Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 9Sefer Even ShelemaPart 102Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:43Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Perek vav, ot vav, part0:04two. We stopped yesterday because we work with time here,0:08and I want to go back to the piece in0:11Even Shlema and elaborate on it because I believe there's a very important point in0:15chinuch that comes out from this piece.0:21V'tzarich lechanecham b'yaldutam limod l'shem shamayim. The Gra says you have to train them0:24from the time that they're young0:26that they should learn l'shem shamayim.0:30And then he says,0:34V'al yashgia al omrim ki hanaar eino tzarich l'zeh, chas v'shalom. And don't pay attention to people that say,0:37Nah, the kid doesn't need this,0:42chas v'shalom. Ad rabba, nochalena al pi darko, gam ki yaskilu yoser mimena. If you train him the right way when he's young,0:45even when he gets older he'll keep on doing it.0:47And that's really, this pasuk is the main pasuk when it comes to raising children,0:52is that people have this idea that raising children means0:57getting them to do what I want them to do in front of me,1:01right?1:02And they assume that just because they did it in front of me,1:06that they're going to do it on their own.1:08And that's a big, big, big mistake,1:10because usually when people are forced into doing something1:15that they themselves don't believe is good for them,1:19then they will find a way to do it1:23when the fear of punishment or consequence is not there.1:28So therefore, I'll give you a beautiful story.1:30Actually, we have the book over here,1:32and I'm reminded of this story.1:34There was once a lady.1:36I'm not against, you know, let me say, when I start the introduction,1:40there was once a lady that had her child in a playgroup in Israel.1:44And she comes to the— she once came to, like, the orientation, right, from the beginning of the year.1:51And, you know, when the kids first come in, they always give them, like, a treat.1:55It was, I think at the time, it was a cupcake or something else,1:57and they gave, you know, each kid one.2:00The mother right away ran—2:01this, we're talking about a two-year-old, right?—2:03ran, and she grabbed the treat away from the kid,2:07and she goes over to the morah and she says,2:10This should not be given to my kid.2:13She's like, No, it's not healthy.2:15I read on it.2:16It causes all these different things.2:17I don't want my kid—2:17She's like, Yeah, okay,2:18but hazita? Your daughter is crying.2:20She said, I don't care.2:21It's not good for her.2:22So, you know, it's very hard because we do give in this playgroup to everybody.2:26It's like, I don't want my kid.2:27Imagine it's an allergy.2:28Okay, but, you know, it's very— you know,2:30it's like, No, you cannot give her.2:31I don't care.2:33Okay, fine.2:34That's what the mother wants.2:35That's what the mother wants.2:36And every time they would give a treat, a candy or something else,2:39the kid will never get,2:41right, in front of everybody.2:42Okay, but that's what the mother wants.2:43That's how she wants to train her.2:44There was once a birthday party,2:46and they took the kids to another room to make the birthday party.2:50They made the celebration and everything else,2:52and then they took the kids from the birthday party room2:55back to the regular playgroup where they're playing.2:58So they send in there, they're looking at the head count,3:01and they realize they're missing one of the children.3:03I can't imagine how many kids were in there,3:05but anyway, they realize they're missing one of the kids.3:07And who was the kid?3:09That's the daughter of that lady.3:11This is a few months later, into a year already.3:14They go back to the room,3:18and they see that the little girl is under the table3:22picking the crumbs from the table,3:24from under the table, taking the crumbs off the table,3:27right?3:27Means to say, okay, this is a clear example.3:30It's a baby,3:31she doesn't understand,3:32but that's my point.3:33When a baby doesn't understand,3:34they're going to do it.3:37Okay, now let's take this a step further.3:40Let's take this a step further.3:41Kids get older,3:42right?3:43And the parents force them to do something.3:46Now, you could and you should, when they're young,3:48don't ask their opinion and don't explain it to them,3:51because it has to be done because I said so.3:53But what will happen now3:55when the child gets older and he still doesn't understand why it's good for me?3:59That means you train this child when he's very, very young.4:02Let's say to a certain diet, a certain food.4:05So when they get older, they don't care about it.4:08You know, sometimes some people will hear,4:10like my kids' schedule, like4:12in Ateret. What? They don't have winter vacation?4:14They only have one day, two days off?4:16Oh my gosh.4:17They don't have a4:19smartphone? They don't have a thing?4:20And now, as I'm recording this today,4:22my kid is here in the room listening to me,4:24and it's okay.4:26So, but he doesn't have off,4:28and how can it be?4:29And this is my4:30favorite. When I tell them when they go to camp,4:33what's their schedule in camp?4:34They learn until one4:35o'clock. What?4:36In the summer they learn?4:38They don't flip out?4:39And the answer is no.4:40Why? Because this is the normal way.4:43Take a kid who summer is not4:46even—don't even, if you say the word the book, he flips out,4:50right?4:50You say the word book,4:51forget about a sefer or anything else.4:52There's no shul, no learning, nothing,4:55right?4:55You put him in a camp that learns for half an hour,4:58it's4:59gehinnom. It's gehinnom mamash.5:01The guy's in kaf hakela maybe,5:02right?5:03It's torture for the kid5:05because he's not used to it.5:07So yes, you train them when they're young,5:09but if you see that you train them and they get to a certain age5:11and it's still—they can't, you know, it's not working anymore,5:14they're going to find a way5:15if they don't believe it,5:16because they grew up learning the whole time,5:19right?5:19So for them, learning is5:21regular, so they have off, Baruch Hashem.5:22They said, then learn.5:23That's what we do.5:25They said, then learn.5:25And when they don't believe in it.5:28Behind your back, they're gonna go do it.5:31But from the embarrassment5:33or from the fear of punishment,5:35they won't tell you.5:36And I believe that's the worst, worst, worst part of5:40chinuch, is when they're cheating and lying,5:41because we've trained them now,5:43not in the right way,5:43because they're not doing the right thing,5:45they're doing the wrong thing.5:46And on top of that, we've trained them to lie.5:48And once they lie5:51and they see they got away with it,5:53it's a disaster,5:55because they could do all terrible things in life5:58and have in the back of their mind,6:00I could get away with it.6:02You know how a gambler falls?6:04You know how people lose a lot of money in AC, in Vegas?6:07A lot of people aren't going to Vegas now, I know.6:08There could be people listening to this in Vegas right now,6:10right?6:11There's a show right now.6:12You know how people lose so much money in these gambling places?6:15And the proof that they lose so much money,6:17because all these places open up6:18and they make tremendous amount of money,6:19right?6:20So the ruba de-ruba, the6:21majority of the people that are going to Vegas,6:23all these things, are losing money.6:24How?6:25When they win the first time.6:27This is like the biggest curse that could come upon a person,6:30is when he enters a casino for the first time in his life6:32and he wins big.6:33That's the biggest curse,6:34because he's gonna think he always wins.6:36And this is an unbelievable psychology in the person's head,6:40that when you know you could get away with something,6:42or you know that something, a system works,6:45and the first time you tried it,6:46the system works,6:47in your head always works.6:48The first time you tried it, it fails, it always fails.6:51Rabbi, what's his name? I forgot his name.6:54He's from the6:55shmooze, I forget his name right now.6:57Rabbi Betzion Shafier, he has a beautiful example.6:59He says if you ever go to these zoos7:01and all these different places7:03where they have huge elephants tied to a rope,7:06and they're tied, they don't move.7:07You think that rope and the elephant can't rip it?7:10The power of an elephant,7:11he can rip that rope in a second.7:13But they don't even try.7:15You know why?7:16What the psychology is,7:17even on elephant, by the way,7:18we make a bracha of meshaneh habriyot on elephants and monkeys.7:22These are two animals7:23that are, according to some opinions,7:24these are two animals that are the most similar to human beings.7:27Why?7:28Because it says when the dor haפלגה, when they wanted to build the tower,7:32Hashem turned them into monkeys and elephants.7:34They say that we came from monkeys and elephants.7:36It's the opposite.7:37We say that humanity turned7:39into—not every monkey came from a human being,7:41but certain types of monkeys came from human beings, actually.7:44And that's why you see a lot of similarity between them.7:46It's unbelievable.7:47I can't go into it now,7:48but you see the similarity between elephants and human beings.7:50In any case,7:51an elephant, when he's a baby,7:53they take him in these zoos7:54as a baby,7:55and they tie him to the same rope.7:57That he for sure cannot break.7:59And he tried.8:00He tries, he cannot break it. He gets big. He's huge. He still feels he can't break it. Why?8:06Because that's in his head. That's the way he was trained. He can't break it.8:10Even though he could, but in his head, I tried, it doesn't work. So he's stuck with it.8:14It goes like that with everything. When you try something the first time, it works,8:18you're going to try to do it again and again and again and again, and you're going to think you can get away with it.8:22So we trained the child that you could lie and get away with it. Why?8:26Because I told him he can't do it. He's going to do it. He did it. He didn't get caught. Nothing happened.8:30He didn't get zapped. All the terrible stories that his mother told him,8:33if you do this, this is going to happen to you, didn't happen.8:36So he says, Okay, it's all a shaker. I can really do whatever I want and get away with it.8:39So now he gets older. He's 35. He's running businesses.8:43He could take from this guy and take from this guy and sketch each one that he's really paying each other back8:48and steal from everybody and get away with it because it works.8:52But it's wrong. You're stealing. But I could get away with it.8:56You see what chinuch is. You see those messages that are given since they're younger.9:01And that's a very important thing to understand what the kids are and to explain to them.9:05And that's what he's saying, chinuch naad. This is what chinuch is, because we want them that even when they get older.9:09He says another important point over here, and that's what I really wanted to focus on today,9:13and that is you have to train kids since they're young to learn9:16l'shem shamayim. I heard a beautiful idea about this, and I tried to—I said it at least a little bit.9:22I said it, you know, once. It was not good enough to my students.9:25But I think it was in Porat Yosef that they told9:30the boys—the boys' minyan at the time was Lilul Avadia Yosef, which eventually became Chacham Ovadia Yosef,9:35right?—is that train yourself to learn once a week without anybody in the world knowing that you're learning.9:42Not your rabbi, not your father, not your9:46chavruta. Learn. Go to a room and learn just because you have to learn9:49l'shem shamayim, and don't tell anybody afterwards, Today I learned9:52l'shem shamayim. I went to the room. Nobody saw me. You know those guys? Today I gave a10:00metanah b'seter. But train yourself.10:04If for sure we should train our kids, we do things because Hashem said to do10:09it. L'shem Shamayim. What's l'shem Shamayim? Because Hashem said so,10:13not because I'm going to get rewarded for it.10:15Last week, I think, but in this series, in the chinuch, I mentioned about how people raise their children with threats.10:23So there's the flip side of it, which is really the same problem.10:27Threats, we said, you know, it shows weakness. I can't control my kids without threatening them,10:31right? So people say, okay, I'm not going to be threatening. I'm going to be very nice. I'm going to be very polite. I'm going to be good.10:35So now they bribe their kids,10:39right? Say, okay, I'm not going to yell at you. I'm still going to take you on a trip,10:44right? If you go to sleep, you get an extra ice cream on the trip.10:49Okay, that's also not10:52chinuch. Bribing is also not10:53chinuch. I'm going to make a point system. You're going to get a raffle ticket.10:57That's not chinuch. And I know there's a lot of places that do it.11:00All the books on chinuch, Jewish and even not Jewish, the professional books, all speak against all these raffles.11:08Why? You don't reward somebody for something that they're supposed to do.11:14So people always ask, so how do I get them to sleep?11:16You look at the kid straight in the face without yelling,11:19say, You're going to sleep. Why? Because you have to go to sleep.11:22Why? Because you have to go to sleep. Why? Because I said so.11:26And of course it has to be age appropriate.11:27You don't do that to a11:3017-year-old after 16 years of you raising him that he can do whatever he wants.11:34But you go to sleep because you go to sleep.11:36That's the way it works.11:38You know when you reward? For the extras.11:41He took out the garbage when it wasn't his day.11:44If you have seven kids, and each one has his day to take out the garbage,11:48and this kid does it when it's not his day,11:50he cleans up his sister's room,11:52he cleans up his brother's mess.11:55He gets, you walk in and he gets you something without you asking him.11:58He helps you with the load without even you saying something,12:00that's extra, you give him a reward.12:03But if he does something he's supposed to do,12:05you don't reward kids for brushing their teeth.12:08But when they're younger, very babyish,12:10when they start off, to give them the incentive, yes,12:14start them off incentive to start off a project,12:18yes, you can start with the reward.12:19But you don't constantly reward somebody for something that they're supposed to do.12:26Learning Torah, in the beginning we have to draw them in.12:29We give them the candy and the sweets and the waffle and everything else.12:31But if we only do that, think of what happens when you don't supply the candy.12:35The kid doesn't learn.12:37So there's got to be that element of l'shem shamayim,12:40doing it because that's what you're supposed to do.12:42You know why you fold your laundry?12:44Not because if maid didn't come and mommy needs help,12:46because you need to be a neat person.12:49You need to be a person who is neat because when you get older,12:53and I don't know if you can afford a maid or not,12:55even if you could, you have to be a neat person.12:57When you go to yeshiva, when you go to work and you get whatever13:00it is, you need to be a neat person.13:01You fold your laundry, you make your bed.13:03Again, age appropriate,13:05whatever the age.13:06You know why you need to go to sleep?13:07Because you have to know there's a schedule.13:08You can't just do whatever you want in life.13:10There's a certain schedule.13:12Oh, I'll give you a candy.13:13And when he gets older and nobody's, and the candy doesn't care,13:15I'll give you twenty dollars if you go to sleep every night.13:17And then when that doesn't care,13:20so how far do we take this already?13:22There's got to be a point where you're doing it because it's the right thing.13:24This is what you got to do.13:26And that's a very, very important thing.13:29Raising children through threats,13:31like we said in the past, is not called raising.13:34And neither is raising them through rewards.13:38Again, there's room for rewards13:40if it's uncalled for, if it's extra. These are two conditions.13:44You need both conditions,13:45but not for their regular responsibilities.13:48Because when they are trained that they need a reward,13:53an instant reward also, because the candy is an instant reward,13:56for the regular things that they have to do,13:59then forget about it also, how far it goes.14:02It's going to go through tremendous problems.14:04You come in, this is what you have to do.14:06You do homework.14:07You don't get candy for doing homework.14:08You have to do homework.14:10Right, that's a responsibility.14:12Oh, you helped your sibling with your homework?14:15You didn't have to do that.14:16You could have went out and played.14:18That's a candy.14:19That's a reward.14:21You did something extra.14:23Again, but you make that kind of what's extra,14:27what's necessary in your house,14:29and you custom make it based on your own house.14:33I think I'm going to stop over here14:34because we pretty much spoke everything out.14:37And yeah, tomorrow, bezrat Hashem, we'll move on to Zayin.