Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 15Sefer Even ShelemaPart 135Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:34Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:08Ha'even shleimah, perek chet, ot yud bet. Ma she'amru, le'olam ya'asok adam b'Torah u'mitzvot shelo lishmah. It says in Chazal, famous Gemara, Masechet Pesachim,0:18amar Rabbi Yehuda, le'olam ya'asok adam shelo lishmah, b'Torah u'mitzvot shelo lishmah, shemitoch shelo lishmah ba lishmah. A person should always be busy with Torah0:24and mitzvot shelo l'shem Shamayim, even if it's not for the sake of0:26Hashem, because from when you're osek even shelo lishmah, not for the sake of0:30Hashem, not for the right reason, excuse me,0:32then you'll eventually come to0:34lishmah. Comes the Gaon, tells us a very important condition:0:40hainu she'eino mechaven משום דבר רק מנהג אבותיו בידיו. You know what shelo lishmah means?0:41Shelo lishmah means0:44not that you're doing it for the wrong reason,0:46but shelo lishmah means0:48you're doing it for no reason.0:50Why are you learning Torah?0:51My father put me in yeshiva.0:53You know, that's why.0:54Why are you learning Torah?0:56Because, you know, everybody in the community0:58now became the new thing, the new style, everybody's learning,1:00right? You're not really learning because that's what Hashem wants;1:03you're just doing it.1:04That's what we do.1:07That's called1:08shelo lishmah, and that's the one where Chazal tell us1:09if you do that, eventually you come to1:13lishmah. Aval lomed misha'akah limudo l'shem kavod. But a person who's learning dafka for the sake of1:16kavod, no, no, no, no, that1:17it doesn't work,1:19as we saw1:22by the Gemara Masechet1:24Chagigah, since the1:25Gra is not bringing over here in the name of the1:28Gra, so I'm going to say,1:29you know, the famous Gemara Masechet1:31Chagigah, when it talks about1:35Acher, talks about this great talmid1:37of a big, big talmid1:39chacham who was the rabbi of Rabbi Meir,1:42right,1:42and he was in Abuya, and it seems like he went off the1:46derech. The Gemara says, Why did this happen?1:47Tosafot says, Why did this happen1:49in the court of Yerushalmi? And says that by his brit milah,1:53a few rabbis were waiting.1:54They didn't know, you know,1:55the certain timing or something.1:56They were waiting for the brit milah to start,1:58and they started learning.1:59So while we're waiting over here,2:00let's start learning. They started learning.2:01A big fire came and surrounded them.2:04The host, the Abiha Ben, comes to them and he says,2:07You came to burn my party down?2:09He says, No, we're just learning Torah.2:11We learn Torah, fire surrounds us.2:12The Maharsha explains those are the2:15malachim. Those are the malachim that surround a person2:17that are created from the words of the Torah.2:19They are fire,2:21okay? So he says, Wow,2:23if this is what Torah is all about,2:24I want my son to be that way also.2:26So why did he put his son in to learn?2:29For kavod,2:31says. And unfortunately, that's what caused2:33them eventually later on2:35that his Torah didn't protect him.2:37So that's what the Gra is telling you.2:38But lo b'mi shehakol midoshim kavod. If your main learning is for kavod,2:41it will not.2:42It will not.2:44That's2:46cause to lo lishmah. You should know2:47there's a2:49yechaveh daat, which is2:52Chacham Ovadia's sefer in Shut, Yechaveh Daat. He has a whole piece,2:55which we've given a whole class on it on Shabbat night2:57one of the years,2:58of what's the different shitot in the Rishonim,3:02machloket, Ritva, Tosafot, Rambam,3:04of what is considered3:07shelo lishmah. Shelo lishmah is3:08davka when I'm going against lekanter,3:11or is it l'shem kavod,3:12or l'shem mamon,3:13or is it just not because of the right reasons?3:16And which one did Chazal say that's the worst thing?3:19Good. Comes the3:23Gra now and says, V'chen im hayetzer mesit oto shelo lilmod klal. Let's say the yetzer hara is annoying you.3:25It's telling you, Ha, don't learn.3:26Go be busy.3:27Did you check the news? Did you hear what happened in Israel?3:30There's elections.3:31Oh, elections. Phew, it keeps you busy, right?3:34And he's trying to get you not to learn.3:38And if you really want to learn for the right reason,3:40very hard, because3:43the yetzer hara has such, such, so many things that are more interesting3:45to keep you busy.3:46So how are you going to distract3:48somebody? How are you going to say, Listen, somebody's going to pay me,3:50I'm going to go learn.3:52That's called shelo lishma, right?3:53I'm not really doing it.3:55... Go learn.3:57Im misho lo lishma, מתוך שלא לשמה, בא לשמה. From learning3:59shelo lishma, you'll come to4:00lishma. And really,4:02you see this. I'm telling you,4:04by myself personally, I see this sometimes, right?4:06Sometimes, you know, a4:08guy is gonna, you know, a guy tells me, Come give a class4:11somewhere. They're paying,4:12okay, so now it gets me to learn,4:14it gets me to prepare, it gets4:16me—because, guess what? Without it, I wouldn't be able to do it.4:18Such a busy schedule. There's always things4:21I'm, you know, I'm busy with.4:22But when I can make time4:25for that class4:26if you're gonna pay.4:27So you see all of a sudden,4:29right? Shelo lishma helps you4:31to learn, says the4:32Gra. When you do that also, that will also get you4:35eventually to4:37lishma. Let's see the words of the4:39Gra in the source.4:41Let's begin from the Gemara4:43Masechet Berachot. The Gemara begins and says,4:48וכל העושה שלא לשמה, נוח לו שלא נברא. Famous, famous Gemara.4:49The Gemara says,4:50Whoever learns shelo lishma, better that he wasn't created.4:58Tosafot asks a famous question:5:00How can the Gemara say better not created?5:02There's another Gemara that says,5:05משלא לשמה בא לשמה, and they explain:5:09בין עוסק לחבור, בין עוסק לקנטר. Depends.5:10The Gemara, when it says5:11shelo lishma, what does it mean,5:12shelo lishma? It's two different levels.5:13If you're doing it for kintur,5:15to knock people5:17down—you know why you're learning? You started the class, you don't like this rabbi.5:19You want to show that he's wrong.5:20You go in to learn, you go and open up5:22Mefarshim, you're gonna knock this guy, show that he's an idiot.5:25He doesn't5:26always talk about—maybe they'll give you the position,5:29right? So5:30this is called5:33lekantur. That's5:35נוח לו שלא נברא. And the Gemara Masechet Pesachim that says,5:40יעסוק אדם שלא לשמה, שבתוך שלא לשמה בא לשמה, that's good to do5:41lo lishma. That's why this guy is doing it for kavod.5:44אבל בתוספות, that's5:46in Masechet Berachot, but5:50Tosafot Pesachim חוזר וכותב בשני הדברים נוח לו שלא נברא. However,5:52Tosafot in Masechet Pesachim, they write differently.5:54They explained that even5:56if you're learning for kavod,5:59also that is6:04lo lishma. What's the difference?6:06If you're osek for honor,6:07if you're learning Torah for your own honor,6:09if you're learning to knock others,6:10it's the same thing at the end of the day,6:12right?6:13Ah, but the Gemara says that there are cases6:16shelo lishma that's good.6:17You know what that's talking about?6:18That's talking about when you're not doing anything,6:21you don't have any intention.6:24You're just doing it because, you know,6:26hekeh. That's what's being done, as we all know,6:28right? A lot of people go to shul6:30shelo lishma. It's a social gathering.6:32That's what we do in our community.6:33That's where we get to meet people.6:35You know, it's nothing against. I have no ulterior motives with it.6:38And in learning, in a lot of circles,6:40a lot of communities, and our community is developing into that,6:43right? A lot of people do learn also6:45shelo lishma. It's the in thing. It's cool.6:48It's, you know, or we're just used to it.6:50That's what we did in yeshiva,6:52okay? So he says,6:54עיין שם בתוספות. He says, look over there in6:58Tosafot. Okay, next, another piece.7:00He says, however, if the yetzer hara is bothering you7:02and he's trying to persuade you7:04to not to learn at all,7:07and he says in that case7:08you should do it7:11shelo lishma, because that will get you to7:12lishma. He quotes it on a pasuk.7:13He brings the peirush of the Gra on the following pasuk.7:17Pasuk says,7:21Im ra'ev sonacha, ha'achilehu lechem. Pasuk in Mishlei says,7:22if your enemy is hungry, feed him bread.7:26V'im tzame, hashkehu mayim, give him water to drink.7:28Why?7:31Ki gechalim atah choteh al rosho, v'Hashem yeshalem lach. Because you're stoking coals on his head,7:35and Hashem will pay you back.7:35What does that mean?7:37Says the Gra, who's this7:40soneh over here? Who's this enemy in the pasuk7:42that's talking about the yetzer hara? The Gemara says,7:44Masechet Sukkah, that one of the names of the7:45yetzer hara is called7:48soneh. Ha'achilehu lechem, feed him bread. What's7:49bread? Famous, bread is7:51the Torah,7:54lechu lachmu בלחמי. And the Gemara says in Masechet... ברכות, אם פגע בך.8:01If this disgusting guy, which is yetzer hara, bothers you, drag him to the beit8:08hamidrash. If he's stone, don't worry, he'll melt. Even if he's steel, he'll burst.8:12V'hainu, says the Gra, what does that mean?8:18Im yifga becha menuval shehu hayetzer hara, v'rotzeh l'hatot otcha min haTorah shelo lomed klal. If the yetzer hara is trying to persuade you not to learn at all, he's really getting you busy in life,8:24as you know, life can get very busy.8:27V'eincha yachol lo, and you really, you can't, you're in such stress and, you know, like you're really, you find yourself that you can't really get yourself to learn.8:35Ta'aseh kach. You know what you should do? Moshchehu l'beit hamidrash. Drag him to the beit8:39hamidrash. What do you mean? That's what I'm telling you. I can't get him to beit8:42hamidrash. I can't. I can't go to the beit hamidrash. He's telling me I don't have time.8:46He says, no, timshchehu oto עמך. It doesn't say leave him alone, go to the beit8:52hamidrash. It says bring him, right? Timshchehu. Bring the yetzer hara with you to the beit8:57hamidrash. What does that mean? Bring my phone and watch, you know, the movie in the beit9:01hamidrash? He says, no.9:04Yeah, learn9:06shelo lishma. Say, no, no, no, don't worry, I'm going to learn. No, I'm going to learn. I'm not really going to.9:09I'm going to learn. They have good sushi over there.9:11We do have, by the way, Thursday night, great sushi,9:15come. Because if you're trying to learn for the right reason, you want to be a tzaddik,9:18the yetzer hara is not going to let you.9:20So what should you do? You got to work with the9:23yetzer hara. Work with him. Don't go head on against him.9:26Work with him. Tell him, I'm going to learn for sushi.9:28Don't show lishma. I'm going to learn because it's entertaining.9:30That's a lot of stories. It's very, very—it's a lot of fun.9:32Oh, I'm going to meet new people there.9:34You know, listen, I want to get away from the wife. I don't want to have a fight.9:37That's all lo lishma. Good?9:44And that's the meaning: bring him with you.9:46Bring with you means work with him.9:49Be with the yetzer hara. Do what the yetzer hara is telling you,9:50to learn like the way the yetzer hara is telling you.9:52Because why? Eventually,10:04she'll lo lishma ba lishma. And when your real, real intentions are l'shem shamayim, and even, you know, he also doesn't want it,10:06even shelo lishma, but at least get him that far,10:08and then he'll agree with you.10:16So he says, Ki gehinam tachto ta'aro. So the pasuk says, what it means, shegam bazeh she'ata lomed shelo lishma hu gehinam lishma. Even you learning the10:18shelo lishma will be like coals on his head.10:28She'ein רצונו של תלמיד של לא לשמה, ורק לפי שעה שסוף סוף בזה יפתה אותך, שלא תמיד כלל. אבל באמת אין רצונו גם בזה, שגם זה גחלים על ראשו, because really he doesn't even want you to learn10:31shelo lishma. But at least, you know,10:33yitamu al mi you have for. You tell me not to learn,10:35and I want to learn10:37l'shem shamayim. So let's meet halfway. Let's learn,10:40but shelo lishma, and you come with me.10:42And that's the way, he says,10:44that's the way you take care of the10:46yetzer hara, because by dragging him in his own way,10:49that's when you get10:51through l'shem shamayim. So that's one piece that he brings from the10:54Gra. I want to jump to the next page where he quotes10:56from the brother of11:00the11:02Gra, the sefer Ma'alot HaTorah.11:04In the sefer Ma'alot HaTorah,11:06which is the brother of Reb Zalman,11:08the brother of the11:09Gra, he writes like this. Turn the page.11:18He says,11:20when I heard from my brother the same thing,11:22that if he tells you,11:23come to the beit, you know, he doesn't want you to learn.11:26Mushchen beit11:27midrash. Come with him to beit11:29midrash and tell him, I'm going to learn11:31shelo lishma, and this way he'll calm down,11:33he'll agree with you,11:34and then afterwards11:37shelo lishma ba lishma, and then you get rid of him completely.11:39But you got to work with the11:40yetzer hara. And now you can understand11:43what the stira, the contradiction in the11:45famous, what's it called,11:48the famous11:49Gemara that we started with.11:51How could one Gemara say11:52shelo lishma ba lishma, and another Gemara says,11:54no, if you learn11:57shelo lishma, it's better that you're not created.11:59Shelo lishma ba lishma is when you're12:00learning with your real intentions is to get12:03lishma, right? You're learning for12:04other reasons, but just to get yourself12:06into learning.12:07That you could say12:10shelo lishma ba lishma, because you really want to get to the12:13lishma. But the other12:15pshat, I mean, but the other Gemara that says12:17shelo lishma, no,12:18shelo lishma, that's a guy who wants to stay12:20shelo lishma. He's only doing it for kavod.12:21He's only doing it to knock other people.12:24That guy, that his Torah is not going to be12:27lishma, and all the things that Chazal said12:29about shelo lishma is going to apply by him.12:31Baruch...