Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 21Sefer Even ShelemaPart 141Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:22Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:21Even shelema perek chet, ot yud chet. Kesheha yetzer hara mesit et ha'adam lilmod l'shem hana'ah o rabbanut, ve'eino yachol la'amod kenegdo. When the yetzer hara tries to get the person to learn shelo l'shem Shamayim, for example, for his personal benefits, or to become a rabbi, or to get a leadership position. Sometimes today you don't even have to be a rabbi. Today, Baruch Hashem, a lot of people are learning, and0:30you can just go start, pick up, make a whole following, and not necessarily against it. I'm just telling you that sometimes people, you know, can do it for the wrong intention.0:33Let's learn so I can be, you know, I can have a following.0:37Then the yetzer is getting you, is just pushing you. That's the only reason he can get you to learn.0:41What do you do at that time? What do you do? Do you still learn the Gemara? Do you still learn the halacha?0:45But you know you're only doing it for the wrong reason.0:48So in that moment, you know what you do?0:53Better to learn at that time0:56with sifrei mussar. Better not to learn real Torah, but to learn words of inspiration.1:00Now we always are accustomed in learning to understanding that if you learn mussar, that's Torah.1:06That's a very light version of Torah when you bring1:09pirsum. You think to understand the Torah. That's like more of a1:12hechsher for Torah. The real learning of Torah is learning of the halachot,1:16learning what to do, learning Gemara, learning, you know, learning the actual text itself,1:22Nevi'im. That's real Torah.1:23The other divrei mussar, words of inspiration,1:27and, you know, the stories that inspire us, all good,1:30but they're considered mussar, learning mussar. It's a lower level.1:33So he says better to learn at that time1:37sifrei mussar until the yetzer hara goes away from you, and then you can learn1:39b'maslot Shamayim. That's unbelievable.1:41The guy is telling you to lower your standards of learning.1:46Because you're going to end up learning1:48lishma and then to learn1:50that shelo lishma. It's unbelievable,1:58right? וכן הרב שאינו ראוי ואינו לומד אלא למלאות פניאתו בשביל ממון או לדבר אחר, אין ללמוד ממנו. Now, up to now, we've been speaking about what?2:01It's being a person who's learning for the right reasons.2:04Now, what if you know that your rabbi is teaching for the wrong reasons,2:09right? Your rabbi is only learning2:12למלאות פניאתו בשביל ממון. He's doing it for his own personal reasons,2:15to make money or for other things.2:18אין ללמוד ממנו. Don't learn from such a person.2:22כי אפסי על ידו, אף מה שלמד קודם, you're going to lose even what you learned already.2:24It's an unbelievable statement,2:25and that's very scary because we don't really know.2:28How can we really know the real intention of a person,2:31right? We don't know.2:32I don't even know what my intention is.2:34And how do we know that person who's teaching2:36is not doing it just because of kavod,2:38just doing it because he wants to become a great person,2:40he wants to become, you know,2:42he wants to have power?2:44How do we know?2:45So therefore he says, better not to learn from him,2:48כי אפסי על ידו, אף מה שלמד קודם, you'll lose even what you've previously learned.2:56וכן להיפך, אם התלמיד הוא רשע, אז יכול לשבש את הרב אף על פי שלומד לשמה. It's an unbelievable thing,2:58and you've got to be careful from all sides.2:59The Gra is saying,3:01even if you're learning3:02l'shem shamayim, even if you're teaching, you're a rabbi3:03and you're teaching3:04l'shem shamayim, if you have a student that is a rasha3:07and has bad intentions,3:09he could mess up the rabbi to get to learn3:13shelo lishma. Wow, these are really three powerful things3:17the Gra says,3:18major3:18chiddushim. I would not think this is,3:21you know, if you ask me3:23regular, my opinion,3:24I would not think to say this.3:25And Baruch Hashem, we have the Gra that can enlighten us3:27and can help us understand.3:28So let's see all those three ideas.3:30He brings it over here3:32from... Three different places over here3:35from3:36Mishlei. Let's see what the Gra himself writes3:38and what he writes,3:39his actual words.3:40The first one comes from3:43perek chav-gimel, pesukim aleph until gimel.3:48There are three pesukim over here that we're going to read, and then let's see what the Gra explains.3:50He says,3:52Ki teshev l'lechom et Moshel. When you come to,3:52when you sit down to battle with a ruler,3:57bin tavin et asher lefanecha. Understand what's in front of you.4:01Vesamta sakin bilo'echa im baal nefesh atah. Put a,4:02swallow a knife4:03if you're a person who cares about his soul.4:07Al tit'av l'mat'amotav. Don't sit4:09there—excuse me, excuse me, excuse me,4:10did I say the word battle?4:11I made a mistake.4:13Ki teshev l'lechom et Moshel, sorry. When you sit to eat together,4:15lechem, when you're coming to have a seudah, a meal together4:18with a ruler,4:18try to understand what's in front of you.4:22Vesamta sakin bilo'echa im baal nefesh atah. If you really care about your soul,4:23put a knife down your throat.4:26Al tit'av l'mat'amotav. Don't desire his pleasurable foods.4:31Vu lechem kesamim, it's foods of falsehood,4:34right? So the simple meaning of the4:37pasuk is, Shlomo HaMelech is telling you,4:38we4:39all—imagine I'll tell you right now,4:40you're invited,4:41I can get you dinner with the president,4:44and don't worry,4:48it's going to be kosher because his daughter is also going to come. You have dinner with the president4:50and his4:51son-in-law and his daughter.4:52Everybody,4:53wow, Trump, we all like him,4:54he's a good guy,4:55right? It's unbelievable.4:56And especially if you go,4:58right, we all, you know, we all have that dream of, like, being famous,5:02and not just famous,5:03but knowing big people,5:05being friendly with big, big people,5:07especially moshlim,5:08such a powerful man in the world,5:10right? Just to eat with him, it's an unbelievable pleasure. People, in fact, pay millions of dollars for that honor to sit and meet with him or to eat with him.5:19So Shlomo HaMelech is telling you,5:21don't desire what he has.5:23If you care about your soul,5:25don't eat anything from his.5:26That's a simple meaning of the5:29pasuk. Comes the Gra, and of course5:30the Gra is always showing us5:31the deeper meaning as well5:33of what Shlomo HaMelech says. He says,5:38When you come to learn5:39with your yetzer hara,5:40who's the moshel, who's the ruler?5:41Yetzer hara. Why?5:42Because, you know, yetzer hara, when he gets you,5:44he's ruling over you,5:48right? So, what's it called? So what does it say?5:50He's sitting in,5:54V'samta sakin b'lo'echa. Put a knife down your throat.5:57What does it mean?6:00If you can't battle him,6:02you can't get rid of him,6:03he's sitting down to learn with you,6:05which means he's getting you to6:06learn for his reasons,6:08for reasons6:11shelo lishmah, then,6:16Tiyaser atzmecha v'temtin ad sheyelech mimcha v'asmad. Work on yourself. Meyaser yourself,6:19which means6:20put yourself, give yourself musar6:22until he goes away,6:23and then you can start learning.6:25And look what it says over here in brackets.6:29V'al tita chashvah shelo lilmod b'oto zman. But don't make the mistake of6:30saying, Okay, I'm not going to learn.6:31I'm waiting for him to go away.6:32I'm not going to.6:37No. Ela tiyaser atzmecha b'sifrei musar sheyelech mimcha v'asmad, right?6:38Give yourself musar. How?6:39By learning musar.6:41Open up sifrei musar and then learn.6:48And don't be confused6:50by the yetzer hara telling you,6:52What's the big deal?6:52You learn Torah anyway.6:53What's the difference6:54why you're learning?6:55You're learning Torah.7:06And7:07don't be confused by the yetzer hara telling you,7:08What are you talking about?7:09You're going to learn with7:10brand. You're going to learn with fire.7:11You're going to learn with such excitement.7:12You're going to enjoy your learning.7:17But you're going to say,7:18Oh, you know, what's the big deal?7:19Baruch Hashem, at least I get an hour of excited learning,7:22right? Don't make that mistake.7:25Al teta'av. That's what the pasuk is saying. Don't desire his pleasures,7:29right?7:29Don't desire his pleasures.7:30It's lechem kezabim.7:32No, better to learn Musar at that time,7:34get rid of him,7:35and learn because you want to7:36know the right thing to do.7:37I want to understand what the right thing to do is.7:45V'chen haRamban says also, the rabbi, Al talcham et lechem ra ayin. Here's another pasuk.7:46Pasuk says in the same perek later on,7:48don't eat bread with a person who's ra ayin,7:52who doesn't mean he has ayin hara,7:53but we'll see what his eye is evil.7:57Pitcha achalta tikiena. If you ate bread from him,7:59you're going to throw...8:02And not only that, you're going to ruin your pleasant ways.8:06As we all know, right, imagine, you know, take a lady, this applies to her more.8:11When you throw up, right, that force of throwing up sometimes could pop blood vessels in your face8:17and makes you, you know, it goes away after like a day, but it makes you look all red like you have a rash.8:22So a lady is getting ready for a wedding and she eats, all of a sudden she throws up,8:26and all of a sudden, I don't know if makeup could cover or not, but she looks pale, she looks sick,8:32and she doesn't look good, right?8:34So not only did you not gain, but you lost what you had already.8:38So that's what happens when you're dealing with the8:41yetzer hara. Not only do you not gain what you took from him, but you lose what you had already.8:47The Gra is telling you, don't learn by a person whose eyeing is8:51bad. He only wants to teach because of personal interest, mishum mamon or because he wants money.8:56He only teaches you because if you pay me, I'll do it.8:59I don't want you to know; I want you just to make money.9:02Or he has other things for9:07kavod, because you'll end up throwing up, and when you throw up, everything comes out, even what you learned till now.9:14Even what you learn from him, unfortunately, because it's done9:18shelo lishmah, like we said, with bad intentions, it will end up messing you up as well.9:23And not only that, he says even by a student, he says over here,9:30right, If a rasha speaks in front of a king, the pasuk says,9:37'Vayakon ba-tzedek kiso.' He'll set up in righteousness his chair.9:44What does that mean? If a person is learning Torah, or to keep the mitzvot, in order to be careful9:50from aveirot, then beautiful, you'll be set up, you'll be okay, you'll be taken care of.9:57But if the student that's sitting in front of you, you're teaching someone, he's a rasha,10:01hu yachol le-shabesh oto, he can mess him up,10:05k'inyan al yeshev talmid boren lefanav, like it says in the Gemara, a student who's empty should not sit in front of him,10:14right? The Gemara, that speaks about that. Okay, so he says over here,10:23V'lachen hagor asham lifnei melech, totzi et harasha shelo yeh... etzom mena yevekon b'tzedek mishpat. Hagor here is explaining, kick out the rasha from the king, and everything will be set up properly.10:28And here's one final pasuk:10:35Otzar nechmad v'shemen ben vechacham, u'ksil adam yevla'enu. A pleasurable storehouse,10:39and oil, a beautiful oil with a chacham, but a foolish person will swallow it.10:44Chazal say otzar refers to Torah, nechmad refers to nevi'im, and shemen refers to10:50ketuvim. So you got the otzar, nechmad, and shemen representing10:54Tanach. He says all these are ben vechacham, are in the house of a10:58chacham, but a foolish man will swallow it.11:02But if you learn with a student, or you teach a student who is not proper,11:06who's got twisted reasons why he's going to learn,11:08it can mess you up. It can ruin your ways.11:11So we got to be careful of learning11:14lishma, learning for people who learn11:15lishma, and even when we engage with others in Torah,11:18only people that want to know the right thing to do. Baruch Adonai, amen v'amen.