Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 8, Lesson 1Sefer Even ShelemaPart 121Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:48Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Even Shelema, Perek Chet, Ot Aleph. We're beginning a new perek.0:05In this perek, the Gra deals, or the Even Shelema deals, with the subject of the ways to learn,0:12and ענייני לשמה, which means doing things for the right reasons,0:17and פנימיות התורה, which is the deep, deeper stuff of the Torah, which could also mean a little bit of Kabbalah.0:25Let's see. Aleph. Let's begin with the first piece,0:28and you see over here it's a little bit of a longer piece.0:32Bezrat Hashem, we'll try to finish it today.0:34כמו שבאומנות צריך ללמד אומנות נקייה שאין בה גניבה ואיסור וקלה.0:41The Gemara, Masechet Kiddushin, and over here they're quoting Masechet Berachot as well,0:46that a person, לעולם ילמד אדם לבנו אומנות נקייה וקלה. A person should always train his kids,0:53because we want our kids, right, to grow up and to become men on their own or women on their own,0:59and to be in life, to be able to support themselves and not always come back to daddy and mommy.1:06So because of that, the Gemara says, so when you're training your son in a profession,1:11teach him a profession that's clean.1:13What does it mean, clean? It means there's no stealing,1:16there's no issurim that have to be done.1:17There's some professions that are just not clean, right?1:20Sometimes the business may be just a business based on people, you know, ripping off people or stealing from people.1:27That's not the business you want to teach your son to go into.1:30Or sometimes the business may be clean of geneivah, but it contains other1:35issurim, because you're teaching him a profession.1:37Let's say he's a photographer of models.1:40That's not nekiyah, right?1:42It might be he's not stealing from anybody,1:43he's hired by professionals, but it's not1:46nekiyah. And also it should be easy, light,1:49because otherwise he's going to let it go and try to do something, you know, wrong.1:53So just like that's the way Chazal have warned us when it comes to training our children with certain professions,2:03also when you're trying to learn, don't try to learn something above your head.2:08Try to learn something that is easy, that's to your ability, that you won't come to hate.2:14What does it mean,2:16nekiyah? Nekiyah means that you shouldn't have—it's clean—that it shouldn't be a subject that will get you misinformed very, very easily.2:26As some people, you know, they learn certain subjects and they interpret it in their own way.2:30It should be clear, very clean, clear what the message of the Torah is.2:36Now I'm going to talk about this a little bit more in detail.2:38We just want to see what the Ibn Ezra first says, then we'll come back.2:42וכן התינוקות לא יחבירו עליהם. So too, when teaching children, we're not talking about babies, we're talking about children. Even when teaching children, don't be too heavy on them.2:51Ki im benachat. You don't want to be too imposing, too2:55enforcing, and too—no, no breaks, no, no vacations, no outlets.2:59You got to be easy on them,3:01and benachat, and nice, vlatet lahem perutot, and to give them a little bit of3:06money. Basically, give them incentives.3:10Ki limud eino nikba badam ki im byeshuv benachat. You want Torah to stick by a person, it's only going to stick when it comes calmly, when it comes in a soft way.3:19It's not going to—not in a way that's going to be, you know, enforced upon a person.3:26Vtsarich shelimdu mikodem kol hachamash, says first also train them. To study the whole Chumash,3:32and then you can build on that, because everything comes from the Chumash.3:35And he says almost that you should remember by heart.3:37Not that you necessarily have to remember by heart, right?3:41Because there's halachot of, you know, for a person who's allowed to quote pesukim by heart or not; it has to be3:47written. But the idea is that you should be very, very well knowledgeable in the Torah,3:53and you can build from there. You can build on top of that.3:56Okay, so there are three points over here.3:58Number one is what to teach something to your children, or even to ourselves,4:04but in something, you know, just like in profession,4:06Chazal told us it has to be a profession that's clean and easy,4:11so too our learning.4:12Easy doesn't mean over here that there's no4:15toil. We already spoke about a person toiling or putting a little bit of effort to try to learn Gemara.4:20But don't learn something that's way above you.4:23Don't learn something, Kabbalah and all these different things, are way above you and you don't have no clue what you're doing,4:27because eventually you're going to fall out of it.4:28And even Gemara,4:30if Gemara, if you're picking a subject in Gemara, it's very difficult.4:33You go into a shiur, ah, you know, you're sitting in a class where they're learning Gemara on a very high level4:39or a halacha on a very high level, then you're going to eventually fall out of it,4:44right?4:45The word yakutz va, which means you come to translate, despise it today, means you'll fall out,4:50you'll burn out.4:51So same thing, a person has to know himself4:54and start building yourself.4:56Build your brain muscle.4:58Build your Torah muscle.5:00Start with a little bit and go higher and higher,5:03because everything is exciting in the beginning,5:06and when things are exciting, people push themselves to do a lot,5:10and when they do a lot, they could crash afterwards.5:13So that's why do it in steps.5:15Don't jump too high.5:16Take it in small steps going up.5:19So that's what he's saying over here:5:20push yourself.5:22Yes, push yourself, but not too much.5:24Push yourself to the extent that you could handle.5:27So let's look on the side where he brings it5:31from the Gra's commentary on that particular5:34masechet, where it talks about teaching your children a clean profession.5:39He writes over there the following words:5:44It says,5:49A person should always train his son with a profession that's clean and light.5:54Mai hi? What is it?5:55The Gra says,5:59Machatah de-talmiyuta. It's needlework,6:01right?6:01It's clean.6:03You're sewing.6:04You're making—you know, back then,6:05you know, today we have machines for6:06that, but back then, you know, sewing to make, like, embroideries,6:09right? That's it, clean.6:11You're not seen from anybody,6:13and also it's pretty light.6:16It's pretty easy.6:17Remember, the Gemara never6:18said—it's interesting, right?6:19Today you ask somebody,6:21just anybody,6:22what's a profession you should go into?6:24What makes you the most money?6:26The Gemara never worried about that,6:28because as the books talk about,6:30when it comes to6:32bitachon, right,6:32Chovot HaLevavot and everybody else,6:34you have to work.6:34You know why Hashem made you work?6:36Because He wants to test you6:37and to keep you busy,6:38to keep you away from6:39aveirot. So when you're working6:41and you're doing what you have to do6:42because this is what you need to make6:44parnassah, all the extra will come by itself.6:46Al tedaag. Don't worry about it.6:47As long as you're making the minimum,6:49anything extra you're supposed to make,6:50you'll get it.6:51It doesn't have to come in the form of cash and6:54dollars. It could come in any other form.6:57If you need it, you'll have it,6:58and if you don't have it,7:00it must be that you don't need it.7:02In any case,7:03that's what the Gemara says.7:04Sorry, I went on a tangent for my own sake,7:07but let's come back to the words of the7:09Gra. The Gra writes on that:7:14The Gemara gives an example of making embroidery,7:17stitch,7:18stitching, sewing,7:19which is something that's clean.7:22There's no stealing,7:22there's no issur,7:24there's no davar metukan. You give the guy a ready garment.7:28What do you have to do? Just a little bit of sewing here and there.7:34It says the7:37Gra, when it comes to learning Torah, pick something that's light7:40that you're able to handle.7:42Don't pick something you can't handle.7:45U'nekiyah shelo yeheyeh ba peniyah. Nekiyah means also that,7:47like we said before,7:48the way we explained it,7:49is that it shouldn't be something that you could misinterpret.7:52That's point number one.7:54Point number two,7:54we said also do the same for children.7:56So the Gra writes in his famous letter,7:59it's called...8:00The Gra, when he sent to his wife, because the Gra, as we know, always used to travel. He put himself in galut.8:06He always used to travel, so he gave guidance to his wife how to raise the kids.8:10He says,8:12Gam le'banai sheyichyu, tegadli otam b'derech hayashar benachat. Raise them in the right way, and also calmly, softly.8:21Utshalmi sachar limud, vtachziki milamed bvitech, and pay for tuition, and pay a hire a person who's going to come and teach your children Torah.8:29Vlo tehi tzamtzemi bscharo, and don't be stingy when it comes to paying the salaries for teaching your children Torah.8:37Vyachmir aleihem kivanachat, and when you get this person who's teaching the kids, make sure you inform him that he shouldn't be too heavy on the kids.8:43He should be with softness, with kindness, with a pleasantness.8:49Kelimud eino noga badam kimishuv bnachat. The kid has to like his rabbi. The kid has to like his teacher,8:52because if he doesn't like them, the learning won't stick.8:58Utfazilahem pirutot vyoter, and give incentives to the kids, because kids are not really, they're not excited about learning.9:03So you got to give them incentives. You got to give them things to inspire them in their first beginning.9:07And that was point number two.9:09And then point number three, he says they should learn the whole Chumash.9:11Comes from the same letter,9:12and he writes over there,9:15Vyishnelmdu mikodem vyilmedu mikodem kol haChumash, sheyihyu regilim kimat bal peh, and they should learn the entire Chumash that should almost be9:22bal peh. And he says, he brings a story over here from Aliyot Eliyahu.9:26It's a sefer that was written about, you know, different things about the9:30Gra, and he says like this:9:39Sipel li haRav HaGaon Mori Yisrael, says this person who said over the following story9:44actually was in front of the Gra and he saw him when he was alive.9:53There was a certain sick person. He went to the doctors,9:55and the doctors told him that he should carry a bone of a dead person as a segulah to heal him.10:02But the choleh, the sick person, was a kohen.10:09So at that time, the rabbi said, the Gra said,10:12he should carry the tooth of a person.10:16You know how the Mishnah, the Ohalot, sheshin adam eino metameh, as the Mishnah explains in10:18Masechet Ohalot, that the tooth of a person is not metameh.10:20It's not considered one of the evarim to be metameh, or one of the bones of a person10:25to make a person tameh.10:27And therefore, Kohen can carry.10:28As we know, a Kohen cannot be around the tumah of a human being.10:33He10:38says, Rabbi Yochanan, then ... Rabbi Yochanan had ten children,10:41and he would go from house, and all of them died.10:46Rabbi Yochanan's tragic story.10:48And then he would, when the last one died, he took a small bone from the kid,10:53and he would walk around10:55when people were sitting avelut and they had also tragedies in their lives.10:59He would walk around and tell them,11:00This is what I have left over from all my children,11:03right? So Rashi explains over there,11:06etzem pachot mi'kisah. He would take a bone that's smaller than the size of a barley bean,11:10so this way he wouldn't have to be—he wouldn't become tameh11:15from, especially not him only, but he wouldn't make, let's say, the Kohanim in the room, he wouldn't make them tameh.11:24The11:31Rashbam explains that he, Rabbi Yochanan, carried the tooth.11:35When the same question was asked to another rabbi,11:38he momentarily forgot about this Mishnah about carrying the tooth.11:45And then the same rabbi who was there when the question was asked to the11:50rabbi reminded him. He says, Hey, remember the Mishnah about the tooth?11:53And right away he remembered.11:57He says, Wow, unbelievable.12:00How great are the words of the12:04Gaon. Then this rabbi who forgot the halacha, the second rabbi,12:07Rav Tzvi Hirsch, who forgot12:11this halacha, he says,12:14Hehu ve'abi ha-rav ha-moreh nal, lamdu mishnayot vachazru sheyadu al peh kol ha-mishnayot. He says he remembers learning,12:16and he remembers reviewing all these Mishnayot till he knew it by heart.12:21And now, so he says, this other rabbi,12:31I remembered the exact words,12:35and he remembered the content.12:36You know, some people remember the words.12:38He says, he remembered every word.12:39I remembered the idea.12:43And they both went, the father and the son,12:46they went to the Gaon of Vilna,12:48and they asked him, what's the better way,12:49to remember the ideas on the shas, to remember every word?12:57Knowing the words is not as important as knowing the content, the idea.13:03It's more important to know the idea than to remember the words.13:08He says, when it comes to the Torah13:12shebichtav, the Chumash, you should know the words.13:17But Torah shebaal peh, the Mishnayot, the Gemara, the words are not as important as the content,13:23to know the idea more13:26than—now this doesn't mean that a person, you know, who could remember the words,13:29of course try to remember the words,13:30because a lot of times the diyukim come from the words.13:32But the content is more important than the13:35words, if you have to choose.13:36By Torah shebichtav, the words are more important.13:39Very interesting.13:40On the bottom, they bring down over13:43here that they bring also from another place in the13:45Gra. He says,13:47there are three times when it comes to Torah:13:51one is when he's learning from his rabbi,13:53one is when he's learning on his own,13:56when he's teaching others.13:58He says that's the meaning of the14:03pasuk, שתה מים מבורך, drink water from a well.14:06That's talking when a person is learning from his rabbi.14:08And then,14:10ונוזלים מתוך בארך, and then drink from your own well,14:15when you learn on your own,14:17which means things that you produce.14:21And then it says, your springs should go outside,14:24that's when you go out and you start teaching others.14:27And there are three levels of a person's learning also,14:29right?14:30What you learn.14:31What you think about and you develop,14:34and then what you teach others,14:36those are three levels that everybody goes through.14:38I'm not sure why he's bringing it over here.14:40I guess he's just talking about also in the concept of learning.14:44Okay, Baruch... amen.