Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 18Sefer Even ShelemaPart 138Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:00Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:09Perek chet, אבן שלמה, ot tet-vav. מה שאמרו אל תהיו כעבדים המשמשים את הרב על מנת לקבל פרס. Mishnah, famous Mishnah in Pirkei Avot, it says, Don't be like slaves who only0:17serve their master in order to get reward.0:23אלא הוו כעבדים המשמשים את הרב שלא על מנת לקבל פרס. The Mishnah says, Be like servants that serve their master not in order to get reward.0:28That's what the Mishnah says.0:31Says the אבן שלמה, לכל התמוה. It's a little strange over here in the wording of the Mishnah.0:36דבתחילה אמר לשון אזהרה, אל תהיו, in the beginning gave us a warning:0:41do not be.0:45ואחר כך אמר לשון עצה, אלא הוו, and then it says, you should be.0:50Well, והאיך הוא כפל לשון? It's a double language, right?0:53He could have just said, אל תהיו, and that's it.0:57Don't be like this, and I'll know what to be by myself.1:01Comes the Gra, I mean comes the אבן שלמה and explains from the Gra the following.1:06וענין דשלושה מיני מעשים יש. And the idea of this is that because there's three types of actions,1:12number one, or three types of levels in people who serve Hashem.1:16Number one, הלומד בשביל פניות. A person who's learning for ulterior motives. That means he's doing it for specific reasons.1:24אקרא בכדי שיקראוני רבי. I'm going to learn so they can call me Rabbi.1:27ופני כבוד ועושר. He's doing it out of honor, out of1:30wealth. That's level one.1:31Level two—not level one, I'm saying that's one type.1:36Type two, שלומד בשביל בוראו. He's learning because of his Creator,1:41meaning שימצאך בעיניו ויתן לו שכר טוב בעולם הבא, that you should find favor in the eyes of Hashem and He should give you a good reward for1:50Olam Haba. That's type two.1:50Type three, הוא רק טוב ביראת השם, כאשר ציוונו לשמור ולעשות ולא לשום פנייה כלל. He's doing it because that's what Hashem told us to do, and we're here to serve Him,2:03we're here to do His avodah, and I need to know what to do.2:08And not for any other reason.2:10You want to give me a reward, not to give me a reward, that's not for any other reason.2:14Those are the three types of people when they're coming to serve Hashem.2:19And now we could plug it back into the words.2:23That's why in the beginning he came to give us a warning and to not be.2:29Al tihyu. Don't be like people who serve just to get reward.2:34Al pinyah rishonah, that's talking about al tihyu. Don't be like that first type, because don't do it for your own reasons,2:40for wealth and honor.2:44And the third type, which is just totally for Hashem, because I want to know what to do,2:50he says on that, Ela hevu. You should be that way.2:55To get to that level.2:56And then there are people in the middle. There are people in the middle who do it because they want to get reward,3:03which is, again, it's okay, but the ultimate is not to get to that.3:07It's to do it just because Hashem told me to do so.3:10The way Mashal I always like to use for understanding a real nice level of this, Hashem3:17Shamayim, right, is, you know, when kids, we sometimes train our kids this way also.3:22When kids are young, we want to get them to be involved to do things.3:25Why do we want them to do certain tasks for us?3:28A lot of times it's because it's easier for us.3:30For example, you're sitting down in the living room and you see your son in the kitchen.3:34You say, Do me a favor, could you get me a cup of water from the fridge?3:36I want a cup of cold cup of3:38water. Or you're eating, right,3:40and it's far. The fridge is not next to you. It's far.3:43So you tell him, Could you please get me a cup of water from the fridge?3:45It's far, right?3:46Why are you asking your son to do it?3:48So 90% because you want the cold water and you don't want to get up.3:52So your son is making it easy for you.3:5410% is because you're also training him that he should do something for you, right?3:59Meaning to say, if it was your son's, I mean, your son's friend.4:04You wouldn't tell him, Get me a cup of water from the fridge, because it's your son's friend, right?4:10So you're not going to tell him. That 10%, you're not going to tell him, right?4:13It's inconvenient for you, so you get up and you get it yourself because it's not your own son.4:16So we do have that little element that we want our son to also.4:19So when they're younger, what's going to happen is they're lazy, right?4:24So what do we tell them?4:25Okay, if you get it for me, I'll get this for you.4:29Oh, you don't want to get me the— oh, some people do it4:31backward. Oh, you don't want to get me the water,4:32and when you ask me to go drive you to a friend, okay, I don't remember, right?4:36It's the same thing, basically.4:38You do for me, I do for you, okay?4:40So now that's when they're still young.4:42We always say, We'll give you candy, we'll give you a treat, we'll give you something.4:47As they get older and older, can you imagine a person who is older? He's in his seventies. His son is in his4:55fifties. His son is already a grandfather himself, and the father is sitting in the living room.4:59He's got the cane over there,5:02and he tells his fifty-year-old son who's in the kitchen, he5:04tells him, Son, could you get me a cup of water? Not cold, please.5:08You know, seventy already,5:11seventy-five. Not cold. Can you get me a cup of water, please, from the kitchen?5:14And the son says, What will you give me for it?5:19Something's wrong here, right?5:20A fifty-year-old man to ask a seventy-five-year-old father, and to say,5:24If I get you a cup of water, what am I going to get for it?5:26There's a little problem, no?5:28What do you mean? I'm asking you to get it because— nothing, because I told you to get it for me.5:33Come on, what are you going to give me for it?5:35You get a mitzvah. Even if you say, You'll get a mitzvah,5:38is that appropriate for a fifty-year-old man to say to a seventy-year-old father,5:42What am I going to get for it?5:44And even if the answer is, You're going to get reward, which is true,5:47is that the right way? Is that the right reason why people should do a cup of water,5:51should get a cup of water for their fathers at that age?5:53Obviously not. It's wrong.5:54So when we come to Hashem and we're doing mitzvot,5:58Hashem, what am I getting for it?5:59Getting Olam Haba. That's great, right?6:00It's good, but fine, but eventually we have to get to a stage6:05and realize that we're doing it because Hashem said so.6:08What do you mean? It's a relationship with Hashem.6:09This is very important, and this will only happen when we come with the attitude6:13that we're here not just for reward.6:15Maybe when a person is starting out, he's a baal teshuva and he's starting something new,6:18so you need an incentive. You need something to inspire us to do it right.6:22So we say, Okay, you get reward. You get6:26segulah leparnassah, or a guy is single, we say segulah to get married,6:30and— Segulot got to stop at a certain point, and for a person to say,6:33Hey, I'm doing because Hashem said so.6:35And that will only happen if a person comes with the attitude6:37that this is a relationship with Hashem.6:41You know, I can't live my whole life6:44segulah for parnassah. You can't. I'm saying it now, and I hope people hear it and spread this word.6:48We as Jews cannot live our whole lives doing something out of6:54a segulah for parnassah, or because we have other reasons for it.6:56We got to get to a point, at least6:59some of its, where we're doing because that's the right thing to do.7:01What will you get for it? I don't care.7:04That's what Hashem told me to do. Hashem told me to keep Shabbat.7:06That's why I'm keeping it.7:08Is it hard? Yeah, it's hard,7:09and sometimes it's inconvenient, but I love it.7:11That's my relationship with Hashem.7:14But it doesn't come right away.7:17It's going to be something that will eventually come, though,7:21and it will only come—it doesn't just happen by itself either.7:24It will only come if a person works on this idea that I'm building a relationship with Hashem7:28and trying to train yourself to do things just because Hashem said so,7:31not because it's going to impress other people7:33and not because, you know, it's going to give me kavod.7:36It's because that's the right thing to do.7:38This is what the Emet Shlomo is saying.7:40It comes—check on here on the bottom.7:45So where does it come from?7:48From the Gemara. The Gemara brings it from a pasuk,7:49famous pasuk7:50in7:51Mishlei, towards the end of Mishlei: שֶׁקֶר הַחֵן וְהֶבֶל הַיֹּפִי, אִשָּׁה יִרְאַת ה׳.8:02Mamash sheker. Sheker, as Shlomo HaMelech says,8:04chen is a lie, beauty is hevel, is nonsense.8:09Isha yirat Hashem hi tithalal, a woman who has yirat Hashem, that's the one who should be praised.8:17Chazal tell us, ... So he brings the same question, he brings the same levels,8:21and now he, well, let's basically, he brings the same thing that the Ibn Shelemah says.8:25I'm going to skip all that,8:27you know, the question of pirkei avot and everything else,8:29and then he explains how it fits8:37with sheker hachen. V'zehu shekatuv, sheker hachen, shehaoseh bishvil limtzo chen b'einei adam ki lo mitkayem b'yado. There's three levels8:39over here. Look at what Shlomo HaMelech says.8:40There's chen, yofi, and yirat Hashem.8:44For chen, he says it's sheker. Yofi, he calls it8:48hevel, and yirat Hashem is8:50tithalal. So we know that yirat Hashem is what should be praised,8:52and that represents the three ways of a person serving8:57Hashem. Now let's see how he explains it.9:02Sheker hachen shehaoseh bishvil limtzo chen b'einei adam ki lo mitkayem b'yado. The people who are doing it just so they can look good in front of others.9:06You know, in some people, they want their kid to get married,9:10they start coming to shul.9:12Let the people know that we're a family that goes to shul.9:15You know, it's a new style. People are looking for religious families.9:18We start coming to shul.9:19They're just doing it to find favor in others.9:22Like we said, other people are coming because they want a certain name in the community,9:26or they want to socialize, right?9:29They're doing it for their own personal reasons.9:32So he says,9:34v'maaseh b'atzmo hu sheker. It's really a sheker. You're putting on an act.9:37You don't really want to learn Torah. You don't really want to keep the mitzvot.9:41You're doing it so you can build a name, right?9:44So you can build a name somewhere else, you do somewhere else.9:46So that's why it's called9:48sheker. You're trying to find chen in other people's eyes.9:52Then it says,9:53hevel hayofi. What does that mean?9:56Shem yafeh atzmo neged HaKadosh Baruch Hu, af shema'asav atzmo hutov. And he's doing good things.9:58He's making—he's trying to make himself beautiful, beautiful.10:00Like Chazal said, like a guy who says,10:05I'm giving money, but I want something in return.10:08Hashem, give me life for it.10:10I want reward for it.10:13Why is it called10:16hevel? He says, still the pasuk is saying, hevel hayofi.10:18He's trying to make himself beautiful, but it's10:20hevel. What does that mean? It's not true beauty,10:22right? A woman who puts on makeup, she looks beautiful, but not really what she looks like,10:27right? It's together with the makeup, and you do the hair,10:30and you edit a lot of,10:32right? So he says, כמו שכתוב, ראיתי את כל המעשים שנעשו תחת השמש, והנה הכל הבל ורעות רוח, והנה תחת השמש. What does that mean when Shlomo HaMelech says,10:41I saw all the actions under the sun, which means in this world,10:45and it's all11:02hevel? So the Gemara11:03explains, מעל לשמיים חזקה, עד שמיים חזקה. כמה משיגים לשמיים, כמה משיגים שלוש שמים. Our seen lishma, הוא דבר שנעלה מן השמיים, לכן על השמיים חזקה להם. משיגים אותם מעשי שלא לשמה, הוא תחת השמיים, והוא שכתוב, והנה תחת השמש. It says it depends if you're doing l'shem shamayim or not. If you do l'shem shamayim, which means just because you want to know what the right thing is,11:07it goes above the shemesh,11:09תחת השמש, then you only get the chesed. That means Hashem will give you.11:13But the hevel that Shlomo HaMelech is talking about,11:15the hevel hayofi, is people who are doing shelo l'shem shamayim.11:18It's still called shelo l'shem shamayim,11:21100% l'shem shamayim.11:22You're doing a good thing, you will get reward for it, but your reward is limited.11:27It's11:29עד השמיים. But a person who's l'shem shamayim, it goes above,11:32and that's אישר יראת השם. That's the third level.11:35He's doing it, and now we finally define what's called l'shem shamayim according to the11:40Gra. He's doing it because of11:44יראת הרוממות, because Hashem is great, and this is what we need to do for Hashem.11:47This is what Hashem asks from me. I don't care about the reward, I don't care about anything else.11:50I'm doing it just because that's the right thing to do.11:54That is how the Gra defines as l'shem shamayim.