Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 7, Lesson 11Sefer Even ShelemaPart 115Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:49Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:06Even shelema, perek zayin, ot yud. Sechar haTorah etz chayim. The reward of Torah is the tree of life. V'shel mitzvot Gan Eden. And mitzvot is Gan0:17Eden. You see that? We're getting to reward now. We're talking about reward now.0:21Habeitzim— I mean, excuse me, the Gra is telling us what it is.0:24V'hifcham, and the opposite is0:29charbo shel Malach haMavet v'Gehinnam. The opposite of etz chayim is the sword of Malach0:33haMavet, and the opposite of Gan Eden is Gehinnam.0:38Okay, what is going on? What in the world is this meaning?0:43It's a little bit Kabbalistic and a little bit0:46pshat. Let's see the Gra from Shir HaShirim.0:50He says—these are the words straight from the Gra.0:52The Gra says,0:54Ki yesh etz chayim v'Gan Eden. We know that the Torah tells us at the beginning of the creation of the world0:57that there was—Hashem made a1:01Gan, and nata, and He planted trees1:04betoch haGan, and there were two trees.1:07Toch sounds like in the center.1:08Maybe it was in the center, maybe it was just in the middle.1:11But it says over there there were two trees.1:12One is called etz chayim, and one is called etz1:16hadaat tov v'ra. He didn't want Adam to eat from etz1:19hadaat tov v'ra, and He was planning to let him eat from etz1:21chayim. And we know that after he ate from etz1:24hadaat tov v'ra, Hashem says—clearly in the Torah it1:26says—that, oh, he might go and eat etz1:28chayim, then he's going to be living forever.1:31So therefore, we need to take him out1:33before he gets his hands on the etz1:35chayim, on that tree of life.1:38Okay? So comes the Gra and says,1:40Ki yesh etz1:41chayim v'Gan Eden. There's etz chayim, and there's a tree of life,1:43and there's Gan Eden, the Garden of Eden.1:46Etz chayim l'machazikim ba, Torah,1:47and pasuk tells us in Shlomo HaMelech tells us,1:51who is zoche with that etz1:54chayim? Etz1:56hachayim hi lamachazikim bah. Vegan Eden? So therefore,1:58a person who holds on to the Torah,2:00whether you are learned, Torah,2:01it seems like over here from the pasuk,2:03as Chazal tell us,2:04machazikim bah, also even those who support Torah,2:06as zocheh to etz2:08hachayim. He says they're also zocheh to that tree of life.2:11Gan Eden, ... Gan Eden is for people who keep the mitzvot,2:17and people who keep the mitzvah of living in2:22Eretz Yisrael al pi halacha. Not just living in2:23Eretz Yisrael. There's a whole big—everybody always talks about mitzvah of2:27yishuv Eretz Yisrael. It's a big mitzvah, there's no question,2:29but it has to be done2:31al pi mishpat, with the proper2:32halachot, not just שם to live because2:34to claim that's our country and everything else.2:36I'm not taking any political stance over here.2:38I'm taking a religious stance over here.2:40It has to be2:43al pi mishpat, al pi halacha. Now, kemo shekatuv, like it says,2:45Melech bemishpat yaamid aretz.2:48Famous pasuk.2:49A king with justice is able to hold up the earth.2:53Ki tamid hayu tzrichim Bnei Yisrael2:55lihyot shenehem. Always throughout the Jewish people,2:56we always needed these two types of2:59avodot, these two types of things.3:00Lo yasur3:01shevet miYehuda. The Gemara tells us, for example,3:03Masechet Sanhedrin, on the pasuk3:07that Yaakov Avinu gives the berachah to Yehuda,3:10he says, Lo yasur3:13shevet miYehuda umechokek mibein raglav, says the Gemara.3:15What does it mean3:16that the stick, which represents3:18the asaya, you know, those who know Arabic,3:21right? You know, the stick that represents the leadership and the rulership.3:24What does that mean,3:25it won't go away from shevet Yehuda?3:27Says the Gemara, elu rashei galuyot.3:28Those are the leaders in galut.3:30Those are the ones who led the nation,3:32you know, like with the stick.3:34Umechokek mibein raglav. Mechokek means the person who engraves,3:36which means engraves3:37the chukim and puts the laws.3:40And who's the3:41mechokek? Says the Gemara, elu3:44melamdim Torah b'rabim. Those are the3:45talmidei chachamim that teach Torah to the public,3:46because they make sure that the3:49chukim, that the laws,3:50remain amongst the Jewish people.3:57אם כן, אלו מחזיקים במשפט, מנהיגי משפט הארץ, ולעולם יעשו ארץ, וגן עדן. Therefore, those who are machazik b'mishpat,3:59those who are the leaders,4:00who make sure that everything is running smoothly,4:02those who make sure that everybody is keeping4:13mitzvot, they're zocheh to yamid ארץ. They're zocheh לעולם יעשו ארץ. They're zocheh to the ארץ, which ארץ, ארץ החיים, that's Gan Eden. ואלו שמלמדים תורה, and the people who teach Torah,4:17who are עץ חיים, בזכות עץ חיים, they're the ones who are4:20the4:21עץ חיים, they're zocheh to that tree of life.4:24אבל חשבו שלום אינם עושים כן, but the people,4:25chas4:25v'shalom, are not doing so,4:28כי מבטלו. By the way, wasting their time4:30watching YouTube,4:31going on social media,4:33and wasting their lives.4:40אז ארוך מאתמול תפתח, גם היא למלך הוכן. Pasuk says in4:44Yeshaya, okay, that it's already prepared4:46from yesterday,4:48the4:49opening, or the receiving, it's also prepared for the king.4:54למי שעמיד במשפט ארץ. Not talking about a real king over here,4:55but we're talking about a person4:56who doesn't hold by the justice,4:58who's not a king over himself5:00and doesn't run his own life5:03according to justice.5:04Pasuk says,5:06הוכן is prepared for him.5:07What's prepared?5:12שהגיהנם ועץ הפוכה גיהנם. Gehenna is waiting for him,5:13the opposite of5:16Gan Eden. ומי שאינו עוסק בתורה עץ חיים, and he's not עסוק in the Torah,5:18which is5:18עץ חיים, a person who's not even learning Torah,5:20forget about teaching,5:21is not even learning Torah,5:23then what does it say?5:25Then,5:30הרי חרב שמלאך המוות, שהוא גם כן היפוך עץ חיים וחיי לעולם. Then you have the sword of5:33מלאך המוות, the opposite of5:36the עץ חיים. Now that's, believe it or not,5:38it does sound a little complicated.5:39That was the simple one.5:41The next comes from the5:44Gra, but more Kabbalistic,5:45and he says like this.5:46The Gemara says,5:50אמרו ליה רבנן לרב המנונא, זוטי, בהלולא דמר בריה דרבינא, לישרי לן מר. Famous Gemara.5:51It's a very strange Gemara5:52if you think about it,5:54but I'll tell you the Gemara.5:55The Gemara says5:56the chachamim were sitting down5:57in a wedding. of the son of6:02Rabina. Good?6:02So the Chachamim turned to6:06Rab Hamnuna Zuta. Rab Hamnuna Zuta seems to6:07be like the younger6:08Rab Hamnuna, or, you know, the grandson or whatever6:12of Rab Hamnuna Saba. So they tell him,6:13Sing for us.6:15Amar lehu. So he says,6:16Okay, I'll sing to you.6:20Vai lan demitnan, vai lan demitnan, u'le'alana namut.6:22Right?6:23That's the song he sings.6:23He6:24says, Woe, we're gonna die,6:25woe, we're gonna die.6:29Amri lei, Hanan, ma na'aneh batrach? Right?6:29He says,6:30first of all,6:31it's a little depressing,6:32right?6:32The Gemara,6:33like, right, he's sitting in a wedding,6:34you tell the guy,6:35Hey, sing for us.6:35He6:35says, Okay,6:36we're gonna die,6:38we're gonna die.6:40Right?6:40Come on, everybody,6:41let me hear your hands.6:41We're gonna die,6:43right?6:44Woe to us,6:44we're gonna die.6:45Well, that's a little strange.6:46That's already a question6:47that I have,6:48right?6:48That was bothering me.6:49Number two is also,6:50the Gemara continues.6:51The Gemara says,6:52so they said,6:53If that's what you're saying,6:55what are we gonna say after you?6:57Hei Torah6:57v'hem mitzvot, d'meganya alan? Where is the Torah?7:00Where are the7:00mitzvot that are supposed to protect us,7:02right?7:02If you,7:03Rab Hamnuna Zuta, you're saying this,7:04what's gonna be with us?7:06V'khtiv b'no. On this Gemara7:08comes the—7:08I mean,7:09not the Torah—7:09comes the7:11Gra and says,7:15Shebeit mitot hen kemo shekatuv, mot tamut. We find there's two types of death.7:17There's two types of7:18death. It doesn't mean the way people die,7:20but after they die,7:21what happens to them.7:23Like, we find the Torah says,7:25mot tamut, and all over7:26we find the7:27double language, right?7:34Mechalaleha, mot yumat. When Yeshayahu told Chizkiyahu, mot tamut, he tells him, right?7:36What does that mean?7:37It represents7:38mavet v'Sheol.7:40There's death,7:41and there's where a person goes,7:44l'aleinu, in the bad place that he goes,7:45which is considered either the grave,7:47on peshuto pshat, Sheol could also mean7:52Gehinam. She'neged etz chayim v'gan Eden, shehu d'chavin ukba. Those correspond to the good,7:56the positive,7:56which is the tree of life.8:00Ein Gan Eden, which are the zachar and the nekevah, which everything Hashem created in the world.8:04The Gemara says,8:09That's the meaning over here.8:13Where is the Torah? Where is it? Ki Torah etz chayim hi. Torah represents the tree of life.8:16For those who hold on to it, v'he kolletet min hamitah, it saves a person from death.8:18As we all know the famous story of David8:21HaMelech, that when he was told by Hashem finally which day he's going to die,8:25and he told him it was Shabbat, he said, Every Shabbat I learn Torah,8:28because he knew by learning Torah, malach hamavet can't get you,8:31right? And that's what we're saying till now.8:33Etz chayim hi, it saves you from the sword of malach hamavet. U'mezuzot matzilim miGehinam. The8:36mezuzot protect you from Gehinam, kemo shekatuv, ki ner mitzvah, like the8:43pasuk says, ki ner mitzvah, right? Why is it compared to a candle?8:46Because Gehinam is supposed to be a dark place.8:48A candle protects you; you could see.8:54V'kemo shekatuv b'Midrash Ruth, kol pegudah v'pegudah... b'sminam zocheh l'etz chayim, kemo shekatuv, v'amicha kulam tzaddikim. V'amar—let's come back to the8:56story—Vai lan. What does he mean,9:00vai? Shehu b'sod vav yud, v'zehu shenistalku, v'zeh sheamar, He Torah, the9:06hei yud, right? If you think about the9:11otiyot, yud-keh, vav-keh, right? He's saying9:15the9:17hei, bet yehin. The hei Torah—where is the Torah? It's really9:19hei hei. Vav yud, right? Vai demitnan. The vav yud is what's left to us,9:25and the hei hei is what's left.9:26In the Shem Hashem, we also have a zachar9:30nekevah. The otiyot of the zachar, yud, as we know, the ish9:33v'ishah—what makes them different from each other?9:36The Gemara says,9:39Zachar shekena mehem; lo zachar, esh ocheltan. And the mefarshim explain9:41that the man has yud,9:43woman has a hei,9:45right? The Shem Hashem is between the ish and the9:47ishah when they're not acting the way that Hashem should be with them,9:51so Hashem goes away, the אותיות left is a fire,9:53esh, esh. Now, from that you see that the letters yud represents9:57a masculine, a zachar.10:00Hey represents10:02nekeivah. So in the name of10:04Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei, right, it's really split into two.10:07There's Yud-Kei and there's10:09Vav-Kei. The male is the Yud, and the female is the10:13Hey. As the Hey, everything female usually has a letter Hey in it.10:16Hey is what receives. Yud is what gives.10:19And the same thing would be the Vav also and the10:22Hey. I don't want to get into the sefirot10:23and connected, but in the sefirot also works out in the same letters,10:26that the Yud is mashpia on the10:28Hey, and the Vav is mashpia on the other, the second10:32Hey. So that's what he's saying:10:35Vai demitnan. When the Vav, the zachar, is gone,10:38so they said,10:40Hey Torah, Hey mitzvah, the two Heys, right?10:42Because the Hey is also missing.10:45When the zachar is not there, so also the nekeivah is not there.10:50The zachar and nekeivah of the afterlife10:52is the etz chayim and the10:54zachar, and the nekeivah is the Gan Eden.10:56And when that's missing, so they said also,11:00Hey. So, you know, when you're missing the11:03zachar, right, the etz chayim, there's no Torah. There's also no mitzvah.11:05There's no Torah for11:07etz chayim, and there's no mitzvah for the Gan Eden to be protected.11:12So what's left? The11:14mitnan, the tishmavet, and the sheol, which is the opposite of these two things.11:17And that's why by11:19Ruth, we read this pasuk all the time in the11:22pasuk pshat, that Naomi and Ruth, after Naomi tried to convince Ruth to go back to her house11:26and Ruth didn't want to go back,11:28right, it says,11:30Vatelachna shteihen, by Naomi and Ruth. What does that mean?11:33And that means that these two parts,11:36which eventually one was mitzvah,11:38Ruth was converting. Gemara says11:40that why is she called Ruth? Because she was11:44mosif—how many mitzvot were the goyim commanded on?11:49Seven. Seven. No, you're right, it was six,11:51but I had—Noach was another seventh mitzvah.11:53Very good.11:59You're מקוון to the12:02Rambam in the Gemara Masechet Sanhedrin, shrecha. The roots, as the Gemara, they were commanded seven.12:03What's the gematria of root?12:07Taf, resh, vav, 606. Add it to the seven that she had already,12:11613.12:13She's mekabel on herself the mitzvot. But you see that Ruth represents the mitzvot,12:17right? And Naomi, who directed her to go and to12:20apply halacha, she taught her the Torah,12:22so she represents the Torah. V'telachna sheteihen, the Torah12:26and the mitzvah, and that's what gave them the etz12:31chayim and l'machazikim bah, and the12:32Gan Eden. That's the meaning of it, the12:35deeper meaning of v'telachna sheteihen. You know, we'll conclude with just a word of12:37Musar. Rabbi Salanter says if a person has a few minutes to learn, what should he learn?12:41Should learn Musar, because when you learn five minutes12:43Musar, you realize you have much more time to learn Torah. Amen v'amen.