Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 10Sefer Even ShelemaPart 130Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:009:52Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:08בן שנמה פרק ח׳, אות ח׳, דף קוף ה׳. מה שאמרו כל שיראת חטא קודמת לחכמתו, חכמתו מתקיימת. Famous Mishnah in Pirkei Avot. Pirkei Avot says, anybody whose sin—excuse me—whose fear of sin, יראת חטא, his fear of sin precedes his wisdom,0:22the Mishnah says over there, חכמתו מתקיימת, his wisdom will be able to survive,0:33will be around. What does that mean? העניין, כי כשיש בו יראת חטא, says the אבן שלמה, is the idea behind this is that when a person has fear of sin,0:41אז הוא מחפש בלמודו לדעת את הדרך אל החכמה. Then when he is learning, he is learning in order to find out what he should do,0:47how he is going to apply his learning, because he’s scared that he’s going to do the wrong thing.0:55And the nature of a person—listen to this—you want to remember your learning, this is how you remember it.1:00When you’re looking for something, and you’re looking for something for a long time,1:06and you find it, you love it more and you remember it better.1:10If you notice, a lot of classes, especially speeches, begin with a question.1:15The idea of the question is to create an interest that you want to know,1:19that you’re going to want to know, and when you want to know it and you have that interest,1:23you’re going to remember it better.1:25So this is the same thing when it comes to learning Torah.1:30He says, the Gra says, being that you’re a person1:34who’s ירא חטא, and you care so much about not making a mistake and not doing something that Hashem doesn’t want you to do,1:40so what are you going to end up doing?1:42You’re going to end up learning with that kavanah to make sure that you’re doing the right thing,1:45and you’re looking for it, you want it,1:48and because you want it, you’re going to remember, you’re going to retain it better,1:52and you’re going to love it even more.1:55אבל, however, מי שאין בו יראת חטא, a person doesn’t have fear of sin, eh, he couldn’t care.2:00Of course, he won’t do aveirot. He’s not scared of2:04the aveirot. Okay, so big deal, you know, aveirah happens. Okay, yalla, do teshuvah, it’s okay, it was an accident.2:09אף כשלומד כמה פעמים, אינו מוצא. If he’s learning a number of times, he won’t find success in his learning,2:13כי אינו חביב בעיניו, because— Didn't care too much about it. They didn't care to know that point2:19because he wasn't looking for it anyway.2:22He didn't care to know if it's asur or not asur.2:25It was more information. He wanted to finish, you know, he wanted to finish the masechet. He didn't want to know the information.2:31And he's quoting over here a famous2:34Chazal. The Gemara says,2:38And anything that a person is not paying attention to it, he doesn't know about it.2:42We apply this in2:43halacha. For example, let's say a person took a spoon that was dairy2:46and he used it to mix a meat pot.2:51Now, and the spoon was used within 24 hours,2:54which means it was ben yomo.2:56So we say that the flavor of the dairy in the spoon came into the meat pot.3:04How much was in the spoon?3:08So he says, since he didn't know it was a dairy spoon, right, obviously because he mixed it, he didn't know.3:13So anything that you don't know, you don't pay attention to the details.3:16You don't know how much of the spoon went in,3:17because if you knew you were doing issur, you'd pay attention how much issur went in.3:21Here you didn't know.3:23So that's what the Gemara says:3:26Anything that a person has no responsibility of knowing, he doesn't pay attention to it.3:30And that's the same thing when it comes to3:32Torah. If you're learning a subject that, you know,3:34let's say you're learning right now about halachot of beit3:38hamikdash, most people don't pay attention to the details.3:39You know why?3:40Because they know there's no beit hamikdash yet.3:42Of course they say, We want beit hamikdash, but they're not thinking, How am I going to use it in the beit3:47hamikdash? But now that we're learning Hilchot Purim,3:49and tonight is Purim, and tomorrow is Purim,3:50and you want3:51to—whoa, whoa, one second.3:52So tomorrow this is what I do, right?3:54Holiday halachot, people pay much more attention to3:58because they know they're going to keep it right away.4:00And therefore, because you want to know, you pay attention to it,4:04and you end up retaining that information.4:10Let's go to the source over here in the4:13Gra, and then maybe we'll do some of the piece on the side.4:15So it's only one letter,4:17yud-gimel. It's not such a long piece.4:19It says in the pasuk in Mishlei, perek aleph,4:21Yirat Hashem4:22reshit da'at. The fear of Hashem is the beginning of knowledge.4:25He says,4:28kan hu hatchalat ha-sefer. He says on this pasuk, which is pasuk4:33zayin, he says that's really where the book of Mishlei begins,4:35because the first six pesukim is more of an introduction,4:38but here's the beginning of the book.4:42And in the first six pesukim,4:45Shlomo HaMelech is telling us the purpose of the book4:47and the author of the book and why it was written.4:49He says, and now he's explaining to you,4:52when he said that the purpose of the book of4:55Mishlei is to know,4:58v'lemoa achshav sheyir'ah hi tachlat da'at, he's now coming to explain to you,5:00how do you get to know?5:01How do you get to know the ways of Hashem?5:03Number one is5:05yir'ah, right? Fear of sin.5:10Like Chazal told us,5:11anybody whose fear of sin is before his wisdom,5:14his wisdom will remain.5:19Because if a person has fear of Hashem,5:21then he's going to learn in order to5:24know how to protect himself5:25from staying away from whatever it may be.5:32And the normal nature of a person5:34is that when he wants something5:36and he finds what he wants,5:40it's beloved on him,5:41and it stays with him.5:42But for a guy who doesn't have fear of Hashem,5:46he doesn't care of doing5:49aveirot, even if he learns a bunch of times,5:51he won't find any success in his learning.5:54It's not learning that he should know what to be careful from5:59and we apply to him.6:02Anything that people don't care too much about,6:05they won't know its details either.6:07And over here they bring on the bottom6:10הנהגות from what the Gra says on the Gemara,6:13Masechet Shevuot. Let's6:15look on6:23the bottom. The Gemara says,6:23and he connects it to another Gemara.6:25The Gemara says that if a person6:27eats without a6:29beracha, he's6:30ma'al. It's like he stole from Hashem,6:32right?6:33You didn't make a6:34beracha. You used something that belonged to Hashem;6:36you used it for your own self.6:37So the Gemara says,6:38mai takantei? What does he do?6:39Yelech etzel chacham v'ילמדנו. He should go to a wise man,6:43which means to a rabbi,6:45and he'll teach him6:46hilchot berachot. And on that it says,6:50v'zeh she'amar, im ein yir'ah, ein chochmah. This is the meaning of6:52im ein yir'ah, ein chochmah. If there's no fear,6:54that means if you don't care about6:56knowing,6:57if you don't care about making6:58berachot, you won't care to go7:00and find out what the berachot are.7:03Only because you care that you don't want to steal from Hashem,7:07you care to make the7:07berachot, then you're going to want to know7:09how to make a7:10beracha. And it's a very, very important thing7:12that this yirat chet means.7:14It's a rule to learning Torah.7:16You have to care.7:18You have to care to do the right thing,7:19and when you care to do the right thing,7:22your learning will retain with you.7:25There's a story that I heard,7:26I remember once,7:28we're learning,7:29and in yeshivot,7:30most of the time, most of the yeshivot,7:32especially7:33Ashkenazim, which is where I learned,7:34they learn,7:35what do you call it,7:36they focus more on Gemara.7:37And even Sefardi yeshivot,7:39they focus more on the Gemara.7:39I don't want to make it just an Ashkenazi thing,7:42but even more so in Ashkenazi places.7:44Anyway, when I was learning there,7:45so if you want to learn7:47halacha, you do it on your own.7:48So I had a very good friend of mine7:50over there in7:51yeshiva. He was a very, very, very strong student,7:56and, you know, he cared very much about learning.7:58He was a serious learner.8:00And we were trying to learn halacha together,8:03so we open up8:04Mishnah Berurah. Those who are not familiar with8:06Mishnah Berurah, Mishnah Berurah is not an easy book to learn halacha from.8:09It's not.8:10If you learn Mishnah halacha8:14with somebody who knows,8:15then it makes it easier.8:16But if you're just learning on your own,8:18it can be very confusing,8:19especially if you're a beginner.8:20You don't know what's going on,8:21what's flying, right?8:23So the learning,8:25we're having a hard time remembering.8:27Like we learn something, a week later,8:28like, what did we learn?8:29We didn't know8:30any. So we went to8:33one ... Sometimes we learn,8:34we put our8:35toil, we put our work,8:36and then we fall out of it.8:39Stop.8:40So what happened to our learning?8:41Yeah, we learned good then,8:43but we're not continuing.8:44We almost kind of regret what we did.8:47That's ... becomes.8:52There’s two types of8:53ladies that don’t have children8:54from two different reasons.8:55One is עקרה אשר לא ילדה. One is a woman who is barren,8:58never gave birth.9:03ואחדה, היא יולדת וקוברת, והיא היולדת לבנים. The other lady is,9:04she also does have kids,9:05but why?9:06She had kids,9:07but ... they died, right?9:09And therefore it comes out9:10that all the pain of childbirth,9:14all the pain of pregnancy,9:15and the pain of even raising children9:16really went for nothing.9:19So too when it comes to learning Torah,9:21there’s also two9:22bad things.9:25A person who is learning9:28just to knock other people down,9:31learning9:31nice, just wants to show9:32that he knows better9:33than everybody,9:33wants to show9:34that everybody’s wrong,9:35and that person’s work9:36is for9:40nothing. Torah shelomed hu reik ve’ein bo mamash. Torah he’s learning is just nothing,9:42waste of time.9:44This is a lady9:45that never gave birth9:46because from the beginning9:47it was nothing.9:50The second is ...