Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 19Sefer Even ShelemaPart 139Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:007:05Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04אמת, משנה פרק ח', אות טז. שלושה עונשים בגן עדן. There are three punishments in Gan Eden. Now, we know Gan Eden is not a place of punishment.0:11Gan Eden is a place of reward, but he's saying over here there are three punishments in0:15Gan Eden. What does that mean? We'll see.0:19מי שלומד על מנת לקבל פרס. One is for a person who learns in order for reward.0:23יש לו חופה בגן עדן. Yes, he gets his reward in Gan Eden, but we're going to see now that's the meaning of punishment,0:30that his reward is not really the best reward.0:32What does that mean? He gets a chuppah in0:34Gan Eden. He gets his own little booth,0:39beautiful chuppah, אבל הוא נכווה מחפתו של חברו שלמד לשמה. But it's not a full reward because he looks over to the other booth and he sees the booth,0:47he sees the chuppah of another person, another Jew, who's standing under that chuppah,0:53who learned Torah l'shem shamayim, and it burns him.0:56It really eats him up,0:58like the way Mesilat Yesharim says,1:01נכווה מחפתו של חברו. That's one type.1:06שני, שלומד על מנת שיקרא רבי. The person who learned because he wants to be the rabbi,1:09which means really he's learning for kavod, that people should say he knows.1:14מתבייש מעצמו. He doesn't have to look at somebody else to feel burnt,1:19right? Sometimes we accomplish things, we feel good about ourselves, and then we see somebody who's done better.1:26Sometimes it might not be an accomplishment; it's more like just buying something.1:31We're so happy we got the newest phone.1:33Wow, we feel chashuvi. We walk around, we put it on the table, right? And then all of a sudden it's like a game of cards,1:40you know? I see your phone, I raise you my phone,1:43right? You got the iPhone X, now they got puts in the iPhone XR.1:48Oh-ho. So then you, you don't feel so good about yourself1:52anymore. You see, the guy has bested you,1:54right? And sometimes you have a blackberry and you're just embarrassed for yourself.1:57You don't need to see somebody else's phone, but automatically it barely works,2:02right? So that's the second level.2:04That's another lower level of punishment2:07that means to say the guy gets again, because he did learn Torah, but he feels embarrassed when he's over there,2:12because he doesn't have to look embarrassed, because he knows, I didn't really do it for the right reason.2:16Then we have the third:2:19u'mi shelamad lekanter, yitbayesh ba'acherim sham. A person who learned to knock, then he gets embarrassed over there.2:25Actually, others embarrass him because he's the guy who learned just to knock others.2:29So look at the Gra over here on the side. He brings it from the pasuk.2:35In the pasuk in Mishlei, it's in perek2:37yud-bet, pasuk chet, it says like this:2:40Lefi sechel lo yehulal ish, based on a person's intellect, that's how he's praised.2:44V'na'aveh lev yihyeh labuz, a person who's twisted-hearted will be for embarrassment.2:47Simple meaning is that we praise people who are intellectual,2:51and people who are twisted, we put them down because they're crooked.2:55The Gra comes and explains,3:02and he says, V'chein ba'olam haba, heim shlosha anashim... And so too in Olam Haba, there are three punishments in3:07Gan Eden. One is shekolo lomed lishma, yesh lo mechitza devarim sheTorah niknet bahem. A person who learns3:09lishma. What does it mean,3:10learns lishma? Like it says in Pirkei Avot, he, with all the 48 things that it says, all the 48 conditions in the last perek of Pirkei Avot3:17that a person acquires Torah.3:20V'yesh lo eshet chayil, atet ba'ala, and he has the Torah as his wife, basically,3:26which means to say that's his crown jewel.3:29Abel kashe, eino lomed lishma. However, that's a guy who's learning lishma, but a person who's not learning3:34lishma, rak hamenat lekabel pras, he's learning because, Ooh, Gan Eden, a lot of reward.3:37I'm going to learn because it's more3:39sachar. It's good, but not the ultimate good.3:41And then3:45yesh lo chaver bGan Eden, achuz nechvim hapatot shehavro shelo lomed lishma. Yay, he has a good place, but he sees his friend, he's got a better place.3:49Why? Because he learned3:50l'shem shamayim. So,3:52it's a... Second is,3:54shelamad al menat sheyikra'uhu ravi. That's a person who learned in order that they should call him rabbi.4:00V'ha'eino meshamesh chachamim, which means he doesn't have kavod. Vayeisham me'atzmo, by himself. He doesn't need to look at anybody else.4:02You know, it's kind of like we know when somebody gives you an honor4:04and you know that you don't really deserve it, so you feel, like, guilty.4:08You know, nobody—you don't have to look at somebody else that's getting a better honor,4:10but you feel a little guilty, like, you know,4:12all you did was, like, you know, make the call.4:15You didn't raise the money or something. You know, you just called.4:17You're happy to have a good friend of yours that became a billionaire.4:20You made one phone call to him and he gave a big donation,4:22so they give you the kavod because they couldn't get the billionaire down, right?4:25So, like, you know, you didn't do really much.4:27You just called him. You're happy to see him.4:28You're just happy to meet. The guy told you,4:30I want to give to an organization.4:31You should sit over here.4:33Okay, you get the4:35kavod. You have the organization, but you don't feel like you really, really, you did it.4:39So same thing, this guy learned for being a rabbi.4:41He had his own reasons of why he wanted to learn,4:44personal interest,4:46and all of a sudden they give him kavod over there.4:47He feels embarrassed because he knows that he didn't really do it for the right reason.4:51The third person is,4:52misha lamad lekanter. He was... a person who learned to knock others4:55and make fun of,4:56and they put him down.4:57And he says that's what the Gemara means in Masechet Bava Batra.5:02HaKadosh Baruch Hu la'asot sheba chupah d'choson... Hashem's going to make seven chupot for each tzaddik.5:05What does it mean, seven5:08chupot? Here we learn that a person will burn from another person's5:13chuppah. He'll feel burned from the fact that somebody else has a better5:17chuppah. The Gemara says,5:20Oy lo, otah bushah, oy lo, otah kelimah. Woe to that time.5:22It's going to be so embarrassing for that guy.5:24Woe to him.5:25He says,5:26V'chlalah eino mevan. The guy says, I don't understand.5:30V'halo heim devarim meyutarim, v'inyan shem shel shal dinim... And you see, like, the Gemara doesn't make sense.5:33Like, why are you saying,5:35you know, nechvei chupato? It seems like extra words over here.5:37The idea is5:39that the three levels,5:40these three, I guess, judgments in5:43Gan Eden. Number one is5:43nechvei, a person who gets burned from another person.5:47Bushah me'atzmo, one who gets embarrassed on his own.5:49And the other one is5:50kelimah me'acherim. Look what it says in the5:56Gemara. It says, Oy lo, otah bushah, oy lo, otah kelimah. Right?5:57And the first rabbi says,6:00Nichveh mechavero shel chavero. And that's what the meaning over here,6:02that there's three levels:6:04a guy who sees another guy,6:07he's6:09nichveh; a guy who's embarrassed by himself;6:11and a guy who gets embarrassed.6:13And now we can connect it back to the6:15pasuk, and the Gra says,6:19V'zehu lefisichlo yehulal ish. And that's the meaning of the6:20pasuk which says6:21that based on a person's intellect,6:23he's praised. Aydei ishah maskelet. Who is this6:25ishah maskelet? Meaning to say,6:26how much6:29kavanah, how much good intention did he have6:31when he learned the Torah?6:33That's the6:34ishah maskelet over here. That's how he's going to be praised.6:38Yehulal ish yihyeh tachat lo ateret teferet. When he gets that crown6:39and he's praised for his learning Torah,6:42how good is that crown?6:44Based on how good were his intentions6:46when he learned Torah.6:48Aval na'efelev, but the end of the pasuk says,6:50the person whose heart is twisted,6:52the crooked guy,6:54Hainah lomekatet. That's a guy who learns just to knock others.6:57Yelabuz. Yeah, get together,6:58everybody's going to put him down.7:00Yitbazeh mehaacherim. He's going to be embarrassed from everybody else around him.