Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 3Sefer Even ShelemaPart 123Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:01Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00So we're doing part two today of0:06the Emet Shema, perek chet, ot bet. One of the things we said yesterday that the Gra says, that even if a person doesn't know how to explain0:11the Mishnah, lefaresh haMishnah, it says, yilmad kulo, learn it.0:14Okay? So now, that's what Emet Shema says.0:19Where does the Gra, where does Emet Shema get it from? The Gra says it based on the Gemara.0:23The Gemara talks about a debate of the goyim had with Rabbi0:28Yehoshua, Sabei d'Bei Atuna and Rabbi Yehoshua. Over there, it's a very, very deep, complex Gemara,0:31when they each give him a riddle. Each one throws like a riddle or debate,0:37and he answers them back something even weirder. It was a very, very interesting Gemara,0:40but obviously the Gemara is coming to tell us something very, very deep.0:43So it says over there the following story.0:46Amar lehu, he tells them, he tells them,0:49Gabra azal l'agma. This person went to the pond,0:53okay? And by the pond there's things that grow. That's what they call agma, usually, or a forest.0:57So it says,1:02v'katal kama tuna v'lo matzivei. He cut off a bundle of reeds that grow over there,1:11and he wasn't able to—tuna v'lo matzivei. He came to carry it; he wasn't able to carry it. It was very heavy.1:15Good? He continued in the forest,1:18katal l'ma'alei. He cut more, and then he was able to put it on his—he was able to carry it.1:24Ad d'atrei inish min d'lilei, until somebody came later on, and they were able to assist him in carrying the load.1:31That's what the Gemara says.1:32Now comes the Gra and comments on this Gemara,1:34and he says,1:35there's a Gemara Masechet Bava Batra that's based on the1:39pasuk. It says,1:42Mesia avanim יעצבו בהם, u'bokea etzim יסכן בם. A person who makes stones travel will be1:46יעצבו בהם. Usually, pashut pshat means gets depressed or gets upset.1:51And the Gemara says, who is that talking about?1:54The Gemara says, אלו בעלי גמרא. Right? Those are ba'alei Gemara.1:58Vokea etzim, misaken bam, elu ba'alei Mishnah. A person who cuts wood may get in danger by them.2:01That's talking about the people who are2:06ba'alei Mishnah, people who just learn Mishnayot. Kashe. Ha kede'amruha, osek b'Mishnah midah, v'Gemara ein lecha midah gedolah menat. That's from the Gemara2:12that, what, I mean, based on the girsa over here, the beginning on the bottom really is supposed to be the opposite.2:15But anyway, the Gemara in Bava Metzia says2:18a person who learns only Mishnayot is good,2:20but when you learn Gemara, it's the best.2:23Also it says,2:27hatanna'im hem mebalei ha'olam. People who just learn2:28Mishnayot—now, Mishnayot means2:30without really understanding the real cases,2:32without the2:33פירושים, just the simple2:35halacha, straightforward—yet they are the people who destroy the world. Why?2:38Because2:40the Mishnah doesn't give you any reasons.2:41The Mishnah just gives you facts.2:43This is what you have to do.2:45It doesn't tell you why you have to do it, right? So how can it2:48be over here, in our Gemara, it sounds like2:50the people who learn Mishnah is good.3:00V'teichlema, oskim b'Gemara, lebad, al hem ne'emar, mesi'ei avonim, v'aval oskim, kodem b'metitim, v'oskim gam ken b'Gemara. See, the Gemara says a big chidush. The Gemara is talking about what?3:03People who only learn with Gemara.3:05They jump Gemarot before they jump into Mishnayot,3:08right? It's good.3:10But the people who learn Mishnayot first3:12and then they come to the Gemara,3:13al hem ne'emar, vokea etzim. For them, that's like people chopping wood.3:20Gemara lebad hu kemo mesi'ei avanim, kemo shehen min hahar bli shum tekumah vhem hana'ah. A person who carries3:23stones—the Gemara compares him to3:24people who learn only Gemara.3:26That's like people3:27who, yeah, very good,3:28they bring stones,3:29they have a lot of stones they can build with,3:30but the problem is3:32it's not refined.3:33It's not. Cut properly.3:34It's not ready to be built,3:37and there's not really so much hana'ah from them.3:41A person who first learns Mishnayot3:44and then learns Gemara,3:45it's like a person who chops wood.3:50First he cuts the wood from the forest,3:51which is like learning the Mishnayot,3:56and then afterwards3:57he cuts them to size.3:58You know, when you cut wood in the forest,4:01you cut it down a tree.4:02You can't do much with the tree.4:03But then you take the tree4:04and you cut it down to smaller sizes,4:06then you can use it for whatever you want.4:07You can use it for beams,4:08you can use it for bookcases,4:10you can use it for firewood,4:11you can make it into tables.4:12That's the next step.4:14He compares that to the way a person learns.4:16When a person learns Mishnayot4:17and he covers the Mishnah, he covers the facts4:19without understanding the whys first.4:22Okay, it's like the log of wood.4:23It's like a big tree you have.4:25What can you do with it?4:25Not much.4:26But it'll be much easier later on4:28when you come to Gemara,4:28you come to chop it,4:30everything makes sense.4:30Oh, that fits with that4:31Mishnah, that Mishnah, that4:36Mishnah. That's why4:37a person who doesn't know how to explain the Mishnayot,4:39they compare him to a person who's cutting reeds.4:41Go back to the Gemara,4:43Masechet Bechorot. What does it say?4:46The Gemara says, That's why. It's interesting.4:47Now you can understand another Gemara.4:48The Gemara says one time—it's a funny Gemara.4:50This Gemara got me laughing a few times,4:52even though I knew it.4:53I don't remember ever reading Gemara4:56and cracking up,4:58but I do remember a few4:59Gemaras that got me laughing.5:00This is one of them.5:01A guy comes5:04in—certainly, a guy comes to the beit midrash.5:06So they ask them,5:09a person who's megaben, a person who makes cheese,5:13right, on Shabbat,5:14what is he5:15chayav? What melachah is he chayav for?5:17Because he's megaben.5:19Because he made cheese?5:20They ask him a person who,5:22I forgot what the other one is.5:25It's basically,5:25you know, we know there's avot melachot and5:28there's toldot. Then they ask him,5:29I don't know, I'm making it up.5:30Let's say a person who makes labneh.5:32I'm making it up. I don't think it was that.5:33A person who makes labneh,5:35it was Yehayafor, because he's making labneh.5:38They told him,5:39What, you're a rabbi? You said just cut—what did he say? Rabah katal kanya b'agma. He's a guy who just chopped, you know, things,5:45right? What are you talking about?5:46So he didn't know.5:47He went to the other beit midrash.5:48They told him the answer.5:49He came back and he told them the answer,5:53right? Right? But that Gemara, you know, I was cracking up when I read that5:55Gemara, because really,5:58like, what are you answering? A guy comes to you, Hey, Rabbi, a person who puts on6:00a light—what is, on Shabbat—a person who uses a cell phone on Shabbat,6:02what's the problem?6:03He's using his cell phone.6:06No, he's using his cell phone. Like, what's your answer?6:07That's exactly the case.6:08We're asking,6:09why is it a6:10problem, right? So anyway,6:11but the Gemara uses6:12the lashon, Rabah katal kanya b'agma. What did he do?6:14Just chop, you know, things in the6:16Gemara. Like, why did they answer that?6:17The answer is,6:21meaning that kanya over here, the kanim over here that we're talking about, means that he just learned Mishnayot.6:27He just told you facts.6:28He didn't explain to you,6:30right?6:31Because the Gemara says6:32over here, a person who just chops wood,6:36right, who6:38just chops—excuse me, kanim—just cuts them,6:39that's like learning Mishnayot.6:41It's good, but you have to go deeper.6:43You have to not cut them to size.6:45It's like, you know, you buy,6:47what do they call it,6:48textile,6:50right? But then you cut them to size of how you want them.6:52You want them to be a tablecloth,6:53you want them to be a dress,6:54you want them to be a suit,6:55you cut them to size afterwards.6:57Mishnayot, unlike buying the textile.6:58Cut the textile, you have it,7:01you have the roll, you have the—and then you got to make it into something else.7:03That's also the learning of Mishnayot.7:06Now,7:07ve'amru perek ha-man tani, next page.7:08I'm jumping because of the time.7:11Yeah, it says7:17in Masechet Ta'anit, the first perek, im keha ha-barzel v'hu lo panim, kilkel. If the barzel becomes,7:20if the iron,7:21if the steel becomes7:22what's called weakened,7:25and it was because it was messed up in the face,7:28I don't know exactly what the Gemara7:29says like this.7:32Based on that pasuk, if you see any student who's having a very hard time learning,7:35and his learning is hard as a stone,7:39as iron,7:42bishvil mishnato she'eina sedurah alav kera'ui. He says the Gemara, you know why?7:44Because he didn't learn Mishnayot.7:46It's not prepared for him.7:48Mata kantei? Yalbei yeshiva. What should he do?7:49He should sit in yeshiva longer,7:51says the Gemara.7:54And he says the Gra, he says, kemo shekatuv, chabirecha yikamchu b'yadecha, kol sheken im mishnato sedurah lo me'ikara.8:02Va'yeshav. Nimsa ki tzarich kodem limud haMishnah. It says, what do you see from here?8:05Because chavrecha kamocha, beyadecha. It's talking about, you go back, you learn the Mishnah properly,8:08you organize it, and then you can understand the Gemara easier.8:14V'af al pi shelo yada lefaresh Mishnah. You know, he's learned Mishnayot, he doesn't know really what it means.8:17And that's a criticism that we said before, that he just learns Mishnah, he doesn't know.8:20It doesn't make a difference.8:23Imod kulo, v'achar kach yelamed Gemara. Because when you know the facts, now it's very easy to put them together.8:26Just read them, it's okay.8:30And that's why in a lot of yeshivot, they make them learn Mishnayot and memorize them. But when they get to Gemara now, oh, they'll be able to cross-reference and say,8:35oh, that's... They know those simple facts, right?8:38And that's how when we learn, if you ever notice, in our classes where we8:42learn, we come to a stop, stop, or put in Chumash. I have to work today with8:46Chumash. We're assuming everybody was learning Chumash now, at least knows8:48Chumash. Today we don't even know Chumash. Most people don't even know Chumash, don't have a8:51clue really. We know the story, we know the basic story,8:55but the details for sure we don't know. We know there's a Korban Pesach,8:57but we don't know how the Torah said the words of Korban Pesach.9:00So we open up and we see the pesukim, we see the words.9:03Now we got a little bit of a story, we can go on to Gemara, makes it so much smoother, so much cleaner.9:08And that's what he says over here. In Mishnayot, it's the same idea.9:23Uchtiv, 'Ish asher teinah lo haElokim osher v'chasim v'chavod, v'lo yishteneh lo haElokim lechol me'enu.' Ze baal Mishnah, ki ish nochi yochlinu, ze baal Gemara. V'af bechen, yilmod haMishnah kinan, mishum shelo shenasu lahaloch kenan, ki memeila tares harbeta bGemara. And he's bringing beautiful Gemara.9:26Gemara says, there's some people have a lot of wealth and9:29Hashem, as a punishment, doesn't let them eat from it.9:31It says, who's that? The Gemara says that's people who only learn9:34Mishnayot. Think about it. They have a lot of wealth, but they don't know what to do with it.9:40The guy knows all the Shas and everything by heart, but lemaaseh halachah, maaseh, he can't do. He doesn't know. It's only Mishnayot. He doesn't know how to apply it and the reasons and everything else.9:45But there's a stranger who will eat it. Who's that? That's a person who learns Gemara,9:50right? Sounds like from here, it's no good to just learn9:52Mishnayot. It says, yeah, but you need to learn Gemara.9:55When you have that, the Gemara, now it makes sense.9:58When it starts to cross-reference, you'll be able to understand it.10:06V'zeh shene'emar kan, 'Gabra d'azila Gemara,' and that's come back to the original Gemara. When he picked it up, he couldn't find the Lord,10:09and then he finally told people that came and helped him.10:12What does that mean? When you are cutting the kanim in the field,10:15the Gemara is talking about a person who wanted to learn10:19Mishnayot. He made bundles of, what, Mishnayot, and he couldn't carry;10:23it was too hard for him to carry. When was he able to carry? When people came to help him.10:26Who's that? That's a Gemara. So you have to cut the bundles first, though.10:31You have to cut them in order to be able to carry them to go home.10:34So you have to learn the Mishnayot, you have to know all the facts,10:36and then when you get to the Gemara and you understand the reasons, that makes a lot more sense.10:41Okay, see what time it is?10:44You know what? The next piece is very short.10:48I really... it's chavruta, like spent a whole... and then the piece after that is very long. So I'm going to do one more piece also.10:53Very important. I really hope people were listening till now. Maybe I should stop it.10:56You know, I'm going to stop it because it's a very important thing. I'm going to talk about it a lot more.