Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 25Sefer Even ShelemaPart 145Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:18Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04Perek chet, אבן שלמה, perek chet, אות כב. So we mentioned this yesterday because we spoke about sodot haTorah, and we said that every single thing that you say,0:12any chiddush that you say has to also fit with the sodot, the secrets, the Kabbalah of the Torah.0:17And then I mentioned on the side, on what I said as a personal note was, which we gave0:23a mashal to a person, you know, buying the expensive cufflinks without the shirt, and now the Gra is actually going to go into it.0:29He says like this:0:36מקודם צריך ללמוד הלכות ולקיים אותם, שהם כלחם לבב אנוש יסעד. First, a person has to learn halachot, and he has to keep the halachot, which are considered like bread.0:43And the pasuk tells us in Berechin nafshi,0:48ולחם לבב אנוש יסעד. Bread satiates you, right?0:52If you eat salad and you eat chips and you eat chocolates, it feels good, but you don't feel full.1:01Bread, you feel full. Carbs, what they call it today, right?1:07And then once you did that, like we said yesterday, once you learn the Shulchan Aruch and you also keep the Shulchan Aruch,1:13then you should be1:17osek. It doesn't say over here, learn;1:19osek. You can be mamash busy with the learning of the sodot of the Kabbalah, which is considered to what?1:26To wine and oil.1:30If you turn the order around, you will not be successful,1:33כי הבית יקום, because eventually you'll lose everything.1:36Now on the bottom he brings a quote.1:40Before we get to, you know, usually we come to the side, the words of the1:43Gra. Before we get to the actual words of the Gra, on the bottom he brings two supporting sources to what the Gra says. Oh, the Ibn Shemas says,1:52he first quotes the1:54Shach. The Shach, the Siftei Kohen, is the commentary on the Shulchan Aruch in Yoreh De'ah and in Choshen Mishpat as well,2:04and the Shach is unbelievable.2:07The Shach is the main commentary on Yoreh De'ah, in fact,2:10and, yeah, I don't even have to give more introductions.2:13This is one of the main, main, main commentaries on Shulchan Aruch.2:15He writes like this:2:16In the halchot of Talmud Torah, he writes,2:22Gam haMekubalim v'shaar haAchronim hifligu b'davar shelo lilmod Chochmat haKabbalah ad2:24achar sheyemalei kreso meShas. Even the Mekubalim, and of course the other Acharonim, the great2:28Talmidei Chachamim, they spoke at length that a person should not learn Kabbalah until he filled his stomach2:34with—and they always call it filling2:36your stomach—you're not considered full until you first learn Shas. You have to know the2:39Gemara, you have to know the yesodot of the Torah.2:44And some wanted to say you shouldn't learn Kabbalah until you're forty years old,2:48like it says2:49in the Pirkei Avot, Ben2:53arba'im laBinah. U'mibalad lo tzarich kedushah v'taharah. Besides that, learn Kabbalah is not something that anybody can just pick up.2:56Not you just go to the Kabbalah center, you sit with Madonna, and you learn Kabbalah,3:00right? Kabbalah, you need kedushah, holiness, taharah, purity, zerizut.3:05You need to be a person who's quick to do things, nekiyut, and cleanliness.3:09And you want to know what these things mean?3:11There's a book called3:13Mesilat Yesharim. Go learn what those things mean.3:14That's what you need for this.3:20Wow.3:21He says, the majority of the people who try to jump levels and to learn the wisdom of Kabbalah3:27before their right time, they got cut off before their time.3:31What does that mean?3:32It means that they ended up messing themselves up tremendously,3:41as all the Mekubalim bring down.3:43Now, also look in the Chayei Adam,3:45another posek, one of the Acharonim who actually lived in the same time as3:49the Gaon miVilna. He writes in his book Chayei Adam, which is a book3:53on—it's a regular halacha book.3:55Mishnah Berurah quotes it all the time.3:57It's a very, very prominent, important Acharon book in halacha.4:01He says,4:07ואין לאדם ללמוד חכמת קבלה אלא עד שמלא כרסו בגמרא ופוסקים, ויהיה ירא שמים גדול ויושב תמיד. A person should not learn the wisdom of Kabbalah until he fills his stomach with Gemara and poskim,4:13and he has to be a real fearful, God-fearing person,4:17and he's sitting there learning Torah all the time.4:25אבל בלא זה אסור. Without this, it's assur. ועוד החמיר בזה רב חיים ויטל. And Rav Chaim Vital, who is the greatest student—this student of the4:29Arizal—was very machmir about this point also.4:31But again, like we said, the mashal yesterday I think is very, very good,4:35right? A guy goes shopping for Pesach for his kids.4:38His wife says, Kids need, you know, new clothing for Pesach.4:40He goes and he spends five thousand dollars on each kid,4:43and he buys them what?4:45Tight clips for thirty-five hundred dollars with diamonds and platinum,4:48and he buys also cufflinks for4:51fifteen hundred dollars. But his kids are walking around with ripped shirts,4:54their suits are all dirty and wrinkled and ripped.4:57They can't even, you know, nothing.4:59You know, ripped socks.5:00Everything is ripped.5:01He doesn't even have basic clothing.5:03What do you say about such a thing?5:05Now, if you have a nice, decent suit, nobody will notice the suit.5:09They usually notice the fancy cufflinks, right?5:11So the cufflinks are noticed much more,5:13and so too Kabbalah people notice much more.5:15But if you have ripped shirts, that means you don't even have halacha,5:18you don't even know basic halachot.5:20Yeah, that's pretty off.5:21That's pretty horrible, right?5:23Especially when you think, you know,5:26it's—whatever, I'm not going to go to it.5:27We went to it yesterday.5:29Now, he brings also from here, from Raya Mehemna, from the Zohar,5:37וכל המתקרב יותר מדרגתו הוא נשרף בהארת דינור. Anybody who tries to go beyond his limitation, then, לא עלינו, it can burn him,5:44it can hurt him.5:45We find even Gedolei Torah, like Chazal tell us about Acher, right?5:51He was Elisha ben Avuyah, who was considered one of the greatest, greatest, greatest5:56Tannaim. He and three other rabbis were able to enter a level of Chochmah that nobody was able to6:02enter, and he got affected from it.6:04He ended up going off the derech from it.6:07So we have to be very, very careful with it.6:10Where does the Gra say now, in his own commentary, about being very careful and not to jump steps?6:15Let's look at the first commentary from6:22Mishlei. There's a lot over here.6:24We'll see, b'ezrat Hashem, we'll see what we can do.6:26Pasuk says in6:30Mishlei, perek chaf aleph, pasuk yud-zayin, אוהב יין ושמן לא יעשיר. A person who loves wine and oil will not become wealthy.6:35Okay, simple meaning,6:36Shlomo HaMelech is telling us, a guy who's always running after luxuries, you're going to end up wasting all your money on luxuries,6:41right? Always going on vacation, always going out drinking with the boys, and going6:46in shemen. Shemen was considered like a, you know, instead of, like, washing with water, you do with shemen, right?6:51You're always running after these fancy things.6:52Yeah, people who love luxurious life, they end up wasting all their money on those things.6:57He says, והיינו, comes over here and he writes,7:01שהלחם הוא הלכות. The lechem is the halachot.7:05והיין ושמן הם אגדות שמרמז בסודות, and the yayin v'shemen is meramez to the aggadot in the Torah, which is the remez and the secrets of the Torah.7:15והרוצה להלך בגדולות ובתועפות, אינו רואה לקיים הדינים וללמוד אותם ולא יעשיר. And a person who wants to go on a high level...7:18Without first keeping the dinim and learning the halachot,7:24he's not going to be wealthy.7:26Who's wealthy? A person who's happy with what he has.7:31He doesn't try to go above his level until he first learns the basics,7:35learns Shulchan Aruch, and he keeps the halachot.7:38Putah zahav tells us is like bread, it satiates you.7:44You cannot truly understand the secrets of Torah until you know the pshat, until you know the halachot.7:52And that's why when it says lo ya'ashir means he won't have anything.7:54That's one area of the7:56Gra. I want to read to you now from the Gra over here.8:00This commentary to Yeshayahu, perek hei, pasuk yud. He says, There's a famous pasuk that says, Go, eat my bread and drink my wine.8:12He says that these represent two parts of the Torah. There's the part that's compared to bread, and there's the part that's compared to wine.8:20Haagadot nikra yayin. The agadot are compared to wine, shekol hasodot genuzim baagadot, because why? All the secrets of the Torah are really hidden in those stories that we find in Gemara.8:31It seems like a simple story. It seems like a simple derashah, interesting derashah sometimes,8:36but he's telling you all the secrets are there in those derashot.8:38Veyayin, we know yayin is the gematria of sod, seventy, right?8:48And this now you can understand the secret that Chazal said. It seems like they're talking about something simple on a physical, biological level.8:58It says, Up to forty years, food is good for you. Afterwards, drinking is good for you.9:02What does that mean? It says forty years is talking about up to forty years, eating, learning Chazal, learning the Sukkan Aruch, understanding it is good for you.9:13After forty years, then drinking, which is the wine, which is the Talmud, which is the learning of the Kabbalah, that's good for you.9:21And now you can understand the Gemara in Masechet Bava Kamma. What does it say?9:30Right? You're the one who's telling us to say9:34halachah. He says, A guy who had two wives, one older and one younger.9:44That's what the Gemara means to say. Why is it comparing halachot and aggadot to a guy who has two wives?9:51It says that's the idea.9:57For the younger wife is for a person under forty. That's referring to the learning of10:03halachot. Above forty, that's the older wife. That's referring to the learning of the Kabbalah.10:13Okay. Let me see. One more place, and that is the Gra's commentary on Shulchan Aruch.10:19On Shulchan Aruch, in the Hilchot of Talmud Torah, the Rama writes that a person should not learn Kabbalah until10:26forty. This is a famous Rama. Even though Kaf HaChaim says even younger, the age is not limiting you.10:32Kaf HaChaim brings down from other mekubalim you can learn younger, and there's no question. He says like twenty-four or something.10:36But everybody does agree that you have to have the foundations first.10:40The foundations is the Shas or Gemarot or10:43Halachot. You have to know what you're talking about first before you jump into Kabbalah, before you jump levels.10:47So he says, the10:54Gra: A person should not start hanging in the garden until he's full.10:58What's called being full? And that is to know11:04the issur v'heter, know what's mutar, what's asur, ... mitzvot, kemo shekatav haRambam, all the other ... like the Rambam writes.11:13And like he says at the end, right, you don't give the secrets of Torah except for specific people,11:18and that's what we mean to say over here.11:19But again, being that the Kabbalah is very interesting, sounds very cool,11:24right? Even like gematriot and all these things, the remazim sound a lot of... they definitely sound more interesting than the regular simple11:31halachot, so people jump on them.11:32It's like the cufflinks.11:34It's very fancy, but people don't realize that they're wearing the cufflinks with ripped shirts,11:40right? When a guy who comes, the guy who comes, the guy who comes, and he does, you know, like a guy who comes and he brings a11:47fancy, you know, he comes and he tells you all these crazy chiddushim, Kabbalah,11:50and he gives you a whole shiur Kabbalah,11:51everybody's like, Whoa, the head is spinning from Kabbalah,11:54and then he tells them, Chabod, let's go eat bread.11:56He takes, he does Birkat Netilat Yadayim. On eating less than12:04a12:06kezayit, ... biracha levatalah. It doesn't know ... from melachot Shabbat,12:09it's ma'aseh, right? So that's, we gotta be, we have to know.12:12Again, ... is great, but it's the next level.12:14You shouldn't be jumping levels.