Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 7, Lesson 8Sefer Even ShelemaPart 112Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:06Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04אבן שלמה, פרק ז' אות ז'. Yesterday we did a big piece, אות ו', and the sources that he brings are pretty much0:10straightforward, because we went into it a lot. It was a big, big piece, and it already explained pretty much what the Gra says,0:15and there's nothing more that they add from the words of the Gra besides the fact that he quotes the actual words of the0:21Gra, but pretty much the summary was exactly the same.0:23Let's go now to אות ז', and he says like this:0:27כמו שהרעב, כשאוכל בעת רעבו, אז הוא לא להועיל.0:32Just like when a person is hungry and he's eating when he's hungry, then it helps him, right?0:40ואם לאו, עברה שעה ונחלש כוחו ואינו מועיל לו.0:42And if he doesn't eat when he's hungry and he's too weak, then it doesn't really help him so much.0:47כן בדברי תורה, לא תמתין עד שתפנה, שמא לא תפנה.0:51So0:53too by דברי תורה. Don't wait for the time that you're going to have free to be able to learn Torah.0:58A lot of people make this mistake, and they always say,1:02בעזרת השם, בעזרת השם, I'm going to learn, but right now there's too much going on in my life.1:05Let me take care of it, and then I'll go learn.1:09Because he says if you wait for that time, it's like a person who's eating when he's not hungry.1:15When does eating help you?1:17When you're hungry, right?1:18Think about this delicious meal that you probably had and you were hungry,1:22and imagine having the same meal and you just came from eating in your house.1:26It doesn't taste as good.1:28You don't really get the benefit.1:30Same thing, don't wait till the time when you're free.1:32Right now is the time.1:33When is the time? Now.1:34Don't wait for the time to be created.1:38וכן בעת שרוצים ללמוד, למד מהים שלא יאבד תורתך,1:43כמו שאמרו: חרבך כימו בידך, ובבינתך אל1:46תשען. He says also, to teach Torah.1:50When you have people that want to learn, teach them,1:54because if you don't teach them, you might lose that opportunity.1:58As Chazal tell us in Pirkei Avot, with the famous words,2:03Chaverecha kamocha b’yadecha. The friends will grab it from, you know, will grab that opportunity from you,2:13okay? Then when you teach Torah, you gain more from teaching, from your students,2:18more than what you gain from your friends,2:20and even more than you gain from your rabbis.2:22That’s why,2:24because the students sharpen the rabbi’s opinions.2:28You think you learned something and you understood it,2:30and I could testify to this so many times,2:34masechtot that I’ve learned on my own,2:35and I’ve learned them very well,2:36I thought I learned them very well.2:37I come and I teach it,2:39and you have about six, seven different opinions, really,2:43each one coming and understanding in their own way and challenging,2:46and really they’re trying to understand,2:47they’re not trying to knock out,2:48they’re trying to understand the Gemara,2:49and then it forces you to now rethink of what you always thought you knew2:55and to explain it in a better way.2:57And if you see some of the mefarshim in the back of the Gemara,3:01like let’s say the Maharam, he says this a lot,3:04even Maharsha, they had yeshivot, and he’ll say,3:07V’sha’al echad mehatalmidim. A lot of the peirushim, really if you think about it,3:10they’re only because somebody had a question,3:12somebody had something that wasn’t clear and they had to clarify for them,3:15and therefore it allowed you to create this3:18chidush. So that’s what he’s telling you:3:20when you have a chance, when there’s a time when the students learn from you,3:25learn with them.3:26Don’t lose the students, because otherwise others will take it.3:37V’chol sheken, shetzarich limod bnei beito shehem metzuyim etzlo hu mishkach, umi she’eino oseh ken yichalelu ruach. This is an unbelievable thing.3:39So important for every parent to hear.3:41Even more so, a person has to learn with his family, who are always around you.3:48Every Shabbat meal, they're always with us,3:50sometimes by3:52dinnertime. And sometimes some people have the opportunity also that they come home3:56and their kids are still up,3:58and you're able to learn with them.3:59Now, that doesn't mean force them.4:01Make it fun.4:03Make it something that's exciting.4:05Make it something that they want to do.4:07Not, Let's go, you have to learn,4:09you know, homework, they have to do homework.4:11And we say, Let's go do your homework,4:13ah, right? But to spend time with dad and to spend time with your husband, your wife,4:20whatever it is, that you can make it,4:23make, and, you know, when you want to have a good time with someone,4:27it doesn't make a difference what you're doing.4:29For those of us who are young enough to remember when we're dating,4:32and if I could take you back to when you're dating,4:34and the single guys, you know, I think most guys out here at least dated once or twice,4:39right? If you want to have fun with someone, you can go anywhere.4:41It doesn't have to be the place.4:43You don't have to go somewhere fun to be fun,4:45because you enjoy the company of the other person.4:47So you want to make it that you enjoy the company of your kids,4:51spend time with them.4:52Now, when you spend time with them, you can make it by doing anything.4:55Make a trip out of learning Torah,4:57and you can make it a great time,4:59just, you know, we learn and then we go to have a fun time.5:01But you learn5:03with them.5:10Unbelievable statement,5:11and this we have to go into it.5:13He says that even if you think you're not worthy.5:17Now, I don't know where he got this from,5:19because we have to see if he gets this from the5:20Gra or it's his own opinion,5:22the Ben Ish Chai's own opinion.5:23He says even... A person who is not really ra'ui, right?5:28He never had so much5:31chidushim. He only learned a little bit from his father.5:33He learned a little bit from the yeshiva.5:34Still, if you have Torah, teach it to others.5:38And don't say, Ah, who am I to teach?5:39Who am I to give over?5:41You heard some nice chidush, share it with others.5:43You just taught Torah to somebody.5:45Now, there is a little bit of a challenge,5:47because sometimes people say,5:49you know, you come to,5:50you know, people don't want to listen to you5:52because who are you to teach me?5:53Which is, I understand.5:54So in that place, you have to be a5:57chacham. And also, there's another thing that we have to keep in mind over here,6:00is that being that teaching itself6:03brings about a certain following,6:05and we're in the generation of following people, right?6:07In Twitter and Instagram,6:09there's followers. There's always people that want to follow.6:12So sometimes people will use this as a base to get a following,6:17and although it's6:18lo lishmah, but the fear over here is6:21that sometimes you might be teaching them the wrong things.6:23So if you know something clearly,6:25you heard it right, you understood it right6:27from your rabbi or from your father6:29or from whatever shiur Torah that you know is clearly6:32emet, you could say it.6:33And when they ask you something that you don't know,6:34you say, I don't know.6:35And that's for sure. That's praiseworthy.6:37That's unbelievable. That's fantastic. That's great.6:39Especially people on Shabbat,6:41that they invite people that are not religious6:42and they share with them Torah that they learned.6:44It's beautiful. That's fantastic.6:46The problem, like I said, is, or the fear is,6:49when people, you know, like you're teaching someone,6:52they say, like, Wow, you know so much,6:53and then they ask you something and you really don't know,6:56but because you feel embarrassed,6:57so you're going to have to make up an answer.6:59That's where it's scary,7:00and that's where a person has to be careful not to make up answers7:03and to say, I need lo yodea,7:05as Chazal tell us.7:07Train yourself to say,7:10איני יודע. Why?7:10When you say,7:12איני יודע, when you actually know,7:13then it's much easier when you don't know7:15to say, I don't know.7:17Okay. In any case, let's come back7:19and see the words of the7:22Ein Yaakov as they're brought in the7:23Gra, the source in the7:29Gra, okay? The Gemara says7:31in Masechet Berachot, Bar Kapara hava mezban7:35mile b'dinarei ad dechafant achol.7:37Bar Kapara used to sell,7:40you know, basically, I guess,7:41I don't know if it's literal or7:42not, but let's say it was literal,7:44he would sell words with money,7:46which means7:47maybe he was hired7:48to come and speak certain places.7:50He was, you7:50know, a man who had something to present,7:52and people would pay for his wisdom.7:54You know what he would say?8:00When you're hungry, come and eat. Wow. Unbelievable. People paid money to hear a lecture by Bar8:08Kapara, and what was his lecture? What was his speech? When you're hungry, you eat.8:14What? That's okay. Comes the Gra and says, Yeah, you know, people paid money because there's something deep over here.8:21He says, Rav Hai Gaon, who is one of the Geonim who lived about over a thousand years ago, writes,8:33If you eat when you're hungry, then it helps you. If you miss a time when you're hungry, eating when you're not hungry doesn't help.8:56Right? And Chazal tell us, anytime it says the word eating and drinking in Kohelet, the Midrash says it's talking about divrei Torah.9:05Like it says, Lechu lachmu בלחמי, and the Gemara says, What is that talking about? That's talking about eating bread, which means learning Torah.9:13So that's what Bar Kapara's wisdom was. He's telling you what? Divrei Torah. When you're hungry, you eat. You learn.9:21You have the opportunity to learn, you learn. Don't wait for opportunities to be created or better circumstances.9:29Sometimes people come to learn, they say, It's not comfortable yet. Let's wait till it gets warm. Start. Don't wait.9:37Don't wait for everything to be perfect. Start learning right away. The same idea is brought also in Imrei Noam, in the book also by the9:44Gra. And he says also, when a person is hungry, not just that the eating helps you. The way you eat, wow, what an enjoyment,9:55right? You eat b'taavon, you know, lemashal, lemashal, Friday night meal. Friday is a day you're tired, you're busy, you're running from place to place to get ready for Shabbat,10:06right? And then the food is cooking, the best food of the week is cooking. You come Friday night, you're hungry.10:13Eizeh achilah. Why is it so enjoyable? Besides the kedushah of Shabbat, I'm sure that also plays a role here, but also because you're starving.10:21I don't know if you ever gone to somewhere and you're really hungry, let's say a barbecue, and it took you so long to set it up,10:27and you're—but then when you're hungry and you're starving, and then you make that barbecue and finally it's ready, wow, wow, wow, wow, right?10:35It's enjoyable. You end up eating three times the amount that you think you could eat. Why? Because you're starving, you're hungry, and you can eat much,10:43and you enjoy the eating itself. Forget that it helps you better. You enjoy it much better also. It's the same thing with Torah.10:50When you're inspired to learn, learn. Yeah, but right now, you know, it's not so comfortable. Learn. You want to learn? Come,10:57walk into a shiur Torah, walk into a shul. You have books in the house, you're inspired. Don't wait. Go open the book and start learning.11:03Don't wait. Don't be distracted by other things. And then he says also, he brings the second point about teaching others.11:11The Gemara says, Bar Mazbin ta'aneh, ta'aneh d'abuch zabin. The son who sells figs to te'enim, it's the figs of your father you should sell. What does that11:23mean? He quotes, the Gra quotes a pasuk in Mishlei, it says, Notzer te'enah yochal piryah. One who guards the figs, he eats its fruits.11:33And he says, People who want to come to you, they want to learn from you, teach it to them. You shouldn't lose it.11:42Don't lose the opportunity. Sometimes, who knows if Hashem didn't give you that Torah in order to give it to others, right?11:55So here, the Gra says it, and even— A person who's not on the level, even if you learned a little bit, give it over.12:03People are learning from you. What did you hear today? Give it over,12:08okay? And he brings another place from the Gra that says, also on the same Gemara, he12:14says, even if you don't have your own chiddushim, even if you yourself are not a person who's able to come up with your own12:20chiddushim, your own insights in the Torah, still give over what you heard. Oh, I know, I heard this shiur from this rabbi.12:26Say it over. That's great. You pass it. Think about it. That's what we do, almost all of us today.12:31All of us, what are they doing? Quoting this opinion, that opinion, this, right?12:36Sometimes people have a skill of putting it together. Most of the time, there's barely any12:40chiddushim. Some people have chiddushim, Baruch Hashem. But even those who don't have chiddushim, what they're doing is they're giving it over:12:45this is what this one says, this is what this one says. Most of the books of our days is exactly that.12:49So for you to say, I heard from this rabbi this and that, that's wonderful.12:54Give it over, and you'll be zocheh, first of all, with the reward also of the other person that learns,13:00and you're learning something great. Okay, with that, we're done with Zayin.13:05... tomorrow.