Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 4Sefer Even ShelemaPart 124Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:12Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Eved shelema perek chet, ot gimel. One-liner, very, very short, small piece, and we wanted to do it yesterday, but we, you know, we said we'll save it for its own time.0:13Ha-lomed kitzur dinim, sof sheyishkach hakol. Isn't that an amazing statement? The Gra says, whoever learns kitzur dinim, at the end he forgets everything.0:22Powerful line. I can't say that. If I would say that, everybody would go crazy on me.0:26I don't want to pick names of books. There are a lot of great rabbis in history, and even in modern times, that have written books on0:35kitzurim. Of the greatest example of the rabbis that wrote kitzur dinim are the Rambam, the Shulchan Aruch, and more recent in our times,0:44books like Ben Ish Chai, Yalkut Yosef, and the Ta'amei Gabriel. Those are kitzur dinim, right? Just halacha, straightforward.0:54So, a lot of people, Baruch Hashem, learn these books. In fact, I also use those books a lot of0:58times, and I use Shulchan Aruch repeatedly all the time, Rambam all the time.1:04So what's the Gra talking about? If you learn kitzur dinim, you end up forgetting everything.1:09What is going on over here? So let's see on the bottom, then we'll fill in more for what we need to understand.1:15Look at the Gra. It comes from Mishlei, perek yud, pasuk daled. Pasuk says,1:24Rash oseh chaf remiyah. A poor person makes a chaf, usually means a spoon or like a plate, that's trickery.1:34V'yad charutzim ta'ashir. And the hand of the swift, people who are, you know, like kind of like zerizim, people who are1:41go-getters. It's a better word for hustlers, right? Hustlers is not a bad word; in a good way. Ta'ashir, will make them rich.1:46He says, the Gra, there's, you know, we all know that, right? A poor person, you know, wants to make himself look good,1:53so he'll make trickery things. It's easier, it's faster money. Right?1:58Think about it. You know, I always used to think, you know, people cheat in big businesses.2:01My father told me, he remembers in the old country that even the2:06better ones, when they, you know, like even like small things, they would sell you like wool that used to stuff the2:11mattresses. Very cheap stuff. And even there there was cheating.2:15A guy would, you know, when he wants to weigh it, he would put, you know, even like crazy things people did.2:20There's always cheating. There's always stealing in everything.2:23Why do people do these kind of tricks? Why do people want to steal?2:27Why do people do basic things that they want to rip off people?2:30And the answer is not because they're bad. They want to make a quick buck, right?2:34You buy a building, you make it go on fire. You buy high insurance, very good, you're2:39covered. You make it go on fire, boom, you collect all the money. You have a free renovation2:44because you plan to do anyway renovation. You got it, you do it. It's easy, quick, right?2:50Cheating is usually done because it's quick, fast money.2:53You don't want to go through the whole hard work of borrowing money and fixing it up2:58and then getting a little bit of a profit and slowly paying back your debts and then buying more.3:02It takes much longer. This over here, one fire, it's like, you know, all it takes is a month,3:07including the interviews and interrogations, and you're good.3:11So that's a3:13kaf remiyah, yad harutzim. But the people who are working very hard and diligent and hustling,3:18that's really what's going to be3:21ma'ashir. And the Gra says, besides the simple meaning that Shlomo HaMelech is telling us about the regular people,3:26that people who are trickery will eventually lose their money.3:30They don't actually become rich.3:33Remember, the rash, right? He's a poor person. The word rash means poor person,3:38not like in English, rash or rich is the same word, which is rich people.3:43No, the rich person—excuse me, a poor person, the pasuk is calling him a poor person.3:48He stays a poor person. He makes money temporarily, but eventually loses money.3:52The Gra says that's also talking about, v'ot shekai al haTorah. It's also talking about Torah. Torah,3:57what's the trickery in the3:59Torah? He says,4:02shehakaf remiyah mi shelomed b'remiyah. You know what's kaf remiyah? That's a person who learns with trickery,4:05has that.4:07Hainu she'eino lomed hashoshei dinim. He doesn't learn the halachot. From their sources.4:14Rak ha-kitzur dinim, bigdei lehar'ot shehu yodea al kol ha-dinim. He just learns the bottom lines.4:16He opens up the bottom lines, and he just sees, okay, what's the bottom line?4:20You know, they have in the back of masechet, in the back of a lot of4:24masechtot, they have something called kitzur piskei Tosafot,4:29the bottom lines from the Tosafot, right?4:32Now, anybody who learns Gemara and knows the difficulty in learning Gemara,4:37the challenge in learning Gemara, and if you learn Tosafot,4:40you know even more so that Tosafot are not so simple to try to figure it out and everything else.4:45So here they open up the book and they see in the back it says,4:49Kitzur4:51Piskei HaTosafot. Why go through the whole long page of Tosafot, which will take you hours to figure out,4:56if you figure it out?4:58Go to the back, see the bottom line, and then you go to everybody,5:00Yeah, Tosafot says in Masechet Bava Batra,5:05daf, I think, mem-gimel amud bet over there.5:07You know, Tosafot says, comes out over there that this is5:09halacha. Wow.5:10Another guy says, You know, it took me a month to figure that out.5:12This guy knows it like that.5:14Yeah, because you looked in the back and you remembered it,5:16right? So you have a good memory. You remembered the kitzur dinim.5:18It's the same thing with any kitzur halachot.5:19Yeah, mutar, mutar, mutar. Chacham Ades matir.5:23Very nice, also. You know, very kitzur halachot.5:25You know it. It says it, right?5:26Did you look at the sources? Did you see everything?5:28No. Says the unbelievable thing.5:31People who do that, and they're showing that they really know,5:34or they believe that this is the way to learn,5:35why should I go through the whole hassle of figuring it out?5:39Zeh oseh oto5:41le-rash. It actually, that's what makes you a poor person.5:43Why?5:44Ki lasof sheyishkach gam otam mechamat she'eino yodea shoreshan. It says you don't know the roots, you don't know the reasons,5:51you don't know how these halachot were developed,5:54you end up forgetting it.5:56For two reasons, I believe.5:57One is because you didn't work hard on it.6:00Torah is not like anything else.6:01The pasuk says, and the Gemara brings it,6:06Ki ta'uf einecha bo ve'einenu. When you blink your eyes when the Torah, and it's not there.6:09Gemara says, what is that talking about?6:09That's a person who— Doesn't put the effort like it's supposed to be.6:12You take it easy,6:15the easy, what we call the shortcut,6:17the Torah, and that's why Rashi says in Parashat6:25Bechukotai, Im bechukotai telechu, v'et mitzvotai tishmoru, says Rashi, shetihyu ameilim baTorah. It says6:29ameilim baTorah, because if you're not ameil baTorah, you won't know the Torah.6:34Even though you learn Torah,6:35there's a difference between learning and working hard to figure out the Torah6:38and see the roots and sources of everything.6:40So a lot of people don't like that6:42knowledge. We're not used to it, especially in our generation.6:45I've spoken about it, you6:46heard in the internet assembly about digital dementia.6:48I spoke about it also in the shul,6:51of we like, we're a generation of shortcuts.6:52We don't realize how much we're damaging ourselves.6:54How many times did you ask your parents when you were a kid,6:58Why should I learn math if I could use a calculator?7:01I think I just, H.com just sent me an email recently.7:03I get their weekly emails,7:05and I think the guy who created the calculator just died.7:11I think I read it from there.7:12It's interesting, I'm saying that now,7:14I'm remembering. Anyway, but why should I learn math?7:17I have a calculator.7:17Isn't that great?7:19Easy,7:20one, two, three.7:21And really, most people don't have a good answer to that,7:25right? And we get the same question a lot of times:7:27Rabbi, תעשה לי טובה, do me a favor.7:29Don't teach me Gemara.7:30Give me the bottom line.7:31Let's just Gemara7:33back and forth,7:34halacha, halacha, at the end of the day, who do we hold like?7:36Who do we hold like,7:36this opinion or that opinion?7:39And what do you mean?7:40Okay, I can tell you.7:41Okay, so what do I have to go through?7:42And I used to say the same thing in my yeshiva.7:44I used to ask the rabbi,7:45I can't,7:45give me7:46halacha. What are we learning, learning,7:47what's the bottom line?7:49Right?7:50And I never understood why,7:53right? And the answer is very simple.7:55There's a skill.8:00Right? There's a skill, like any other skill. For example, there's a skill that—I'll just give you an example for right now, for a second.8:06We have a lot of skills in our lives8:08that we need to learn.8:10And we don't just pick up. And if we do pick it up, we're not actually learning it properly,8:14we may never have it properly. I'll give you a basic skill. It's called etiquette. It's called what we call derech eretz,8:21okay? And that applies in how we eat.8:24Proper etiquette, proper derech eretz in how to eat is8:27that what? You don't lick your fingers when you're eating, right? Because your hands got dirty. You don't eat with your fingers,8:35right? You use a fork, you use a spoon to eat a soup.8:38You don't pick up the bowl and just take it and put it in your mouth.8:40There's certain things are derech eretz, right? And this we have to teach our kids.8:44We can't expect our kids to just know it by themselves. And the proof is, a lot of times we see the little ones,8:49you know, that's sticking their hand. Okay, French fries, you can use your hand, but you can't use your hand for a noodle soup,8:56right? That's not the way to eat noodles.8:58You don't stick spaghetti and you just go like that, and when you're done, you lick your fingers.9:02That's not. But we have to teach it. It's a skill that has to be taught. And9:06kids who are not taught that way, we see them as adults, the way they eat.9:10We see them the way they just stick their hands. And even as they get older, you see certain people9:15who are—you can see clearly these kids or these adults never really got those skills when they were kids.9:21So these are skills that we have to develop.9:24One of the skills that we have to develop as human beings is also problem solving,9:30that figuring out things, because it applies in every single area.9:34If we can't figure out, if we can't figure out things, if we don't use our skills, if we're not trained, and9:40to develop the skill of problem solving, then what happens? We9:45don't learn it. Or even if we learned it and we start depending on something else,9:49then we end up forgetting how to problem solve, and without it we can't do anything.9:53Because we feel like, ah, we're just faced with a problem, we can't figure out anything.9:57Why do people go to rabbis for their problems? All of a sudden the rabbis, if they're going there for business advice,10:03they're going there for other advice.10:04It's not just halacha question, right? People go to rabbis for regular advice in marriage and shalom bayit10:09and what to do with the kids, which house to buy, and the rabbis give them great advice.10:14Why is that? Because their minds are trained through the Torah to problem solve the way the Torah wants you to solve, and that's what the10:20whole Gemara is. So we develop that skill as,10:24what's it called, as we learn, as we develop, as we, what's it called, as10:31we train our minds to problem solve. This is what happens when you learn the Torah properly.10:38This is what happens when you learn math10:40properly without relying on a calculator. You can figure out things. You train yourself to solve problems.10:46But when you're dependent on a calculator,10:50or you're dependent on kitzur dinim, let's bring it back to what we're talking about, when you're dependent just on kitzur dinim10:56and just, okay, on memory, says the Gra, and the Gra was a genius, and he could have said, listen, I remember everything.11:02No, he knows. It's not why you remember everything. You're going to forget it. You don't know the reasons.11:07You don't know how you came to that conclusion.11:09Besides, you're going to mix up the Rosh himself already.11:12Rabbeinu Asher was one of the Rishonim, says besides the fact that you're going to for sure11:15mix it up and you're going to mess up because you don't know the reason, you're going to apply the issur on the11:21mutar and the mutar on the issur, and it doesn't really apply. But besides that, if you don't learn it properly, you just won't retain it.11:25The brain just cannot hold that much information. When you know the reasons, okay, the reasons make much more sense.11:31He says,11:37However, that's the guy who just learning kitzurim, just learning the Shulchan Aruch basic.11:42He doesn't understand the roots from the Beit Yosef and the Gemara.11:46אבל ... מי שלומד הדינים שורשו, a person who learns the halacha, but he learns the sources,11:52he opens up the Gemara, opens up even sometimes you have to go back as much as the Torah, the Chumash,11:57ויודע כל דת ודין. Good timing, right? We're in Nedarim. And he knows every12:04halacha, every source of halacha, תעשיר. He'll be rich, ידע הכל. I remember saying this. I remember12:10when we were starting out in yeshiva, just newly got married, my12:15brother-in-law, now he's holding very, very well in learning,12:18and he used to sit there, he said he used to spend two hours12:21learning about one or two halachot.12:24Two hours, he would learn it from the source and everything else.12:27But you know what? Everybody,12:28you know, most people are running, they want to know quickly what to do, everything else,12:32so they're opening up the Yalkut Yosef, and they're opening up the12:34Ben Ish Chai, and they're opening up the Kitzur Dinim, right? Or the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch, or whatever it is. They want to know bottom line, right?12:40He learned it with the ... and that's what he retained. But they,12:45the other ones who all had the Kitzur Dinim, don't retain what they have.12:49And you see a lot of times, a lot of people, like they just forget it.12:52And that's what the guy's saying: you learn Kitzur Dinim without learning the source of the halachot,12:59so ... like we gave a psychological explanation, but really, like we said beforehand, it's13:05more than just psychological. It's also a spiritual reason as well. Baruch ... amen v'amen.