Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 17Sefer Even ShelemaPart 137Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:008:32Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:10Even Shelema, perek chet, ot yud dalet. Arbaa devarim yesh b'inyan shel lo lishma. Finally, we're getting to define lishma, shelo lishma. We saw already what the definition of lishma from the words of the Gra in his peirush, not from the Even Shelema, where he talks about yirat Hashem, learning Torah with yirat Shamayim, which means to know what to do, to know that, you know, I have to do what Hashem wants me to do.0:25That's the tachlit of all learning. So he says, arbaa devarim yesh b'inyan shel lo lishma. Okay, there are four types of levels, basically, when it comes to shelo lishma. Number one is sheHashem yitbarach yiten lo chayim. A person is learning Torah, why? He wants Hashem to give him life.0:39As we see that in the Gemara, He's going to bring proof to all of them. Level two, another level, sheyeh lo gedulah, where a person is having learning Torah so from that he gets a promotion. He gets raised up, whether it's, you know, in parnassah, in chochmah, people, oh, oh, Tacham, right? You know your stuff.1:00Number three is lehityaher, to show off, where that's a third level in shelo lishma. A person is learning Torah to show off, look how much I know, eh, the sechel and that and this, right? There's another level. And the fourth level is the worst, which seems to be the worst level, lekanter, to knock others.1:19Ah, what are you talking about? You don't know what you're talking about. Like we found by Doeg ha-Edomi a little bit, right? Just to knock others down. Am ha-aretz atah, lo yada ma atah omer, right? Did you see the Rashba? The Rashba says exactly like you, not like you, right? And you might be right, but that's why you learn Torah, in order to lekanter, in order to knock others.1:37Now, he says, veha-rishonah, the first one, which is what? sheHashem yitbarach yiten lo chayim, that Hashem should give him life, eina kashah ukrovah lakedushah. It's not so bad. It's not so hard. And it's actually kadosh, and it's very close to1:58kedushah. That's what we find in Gemara, such an interesting statement. The Gemara says in Masechet Baba Batra, a person who gives money to tzedakah. Now, tzedakah is supposed to be like any other mitzvah; it's supposed to be done l'shem Shamayim. But tzedakah, it's easy to have2:11shelo l'shem Shamayim. So a person gives money to tzedakah, and he says, I'm giving this money, why? In order that my son should live. The Gemara says, Tzadik gamur. But that's not l'shem shamayim. You're supposed to give tzedakah because Hashem wants me to give tzedakah, because I'm supposed to help others.2:26But the Gemara says that if you're saying it because you want your own personal benefit, you want that your son should live, that's tzadik gamur. So you see it's kerovah, it's close to kedushah. U'shloshah, the other three, keneged ha-kinah, ta'avah, v'kavod. The other three are actually mitzad sitra achra, and they correspond to kinah, ta'avah, and kavod, the three things that Chazal tell us,2:52motziin adam min ha'olam. How do they correspond? What are these three things? First of all, let's translate. Kinah is jealousy. Ta'avah is desire. Kavod is kavod. So kinah, the jealousy, that's what? Lekanter. That's a person who's knocking, right? Ta'avah, a person who has all his desires, that is shelo gedulah. And kavod is lehityaher, to show off, right? Those are the three corresponding to these three levels.3:24Shofuni. Yeah. Okay, chaf-bet. Look on the bottom in the Gra's words, the source in the Gra's words. So he quotes the Gemara. Gemara says,3:36Amar Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai לתלמידיו: בני, מהו שאמר כתוב 'צדקה תרומם גוי' ו'חסד לאומים חטאת'? So Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai asked his students, what does it mean when the pasuk says, Tzedakah will uplift a nation, and chesed le'umim, the kindness of the nations, is a sin?3:48Rabbi Eliezer answered him, and he said, Tzedakah teromem goy, when the pasuk says that tzedakah will uplift the nation, elu Yisrael. Let's talk about the Jewish people. As it says, how do we know the Jewish people are called3:59goy? As it says, 'ומי כעמך ישראל גוי אחד בארץ' — who's like a nation who's considered goy echad ba'aretz? V'chesed le'umim chatat, and the chesed of the goyim is a sin. What does that mean? He says, Kol tzedakah v'chesed she'umot ovdei kochavim osin, chet hu lahem. Every tzedakah and kindness that the goyim do is actually a sin for them.4:20Why? She'ein osin ella l'hitgadel bo. They're only doing it to become... To become great in it.4:29The Gemara asks one second. A guy who does like what Rabbi Eliezer says, like what the goyim are doing, that why he's giving tzedakah l'hitgadel, for his own benefit basically.4:40It's סתם צדקה גמרא. One second, what about the famous braita? The Gemara says, Ha'omer sela זו לצדקה, בשביל שיחיה בני, ובשביל שאזכה לעולם הבא, הרי זה צדיק גמור. A person who gives money to tzedakah, he says, I'm doing it in order that my son should live,4:55is considered צדיק גמור. How could you tell me that when the goyim give it l'hitgadel bo is a חטאת? So my answer is לא קשיא. No, that's not a contradiction. It depends who's doing it.5:06One is by the Jewish people, one's by goyim. The Gemara doesn't explain how. Why is it when the goy says it, it's considered שלא לשמה, and when a Jew says it, it's considered5:21לשם שמים, it's considered a צדיק גמור? By a goy it's considered a חטאת. The Gemara doesn't explain. We'll see later on. The Gemara continues. Now Rabbi Yochanan comes to give his explanation on the pasuk.5:30He says, Kotzer קבע חסד שומותם דרך עמים מעשים, חטא להן. The tzedakah and chesed the goyim do is considered a sin for them. Why? שאין עושין אלא כדי שתמשך מלכותן. They're only doing it that their kingdom should last.5:42They should have power that continues. And Rabbi Gamliel says, Kotzer קבע חסד שעכו״ם עושין חטא להן. You know why when goyim do a tzedakah it's considered a sin for them? שאין עושין אלא להתיהר בו. They're doing it only to show off. רבי אלעזר המודעי אומר, Kotzer קבע חסד שעכו״ם עושין חטא להן. You know why? שאין עושין אלא להחריף אותנו בו. They're only doing it to embarrass us.6:04כתבו רבינו, comes the Gra and says, what's going on? They're all explaining why when the goy gives tzedakah, when goyim give tzedakah, it's considered a sin for them.6:23The Gra explains, he says, אמרו ארבעה דברים. Notice over here, they said four types of reasons why people give tzedakah. One is להתגדל, one is become great, one is שתמשך מלכותן, that the kingdom should6:55continue, one is להתיהר, is to show off, and one is להחריף, to knock, to embarrass us. He says, שבית שלא לשמה הן בכל אחד בית. Each one is another two subcategories. Number one is, לשם יתברך ייתן לו חיים. One is, level one. One part is one type isdashim, should7:51give him life, u'gedulah, and should become great. Two is lehityahev u'lekanter. The other part is to show off or to knock others. V'ein arba setrin dilhon, bein b'techulah bein b'dikubai, says, apikabala, they represent the four sides, two in zachan, two negeba. The first part, which is what, that7:51person should have life and he should have gedulah, right? So it's not only the level one, and only level one, like we said in ... level one and two, those are karov likdushah. For a person to become great, if he's learning Torah or doing tzedakah, to become great or to have life, it's karov likdushah. It's not l'shem shamayim, but it's karov likdushah. Therefore, if you're giving tzedakah in order you should have life or gedulah, ... And the other three—so I made a mistake. The first one, which is only the first level, which is life, is fine. The other three, which is lekanter, or which is to knock others, leharef otanu, or gedulah to become great, or lehityahev, or to show off, all those correspond to ... taavah v'kavod.8:00From the Sitra of the8:02tumah. And that's what the Gra is saying over here,8:04and it applies not only by8:06tzedakah; it applies also by a person's learning Torah.8:07What is your kavanah when you learn Torah?8:09If your kavanah is for life,8:12you should have Olam Haba,8:13okay, it's not exactly8:15l'shem Shamayim, but it's good.8:16If you're doing it for other personal reasons,8:18that people say you're8:20a chacham, to show off, or to knock others,8:22and to have your own personal benefit in it,8:25that's not8:26l'shem Shamayim, and it's probably more dangerous. Amen v'amen.