Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 14Sefer Even ShelemaPart 134Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:40Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00I wanted to just read once more a piece from yesterday, from Yud Aleph. I didn't want to make this its own recording.0:05Yesterday we went already a little bit long, and that is on the following pasuk.0:10The pasuk says, Al tit'av lemat'amotav, vehu lechem kazavim. Don't desire his mat'amotav, his foods, because it's bread of lies.0:24Okay? That's what Shlomo HaMelech is warning you about. He's talking about something over there that somebody's trying to deceive you.0:29Comes the Gra and explains, on a deeper level, what Shlomo HaMelech is also talking about.0:39Al yabhilecha yetzer hara lomar, ma yazikeni im elmad l'shem hana'ah o rabbanut. Don't let the yetzer hara confuse you and tell you, Hey, you know, what damage?0:45Al zog I'm learning, so what's the big deal? So I'm learning for0:50shelo lishmah. I'm learning because I want to get personal pleasures. You know, what does that mean?0:55When I learn, I get, you know, I'll be in the class with that rich guy, and then I'll get, be'ezrat Hashem, you know, that account.1:01Or rabbanut, I'll become a rabbi, or people will stand up for me, kiss my hand.1:07V'hu arev me'od b'sha'at ha-limud, and it's great, I'm enjoying my learning.1:14V'nafshi gechalim telahet, lilmod b'ahavah v'chibah v'hashkifah b'Torah yitrabeh, and this way I'll learn better and I'll have more desire to learn more Torah. And when I do it for the wrong reasons.1:20That's what the yetzer hara is telling you. Look, let's be honest. If you're learning l'shem shamayim, there's no money, there's no1:25parnassah in it. What do you get from that? What do you matter? You know a lot of Torah.1:31Woo, you big haham, right? Okay? So listen, sometimes as a rabbi you have to learn because you have to answer people.1:38It's not a question. But somebody just תלמיד חכם doesn't have that position, right?1:42And you're learning just to get to that position. So he says,1:47תשיבה דבריו. This, I might tell you, what's the problem? Big deal. So at least I learn with more, as they say, more1:52bren, right? More excitement. It says, you answer the yetzer like this.1:56The pasuk tells me, Don't desire his food.2:00He'll affect you. This kind of learning will affect you in two ways.2:03Number one, think about it. The whole time you're learning, you're thinking, Wow,2:10I become big rabbi, right? That's what you think the whole time,2:15and you have all these, as you're learning, that's your thoughts.2:18Number two, when you don't have that desire anymore, you're looking for that position.2:24All of a sudden, they hire a ... from Israel, big2:29talmid chacham. You don't have that position. What happened? You fall out of it.2:32And that's why I always try to stress to people is that when you give people false hopes, right?2:38Yeah, but as long as they're doing it, false hopes. But then when those, you know, like, it's like,2:44I remember I knew someone who was very turned off from this whole Mashiach.2:48He doesn't believe in the whole thing of Mashiach. He says, Why?2:51Because he says he knew people that told him, This Mashiach is here, and this guy is Mashiach,2:57and then he died. The Mashiach didn't come. It really put a lot of people in disappointment.3:00He says, It turned me off, right? You give people false hopes,3:03and this happens like every other year. Every, like, some guy comes up with a whole article,3:08Mashiach is going to come at this date. And I hate them. I can't stand them.3:12And look, he has good proof. Why not? Why can't we believe?3:15I don't mind believing, but don't base it on a lie.3:18Or like I said this in the past, somebody once texts me,3:21and he says a whole long text, a conversation between the Satan and Hashem,3:25okay? And the text says as follows: the Satan comes to Hashem, he says,3:29Satan says to Hashem, Your kids don't love you.3:32I says, What? Yeah, your kids don't love you. They don't care about you.3:34Watch, I'm going to send out a text right now, and the text is going to say,3:37Say one mizmor Tehillim and forward this to other ten people to say another3:41mizmor Tehillim, right? And watch, they're not going to send. They're not going to care.3:46Somebody sent me this, and it happens to be the guy who sent it to me3:49is a guy who spent some time in yeshiva, and I ignored it.3:52He's like, Rabbi, what do you think? I said, It's3:55assur. He said, What do you mean? It's good. It gets people to say perek Tehillim,3:58but sheker. You can't do a good thing based on sheker.4:04Don't steal people's money and give it4:06tzedakah. Give tzedakah then, but you did it based on an4:09aveirah. This is sheker. And no, there was no conversation about text messages.4:13If there was a conversation, there's Satan saying, Watch,4:15I'm going to get people to use their phone in the middle of learning,4:18or people use their phone.4:19That's a conversation with Satan,4:22not this. This is sheker, and it's assur to do such a thing.4:25It didn't happen. And even if it happened, you don't know about it,4:27so it's sheker anyway.4:29So we can't— and the same thing with kids, the same thing with how we raise kids.4:34We can't give them hopes based on lies,4:36because when they discover our lies, it'll be very, very bad.4:39Sometimes people, they tell their kids—4:43people come, they threaten their kids, and they tell them,4:45Oh, if, you know, I did this, right?4:49And they give them this whole sense of like, you know,4:52like they did something, but they really didn't.4:54Okay, at least I got the people to do it.4:56I got my kids to go to sleep on time.4:58I got my kids to learn. I got my kids—5:00that's not good.5:00You know, this whole thing that came out, the Momo challenge,5:03it's sheker.5:05There's no such a thing.5:06No such a thing. It's a5:07hoax. That's part of the bigger issue.5:10People are so focused on the small issue5:12that's part of the bigger issue with the internet5:15that we just believe everything without verifying it.5:18The internet has many, many problems,5:20many, many, many problems.5:22One of them could be that people will, you5:24know, you start talking to the wrong people5:26that challenge you to do stupid things.5:28That's the things.5:29One of the bigger issues also of the internet5:31is that we just believe everything without verification.5:34Now, sometimes it can be not so5:36harmful, like this5:38moment. Okay, so we got people to stay off YouTube.5:40Even kids don't want to go on YouTube.5:41Okay,5:42beseder. I'll get to that in a second,5:44why it is a little bit—I'm not telling you to go on YouTube, by the5:45way—but I'll get to why it's another problem.5:49But, and sometimes it can be a very problem.5:51When you get a text and it shows you,5:52look, there's bugs in this company's food.5:55Yeah, one guy had, you know, bugs, by the way,5:59in any of the best, best companies,6:01the freshest of companies,6:02if you don't store it properly, it'll get buggy.6:05I have a cabinet, right? Right6:09when you walk into my living room,6:10I'm attached on both sides, by the way.6:12I have no windows on those sides,6:13only the front and the back. You've seen my house, right?6:16So I have over there, I put wine over there.6:19Why do I put wine over there?6:20Because it's right next to, right,6:22when I need it for Kiddush, whatever, it's right there.6:23I'm not a wine drinker,6:25and if I have grape juice, I'll never use the wine.6:27I'll only use the wine for6:30Leil Pesach and, you know, when I run out of grape juice.6:32So you can imagine how long those stay in there.6:34So my wine bottles actually, over the summer,6:36because it got hot, and sometimes I'm not home,6:39so I'm not putting on the AC anyway.6:41So because of the hot, what happens to the wine bottles?6:43It gets bad, right?6:44Because you're supposed to leave it in a cool place.6:46Again, I'm not a wine drinker, not that.6:48So what happens? After the summer,6:50every wine bottle that was in there was bad.6:52Now imagine I come and I open up this bottle.6:54Let's say somebody gave me a bottle that was $80, right?6:56And I open it, I taste it, and I say,6:59This is horrible, right?7:01And then I go and I advertise.7:02Let's say I'm able to somehow show everybody,7:04Look, it's all bad to everybody, right?7:07And I show the company, Don't buy this wine bottle.7:10It's full of— it tastes horrible.7:12Whose problem is it really?7:14It's my problem because I didn't store it properly.7:16It's the same thing with all these beans and these dried foods.7:19If you store it in rice and— if you store it in a cool place, it won't become7:25wormy. So if the store doesn't store it properly,7:27if you don't store it properly, of course it's going to be7:29wormy. They go around and they show videos, Look!7:31and they got people with beers and7:34mashgiachim. It's7:36שטויות והבל. Store properly.7:38God, show me something that he stored in the basement,7:40in a cool place. Show me bugs.7:42But what happens? Everything goes crazy.7:44They found one or two cases, and they posel everybody.7:48So the damage, if it's a Jewish company, is horrendous.7:51It's crazy.7:52You're motzi shem ra on people7:54because you are an idiot and you didn't store it properly,7:56and you motzi shem ra and you—8:00You're scaring everybody. Nobody can eat it. Now it becomes a bug problem. It's not a bug problem. It's an order problem.8:08But nobody verifies. And now that's also another issue.8:11But I can even give you worse cases, when people start spreading rumors about other people.8:15They took a picture. You saw how this lady acted. You saw what this guy did. You saw what this rabbi did. You saw what this person did.8:22Nobody verifies. Get the video, you laugh, you believe it, and you forward it,8:28right? That is a huge, huge, huge problem. And we come back now to the momo challenge.8:32We just believe everything.8:34Momo challenge, people are scaring their kids and saying, Look, there's Momo. It's gonna get you.8:38My kids, who don't even know how, don't have a clue, don't have internet, don't have anything, they're all talking about Momo.8:44What does my older son do?8:47He sees, like, you know, so he starts saying a joke, Momo's gonna get you.8:53Then he gave the joke, right? So does he even know what Momo is?8:56Nothing, but he's talking about it.8:57He sees that the younger ones falling for it, so he gets attention.9:00That's what happened with us adults,9:03right? Momo got attention, so everybody starts spreading it.9:05Oh, now people started really coming out with videos.9:07That creates more problems.9:09But what I'm trying to say over here is that when you scare your kids based on Momo,9:14and they get older and they realize that Momo's9:16sheker, so only admit that you said the 99% אמת that you did tell them, the warning about the real dangers of the internet.9:22Because of that 1%, you lost your validity.9:27They don't believe anything you say.9:29We cannot base things on9:31sheker. If I come and I teach you a halacha and I teach you9:34a mussar based on a lie that I did because I'm going to do something right,9:36I'll discover one day, and it can be 30 years down the drain,9:40that it was a lie, you start to doubt every single thing that I said,9:43and even if I've never lied about anything else.9:44It's the same.9:47He said, and he was lying.9:49Who knows what else he's lying about?9:51That's how people are.9:52Therefore, we don't raise out based on9:55kezavim; it's something else. And that's what happens with this guy who's learning9:57shelo l'shem shamayim. He's learning because of that reason.9:59He's learning because he wants to become—he wants to get10:02that hana'ah. He realizes that the rich man doesn't want to buy the account from him.10:06The rich man changes shoes; he doesn't learn anymore.10:09So the yetzer hara, that's what the yetzer hara is doing.10:11He knows that from the beginning,10:12yetzer hara. So he gets you to come learn for this wrong reason.10:15What's going to happen when you learn for the wrong reason?10:17The moment you don't have the reason, you're going to drop the whole thing altogether.10:21But he's going to get you completely focused on that wrong reason,10:24and now you can understand the Mishnah,10:30Pirkei Avot: Kol ahavah she'teluyah b'davar, batel davar, batelah ahavah. Mishnah says any love for10:32anything—we always use it for love for10:34people—but it's telling you even love for anything.10:36You love Torah, why?10:38Teluyah b'davar, because of something.10:40Why do you love Torah?10:41Because when I learn Torah, I'm becoming close to that rich man.10:46When I learn Torah, I'm going to become a rabbi.10:49But you lost that position.10:50They hired somebody; you don't have a position anymore.10:55Batelah ahavah, batel davar. When the reason is gone,10:57batelah ahavah. And we don't want Torah to be that way.10:58Yirat Hashem, Torah11:00omedet la'ad, says it's a klal pasuk.11:01Yirat Hashem is pure; it stands forever.11:03Pirush she'tema'alot yesh kishlonim yirat Hashem,11:05but if you do it because yirat11:07Hashem—what does it mean, yirat Hashem?11:08Let's define it right now.11:10Fear of Hashem. There's a certain fear:11:12I don't want to do the wrong thing.11:13I want to do what Hashem wants me to do.11:15Now, of course, there's levels and levels.11:16It can get higher and higher and better and a better relationship,11:19instead of being the scary cat every time.11:20But that's where it starts.11:22I want to do the right thing. I don't want to do the wrong thing.11:24When you first come to a new job and they're paying you tons of money,11:28imagine somebody's hiring, they're giving you $700,000 a year.11:32Right? Beautiful.11:33So the first thing is, you ask 10,000 questions.11:36I just want to make sure I do everything right.11:38Good?11:39So now he says, that's why I'm learning Torah.11:41I want to make sure I'm doing everything right.11:43He says, what happens,11:44what are the ma'alot when you're learning with At Hashem?11:46Number one,11:49shebe'atah tzomed hu b'taharah u'vifnei echad, chas v'shalom. Number one is that when I'm learning, it's with purity,11:52Baruch Hashem.11:53I'm doing it, as I'm learning, it's good,11:56not just the result.11:57Number two is,11:59this learning will stay with me forever and ever.12:01And that's the meaning of this pasuk,12:05Ve'atah tavle mat'amotav. What does it mean12:06when the pasuk says, Don't desire his food?12:10Achshav, ki gam b'et halimud hu ra. Don't desire the food that he's giving you,12:12food which is right now.12:13Why? Because even as you're learning,12:15that's not a good thing.12:17And also, pasuk says,12:23Hu lechem kezabim, which means, ... peniyot, tafsik lilmod. You'll also stop learning.12:25Now, I thought that we're going to do12:27Yud Bet today, but I made a mistake.12:28We did Yud Aleph again,12:30but it was a very nice piece.12:31I think we got into a big lesson about chinuch as12:35well. Baruch Hashem, amen, amen.