Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 7Sefer Even ShelemaPart 100Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:18Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Today we are actually going to do the letter that we said in the beginning.0:06So, let's explain. Let's read, excuse me,0:14and we'll explain. וצריך להוכיח את הבן בגערה בדברים רכים. And when we come to discipline the children, it has to be with soft.0:19It has to be a lot. You know, when we speak, that means our tone of voice cannot be a tone of anger0:24and tone of yelling. It has to be soft.0:28Like the words of מוסר, which would make sense to a person.0:32Which means if I would speak to you and I would yell at you, how would you take it?0:36Always it's a good idea to always, like, reflect on yourself. You know, see what you're doing and see how would you take it.0:43And the best way, you know, a lot of us maybe could be bosses,0:47we have our own businesses, but let's say we were to be employees.0:51How would you like it when your boss yells at you?0:52Sometimes, you know, that's—you say, What do you mean? That's the way it is. That's the way life is.0:56I get yelled at all the time.0:58And how do you like it?1:00If you have ever worked for a boss that's really nice and soft, you would run to do his work.1:05You feel very happy.1:07You don't take advantage.1:08So you may not be as strict, but you know what?1:10You want to do what he tells you to do.1:13You have a good relationship with1:17them. והעיקר בחינוך והרגל. And the עיקר in what you're saying, he's saying, What do you mean?1:19It doesn't work.1:20So this is a big mistake that we all think.1:23There's a beautiful video.1:25Maybe I should put it on the chat after this piece over here.1:31You'll see that video, where the video basically shows two types of relationships between teachers and students.1:43I'll explain to you the video outside, and then you'll see the video for yourself.1:46The first part, half of the video, it's about a minute and a half of the video.1:51It shows what looks like clearly like an American, or at least in the Western world, teacher standing outside the building as the students are walking in,2:00and each student walks in, has a special handshake with this particular teacher.2:04And it's not just a handshake;2:05it's a beautiful thing.2:06You know, they all come in.2:07Clearly, they're all looking forward to do that handshake with the teacher.2:10The second one shows a Mid-Eastern teacher,2:14you know, and as the students are walking in—and not walking in, they're going to the2:20class—he has a whip, and each kid is walking2:23in, he whips one kid at a time,2:25right?2:26So it's a very, very funny video in the way it contrasts between the two different ways.2:32So a lot of people look at that, and I really, you know, I'm very interested to see what you think about it.2:37But everybody has their own different views about it.2:39They say, Yeah, some people say that's the right way,2:40that's the wrong way,2:41right way or wrong way.2:42You know, I have my own opinion.2:44Obviously, I'm very for the first way.2:46But I'll tell you what he's saying over here in Ibn2:50Shlema. The first way of learning the handshake, or the special handshake that creates a bond between that particular teacher and the student, takes much longer to figure out,3:03and it takes longer to get it right, to build the bond between student and teacher.3:10The second way is much easier.3:13It doesn't take skill, and it doesn't take time for a person to take a whip and to just hit.3:20The ikar when it comes to raising children, the word that's used in the pasuk, חנוך לנער על פי דרכו, which is where the word chinuch comes from, is training.3:33Chinuch is getting someone to be trained, like any training in the3:38world. And let's talk about professionalism,3:42professional sports. This training,3:45the training is, let's take, you know, there's a Super Bowl coming,3:48right? For those who don't know what Super Bowl is, it's not a big bowl of ice cream.3:52Super Bowl is actually a game of football, which is an American sport that is very, very popular,3:57and it's going to be watched by millions, if not hundreds of millions of people this Sunday coming up.4:03That game takes about, in total playing time, or at least on TV time, it's going to take about maybe three hours, maybe three and a half hours.4:12The actual playing time is about an hour, an hour and a half, because there's always, you know, they stop the clock and they huddle, they come back, and they actually play.4:20The training for that game is weeks upon weeks, if not months,4:24because, yeah, you're right, they play throughout the whole season, but they train and they train and they train until they get to that point.4:30In professionalism, in anything that's professional, when you want to get to where you want to get to, you must train, and training takes a lot of time.4:38This is what chinuch means.4:40Chinuch, people think, I'm going to say it because I'm a father, I am entitled to do whatever I want, and therefore my kids have to listen.4:48They don't listen, they are not respectful, and they're the ones who are wrong.4:52It's not me, it's them.4:54The blame is always on them.4:57Well, this is a very important thing to keep in mind right now, as a side point.5:02If your children fail, it's your fault.5:05And if the teacher is listening to this, if your students fail, it's also your fault.5:10If you tell me 90% of your students or children are successful in the way you want them to be, and one is not, or 10% are not, okay, you were okay.5:20Listen, you can't get everybody all the time.5:22There's always going to be that special, exceptional one.5:25But if your whole thing failed, then you're a failure.5:29You did not do the job. You can't put the blame on them.5:31You obviously didn't know how to speak to them.5:34You obviously didn't know how to relate to them, and it's your responsibility.5:38Because chinuch is not me declaring something and everybody's going to jump.5:42I'm going to say something. You're not a boss.5:43When you pay people and they work for you and they're scared to lose their job, especially if you pay them a lot of money,5:48so you can do whatever you want. Whatever you say is going to go.5:51But in your own house, even though you're paying a lot of money for your children's tuition5:56and your children's well-being and your home and your car and everything else and their entertainment,6:01it doesn't make a difference.6:03They're not just because you said they're going to listen, and definitely just because you said it doesn't mean they're going to follow in the way.6:09Chinuch is a process.6:10It's a process. It's a long process.6:13It needs training and getting accustomed to.6:16And therefore, think about right now this point.6:19If I have to train my children, what's the best way to train them?6:22By yelling at them all the time to do a certain thing, or by speaking softly?6:27And here is a very big key.6:30Because chinuch is a training, and because it is something that you have to get used to,6:34it means it will not happen the first time, but it will happen over time.6:37It takes a long time for it to take effect.6:40Don't expect to see magic right away by saying something.6:45Understand that it takes time.6:46Just like children grow, so too they grow into the good middot that we want them to grow up into.6:53You want them to be neat and clean up their room6:55by you yelling, Clean up your room!6:57It's not going to happen.6:58By you coming and showing them, This is how we do it,7:01and let them fail once and again and again and again and again and again.7:04Be on top of them.7:05Speak to them softly.7:06No, that's not the way the room is supposed to be.7:08Let's try again.7:09Oh, I have to stand there physically?7:11Yeah, it takes effort. It takes time.7:13Who else is going to raise your children?7:15Let's continue in the words7:19now. Look what he's telling you.7:21You want your kids to speak in a certain way.7:25You want them to act in a certain way.7:27The middot, it needs a lot of training.7:32And when a person gets trained, to get accustomed to something, that's called having ownership.7:39That's called having complete control over something.7:44And you should know another important thing about this whole thing that we're saying,7:48what we're reiterating, and now you're seeing inside, and he's telling you, and he's going to bring you a pasuk:7:53All beginnings are difficult.8:02Ve'oze lo az ithalal. Afterwards, then if you go, you get praised, which means, you know, it becomes easy.8:08Anybody who's encountered something for the first time has known that it's very, very difficult.8:14If you're a baal teshuva and you became religious, you could totally relate to what we're saying,8:19that the first time you kept Shabbat, it's so hard.8:23When it says, you know, Shabbat is me'ein olam haba, it's part of the next world,8:26you thought that the next world is Gehenna, like it's so difficult to really keep Shabbat.8:31But after a while, you see how wonderful it is. Not only that, you look forward to it, right?8:36What was your most inconvenient day of the week is actually your most pleasurable day of the week.8:41And that's the same thing when you train for anything.8:43It's very difficult the first time. You want to learn piano.8:47It's not easy, and it's so tedious, and it's so like you have to press this one, and it's so like,8:52ah. But after a while, it becomes easy. You go to the gym, you start working out.8:56You take a deep breath and you look at the clock. What?8:59You know, just recently, I used to be very athletic. Yeah, thank you. You know, can't tell anymore.9:06But just recently, I went to a hotel and they had this exercise room.9:10I said, you know, I want to go on the machine,9:11and I started doing this, like, step machine, you know, going up.9:15I'm like, wow, sweating. So, whoa, I'm out of breath already.9:18How long did I do for? I looked, it wasn't even three minutes,9:21right? It's very hard in the beginning, very hard.9:24But after a while, you'll be able to do an hour on the machine.9:28You'll be able to do the piano beautifully.9:32Training takes a long time. It's very difficult in the beginning,9:35but after a while, you become a pro. It just becomes smooth,9:38and that's really in every single area.9:41And yes, even in parenting, and even in parenting certain stages of children,9:47it's very difficult in the beginning. Don't let go. Keep going at it,9:51and keep speaking softly. Eventually, you'll see the fruits of your labor, literally.9:57And he says over here,10:04However, a rasha, a person who's wicked, knows what he's doing is also wrong.10:10Knowing that something is right or wrong, you're not there yet.10:13It's a beginning, but you're not there yet,10:15because even a rasha knows what he's doing is wrong.10:16But what makes—according to the Gra—what's the difference between a rasha and10:21a tzaddik? The rasha knows what he's doing is wrong, but he can't stop,10:26and he keeps on going at it. He keeps on doing the aveirah. He keeps on doing what's wrong for him,10:31because he doesn't want to go through that difficult stage of changing.10:36Therefore, being that this is so, that changing is hard,10:41so the Gra is pointing out something very important.10:43If we have to change a child, it's going to be very, very difficult,10:48and he may not actually be trained in the right way.10:51Therefore, the hakar chinuch starts when they're young,10:53when they don't know any better.10:55And right from the beginning, you start training. From the beginning,10:58you start making the system from the beginning that you're going to be much more successful.11:03As we all know, it's easier to remove the peel when it still, before it gets ripe,11:11because when it gets ripe, it's hard,11:14and you just, like, make a small little incision and then boom, it comes right off.11:17But afterwards, when it becomes ripe, then you have to, like, peel one piece at a time.11:22So that's what the Gra is telling you over here in raising children.11:26To remove the bad middot from children who are teenagers is very difficult.11:30So if in your house you have different ages of children, work with the easiest one.11:36This is a practical step.11:38Take the youngest ones.11:39The youngest ones are the easiest ones to work with11:43because they're still young and they're still impressionable,11:46and it's easy to work on them,11:48and work from the easiest and get to the top.11:50The older ones are a little bit harder.11:52I'm not telling you to ignore your older ones.11:54I'm telling you, though, put the work on the little ones and put them in a certain system11:58and the way you want them to be.12:00And all the ones understand it's going to take longer12:02because up till now they haven't been going in the way you want them to go.12:06Maybe use a lot of threats, maybe a lot of12:08yelling, so that's why it's understandable. But it's going to get there.12:12It just takes a little bit more of a longer time.12:17And with this we finish. Amen v'amen.