Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 30Sefer Even ShelemaPart 150Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:37Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Even shelema, perek chavav, עוד חבב. We're almost done with the perek. We have two more letters for the0:06perek, which has been so far the longest0:09perek. Then points of Torah, points of the sodot haTorah and who is fit to learn the sodot0:16haTorah, and the more, I guess, you know, when you learn about something,0:20especially if you're learning L'shem Shamayim, I hope0:22we're learning L'shem Shamayim, you get experience.0:26And unfortunately, we're exposed to people that think they know things about Kabbalah,0:30and they talk about great rabbis, great mekubalim,0:32as if they know what they're talking about,0:34and Hashem yishmor from such people and such0:39da'ot. But you see more and more the power and how the Gra said it so, so importantly.0:44People who don't really have a background in the regular simple way of learning Torah,0:49which is what—we're not talking about just the Chumash.0:52We're talking about people who don't have a background in Mishnayot and Gemara and0:56Halacha. To learn Kabbalah, to jump into Kabbalah, is not just dangerous;1:00it's just so pitiful and so, so silly.1:04They distort the words, and then they make it look like,1:08chas v'shalom, that they know what they're talking about.1:10There's so much sodot.1:11Now, in today's Even Shelema, he discusses even the simple is not really so simple.1:22The aggadot—we have a lot of1:24aggadata, we have in Chazal, we have Midrashim, we also have in the Gemara,1:28and besides what we have also in the Zohar, a lot of stories, or seem to be stories or derashot,1:33or, you know, rabbinic advice, what seems to be.1:35There's a whole set called Ein Yaakov, which puts them all together,1:39and a lot of people learn from that.1:40So the Gra says regarding those, the Gra says,1:47Ha'aggadot shelefi hanir'eh chas v'shalom hem devarim batelim. The aggadot which, on a superficial level,1:50it looks like— They're like, things are not so really important.1:54They're not talking about mitzvot,1:57hen ganuz kol hasodot. What's hidden inside of them is all the secrets of the Torah.2:02V'zeh ... ma shekatuv, hu mecholal mipeshaeinu. And this is what Yeshayah says:2:06from our peshaeinu, from our sins,2:10he's mecholal. What does it mean, mecholal? He has become2:12chol, really mecholal from the word holy.2:14He's become sick from our sins.2:17That is referring2:19to the sodot of the Kabbalah, of the sodot, the secrets of the Torah which Chazal put inside the aggadot,2:25and because of our sins2:26that we don't know how to understand, we don't know how to read them,2:28therefore we make it look like a regular2:32chol, a regular weekday stuff.2:34He brings over here the source of the2:36Gra. The source of the Gra says all these things from the side over here,2:41and I'm going to read that first,2:43and then I'm going to bring you something else that2:45the ... doesn't quote,2:46but over here the author brings it in,2:49and it's very, very important.2:50He says like this:2:58העניין כי סוד משה הוא תורתו, הלכה למשה מסיני, שהוא הסוד והוא גנוז ברמז. The secrets of Moshe Rabbeinu's Torah,3:01which has come from3:05Har Sinai, those secrets are stored in just a hint,3:11v'hen ha'aggadot שהם בש״ס, and these hints are all found in the aggadot of the3:15Chazal. כמו מעשים דרבה בר בר חנה, for example,3:17if you look at the stories of3:19Rabba bar bar Chana, Masechet Bava Batra, a few pages, which seem to be wild,3:22really one of the wildest gemarot,3:25right? V'sanherib, even the story of3:30Sanherib, ... which seem to be like really,3:31there's no reason.3:32Why is the Gemara telling3:33us? The Gemara says3:34one time he was riding on a boat,3:35and he saw in the ship3:36this fish,3:37and this fish had an eye,3:38and it was going up to the3:39shamayim, and it seemed to be like really non-...3:43And some mefarshim say that was all a dream.3:45It cannot be real.3:47But he says— Chas v'shalom to think3:51that they're nonsense,3:52right? What do you think?3:53Chazal, who were so makpid on Talmud Torah, who were so careful to tell us3:57that we have to utilize every moment for Torah,4:00and yet they tell us4:02all these things. They bring in the4:03Gemara, for what?4:06All the light4:08and all the Torah,4:09the secrets of all of Torat Moshe.4:15And this is what Moshe asked for,4:18but he wasn't given the request.4:20Moshe Rabbeinu didn't want4:21that the secrets should be hidden,4:23that he wanted it to be revealed at all,4:25but he wasn't granted that permission.4:33From our sins,4:34like we said before,4:35from our4:36avodah, that we are not on the level,4:39therefore we make the words of the Torah4:41that are very, very holy and deep,4:42we make them,4:43we turn them into something4:45that chol, that's something4:47that seems to be on a simple level,4:51right? So over here4:51I'd like to read you some notes4:52on the bottom.4:54First of all,4:55he brings over here4:56in the words of the Gra,4:59זה ... אות נון, זה מושלקת ... המשניות. מוסר וסודות. The Hagadot of Chazal tell us there are two parts, there are two types. One is musar, directing a person in how5:13to live his life with the attitude towards life, and number two is5:15sodot,5:16the secrets.5:18וזה לשון הרמבם בהקדמה לפירוש המשניות. The Rambam writes the following5:20in his introduction5:21to his commentary on the Mishnayot.5:25ועניין הרביעי הזה, כלומר הדרש שהוא בא בתלמוד. It says5:26regarding the drash5:28that Chazal bring5:32in the Gemara, אין לחשוב שהוא במעלה נמוכה או שתועלתו מועטה. Nobody should think,5:34Ah,5:35it's aggadata, it's only stories,5:36yalla, skip it,5:37it's fast,5:38or,5:38Eh, it's all for5:39amei haaretz, for talmidei chachamim, now we learn5:44the lomdus. אלא תכליתו עצומה. The Rambam writes,5:45the purpose of it is unbelievable,5:50כמו שהוא כולל מן החידות והעמוקות והארוכות הנפלאות. As it includes many of the deep, deep riddles5:53and really wondrous,5:54enlightening things.5:57כי אותן הדרשות מן הטוב המעשי. It's like Adam Harishon's sin,6:05שאכל מעץ הדעת טוב ורע, הוא אכל from the eitz hadaat tov vara. רק היודעים לכוון כוונות יחידים מעוררי. Only people have permission to do it,6:08only the people who know how to have kavanot6:10and to make the yichudim of Shem Hashem6:12exactly as it's supposed to be.6:15בכל מצווה הכוונה מיוחדת מקובלת. In every mitzvah,6:16in the right kavanah6:18and the accepted kavanah.6:27כל שם איך יוצא משם הוויה. Every name, how it comes out from the name Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh. והויות משונות בנקודות והכול בכוונתו. And every single name that comes out of6:29it has specific6:31nekudot, and everything has6:31not only just6:32nekudot; you have to know what these nekudot also mean.6:36וזהו עץ החיים. And knowing Hashem's name,6:37knowing the combination of Hashem's name6:40and where they apply,6:43and knowing how the kavanot6:44fit together with the6:47nekudot and how they apply,6:49that's the knowledge6:50that's called6:51eating from the eitz6:54hachayim. להבוקש ... אדם הוא בעץ הדעת. However,6:56a person who's using Kabbalah Maasit6:58in order to,6:59for his own personal benefit,7:01that's called7:02the etz hadaat tov vara.7:04Before we go on7:05to the source over here,7:08to other places,7:09I would like to first7:10explain a little bit of a background7:12that we really, really, really need7:14to understand what's going on.7:14I'm very happy7:16I read the quote of the Chaim Vital7:16because I wanted to quote him also.7:18The Ben Ish Chai also quotes him.7:19So let me just say7:20something, a little background,7:22okay? This Kabbalah7:23is the secrets of the Torah.7:26Kabbalah,7:26the reason why it's called Kabbalah,7:27it's also called sod,7:29secret,7:30it's because,7:31as the name implies,7:31it was never public.7:33It was7:34always—Moshe Rabbeinu, of course,7:34had a mesorah for Kabbalah,7:36right?7:36He got it from Hashem,7:38and he passed it down to7:39yechidim. It was never taught in public.7:41And these7:42yechidim passed it, passed it,7:43passed it down,7:44and people7:44who knew Kabbalah7:45walked around7:46like the regular people7:47and never ever spoke7:47and never showed it off.7:49The first one7:50to publicly write about it7:52in a public7:53setting—people even wrote7:54small...8:00Books about Kabbalah kept it private. The first one to actually write it in public was the famous Rabbi Moshe ben8:07Nachman, the Ramban, in his commentary on the Torah. Over there, he was megaleh tefach, right? But he was8:18ma'alim olam, you know what I'm saying? Like, what he revealed was very, very little compared to what really was there.8:22For example, whenever you see in the פירוש of the Ramban, he says,8:26ועל פי חכמי האמת, means he's going al pi Kabbalah, and very, very hard to understand.8:30It was very, very mysterious, the way he wrote, because he's like writing it, but he was very, very careful.8:35We're going to read tomorrow at a pace a lot of people have a minhag of reading8:39the letter of Rabbi Shimshon miSropoli that he wrote to the Jewish community8:43explaining the8:46טעמי מצות על פי האריזל, okay? The Arizal is a beautiful thing.8:47In every other line, you notice he8:49says, והוא רחום יכפר עוון, והוא רחום יכפר עוון, really not supposed to say8:53והוא רחום יכפר עוון, right? Meaning, he keeps on saying, he keeps on mentioning this point that I can't really reveal.8:59I know what it means, but it doesn't mean just because everything you know you're supposed to reveal.9:03Kabbalah is supposed to be a sod, secret.9:06And this Rabbi Shimshon miSropoli lived in the 1700s, perhaps, you know, a little later even,9:12and still what he revealed was very, very little, and he kept it as secret as possible.9:17Even though Kabbalah has been publicized much more.9:20The Zohar was in a way before by9:23Tana'im, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, and the Arizal says we got to, you know, learn more Kabbalah to bring to9:28hasten the geulah, and even the Zohar says that.9:29But even then, the Kabbalah itself, even the study of Kabbalah was always, you know... Not so public,9:36and even when it's public, not so, so public,9:38right? Certainly, the great rabbis would probably get a heart attack,9:44actually. They're mitzta'er very much when they have goyim and ladies learning Kabbalah centers, right?9:49Now, it doesn't have to get that bad, but when you have people, like we saw already,9:53don't even know pshat and they're touching Kabbalah.9:55That's Kabbalah9:56b'limud. There's a second form of Kabbalah, and that's called Kabbalah9:59ma'asit. Kabbalah ma'asit is much, much, much different.10:01Kabbalah ma'asit is you actually do things based on Kabbalah.10:04One of the famous things is, like for example, creating a golem,10:08right, which the Gra almost created when he was 12,10:10until he understood that he shouldn't be creating it.10:12Kabbalah ma'asit is actually changing the world of nature10:16based on the study of Kabbalah,10:18and you can literally be mashbia.10:19You can make angels do things for you.10:22You can do a lot of things with Kabbalah ma'asit, actually.10:24And there are people that may know how to do these things.10:27The Gra in the 1700s, in the late 1700s, writes,10:31as we can see soon from the10:34Zohar, he says that in our days, nobody can do this.10:40The only people who could do these things10:43are the Kabbalah ma'asit, are people who really know10:45how to be10:47mechaven, and how to be mechaven everything in the right way,10:49right? We learned a little bit about10:51kavanot. You're supposed to have kavanot by10:53korbanot, right? Now, imagine a person,10:55right? Now, we learned basic, for10:56example, you need to have10:58kavanah what type of korban it is and who it is for.10:59So imagine a kohen comes in,11:01wasn't really trained, he snuck his way in,11:03and he's now in charge of11:05the shechitah, and they tell him, You have to have11:06kavanah, okay?11:08So he has11:10kavanah. What's11:10kavanah? It means you have to concentrate on something.11:13He concentrates that this animal is going to be such a holy animal,11:16it's going to be burned completely to Hashem.11:17Meanwhile, it's11:19korban shelamim, which people have to eat from it.11:20It's11:21pasul. That's a simple11:23kavanah. Now, people could tell you,11:25they could tell you,11:25you'd11:28kavavke, oh, they kaven, and nekudot and this, but you can mess it up.11:29Who says that's the right kavanah for that thing?11:32And if you don't know,11:32you can really, really mess it up,11:34right?11:35So that's just in regular11:38kavanot. A kavahomer, a guy who doesn't even know these11:40kavanot and he's trying to apply in different places,11:42right, he could be messing up.11:44Now you're going to go and do Kabbalah Maasit?11:45That's very, very dangerous,11:47and it should not be done.11:49So he quotes over here on the bottom.11:52Look on the bottom.11:52Masechet Avot says,11:54Mishnah says,11:54famous Mishnah:11:55Ud shetamash b'taga halaf.11:57A person who uses the crown11:59has substituted that benefit of usage of the12:03crown for his life.12:05What is that talking about?12:06The mefarshim explain that12:08if you use the crown of Hashem,12:10the crown means your power,12:12right?12:12You're a king.12:14Hashem has the power to control nature12:15and to command malachim to do things for Him.12:17If you start playing with that,12:20you're—whoa, whoa—it's very dangerous.12:21You're risking your life.12:25A person who uses12:28the Shem HaMeforash, what's Shem HaMeforash? Knowing what Hashem's name12:29and how to combine it together,12:31you could do major, major things12:33if you use it.12:34Yeah, there's such a power in the world,12:36and if you do it—