the learning itself doesn't... You know, he wants to know basically the idea at the end of the day. He doesn't care about that he's mekayem mitzvat Bor'o. That's a very, very deep line over here that he's telling us. So we're going to see the words in the Gra, that, be'ezrat Hashem, will shed light on how we should learn Torah. It says from the pasuk in Mishlei, it says, את פני מבין חכמה ועיני כסיל בקצה ארץ.1:50The face, or in front of the mevin, is wisdom. ועיני כסיל, the eyes of the fool, is by the end of the earth. כלומר, says the Gra, המבין אינו רואה לקפוץ.1:52A person who really understands doesn't want to jump levels. אלא מבין2:03מה2:05שלפניו, takes it one step at a time. What is in front of him, whatever is directly in front of him, that's what he understands. אבל2:09כסיל, a fool, עיניו לקצה הארץ.2:12His eyes are always by the ends of the earth. בעת יחל ללמוד, עיניו יחלו2:19לסיים2:41הש"ס או מסכת. When he starts to learn, already he's looking to finish the Shas. He wants to finish Gemara. He wants to finish Masechet. And you say, What? You shouldn't learn to finish. Of course, you should have goals, but understand that every day of your learning is itself a goal. Every moment of learning is itself a goal. It's not how much you finish; it's how much you learn. והעניין, he explains a little deeper, and he says, שבעולם יש ג' דברים.3:12There are three things in the world which we discussed in the past. There are טוב,3:25ערב, ומועיל. There's what's good, what's pleasurable, and what's beneficial. ערב הוא כמתענוגי העולם הזה הערבים לגוף. ערב, pleasurable, are things that are physical pleasures that the body enjoys. טוב3:44ומועיל, ישניהם כאחד טובים. What's good and what's beneficial are both good. So what's the difference between what's good and what's beneficial, which is טוב and מועיל? He explains, אך החילוק שהם מועיל הוא4:10מועיל לאחר זמן. The difference is like this: beneficial, when we say something is beneficial, it means it's not only good, but it benefits you also in the future. ועתה בעת שאוכל זה אינו5:46טוב5:47לו.7:02For example, you may take some medicine and it might taste bitter. And you may go through a surgery, and it might be painful, but that's not what it seems like at the moment. It's not good for you, right? However, achar kach, eventually it will be beneficial for you. Tov hu shebsha'at ma'aseh hu tov gam ken. What tov means is that at the moment also what I'm doing is, it's also good for me right now. So for kids, for example, you know, their antibiotics comes with all different types of flavors, either bubble gum or cherry or, you know, those vanillas, whatever it is, right? So when the kids are taking the antibiotics, it's tov u'ma'ayil. It's tov, it tastes great, has that sweet flavor, and it's also going to benefit them in the future also because it's going to get rid of the pain. V'chein b'inyanei olam haba. He says, just like we see this in this world, also when it comes to olam haba, there's tov and arev. Arev hu ha-lomed k'dei sheyikrahu rav. There's tov, arev, u'ma'ayil. How's that? What's pleasurable in spiritual matters? And the answer is, a guy who's learning, why? Because he sees the pleasure in learning. How is that so? How is there physical pleasure? And the answer is, there's kavod. A guy is learning so this way he will have a title, he will have a position, right? He's learning to become a rabbi so he can have a position, or people should give him a title. He's an influential person. He has honor, depends which community. U'mo'il hu ha-osek baTorah k'dei leda kodem lamito. Mo'il is a guy who's learning because he wants to know the emet. Even though he may be struggling right now, there's no title, there's no fanfare, but he's learning because he wants to know what the right thing to do. V'zeh ha-lomed ein tov lo b'sha'at esko. And this guy who's learning to be mo'il, it's not really benefiting him at the time that he's osek baTorah, because at the time that he's osek baTorah, he might be struggling. He might be struggling financially, because, you7:03know, but he's pushing himself to learn. He might be struggling physically. Why? Because he's exhausted and he wants to go to sleep, but he's pushing himself a little bit more. He might be struggling emotionally, right? He wants to say something, he has other things to do, he has to express himself, but he doesn't want to be mevatel Torah. And all these things, it may not be tov for him at the moment, but he knows that this is the right thing. He's learning to understand the din Torah. But in the future it's good because he's going to learn Torah properly. It's going to be with him. But a person who is learning, and he's pushing himself even though he's struggling in everything else, but he's learning because that's what Hashem tells him to do, then tov lo gam ken be'et shelomed, ve'oseh mitzvat Rabbo yitbarach b'mah shelomed. Then he understands that, lefum tzaara agra. I am right now in pain, whatever all the other pain, like we said, it's hard, he has to be somewhere, but he says, No, I'm committed to that hour of learning. I'm here to stay. And he shuts off his own, or even if he doesn't shut off, but he puts it away from him and he says, No distractions right now, I'm going to sit and learn. And he understands that the more pressure I have to leave this time of learning that I've dedicated, that I've committed to, the more I'm doing Hashem yitbarach's, Hashem's command, that is tov for him at the moment that he's fulfilling Hashem's mitzvah. It's also going to be mo'il; his learning also will be beneficial also with him in the future. V'zeh shekatuv, Ein tov l'adam sheyochal v'yishteh. So the pasuk says in Kohelet, it's not good for a person just eating and7:04drinking. What does that mean?7:08Pirush, tov eino ba'adam sheyochal v'yishteh, ela sheya'asok b'Torah u'mitzvot. The good for a person is not the eating and the drinking;7:10it's that he should be7:18osek in Torah u'mitzvot. V'haro'eh nafsho tov b'amalo. Pirush, ela im ken hu mar'eh lenafsho sheyeh lo tov b'amalo atzmo. Also, when you're learning,7:20understand that when you're learning,7:22you know, it's not a step to an end goal.7:27The learning itself is,7:29in itself, you have accomplished by coming to learn itself.7:33I'll give you a little bit of a mashal.7:34If you ever see, if you ever went to a kids' program7:39where they give out kids raffles and prizes and everything else.7:44So let's say they're raffling off something that every kid wants,7:46an electric scooter, right? Electric bike,7:48one of those expensive items that every kid wants.7:51So they give out raffle tickets as everybody's learning.7:54Why are the kids learning?7:56So a lot of them...8:00The raffle tickets are incentive to bring them to8:02learn. If there's no raffles, maybe two, three kids would show up.8:05Now with the raffles, like a hundred kids are showing up.8:07They all want to get that prize.8:08So, Baruch Hashem, they're also enjoying the learning.8:10They're sitting there, they're enjoying the story, they're enjoying the Mishnah, whatever they're learning.8:14At the end, when they finish their learning, they make the raffle,8:16and only one kid is going to walk out with that big desired prize. Prize,8:22excuse me, right? So when that kid walks out with that bike, everybody feels like a8:26loser. Ah, I can't believe I'm here for two hours and I didn't get anything,8:30right? And all the rabbis will always say, you know, in the program,8:33just understand, keep in mind, boys, everybody is a winner.8:38Everybody's a winner for coming to learn.8:40That's the8:41emet. But the kid doesn't understand because he came for the bike.8:44So some adults never grew out of that stage,8:47right? They come to learn, and they may have had a hard Gemara.8:51They struggled to learn it.8:53They may have not come out with a8:55maskana, and they didn't come out with anything,8:57but they did put in effort.8:58We're not talking about that they wasted their time.8:59We're not talking about that they were distracted, they were talking, they gave one up.9:03We're talking about that they really put in their effort and they worked hard on the Gemara,9:06but didn't come out, let's say, with the bottom line.9:08So they may not feel that, ah, it's beneficial.9:11He's telling you, the Gra, understand that when you're learning itself,9:14the learning itself is9:16tov, because you're mekayem, it's ratzon Hashem.9:17That's what Hashem wants you to do.9:19There's a famous story9:20I heard from one of my rabbis in yeshiva9:24who is very, very careful in saying stories are true.9:28I remember one time he came over to me.9:29He knew that I was from the Syrian community,9:31and he came over to me, he's like,9:32I heard a story yesterday about Rav Moshe Feinstein,9:35and the person said the name of David9:37Roseri. Do you know him?9:38I said, Of course, I know Rav9:39Roseri. He's like, Could you get in touch with him and ask him if this story is true or not?9:44It happens to be, just a month before that,9:46Rabbi David Roseri was the one who, you know, set me up in the shidduch already,9:50you know, so already was calling him anyway.9:52So I called him up and I asked him, you know, about the story.9:55He's like, Yeah, of course, that's my9:57consuegro. You know, I said this story,9:59and that's my ... about Rav Moshe Feinstein, whatever.10:00It's a great story.10:01So this rabbi is very, very medakdek, you know, when it comes to say10:04so, he won't say it until he...10:06So he said the following story,10:07and he was a big fan also of Rav Chaim Kanievsky.10:09He used to talk about Rav Chaim Kanievsky all the time,10:10and he said whenever he goes to Israel,10:12he makes sure to go visit Rav Chaim Kanievsky.10:14He's an older rabbi; he wasn't a young man.10:16Now he's probably in his seventies at least.10:18So he said that10:20Rav Chaim Kanievsky, when he was younger,10:22he went to his father, the10:24Steipler, and he says,10:26Tati, which means daddy, Abba, right?10:27I'm learning and I'm not understanding my learning.10:29So his father, the Steipler, tells him,10:31And who says that you have to understand?10:35The Torah says,10:39right, Vilmadtem otam. You have to learn.10:41You have to put your effort to understand.10:42If you don't understand, that's from Hashem.10:45You have to go and keep learning.10:47Now, if there are ways that you could understand,10:49of course you have to use those ways to understand.10:51Torah is not just meant to be10:53... right?10:53Torah is meant to be understood.10:54But if you don't understand it,10:56okay, so it's not coming out.10:58But who says that's the goal?10:59The goal is to learn,11:00because it's tov.11:01That's what the Torah is saying over here.11:03Understand, while you're learning,11:04you11:05mekayem mitzvat haboreh. And Baruch Hashem, today11:06you see Rav Chaim Kanievsky,11:07he understands Baruch Hashem a lot.11:09He is better than Google,11:11right?11:12So this is what he's telling you.11:15In learning Torah,11:16we have to also learn it in such a way11:18that it's not only to get11:20the tachlit. Yes,11:20you're going to make this siyum.11:22Yes, you're going to understand.11:23Yes, you're going to come out with11:24a maskana, and that's bottom line in11:26halacha. But even if you don't understand,11:28and how many of them מקבלים שכר also?11:30You work and we're מקבל שכר for just to11:32learn, because we're11:33מקיים, every moment that we're learning,11:34every moment that we learn another line,11:37we are fulfilling God's command,11:39and that's the greatest pleasure.11:40That's in itself good itself.11:42That's a goal11:43by itself. Tomorrow I would like to read from the bottom over here.11:46This is a very, very important11:48concept he said,11:49... more tomorrow.