Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 13Sefer Even ShelemaPart 133Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:21Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:20Even shelema perek ot yud alef. Kemo shebalechem hagufani yesh teben u'motz vesubin u'mursan. Real physical food and0:59bread. When they come to make bread, so the way it's done is that they go to the field, they cut off the wheat stalks. The wheat stalks have a long stem, and on top of it is what they call—it's where the kernels are—senabel. You know what's it called right now in1:29English? It's the whole head of the wheat stalk. Okay, then they take out the kernels, but the kernels really are coming into a shell, that little, small little shell, very, very small little shell, like kind of like—not like sunflower seeds, not that heavy, but it's a little lighter of a shell, and that's called subin. And then you take it out of that, and then there's—you slice it in1:32a certain way also, and then you grind it to make it into flour. It has to be, again, sifted and sifted and sifted until you get the pure grain flour, the way we have it today. So he says, just like—now if you buy whole wheat, you just take the whole thing, you know what I'm saying? Okay. Now, just like in1:52the physical real bread, there's the teben, which is the straw, right? That's that long stem; u'motz, that's the head; and subin, and the shell; u'mursan, and then there's like some of the dirt. Vetzarich lechamem min hachodesh asu lechem, and you need a lot of different melachot. The Mishnah, Masechet Shabbat, lists eleven different steps till we get bread, right? From zeri'ah, and let's say even from ketzirah onwards, you still need to be memare'ach. There's a lot of steps, right? Ken baTorah shekatuv ba—okay, sorry, let's come back. Ken baTorah shekatuv ba, lechu lachmu בלחמי. So too, when Shlomo HaMelech says regarding the pasuk, Go, lachmu בלחמי. Which pashut pshat means, Go eat my bread.5:59We know that Chazal tell us that Shlomo HaMelech was hinting to the Torah. He's talking about Torah, but he called the Torah bread. It's not random that he called it bread. Why did he call it bread? So he says, V'zehu kol amal haTorah l'hotzi halacha berurah. And so it's just like bread. It's not a simple thing. We buy it today very easy. We go to the shul and pick it off, and that's like somebody going and picking off an article off the shelf or listening to a class, randomly recorded. But there was work that was done to get to that point. You're just getting it ready. So too, the bread that you got, there was work that was done till you got to become bread. You just came and picked it off because, you know, you didn't do any work, but somebody did do work to get to that point, and that's what we're telling you also over here. When it comes to Torah, there are many, many melachot, many steps in6:02order to really get the halacha clearly. And that's the meaning also when the Torah says that after the curse, or after the chet of Adam HaRishon, after the sin of Adam HaRishon eating from the etz hadaat, eating from the forbidden tree, what happened is that Hashem tells him that the ground will start to sprout thorns and weeds, and it's not going to be easy now. Now you got to select the good from the bad, right? And that's the same thing when it comes to Torah. Also, you will go through the Torah, right, and you'll see that throughout the Torah there are people. Sometimes, unfortunately, that's the reality, and I have to tell you the truth is there are people that are off, even they wrote books. I was just reading a text recently somebody sent me. The guy is off. There's no proof whatsoever from this book. Now this is a guy who I believe is off anyway, mentally and everything. He has, I believe, he has psychological problems, and nice putting in6:06the Torah. The guy is off. But I'm not dealing with that right now. Let's say even with sometimes, sometimes there are mistakes, Gedolei Torah, big talmidei chachamim, sometimes can make a mistake. And, right, as Baruch Hashem, you see sometimes that somebody good, let's say a chacham עובדיה יוסף, right, he'll come up with a—Baruch Hashem, he passed away—but sometimes, you see in certain books that he wrote a certain halacha one way, many years later he wrote different, and he says, I'm chozer. I learned the sugya again, and I made a mistake. And that's a shevach, that's a great praise. We have Gedolei Torah like that that admitted mistake and say, Hey, I made a mistake. I researched it again, I see many different opinions. I was not aware of them, and okay, here you go, I refined it. So people that make mistakes—everyone makes, we're all human, we all make mistakes. But even in6:08sometimes in6:12the learning itself, right, a very shallow way of learning, we can, for a certain level, okay. But a very shallow way of learning is everything that's written, that's okay, we accept. For who wrote it, right? That's the first. Oh, somebody of authority, okay, that's a very big thing. But then when you get to a higher level, and now you start learning, start understanding, you start saying, Hold on, things just don't make sense. Yes, this opinion wrote it, but I have seventy opinions saying not that way. And also it doesn't fit according to that opinion when you go and ask. Look at the Gemara. Whoever learns Gemara sees, the Gemara says an opinion, Amar Rav, whatever, right? He says the halacha. All of a sudden the Gemara comes and says, Ah, v'ha tanya—what do you mean? The beraita doesn't say like that. And according to this beraita, you see, and then the Gemara says, Tiyuvta. You knocked out—I'm sorry, buddy, this is, we don't accept it. Ela mechavrata—no, no, no, no, no, okay, okay, that's not correct. The correct answer is this way. So you see, even in6:15Gemara itself, the rabbis have said their opinion, but after analysis and digging through it, you got to the right halacha. You don't accept just everything. But again, on the first level is, like we said, there's levels in6:16learning. So, but you see, just like bread also. You come to make bread—no, no, no, this is not a good grain. No, this one, there's shells over here. It's not a good flour. You sift till you get the right thing. Listen to what he says now. והלומד לשמה דומה למי שאוכל פת נקייה על הסובה. A person learns l'shem Shamayim. We're going to talk about what l'shem Shamayim — I don't want to say what l'shem Shamayim means, because we always talk about learning l'shem Shamayim, right? And we have a famous Gemara that says, לעולם יעסוק אדם בתורה ומצוות שלא לשמה, שמתוך שלא לשמה בא לשמה, right? All this will be defined in6:36this perek, בעזרת השם, by the Gra, so I don't have to — you don't need my opinion. He says, a person who learns lishmah, a person learns for the sake of the Torah, דומה למי שאוכל פת נקייה על הסובה, is similar to a person who eats clean bread to be full. כן הוא העוסק לשמה זוכה להשיג קיום התורה, which means if you're eating bread to be full, it's great.6:40You're hungry, you eat, you feel full, you have energy, you go out, it's great.6:44And that's the same person whose same idea when a person is learning6:47l'shem Shamayim, he learns the Torah and he gets6:51— Hashem gives him siyata d'shmaya — he accomplishes his goal, he gets to understand really what the kavana of the Torah really means,6:57וגם מתקיים בידו, and not only that, it's also, he zocheh that he's able to carry it with him, right?7:04Sometimes people learn it and they're not zocheh to fulfill what it says.7:09They don't have that zechut.7:10They learn about a mitzvah of, I don't know,7:16a very rare mitzvah — I don't know what a rare mitzvah7:19— okay, owning lands in Eretz Yisrael, right?7:22So you can do the mitzvot. There's about twenty, thirty mitzvot that you can do7:26if you own land in Eretz Yisrael, pe'ah and all these things.7:28So you learn about it, you're not zocheh to keep it.7:31Sometimes a person is zocheh — he owns real estate7:34in Eretz Yisrael, and he's zocheh that he should do, you know, in his real estate some mitzvot.7:38That's a big, big zechut that he's able to mekayem the mitzvah.7:44וכמו שאמרו, לוקמיה גירסא סייעתא דשמיא. And sometimes, right, the Gemara says,7:47Megillah, to be mokim the girsa, to get it right,7:51you need siyata d'shmaya. אבל הלומד שלא לשמה דומה למי שאוכל...8:00Pasuk is lo l'shem shamayim, it's like he's eating the bad8:05part. You know, and he's not eating to be full.8:08We are in a very good time to understand this example.8:11We are less than a week after Purim,8:15and think of how much junk you ate not8:21l'sova. At this age, right, kids, my kids are loving it.8:25This is gan eden, right? For us older people, it just happened to me the other day.8:28My wife was not feeling well8:32on Sunday, the whole Sunday she was in bed. So what am I going to eat? I don't want to be meat for lunch.8:35I want to call, you know, you don't know if you need that coffee,8:38right? So I'm looking for food,8:40but then I see all the8:43mishloach manot. So I'm not—this is not food, it's junk.8:45Okay, I'm just going to take a taste,8:46make a beracha. Let me make all the8:51berachot. Ha'etz, adama, shehakol, mezonot. Okay, I got all the berachot, good. Now I'm covered, now I can eat whatever I want,8:54right? And I felt so horrible afterwards,8:57not because of guilt, I don't care, weight and not9:00weight. You just feel heavy,9:02feel—feels good when you eat that chocolate,9:04but me, I get pimples,9:05right? I feel something popping up somewhere in my body.9:07And then I feel like, ugh,9:11and then like, you're not full.9:12At the end of the day, you're not full.9:14You ate, you ate, you ate, you ate,9:16you think—I went to kollel, I'm still not feeling full.9:18There was no real food,9:19right? But I didn't want to get meat,9:20you know what I'm saying?9:23So that is, that's junk.9:25Snacking or junk, you know, eating the junk,9:27it's not healthy for you.9:29It's bad for your body,9:31and it's also—you don't actually get full.9:34Says the Gra, that's the same thing of a person who learns shelo l'shem shamayim.9:37But you know what looks good?9:39It tastes good at the moment.9:41Tell me what looks better. What looks better,9:43a sandwich, a bagel with cream cheese, or chocolates,9:48and then the fudge and the ice cream?9:50What looks more tempting?9:52There's no question what looks more tempting.9:54And also, a person who learns a lot of Shema also sometimes looks more tempting.9:58Woo, he could come and tell you10:00chidushim. Is it emet or not10:03emet? It doesn't make a difference, right?10:05But it's l'shelo lishma, and he could quote you things,10:07da da da da. When10:09it's l'shelo lishma, then it's not,10:11you know, at the end of the day it's like eating junk.10:13It looks good, but it's not good.10:18And that's the meaning.10:20When it says in the pasuk, Yirat Hashem is pure,10:22it stands forever.10:26Sheb'limud b'yirat yesh שתי מעלות. When learning in yirah, right,10:29learning with yirat Hashem, there's two levels.10:32Shehi tehorah b'et ha-limud. What is that?10:33As you're learning, it's pure10:36for the sake of learning,10:38and also gives you the10:39taharah, and also it stays with you forever and ever.10:43Okay?10:45Next.10:46Now, on the side,10:48happens to be there's a lot of stuff over here on the side.10:51I'm debating which one should we go through.10:56Okay,10:57I want to go to11:00Yud Chet. Everybody see it?11:01Okay.11:02It says on a pasuk in11:06Mishlei, pasuk says,11:09Shav u'dvar kazav harchek mimeni. Shav, which means nonsense and lies,11:13distance from me.11:15Comes the Gra and says, Ki yesh shnei minim ra'im b'limudei Torah. There are two bad things where people will learn Torah.11:21Ha'echad, ha-lomed mipniyot will conter. A person who learns with ulterior motives.11:25He has his own reasons of learning, not because of what Hashem told him.11:28He has, you know, plans of why he wants to learn,11:35will conter also to knock people. V'hu nikra shav. This is called, you know, waste of time, basically11:45nothingness. Shebet lavo, aven tamud bechubo uvlibo mirma. When he is learning, evil is lurking inside.11:49I want to learn so I can knock.11:51I want to learn so I can show people that I know better than them.11:53Vecheni, another evil thing when people learn Torah,11:57shelomed bli shum pniyah. He doesn't learn with any, you know, with any, like, goals that are not12:06lshem shamayim. Ela sheachar kach poresh atzmo meTorah uposek lilmod. He's learning, stam, but afterwards he doesn't want to learn anymore.12:11He stops learning, he falls out of it.12:15Vazeh anu mispalelim lmaan lo nigala larik vlo nelehabalah. It's what we say every morning12:18in Uva LTzion: Hashem, make sure that when we learn,12:20that our hard work should not be for emptiness12:24and that should not be for waste,12:26right? Anybody who is at work,12:27anybody who works knows this feeling.12:29When you work on a project and it doesn't go through,12:32what a waste of time.12:34What a waste of time,12:38right? You work, you know, like, remember, I can tell you many, many things,12:40but this is, I know for sure you guys at work probably feel it much more.12:43You work on a client12:45over, over, you know, not your business,12:47but other people's business,12:48right? You're working on a client, you keep on emailing him12:50and you keep on saying, yeah, and they look interested,12:51and you meet and you meet and you meet and you meet.12:55So at the end of the day, we're not interested.12:57And you put your hopes up,12:58you build like a whole12:59thing in your mind, and everything13:01from this guy, you're gonna go up,13:03you got nowhere.13:05Now what's worse than that is when they take your idea.13:08That's even worse.13:09But let's say we're not that bad.13:10So, it's the same thing in the Torah.13:13How could that be? What do you mean?13:13Didn't we learn that if you learn,13:15itself is an accomplishment?13:17So what does it mean,13:19lo nigala larik vlo nelehabalah? The answer is that—