Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 29Sefer Even ShelemaPart 149Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:20Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01אבן שלמה, פרק ח', אות כה. מעת חורבן בית המקדש. The Ibn Shemah is telling us that from the Gra, from the time the Beit HaMikdash was destroyed, נתערב הכל, טוב ורע. Everything got mixed. Everything got mixed.0:13Good and evil got all mixed together.0:19ולכן כל מי שעושה קבלה מעשית הוא עוון פלילי. Therefore, the Gra is telling you, anybody who is going to start doing Kabbalah Maasit,0:23he's doing not a sin, but a grave sin, a very, very severe sin.0:31והוא דומה לחטא אדם הראשון. It's similar to a person who is doing—excuse me, the person who does Kabbalah Maasit, it's like Adam Harishon's sin.0:45שאכל מעץ הדעת טוב ורע, who ate from the Etz HaDaat Tov VaRa. רק היודעים לכוון כוונות יחודים מעבוריאן. Only people who have permission to do it, only0:48the people who know how to have kavanot and to make the yichudim of Shem Hashem exactly as it's supposed to be,0:55בכל מצווה הכוונה מיוחדת מקובלת. In every mitzvah, in the right kavanah and the accepted kavanah.1:01כל שם היוצא משם הוויה, every name that comes out from the name Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei, והויות משונות בנקודות וכל בכוונתו. And every single name that comes out of it has specific1:11nekudot, and everything has—not only just nekudot—you have to know what these nekudot also mean.1:16וזהו עץ החיים. And knowing Hashem's name, knowing the combination of Hashem's name and where they apply,1:22and knowing how the kavanot fit together with the nekudot and how they apply,1:29that's the knowledge that's called eating from the1:35Etz HaChayim. לבוקש שימושים לצורך האדם הוא בעץ הדעת טוב ורע. However, a person who's using Kabbalah Maasit in order for his own personal benefit, that's called the Etz HaDaat Tov VaRa.1:44Before we go on to the source over here or to other places,1:49I would like to first— Explain a little bit of a background that we really, really, really need to understand what's going on.1:55I'm very happy to read the quote of Rabbi Chaim Vital because I wanted to quote him also.1:58The Ben Ish Chai also quotes him. So let me just say something, a little background,2:03okay? This Kabbalah is the secrets of the Torah.2:06Kabbalah, the reason why it's called Kabbalah, it's also called sod, secret,2:10it's because, as the name implies, it was never public.2:13It was always—Moshe Rabbeinu, of course, had a mesorah for Kabbalah,2:16right? He got it from Hashem, and he passed it down to2:20yechidim. It was never taught in public.2:21And these yechidim passed it, passed it, passed it down, and people who knew Kabbalah2:25walked around like the regular people and never ever spoke and never showed it off.2:29The first one to publicly write about it in a public2:33setting—people even wrote small books about it but kept it2:36private—the first one to actually write it in public was the famous Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman, the Ramban.2:42In his commentary on Torah,2:43over there he was megaleh טפח, right?2:47But he was2:53מעלים עולם, you know what I'm saying? Like, what he revealed was very, very little compared to what really was there.2:57For example, whenever you see the פירוש of the Ramban, he says,3:00ועל פי חכמי האמת, means he's going al pi Kabbalah,3:03and it's very, very hard to3:04understand. It was very, very mysterious the way he wrote,3:07because it's like writing it, but he was very, very careful.3:10We're going to read tomorrow, im yirtzeh Hashem, a lot of people have a minhag of reading3:14the letter of Rav Shimshon Raphael Hirsch that he wrote to the Jewish community,3:18explaining the3:21ten makot al פי האריזל, okay? The Arizal has a beautiful thing,3:22and every other line, you notice, he says,3:26והוא רחום יכפר עוון, והוא רחום יכפר עוון. Really not supposed to say והוא רחום יכפר עוון, right?3:29Meaning, he keeps on saying, he keeps on mentioning this point3:31that I can't really reveal.3:35I know what it means, but it doesn't mean just because everything you know3:37you're supposed to reveal.3:38Kabbalah is supposed to be a sod, secret.3:41And this Rav Shimshon Raphael Hirsch lived in the 1700s, perhaps,3:44you know, a little later even,3:47and still what he revealed was very, very little,3:51and he kept it as secret as possible.3:53Even though Kabbalah has been publicized much more.3:55The Zohar was written way before by4:01Tanna'im, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, and the Arizal says we got to, you know, learn more Kabbalah to bring the Geulah, and even the Zohar says that.4:04But even then, the Kabbalah itself,4:07even the study of Kabbalah was always, you know—4:10Not so public, and even when it's public,4:12not so, so public, right?4:14Certainly the great rabbis would probably get a heart attack,4:19actually. They're mitzta'er very much4:21when they have goyim and ladies learning Kabbalah centers, right?4:25Now, it doesn't have to get that bad,4:26but when you have people, like we saw already,4:28don't even know pshat and they're touching Kabbalah.4:30That's Kabbalah4:32b'limud. There's a second form of Kabbalah,4:33and that's called Kabbalah4:34ma'asit. Kabbalah ma'asit is much, much, much different.4:36Kabbalah ma'asit is you actually do things based on Kabbalah.4:39One of the famous things is, like for example, creating a golem,4:43right, which the Gra almost created when he was 12,4:45till he understood that he shouldn't be creating it.4:47Kabbalah ma'asit is actually changing the world of nature4:51based on the study of Kabbalah,4:53and you can literally be4:55mashpia. You can make angels do things for you.4:57You can do a lot of things with Kabbalah ma'asit, actually.5:00And there are people that may know how to do these things.5:02The Gra, in the 1700s, in the late 1700s,5:05writes, as we can see soon5:08from the Zohar, he says that5:12in our days, nobody can do this.5:15The only people who could do these things5:18are the Kabbalah5:19ma'asit, are people who really know how to be5:22mechaven, and how to be mechaven everything in the right way, right?5:24We learned a little bit about5:26kavanot. You're supposed to have kavanot by korbanot, right?5:29Now, imagine a person,5:30right, now we learned basic, for example,5:32you need to have kavanah what type of korban it is and who it is for.5:35So imagine a kohen comes5:36to the Beit HaMikdash, wasn't really trained, he snuck his way in,5:38and he's now in charge of5:41the shechitah, and they tell him, You have to have5:42kavanah, okay? So he has5:45kavanah. What's5:45kavanah? Means you have to concentrate on something.5:48He concentrates that this animal is going to be such a holy animal,5:51it's going to be burned completely to Hashem.5:52Meanwhile, it's5:54korban shelamim, which people have to eat from it. It's5:57pasul. That's a simple5:58kavanah. Now, people could tell you,6:00they could tell you,6:01Yud kevavke, oh, they kaven and nekudot and this,6:03but you can mess it up.6:04Who says that's the right kavanah for that thing?6:07And if you don't know, you can really, really mess it up, right?6:11So that's just in regular6:14kavanot. A kabbalah guy who doesn't even know these6:15kavanot and he tries to apply in different places,6:18right, he could be messing up.6:19Now you're going to go and do Kabbalah Maasit?6:20That's very, very dangerous,6:22and it should not be done.6:24So he quotes over here on the bottom.6:27Look on the bottom.6:28Masechet Avot says, Mishnah says,6:30famous Mishnah:6:32Ud shetamash b'taga halaf. A person who uses the crown6:34has substituted6:36that benefit of usage of the crown6:39for his life.6:40What is that talking about?6:41The mefarshim explain that if you use the crown of Hashem,6:45the crown means your power,6:47right? You're a king.6:48Hashem has the power to control nature6:51and to command malachim to do things for Him.6:53If you start playing with that,6:55you're—whoa, whoa—it's very dangerous.6:56You're risking your life.7:03Rabbeinu Tam פירוש: הכוונה, המשתמש בשם המפורש. A person who uses Hashem HaMeforash—what's Shem HaMeforash? Knowing what Hashem's name7:05and how to combine it together,7:06you could do major, major things7:08if you use it.7:10Yeah, there's such a power in the world,7:11and if you do it—and it comes from kedushah—but if you do it7:13and you're not the right person,7:15whoa, Hashem7:16yerachem. In the way Rav Yaakov Edel—I read it from him,7:19and he got it from somewhere,7:20I don't remember where he got it7:21from—but he says something very nice,7:25right? If, you know, if the rabbi of the shul that you're praying at7:28asks you to do something,7:29what do you say?7:30You feel okay. You feel honored and privileged sometimes7:32to go and do something for him,7:35right?7:36He asks you, Go get me something,7:37you feel. Sometimes a little7:39bit, you know what? Not honor and7:41privilege, but okay, listen, it's for the rabbi,7:43I'll do it, right?7:45Now, all of a sudden the rabbi's son comes in,7:4813 years old, or teenage,7:4916 years old, little punk, right?7:51Says, Hey. Can you go to the store and get me something?7:56All right. Maybe out of respect to the rabbi,7:58but, like, you're not so happy.8:00If you do it because you're a very nice person and you want to give a little bit kavod, you're really not the happiest,8:05right? And so, same thing. Imagine a big tzaddik comes to malach,8:11Yaakov Avinu vayishlach Yaakov malachim, el Esav achiv leSe'ir, right?8:15Malachim, want you to go and put Esav in his place.8:18Yaakov Avinu, it's a zechut and privilege,8:21a kadosh Hashem, that his panav chakukim al penei ha... right, his face is on the kisei8:28hakavod. Pleasure. Comes a little guy who speaks lashon hara.8:33It's not makpid on what he looks at.8:36He, you know, I could go on and on, right?8:38His Torah is hekeh, good?8:40And he comes and he tells malachim, go do things for me.8:43Now the malachim, they're bound8:45because Hashem put it that if somebody calls the malach's real name8:48and he tells them, he's mashbia them, they have to listen.8:51Are they going to be happy?8:52They're not going to be happy. And if they're not going to be happy,8:54trust me, they're going to get you back.8:56They're going to get that person back.8:57And that's why it's an amazing thing.8:59People who are doing kabbalah ma'asit, they have problems.9:02Not only that, they have other problems in their life.9:05Why? Because you're not supposed to do it that way.9:08So he quotes that. Then he quotes the Rama.9:11Hamishtamesh b'shemot hakodesh is what the Mishnah in Pirkei Avot says,9:16b'tagesh b'tagah alav. Listen to Rav Chaim Vital writes,9:18the student of the Arizal, the great student of the Arizal from9:20Shem, he writes,9:26Hamishtamesh b'shemot hakodesh amurazal, b'tagesh b'tagah alav, v'ne'ekar min ha'olam. He's uprooted from the world.9:27V'yishtamed hu9:29u'vanav. Eventually he'll go off the9:32derech, he'll become a goy, or his children,9:35or yamut hu9:36u'vanav, or he will die, or his children will die,9:38or ya'ani hu9:39u'vanav, or he'll become poor, or his children.9:41Chaim Vital, amazing.9:43This is a rabbi that knew everything of Kabbalah,9:46and he saw his rabbi doing it.9:51A person who does Kabbalah9:54ma'asit... It has to be that he gets stuck to the evil,9:59v'hashemetah et nafsho, and he thinks, no, he's really purifying himself.10:03Be'emet umtanefah, he dirties his neshama.10:07Melabesh umetamei nafsho, yanesh b'Gehinnam. Besides that you contaminate your soul in this world,10:10you also get punished in10:19Gehinnam. And even in this world, says the Rabbeinu Chaim Vital,10:21we have a tradition,10:22a person10:23is also, b'kavan ma'asit, either becomes poor or he gets sick,10:26or, lo aleinu, him or his children become goyim.10:36And even in this world, says the Rabbeinu Chaim Vital, we have a10:38tradition, a person is also, b'kavan ma'asit, either becomes poor or he gets sick, or, lo aleinu, him or his children become goyim. In Sefer Chasidim, siman ..., v'katav b'Shulchan Aruch, v'al yedei Sefer Yetzirah mutar la'asot ma'aseh. The Shulchan Aruch writes, you know,10:40that it's asur to do magic,10:43but on Sefer Yetzirah you are allowed to do ma'aseh. The Shach writes on it,10:47shekatav, Sefer Yetzirah hem10:48shemot hakodesh, Hashem yitbarach natan them koach sheyuchlu lif'ol al10:51yedeihem chasidim v'nevi'im. In Sefer Yetzirah, it's all about how to combine Hashem's name,10:54and Hashem gave the ability through10:56Sefer Yetzirah to be able to do things,10:59but that's only to the11:02chasidim and nevi'im, v'po'el bahem ma'arei gedulato u'gevurato shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu. A person who knows how to use it11:04will show to the world11:06it's b'kedushat Hashem,11:07the power of Hashem.11:10Ach sheyit'asku bahem b'kedushah. However, it can only be done,11:11a person is doing it11:13b'kedushah, v'tzarich kedushat Hashem uletzorech mitzvah11:14haba'ah, only to be mekadesh Shem11:16Shamayim or for a big mitzvah,11:17like the way the Maharal did11:18to save the Jewish community11:19from a blood libel,11:21so he created a golem.11:22The Gra could have created a golem;11:23he was a11:24kadosh. But no, for what?11:25To show that you know how to do it?11:27To show off?11:28To flex your muscles?11:29Asher ze lo11:32... ba'amotenu harabim. He says,11:33the11:33levush, who was in the 1600s,11:35says,11:36we don't find anybody in our generation11:38that can do this.11:41And even in their days,11:42the Gemara says,11:43Yeshaya Hanavi was punished for this.11:45Listen to this crazy story.11:46What would you say11:47about this story?11:49Yeshayahu had a grandson11:50who was a king.11:51His name was11:52Menashe. He was the son of Chizkiyahu Melech.11:56Yeshayahu's mother—I mean, Yeshayahu's daughter—was Menashe Melech's mother.11:59Menashe Melech12:00got very upset12:00at Yeshayahu because Yeshayahu kept on telling him12:02in the name of12:03Hashem bad things are going to12:04happen because he's such a rasha.12:05Besides, he's going to12:06get rid of the problem;12:07besides, to kill his grandfather.12:09So he set a hit list.12:10He said,12:10Most wanted:12:11Yeshayahu, and I'm going to kill him.12:12He sent12:13executioners to go kill12:15Yeshayahu. Yeshayahu ran away.12:16They chased him into the woods.12:17Yeshayahu was in the woods.12:18The Gemara says,12:19in order to save himself,12:20what did he do?12:21He turned himself into a tree.12:24He turned himself into a12:25tree. Nice way; he won't find him.12:27Now, to turn himself into a12:27tree is not, you know, it's not Harry Potter,12:30right?12:30So what are you doing?12:31You're doing kabbalah12:32ma'asit. Yeshayahu was a holy man or not?12:35A navi. We read his haftarah almost every day.12:36Every week we read12:37from the haftarah of12:39Yeshayahu, right?12:39The Gemara says,12:40they said,12:41You know what? Maybe he's hiding behind this tree.12:43They chopped the12:44tree, and guess what tree12:44they happened to chop?12:46Him.12:47And where?12:47Right by his mouth.12:49That's what the Gemara says.12:51Why?12:52Because the Gemara says12:53because he used Shem HaKodesh.12:56What are you12:56saving his life?12:58He killed12:59so many people.13:00But he did it for his own personal benefit.13:03Is that crazy?13:04That's13:05Yeshaya Hanavi. Now,13:05people feel that they are better13:06than13:07Yeshaya Hanavi. Okay,13:07that's13:08there. I just want you to know,13:09right?13:10When you do13:11Kabbalat Matzi, just know where you are.13:15This is the13:16musar writing in13:171600s. You can't even be13:19noheg taharah v'kedushah, chabibi, in our days,13:19unless you live in a deep,13:21deep cave13:22under the ground.13:23There's not even a13:25shaft of kedushah v'taharah. Just walk in the street,13:27the taharah and kedushah is all gone.13:29And of course,13:29the main thing is the kavanah13:33and ... And the Shach writes on the words13:34of the13:35levush, his words are correct.13:59Therefore,13:59if you know about it,14:00even if you know how to use it,14:02if you don't use it,14:03you're14:04mevorach, you're blessed,14:05avoid it completely.14:06So14:06this is just other sources14:08supporting the14:08Gra. We didn't even see14:09the source from the14:10Gra, but we're not going to see14:10the source from the14:11Gra. I think we hit the point very well.14:13Anybody who wants to see14:13the source from the14:14Gra, it's in14:15his peirush on14:18Tikunei Zohar, daf kuf yud gimmel amud aleph.