Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 2Sefer Even ShelemaPart 122Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:31Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Perek Chet, Ot Bet in Even Shelema.0:04This is a very, very important piece,0:08and the piece I'm telling you right now is going to talk about Kabbalah.0:11It's talking about the importance of Kabbalah,0:13right?0:13But we're going to see about that.0:14We're going to talk about that,0:16be'ezrat Hashem. Now, just to give you an idea,0:18look how, when you look at the notes that they're bringing on the side,0:23they bring a bunch of notes.0:24They bring from a few different places about the subject.0:27So it seems like the Gra spoke about this in a few places,0:30and it seems to be an important thing that he spoke about it in a few different places,0:34right?0:34If he mentions it here and there again.0:36Now, I would like to go through all the sources because it's a very, very important thing,0:39especially recently people have spoken about this a lot,0:43and I'll clarify also what's good and what's not good.0:47Let's read first the words of the Even Shelema,0:49and then we'll see the words of the Gra later on from its source.0:56First has to fill his stomach.0:58A guy, he's eating, right?0:59How do you eat?1:01So talk about in Torah now, how do you learn?1:04What are you supposed to learn first?1:06So he says first you fill your stomach with1:10what? With Mikra, pesukim,1:12which means not just reading pesukim,1:14but learning1:16Tanach, and then Mishnayot.1:17Ve'af al pi she'eino yodea lefaresh haMishnah, and even though if you don't really understand the full explanation of1:25the Mishnah, yilmad kulo, don't worry, learn it.1:27Even, that's why in a lot of yeshivot they make kids memorize and know.1:31Now we saw yesterday, if it comes to memorizing and knowing the1:34concepts, knowing the concepts is better.1:35But when kids memorize the Mishnayot,1:37and a lot of them may not really know the concept, that's fine,1:40because Mishnayot is the source of everything.1:42So when you come to learning Gemara,1:44which you can't memorize Gemara,1:46it's purely logic, right?1:48It's you opening your mind,1:50the Mishnayot will be at hand.1:51You say, yeah, yeah, I remember1:52the Mishnah. Oh, that's what it1:53means. Ah, how does it fit? And then you'll have to work it out.1:56So even Mishnayot,1:58this is not about just kids,1:59but in the yeshivot that's what they do, I'm telling you,2:01is that even Mishnayot, even if the guy doesn't know how to explain the whole Mishnayot,2:05it doesn't make a difference.2:06Learn all the Mishnayot.2:07Don't worry, cover it.2:09U'Gemara. And then you do Gemara, Babli,2:13VeYerushalmi, and Yerushalmi,2:15Tosefta.2:16Tosefta is what we call2:18beraitot, the words of our... and every masechet in the back,2:20every masechet has in the back a section called Tosefta,2:23which is all the collection of all the2:25beraitot. Many of them do appear in the actual Gemara,2:28but there's Tosefta.2:30Mechilta.2:31Mechilta is the pirush of, I believe, Rabbi Yishmael on Sefer Shemot,2:35which is again another form of Mishnayot,2:37but it's considered2:40beraitot. Sifra veSifri are also sefarim written by Tannaim,2:44which are like2:46beraitot, mechol ha-beraitot and all the other2:48beraitot, which basically whatever is in the back of the Shas set that we have,2:53not an Artscroll one, whatever in the back of the Shas set that we have,2:56that is you're supposed to learn that first.2:59Good? You're done with that,3:01then you come back and you continue in the3:04Gemara. Ve'achar kach la'asok b'pirpul chaverim. Once you do that, then you can start now discussing it.3:09Pirpul chaverim, we're going to see what that means soon,3:11but it means analyzing, going over to, you know, somebody else,3:14what does that mean, going back and forth.3:16Vezehu hadrasa Torah, and that's the beauty of Torah,3:18because once you're full of knowledge3:20and you can ask and you can, you know, discuss something,3:22then you can, you know, sharpen it even more.3:25It's kind of like, I know in3:27Kolel, if you're going to ask a rabbi a question,3:29our rosh kollel, you better be prepared.3:32You better know what you're talking about.3:34If you ask a question that you could just look up,3:36he's going to turn the whole world3:38again. What? Go read it.3:40It's like somebody comes and asks you,3:42Rabbi, why do you have to3:44wear tzitzit? What? I have to teach it to you?3:46You're learning kolel, right?3:47You don't ask such a question.3:49If you're a guy who's a baal teshuva and you don't know,3:52okay, fine, we'll give you, we'll teach you, we'll explain to you.3:54But you don't ask simple questions.3:56Same thing when we come to discuss a halacha with3:58a rabbi, you have to be ready. You have to be ready4:02to, especially if you're coming to introduce a subject,4:03you have to be very well prepared,4:05and that's pilpul4:07chaverim. You're already prepared,4:08and now you see the other person's opinion,4:10especially if I know that the other person doesn't hold like that.4:12I know my sources, and I come and I ask.4:21But if you change the order of learning,4:23and what does that mean, you change the order of learning?4:25That means you don't first cover,4:28you don't first learn the basics,4:30which he's calling the basics,4:33all, right, all basically Shas, right?4:36And then you start coming in,4:39mefalpel. And what if—by the way, I'm going to explain what pilpul is.4:42Pilpul is also, there was in the times,4:45in the 1500s, it became very, very popular.4:47I'm not going to say any names right now.4:48Big geonim, big4:51talmidei chachamim, they started instituting pilpulim,4:53and a lot of more famous, to us,4:57geonim wrote against it tremendously,5:00like the Maharal wrote against it and everything else.5:02What was pilpulim?5:03Pilpulim is basically developing ideas that are not there.5:08What if? This sharpens the mind like tremendously,5:10because you're taking the level, the learning, to the next level, right?5:15There's a guy called Bloom.5:18You never heard of him.5:19If you know anything about psychology, you have to know about Bloom.5:22Bloom made a taxonomy, which means he made six levels of learning.5:25There's the most basic, which is remembering, right?5:29Think about it.5:30A lot of people who know Tehillim maybe by heart.5:34Don't really know5:35the halim. They remember the words,5:37but they don't really understand what they're saying.5:39So next level is understanding, right?5:42And then that's level number two.5:44Next level is applying.5:47That means, okay, now I learn. Next level, think about it.5:49If you take the learning, right?5:50Okay, I don't know anything about tzitzit.5:51Now I read, V'asu lahem tzitzit.5:54I don't know what that means really.5:56All I know is that Hashem is telling us to make tzitzit.5:58Then understanding. Oh, I understand now.6:00Oh, I got to make6:02strings. Good.6:03Now applying.6:04That's the next level.6:05If I have four corners, okay,6:07wait, that's based on what I learned already,6:10and I understand, I can take the nekudah and apply it.6:13This needs, this garment doesn't need all the conditions, right?6:15Then analyzing.6:17Good.6:17And then evaluating to see if it's proper or not,6:22and then finally creating, which is6:25that chidush, that pilpul, right?6:26So he's telling you, if a guy is making and being6:28mefalpel, which is creating chidushim, right?6:31Creating chidushim before you know the basics,6:35you're jumping steps.6:36So we don't need really this guy, blum, to come and tell us this chart, right?6:40The guy is saying it, but based on what?6:43Based on6:44Gemara. There is a6:45sevara. There's a way of how to learn.6:47So he says,6:49Ve'eino yodea Mishnah achat k'sidrah. You don't really know one Mishnah properly.6:53Yabed gam miktsat haTorah shelamad b'na'aruto. Unfortunately, you'll lose also some of the Torah that you learned in your younger days.6:58Now why do I say this is very important?7:00Unfortunately, there is the concept of pilpul, of using your mind, sharpening your mind.7:05We have to understand that it's a level,7:09it's a level, but it's got to come after the other steps.7:13If you jump a step before you7:16got—if you don't walk up those steps first,7:18and you jump to that step,7:20you're standing really in the air.7:21These steps are not there.7:23You create the steps.7:25If you don't do those steps first,7:27if you don't first cover, understand the basics,7:30you know, as the Reb Chaim Brisker—I think it7:32was—oh, the Brisker Rav, I don't know,7:34there's Reb Chaim Brisker, there's7:36a Brisker Rav, and there's7:37Reb Soloveitchik. Okay,7:38one of the Briskers said a7:40very—first, said in Yiddish,7:41I can't say it in Yiddish, but I'll tell you in English:7:43first what, then why.7:46You learn the Gemara is what is the Gemara saying?7:49We're not asking questions.7:50We want to first absorb.7:51What's the Gemara telling us?7:53Once we got what the Gemara is telling us,7:54now we go to the next level is, okay, why?7:57Why does it work this way?7:58And you can only do that.8:02Once you get to a sugya, and, you know, sometimes I tell the guys, okay, make a line over here. For sure in the beginning class, that's what I tell them. There's a line over here. We're done.8:08Now you can ask whatever you want on this sugya, right? You got the basics. You got that first step, but the next.8:14But it's really so important in learning, it has to be done. And he's telling you, if you don't do it that way, the fear of messing it up is very, very real.8:22Okay. Look at—where am I? Okay, let's see the source now in the words of the8:31Gra himself, because this is Eben Shlema. We saw one time, one time only, and chas v'shalom, this is not to discredit8:37any—this is only one time we saw that the Eben Shlema quoted something from the8:42Gra. Or basically, Eben Shlema, just the way it was written, there was no sources on the side.8:46He quoted sources like, you know, as a roshei teivot, you know, like he'd say, Look in this sefer, look in that sefer.8:52And this book, the one that we have, opened it up, went to that sefer and quoted the whole piece, right?8:57And he's very good, and he quotes usually very, very well.9:00The Eben Shlema usually quotes almost word for word from the words of the Gra, cuts and9:04pastes, but the concepts we saw, he's usually 100% on the ball.9:08One time we saw that he quoted a line, and it wasn't really what the Gra said, or at least it wasn't there.9:14They looked in the source, it wasn't there. Maybe there was a source that was missing.9:17The Eben Shlema is here, not here?9:18The top is Eben Shlema, the dark words. Yeah,9:21but these words are the words of—the Eben Shlema is the words of the author of the book, which is—9:27No, no, no, no. Rav Shmuel Malatzen, or Malvsen. Yeah.9:33Yeah. And the Gra, right, it comes from the Gra, though.9:37And the words that every time we go on the side, that's the9:40Gra. That's the Gra's actual words, and where he pulled it out from,9:43right? Sometimes we saw a little bit of a difference, or a lot of times we saw that the Gra explains it more,9:48and it's easier to understand.9:49This is like a sikum.9:50Okay, let's see now.9:54No, the ground was before.9:56So why would they have a פירוש at the bottom?9:58They should make it easier for the reader.9:59No, it is easier for the reader.10:01You weren't here. Listen to the introduction.10:06Okay. כבוש אמרו להזל. Everybody with me? The Gemara says,10:14גמלא אזיל למבעי קרני אודניה, דהוו ליה גזיזי מיניה. The camel goes to look for10:18קרני אודניה, I think קרני is the horns of his ears,10:21which were cut off from him.10:23What does that mean?10:26אני אנוקי, אמרו לגמור איניש והדא לסברא. Oh, here we go.10:27Same words of the Gemara,10:28what the Biskerov said in different words.10:30First a person has to learn,10:33and then to use the sevara to try to understand.10:45שנאמר, שתה מים מבארך, ואחר כך מבורך. The word bor and be'er, we explained many times in the past,10:48what's the difference, bor and10:51be'er? Bor is a hole in the ground that they all used to make,10:54right?10:54Why?10:55Of course, that's where you store water.10:57Where are you going to store it,10:58in Poland, spring bottles,11:00right?11:01So you dig a hole in the ground,11:02especially when it rains,11:03that's the easiest water collection that you can have,11:05and that's what you use all the time for whatever it is.11:07Sometimes they had a bor for laundry,11:09and they had a bor for shetiyah.11:11Now, for shetiyah, obviously you cover and you seal very well.11:14The one for laundry, who cares?11:15You just use it over and over again.11:17Good?11:18This is the water system that they had in those days.11:21Now, be'er is very different.11:22Be'er is what we call a well.11:24A lot of people make that mistake.11:25When you learn bor, they always say,11:26Oh, the guy dug a well.11:29Not dafka, right?11:30Yosef fell into a bor, not a11:32be'er, right?11:32That's a hole in the ground.11:33The hole could be as big as you want it to be.11:35So a be'er is the one where it has water.11:38It's already full of water,11:39and that's already the best water system.11:41You don't have to wait for rain;11:42it's natural while you're always pulling out.11:45It says, what does the pasuk say?11:46Shetei11:48mayim miborecha. First drink water from your ditch in the ground,11:51and then afterwards, mibe'erecha, from your well.11:55What happens?11:58So, we discussed this in the past.12:00I think I looked at the wrong letter yesterday,12:02is that12:03there's—we discussed this yesterday, actually,12:04and I put on the wrong piece,12:05and I said, what is this doing here?12:06Now I understand.12:07I looked at the wrong letter.12:08So he explains on the bottom12:09that there are three levels when a person learns.12:12There's a level one,12:13which is when a person learns from his rabbi.12:16Level two is when a person himself is12:19mechadesh; he learns on his own,12:20and he takes it to the next level.12:21Level three is when a person teaches,12:23right?12:23Those are three levels.12:24So he's telling you,12:27miborecha, first you learn,12:28you absorb,12:29and then you take it to the next level.12:31He says,12:32the Gra continues12:33in the words of the12:33Gra, v'na'asheh zehu12:34shekatuv, bechor shoro12:35hadar lo,12:38v'karnei re'em karnav. Now he's coming to12:39apply it back to the words.12:40He explains,12:41this is the meaning that12:42bechor shoro...12:44The bechor of the12:47shor — this is a Berachah of Yosef12:49— the bechor of his ox12:50is his beauty,12:52and the horns12:54of a re'em are his horns.12:58Ki ne'emar, v'ravtev ot b'koach shor. A guy who has a lot13:00has the power of an ox.13:01A lot of produce,13:02the power of an ox.13:04What is the remez in that pasuk13:06that Shlomo HaMelech says in13:07Mishlei? He says, like the Gemara says,13:11A person has to make himself13:13like an ox13:14to13:15carry, right,13:15to carry a yoke,13:16to carry burdens,13:18and like — actually, to carry a yoke,13:19to carry the work13:20— and like a13:22chamor, a person has to make himself13:24like a donkey13:25to carry a load.13:28Shor l'ol l'se'et. What does it13:29mean? What are these things?13:30What is the Gemara's meaning over here?13:31It means,13:32when it says13:33you have to be like an ox13:34to carry the yoke,13:35it means what you heard13:36from your rabbi.13:38V'zehu bechor shoro hadar lo, and that's the meaning in the13:40Berachah. The beauty that he has is13:44his bechor shoro.13:46Hadar hu ligmor mi-rabbo k'shor la'ol, which means to learn from your rabbi.13:48V'achar kach kaner im kanav, and then afterwards,13:49kaner im kanav, which is13:52b'masa u'matan shel pilpul, which is what13:53to give and take13:54in the discussion of the Gemara,13:56kemo shekatuv, ba'alei keranaim shemenagachim Torah, as14:00Chazal tell us, Talmidei chachamim are compared to people14:03with horns. Why?14:03Because,14:05right, when I have so much14:07that I learned from my rabbi14:07and you have so much14:08that you learned from your rabbi,14:09and then we go and we compare,14:11right,14:11it develops a lot of different things.14:14V'chen ba'alei terisin, we find also the Gemara14:16when it says,14:16wait till tomorrow,14:17the ba'alei terisin will come in.14:18What? Talmidei chachamim are called14:19people14:20with terisin, which is like shields.14:23Hakol mashal, people, all talk about14:25pilpul. V'hu hadarah v'hu zivah shelah. That's the beauty of the Torah.14:34She'memalekes otah mikra, Mishnah, Gemara, Bavli, Yerushalmi, Tosefta, Mechilta, Sifra, Sifri, v'chol ha'beraitot, v'achar kach עוסק b'shimush b'nei chachamim l'hasbir kraei b'pilpul ha'amiti. First you learn the basics.14:38When we call the basics14:39is what some people's lifetime14:41maybe they'll accomplish, right?14:42Learning all the basics14:43of the Torah,14:43and then you take it. We take it14:44to the next level,14:45which is trying to learn from14:48going to Pilpulim.14:50Wow, we went way over time.14:56And a guy who changes15:00the order of learning,15:01if he's jumping like the levels15:03that we said,15:03the six levels that we said,15:05the Gemara says,15:07Hamra azilin b'alei lekarnei. The Gemara compares him15:08to a donkey15:09that's going to look for horns.15:11Donkeys don't have horns.15:14Right?15:19So even a little bit15:20that you heard15:21will also, the hill lose,15:22and that's pretty much15:23summarizing what15:24the ... brought over here.