Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 16Sefer Even ShelemaPart 136Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:59Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Eben Shelema, perek chet, ot yud0:03gimmel. In this perek, as we're discussing the attitude for the person supposed to have when he's learning,0:09so he says over here, the Eben Shelema,0:11ma0:18she'adam lomed lishma af shehu me'at, hu yoter tov0:22mima shelomed harbeh u'maleh machshavot pesulot kegon kavod vekedomeh. It's so much better than if he learns so much more with the wrong thoughts, with the wrong plans.0:28Like, for example, he wants to learn for kavod and everything else.0:33So that's an amazing statement.0:35The little that a person learns l'shem shamayim, because what's l'shem shamayim?0:38We haven't really defined it yet,0:40but kipshuto, it's because I want to know what to do.0:44We did allude to it a lot, as he kept on saying that it's with yirat Hashem.0:49Yirat Hashem means I want to know what to do.0:52I don't want to do the wrong thing.0:54I want to enhance my relationship with Hashem.0:57I want to enhance other people's relationship with Hashem,0:59because sometimes through enhancing other people's relationship with Hashem,1:03you know, that's how I enhance my relationship with Hashem.1:06The only thing is, when it comes to other people, since there's another element that comes with it,1:10for example,1:12kavod, so a person always has to examine himself very well to see if that's really his kavanah or not.1:16But in any case, when you are doing it l'shem shamayim,1:20even though you may not be doing so much, that little is so much better,1:25yoter tov. It's much better than what a person is doing a lot, a lot, with the wrong1:34machshavot. Again, the wrong machshavot could be also on different levels,1:37but he's saying even for honor, even1:40for kavod, that people should say, Look how much you know, that is not worth it.1:44So this is a good feeling.1:47Why?1:48Because sometimes we may not have the ability to learn so much.1:53and become a feeling bad.1:56But we could control at least the advantage.1:59You know, let's say whether you don't have the ability to learn because you don't have the skills to learn,2:05or you can't learn because you don't have the time to2:08learn, and you're really, really anus. You're really in the situation where you're not just giving excuses for yourself.2:13You're not busy on your phone and internet and your TV and your entertainment instead of learning Torah.2:18You're really trying to find, but, like, you know, life just has so many things going on.2:22Sometimes we hit periods, you know, where just so much things are being thrown at you at the same time.2:26You don't find time to learn.2:28Just to help you that, you2:29know, there's a2:32Chovot HaLevavot, Shaar Bitachon. There's one piece that I always try to2:35find, and it's a very good attitude to have in life in general.2:37He says that whatever situation you find yourself,2:40see how the benefits of that situation, how to make the best of that situation.2:44So one of the things we could say over here is also2:48is that the advantage—and of course it's always better to learn more2:52Torah—but the advantage of when you're learning a little bit2:54is that you could focus on that little bit to make the best of that little bit.2:58How do you make the best of that little bit?2:59To learn it for the right reason,3:00to learn it l'shem shamayim.3:02And that little, says the Gra, is much better than a lot3:06that's not l'shem shamayim.3:07This doesn't mean you don't learn a lot.3:08No, of course if you can learn a lot, that's much better than learning a little bit.3:12We're just saying that the little that's l'shem shamayim is more than a lot3:17shelo l'shem shamayim. Look on the bottom.3:19He brings it from a few different pesukim in Mishlei.3:22He says the same idea,3:24and because it's a small piece,3:26we'll be able hopefully to do a bunch of pesukim over here from Mishlei.3:29The first one comes from Mishlei,3:34perek tet, vav, pesukim tet-zayin and yud-zayin. Look what he says.3:36This is what the pasuk says:3:40Tov me'at b'yirat Adonai me'otzar rav u'mehumah bo. A little bit with fear of Hashem is better than a whole treasure,3:44but there's confusion in it.3:46The next pasuk says:3:52Tov aruchat yarak v'ahavah sham mishor abus v'sin'ah bo. Better is a meal of vegetables with love than a stuffed ox but full of hate.4:01The Gemara uses this second pasuk to talk about the mitzvah of kibud4:05av va'em. Better a person who's fulfilling the mitzvah of kibud4:10av va'em, it's better that he gives his parents with love.4:13And he's mechabed him. He shows him respect.4:16If he gives him a little because he can't afford more,4:18better than the guy who gives him much more, right,4:22and he does it with4:24sinah. Somebody recently sent me a video,4:26כאילו, like, you know, a chidush that they made it.4:28You know, like the goyim came up with this idea.4:30It's an idea, it's a pasuk from Mishlei,4:31and the Gemara says it in Masechet Kiddushin as well.4:35Anyway, in any case, the Gra uses over here now,4:39לעניין תלמוד תורה. Look what he says:4:43ועניין הוא להורות בדרכי לימוד תורת ה' תמימה. This pasuk is coming to tell you an approach of how a person should be learning the Torah of Hashem.4:51כי לפעמים ילמד אדם הרבה מאוד. At times, a person finds himself that he's able to learn a lot of Torah,4:56אבל מלא פניות. But he's full of different reasons of why he wants to5:00learn. For example, לכבוד, wants to show off his learning,5:03וגאווה, feels better than other people,5:07ומרמה, and sometimes you can use it just to show other people that they don't know,5:11וקנטור, or to knock other people down.5:14It could be other people don't know,5:16but you're learning just to show where they are mistaken,5:24and ודומיהן, etc. ובתוך הרוב שלומד, and sometimes because he's learning so much,5:27it could be5:31יקרה מעט שלמד ביראת השם. It's possible that will happen,5:34that from all that, let's say a guy spent hours, four hours a day for three weeks learning,5:40unbelievable, right, for a working guy,5:41but let's say another guy spent 12 hours a day learning.5:44It could be possible that one of those hours he learned5:48לשם שמים, he did it with5:50יראת השם. So אותו מעט הוא יותר טוב מכל האוצרות כבית מלא למד ומה בו. That little is better than all the things that he gathered5:59that's full of מהומה, like we said, full of confusion.6:10והוא בתורה גם כן מורה ללמוד מאהבת השם יתברך ברוך הוא, מה שיהיה. And the same thing when it comes to Torah.6:12He's telling you like this:6:14better to learn a little bit with love of Hashem6:17than to learn a whole6:19axe, to learn a whole thing full of hate.6:23You do, right?6:24Ah, I have to learn.6:26Ah, why am I learning?6:27Ah, I have to, whatever.6:28You know, if I don't do it, my wife is going to kick me out of the house.6:30She already kicked me out of the house.6:31She told me to come to class.6:32You know, she6:34says, Stop being a bum.6:34All your siblings are learning.6:35Go, go to class already.6:36Go do something.6:37Get out of the house.6:39Go, go. You know,6:40I want to tell everybody my husband also learns,6:42or whatever it is.6:43You don't want to be there,6:44right?6:44That is shor shalem,6:47it's an abuk. Next, another pasuk. This pasuk is in Mishlei, perek zayin, pasuk6:53chet. The pasuk says,6:54A little bit with6:57tzedakah than to give a lot of produce7:00unjustly. Now, the simple meaning of the pasuk is that,7:02look at this guy,7:03he's giving so much7:04tzedakah. He's giving so much7:06tzedakah to what? What7:07is this guy giving so much tzedakah to? To organizations.7:10But where is he getting the money from?7:11He stole from people,7:12and he's giving7:14tzedakah. Chas v'shalom. Better the little bit of money that you earned honestly7:17and you give tzedakah from that7:19than a lot of money that you stole7:21and you give7:26it without mishpat. He7:26says, וכן הוא בתורה: טוב שילמד מעט מעט צדקה מרוב תבואות ולא במשפט. Better that a person learns a little bit of7:28tzedakah than he does a lot of produce7:30without according to7:31halacha. What does that mean?7:32If a person is learning a lot of Torah,7:34but7:36lo b'mishpat, שאינו יודע הדין על בוריו, he's not learning properly,7:39או מה שמדבר ויהיה מלפניו, or you're learning a lot7:41and you're understanding your learning,7:43you know what you're talking about,7:44but you're doing it because of the wrong reasons,7:47that is not as good.7:52That is not worth as much as the guy who's learning.8:00Like we said, with a little bit l'shem shamayim.8:03Another, here we go up to the fourth pasuk8:06already. Tov pat8:09charevah v'shalvah bah, bayit malei zivchei riv. Another pasuk in Mishlei, perek zayin, pasuk aleph.8:11Better a dry bread with peace than to have a full house of luxuries, right,8:18but full of fights.8:20So he says,8:22v'chen b'Torah. Same idea also with Torah.8:24Tov l'mod8:28me'at v'hatvin lishma, v'limod harbeh u'vli l'kanter. Better to learn a little bit l'shem shamayim than to learn a lot that was full of fighting.8:33He quotes the Zohar.8:34Inu d'askin b'oraita v'tzavchin k'chalba u'makshin kushya v'tzvachin hab hab.8:39Those people who are osek b'Torah, but they're yelling like dogs8:42and always knocking, right?8:44And say, Give me, give me, I got it.8:46I'm the one. I know it's mine.8:47I know better.8:49That better is little.8:51And then one final pasuk over here, because the time allows it.8:56Tzadik ochel l'sova nafsho,8:59u'veten resha'im techsar. A righteous person eats to be full, and the stomach of the wicked will always be lacking.9:03Comes the Gra and says again the same thing in the Torah.9:06Tzadik ochel l'sova nafsho,9:07who's9:08a9:11tzadik? Shelomed bichdei sheyesabea v'eino ro'eh me'at im harbeh. Very important for us.9:12He learns to be full. What does it mean? He learns to know,9:16and he's not looking, Did I eat a lot? Did I eat a little bit?9:18Did you ever notice with your kids?9:20It's the cutest thing when you see with kids,9:22because as kids, they're undeveloped.9:25Kids are really not developed.9:27Whatever you see by kids, it's a big mussar for adults.9:30Whatever kids are doing, keep in mind they're doing it because that's their nature,9:35and just because it's their nature doesn't mean it's right.9:38We have to teach them, right?9:40Look at babies when they start eating. They stick their fingers, they throw up, they make a big mess.9:45Can you imagine a 45-year-old man? Eating like that.9:49His kids are about to get married, and he's meeting the new9:53in-laws, and he's eating, he's sticking his hands in the food and everything.9:56Disgusting.9:57He's with the dignitary, and he's doing that.9:59Disgusting, right?10:00There's obviously some problem over there10:02from the time that he was one until he became 45.10:04Somebody didn't teach him along the way.10:05That's not10:07derech eretz. So kids have to be taught.10:09So it's one of the interesting things you see with kids.10:12You give them, they're all excited.10:13You give them, you got them ice cream.10:16Everybody's excited, great.10:17One kid gets a bigger ice cream than the others.10:20What happens?10:22All of a sudden they're all upset.10:24Why does he have more than me?10:25One second,10:26are you happy with your ice cream?10:27Yeah.10:27Were you happy before?10:28Yeah.10:28What happened?10:29He has more than me,10:32right?10:32Sounds funny, but guess what?10:34Adults are the same way.10:35You have these guys, you know, the greatest10:38is a few years ago, my wife read an article.10:41She shared it with my kids just to understand this idea.10:45I remember a few years ago, Walmart, you know, at the end of the year10:49when they showed how much they made, they made 13 billion10:53dollars, right?10:5413 billion10:54dollars. I think Anivos will jump for joy with 13 billion10:58dollars. But they were burning.10:59It was killing them.11:01They made 13 billion11:02dollars. Why?11:03Because Amazon made 90.11:06It killed them.11:08It's the craziest thing.11:10It's not that you're not happy with what you have.11:14You're just upset that he has more.11:16So comes the guy and says11:17the same thing when it comes to learning Torah.11:19Same thing when it comes to learning Torah.11:21You're learning.11:22You understand what you're learning?11:23Yes.11:24You know what to do,11:25Baruch Hashem.11:26Yeah, but he knows more than11:27me. I didn't learn it.11:28Oh, he finished Shas in one year.11:29I want to do that.11:30Why?11:32What's the race for?11:34No, because he can't be better than me.11:36That's11:38a lo shma. That is11:40lo shma. Rak sheyodea—what's the purpose of learning?11:43Sheyodea al boryo v'yeshban nafsho v'kayem. Here, you want to know what lishma is?11:45Here the guy is saying it.11:46You should know things clearly,11:50and you should be happy,11:52and your soul should feel fulfilled.11:54You should feel a certain sense of accomplishment,11:58and yekayem and keep on doing.12:00That's12:02lishma. Ach, the pasuk, however, says,12:04Beten resha'im techsar. The stomach of the wicked is always missing,12:09ki ein kavatam rak l'hitgader ba'einei habriyot, because the resha'im, the people who learn Torah12:11not for the right reason,12:12their whole intention is to look great in the eyes of people.12:16Therefore, how do you look great?12:17By showing, Look how much I know,12:19and look how much I covered.12:20I finished that,12:20and I did this,12:21and I did that.12:22Sometimes, you know, keep it.12:25V'kovtzim harbeh b'pa'am achat, and they gather a lot at once of him,12:30and they can look, lo hakol kach harbeh al yedei zeh yihyeh b'tam chaser. But they gather so much,12:31but they can't really absorb so much.12:33It's just impossible.12:35And what happens?12:35They end up missing.12:38Kemo shekatuv, Ki na'im ki tishmerem b'vitnecha. They're only pleasant when you're able to retain it.12:43V'lachen yihyeh b'tam chaser, ki lo yishtayer bahem me'umah. You're stuffing them,12:44you're stuffing them with information,12:45but at the end of the day, right,12:48how much are they retaining?12:49Nothing,12:50or a little bit.12:51So it's not pleasant.12:52Take a little bit,12:53learn it properly,12:54and retain it12:55instead of taking a lot and saying, I know so much.