Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 6Sefer Even ShelemaPart 99Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0010:32Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Eben Shelema. Now we're really up to Perek Vav, Oteh. But before we move on to Oteh again, I want to take a little bit of time to talk about0:09ODalet, because yesterday, after we stopped the recording, a few guys in the class mentioned something.0:13Yesterday we spoke about hitting, and now hitting, if it's not being done.0:18So we said, you know, we already spoke about hitting way, way in the past.0:21Now we're speaking now about disciplining.0:24So disciplining in the olden days was with hitting, and kids understood that that's the way to discipline.0:29And in our days, so whatever it is, we give punishments and whatever it may be.0:33So the Gra says very important that if disciplining is not being done for the future,0:38that the child should, in a better way, improve himself for the future,0:42then disciplining is אסור to be done, especially when you're hitting.0:45Keep in mind, about that, there's an0:48איסור דאורייתא. There's an איסור דאורייתא that says,0:51ארבעים יכנו לא יוסיף. Good? And that is actually quoted by Sefer Hinuch as one of the0:58איסורי דאורייתא, that any person who is getting malkut and gets an extra lash,1:04he's supposed to get, let's say, 25. You know, they always evaluate the person.1:08He gets 26, then that person who hit him has done an איסור דאורייתא of hitting.1:13You're not allowed to hit another Jew. Now it applies to anybody.1:15You're not allowed to hit another Jew.1:17Ah, self-defense? Okay, I'm not dealing with self-defense, but hitting another Jew is1:21אסור. So when a person hits his child when it's not necessary,1:24when there's no mitzvah with it, it can become an1:27aveirah. The Gemara says, just like the person, the executioner1:32who hits the person who's chayav malkut, and he hits him an extra hit1:36that he's not supposed to hit him, that's an aveirah, it's not a mitzvah anymore,1:38even though two seconds ago, or the beforehand was a mitzvah.1:42So the exiting is not a mitzvah, right? It becomes an1:45aveirah. So the Gra says that, just a little bit of review of what we said yesterday,1:49if the hitting is there to help him for the future, it's a good hitting.1:54If it's not there to help him for the future, then it's going to be an aveirah. It's asur1:59because, you know, you're not getting any toaלת from it.2:04To hit a child out of anger because you're upset is not justified. It's asur.2:09And we said most people today, being that the culture is such that we're not supposed to hit,2:16but we do hit under the radar, right? We're not being watched.2:20So when we do hit, we actually do the exact opposite.2:23It turns out that all the hitting that we do today is really an2:26aveirah because we're only hitting out of anger. We're only hitting because we're upset.2:30And yesterday a very good question came up to really evaluate and to measure yourself,2:36to see, to test yourself if what you're hitting is a mitzvah or not a2:41mitzvah. Let's say you're at work and it's one of those pressure days. You know,2:45it's like everything's happening so fast and so speedy,2:48like it's so much pressure, and you're getting yelled at from this and that,2:51and there's really a lot of pressure on you, right?2:53On top of that, your wife keeps on calling. You keep on hanging up. You can't talk right now.2:57Finally, what happened? Oh my gosh, your kids are driving me crazy.3:01Well, they're not your kids all the time, my kids only.3:02Oh, what happened? He's what a chutzpah.3:06I don't know. For me personally, chutzpah really bothers me, right?3:09Those kids, when they think it's a wise guy comment, but it's really, it's real, real chutzpah, right?3:13And they say things that are very disrespectful.3:15He called me this and that and that, right?3:19And now you better come home and do something about it, right?3:21It's always her fault.3:23Anyway, b'kitzur, right, she now adds to the flame.3:27Now you can't yell back at your vendors, at your clients.3:33Some of your employees maybe you can yell at them, but, you know, last time you did, you lost one,3:36so you're like a little bit more careful now,3:38especially if you don't have any employees under you, you are the employee, right?3:41So it's very hard to yell at them, right?3:43So all that's bottled up inside of you.3:45You come home now. And the second you come home, the kids run to you,3:51Oh, this kid is bothering us!3:54Ah, now another tosefet, right?3:56And now your wife comes and says, Your son was a disaster today.4:01You just take one look at him, and you come to hit him.4:04But right before you hit him, he says, Dad, I'm sorry.4:08I really realized I did something terribly wrong.4:11I just had a bad day today.4:13I'm sorry. I'm not going to do it anymore.4:15So we said you came out with a new app.4:18There's no such an app, but let's say they came out with a new4:20app. You take out the app, and it says on the app, you know, the truth app.4:25You press the button, and the app scans the person and will tell you clearly4:29if this person is sincere, what he's saying, and he's not going to do it again.4:34You scan the kid, and the kid says that really this kid is sincere.4:39He's not going to do this again.4:41He's not going to be this chutzpah again.4:42He's not going to call his mother names anymore, and he's not going to bother, right?4:47Now the question is to you, okay, the app says he's not going to do it again.4:51Would you still hit your son for what he did or not?4:55This is the question.4:57That's the mashal we give yesterday.4:58If your answer is yes, I'm going to hit him because of what he did,5:01then your hitting is an5:05aveirah, because hitting is only there to help the kid in the future that he shouldn't do it anymore.5:09When he sees discipline, he sees a consequence,5:12he did something wrong, and therefore he did A, you get B,5:14and therefore in the future he won't do A again.5:17The consequence is justified.5:19The B is justified.5:20B by itself is nothing5:22unless B leads him to not doing A anymore, right?5:26So if I give him a makah, I hit him, You drove your mother nuts today.5:31You're already nuts, right?5:34That's asur.5:35It's clearly enough that.5:36Now, we don't have such an app.5:38Hashem has such an app.5:39And that's when we do5:40aveirot, and we're supposed to be5:43chayav punishments, whether, lo aleinu, it's karet or something, unless it be like malkut or whatever it is,5:47and we come and we say, Hashem, I'm really sorry.5:49I'm really not going to do it again.5:50Hashem doesn't hit us.5:52We're forgiven.5:53Isn't that an amazing thing?5:54Why?5:54Because Hashem has such an app.5:57Hashem yodea nistarot. Hashem knows that we're not going to do it again.5:59So what's the purpose of hitting you?6:01What's the purpose of a person getting a punishment?6:03Because I know you're not going to do it again.6:05The punishment is only for atid.6:07But we as humans who don't know this,6:09but it's a good way for us to think before we discipline,6:13or as we're disciplining, to always really evaluate ourselves:6:17are we hitting for the future or for the past?6:20That's a very, very important question that's always in the minds of parents.6:25Today, you know, in books that deal with class management, that's a new term,6:31right? Class management means how to efficiently run a class with kids who are trying to disturb and get them to6:38learn, right?6:39So punishment is the lowest, lowest, lowest.6:43A teacher who needs to punish the kids to get them to listen is the lowest, lowest level.6:49That's a very weak teacher.6:51That's always resort to punishment.6:53Is punishment needed?6:54Yeah, once in a while, on a blue moon.6:56But you cannot control the class without punishment. It means you really have no control.7:01If we, unfortunately, if you think about it, it's such a crazy thing,7:05but most parents, that's the only way they work, with threats and punishments.7:10Again, I'm not telling you that there should be no threats and that there should be no punishment.7:14But if that's the only way you can really run your house, it means you're not running your house at all.7:20You know, in the words of Chacham Asher, who talked about kashrut,7:24we once brought Chacham Asher over here,7:26and he spoke when we first came to the shul, I brought him to speak about meat and kashrut,7:31and somebody asked him, And how do you know, right, that every moment that this guy—he says,7:38Look, if there is a store that I have to give hashgacha to that I don't trust the guy, that every moment I have to be on top of him,7:44I don't want to give kashrut to such a place.7:46If I have to turn my— if I can't turn my back because I can't trust a guy, I don't want to deal with such a guy.7:52I'm not here to just get my money.7:54I'm here to, you know, to make sure that people get kosher food.7:56So they need a little bit of...8:00But to have a little bit of fear to know that they could get caught.8:03But at the same time, if anybody could play tricks on you,8:06and we all know that in every business you can play tricks,8:10right? If you always— so that means it's not really a functional business over here,8:13right? Same thing, if your job is always threatening and firing, you're really not running the show,8:18right? Everybody's just scared and intimidated.8:19You don't want your house to be like that.8:22You know, a house is not a business for sure,8:24and even business, you don't want to live such a8:26business. You want a house to be a nice where kids could grow and blossom and be happy.8:30That's a very important ingredient that we're missing today,8:33and that's why people are on drugs and alcohol and all these different types of medicines to get over that,8:37because people are not happy.8:39We want them to grow up to be happy kids,8:41and the way they're going to grow up to be happy is that they want to come home.8:44A lot of— it's one of the saddest things8:46when you talk to people who have issues in the house and they say,8:49I stay at work as much as possible because I don't want to get home.8:52It's miserable in the house. Wow.8:53And, right, and what is it? And shebeito— what is it?9:05No, no. No, not that. There's a— basically, the oyev becomes the people, and shebeito becomes the9:09oyev. That's a very scary thing.9:11There's a pasuk like that, a line9:14in Chazal. And either way, that's really, really not a nice thing,9:17and you don't want the child to feel that way.9:19When they're young, they have no choice.9:21But when they get older and they have a choice and they have friends,9:24and that's really the scary part.9:25When they get to those teenage years and they have the option not to come home,9:30right?9:31So as right now, I joke around with, you know, like, you can leave the house,9:34right?9:34But I can't say that when they get to a certain age,9:36and I know that.9:38I joke with it a little bit,9:39but I know I can't say that because when they get to a certain age, 14, 15, 16,9:44and it all depends on the kid, and you say,9:46You're not welcome to come home,9:47guess what? They're not going to come home,9:48and that's the worst thing you can do.9:49The worst thing you can do is that the kid doesn't come home,9:52because then he's, lo aleinu, who is he with?9:56Because no normal parents or people from the community that you trust9:59will take a random child just without the parents calling.10:03Why, here, oh, my parents don't want me home.10:04Really? They're going to call you, right?10:06And everybody who is taking them is, guess what?10:08I don't want them to be there.10:10So therefore, you got to make sure the kids are happy that they want to be there.10:13There has to be a structure in the house,10:15there has to be things,10:16but just keep in mind that the hitting that's happened for the past, for the future,10:21is much,10:23much, much. Okay, I think we're going to go on to10:24hey, even though I said it's supposed to be hey today.10:26I think it was an important thing we had to add on to daled from yesterday.