Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 5Sefer Even ShelemaPart 98Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:39Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Even Shlema, Perek Vav, Ot Dalet.0:06So I want to move on to Ot Dalet, but there's one thing.0:10I know yesterday, because of the time, we even went way over time yesterday.0:13There's one line I would like to read from the0:15Gra that wasn't mentioned in Even Shlema, and I think it's very applicable to our days.0:19If you look at just yesterday's piece, we're talking about that,0:24you know, obviously it's all about raising children, so that's why it's all connected.0:26It says, Ki derech ha-nar — you see that right above chet?0:31— Ki derech ha-nar shelo yekabel0:36tov ad shemyaserehu. The way of a child is that he doesn't accept good advice or good direction until he is disciplined.0:47But still, to actually be bad, he would not be unless if he would have heard somebody reproving him, disciplining him.0:59And therefore, if you see he's out of control, it's because somebody didn't do their job in disciplining him.1:04Why I read this, I wanted to point out something very, very important.1:08Children, by nature, right, and sometimes you'll have very easy children, very easy children1:14that are an exception,1:15and sometimes you have very, very, very hard children that are also an exception.1:19But in general, most of children, and definitely in your house it's probably like that,1:24especially when they're younger, children need direction and need structure.1:29But keep the following in mind.1:31Even when you do make structure, which in my opinion a lot of people fail to do that,1:36they kind of let things go, and then as problems develop, they start, you know, fixing and making structure.1:42You know, let's compare this to a person who lives in a house.1:46Imagine you go and you live in a house, right? You first, you know, you bought a house. You bought just an empty lot,1:54right? Let's make it a nice sizable house in Brooklyn, which is1:584,500. This is, consider a big house in Brooklyn.2:00If you're out of town and you're listening to this, you probably think we're a bunch of poor people,2:03but if you know the prices, it's really crazy.2:06Anyway, 4,500, right? You just have land.2:08So what do you do? You hire an architect.2:12Not because the law only requires to hire an architect, because you need somebody to build right.2:16You don't just come and you grab anybody.2:18Imagine there was no law, you have to hire an architect or somebody professional, right?2:21Would you just take a bunch of workers from 65th Street, which is basically some foreign workers2:26that know how to build, they know how to fix, right?2:29You tell them, just make a roof, and then as you go along, you find problems, you start fixing.2:33What kind of living is that, right? It's crazy.2:35A smart person will first come and build the structure2:41and make sure that everything is working properly, and then you move in.2:43And sometimes maybe as you move in, you might find some cracks or some things break,2:47so you need to fix them.2:48So in parenting also, when children are born, or really as some rabbis say,2:53even when a woman is pregnant, that's the time when you already start to make a structure.2:58How should they go to sleep? How should they wake up?3:01At what age do we start already taking off the bottle?3:04At what age do we start ignoring the cries?3:07And when they get older, how do they interact with friends?3:11How much time is he allowed to be on the iPad?3:12How much is he allowed to be on the screen, let's say for those who allow such things?3:16How often do we allow him to go out to play with his friends?3:19At what time does he have to come back? At what age,3:22and different children. But there's a system already that you set up before the children reach that age.3:28And that's why parenting is always, I've mentioned this in the past,3:31it's always easier with the younger children,3:33because the first child, you're still learning.3:35You're like, you know, you're learning on the job, as they say,3:38right? The younger ones already know this works, this doesn't work.3:41So therefore, you already adjusted properly to the older one.3:43But if you adjust everything, if you have a structure,3:46it's easier for the child that he follows the structure.3:48Now, that's if you do your job properly.3:50Most people, I feel that they don't do it properly,3:54right? Because of different reasons, not because they're bad.3:56It's just we're so busy in life, we don't have time to really,3:59and we're misguided, or we still feel that, you know,4:01the way I grew up, that's the way it's going to be naturally,4:04and we don't realize that really we need a structure.4:06In any case, even when you make a structure, you have to know the following points.4:11Every child will always try to break the rule.4:15Every child, when you put that red line that the child cannot cross,4:18every child will always try to break that line.4:21And when he breaks that line, right, when he crosses that line.4:26What's going to happen is that he's going to see, what are you going to do?4:33Are you really keeping to your rules4:35on that? And I'm telling you this in the house, and it applies also in school.4:38You come in as a teacher, you set a few rules.4:41There's always going to be one child who's brave enough to see,4:46let's see this teacher if he's really going to hold by the rules.4:48Well, they're not psychologists thinking this way,4:51but without realizing, they're going to push their limits, right?4:55So let's give you a mashal with adults.4:57It's the same thing with every human being.4:59So in Brooklyn here, in our neighborhood, they put a new law:5:02they can't drive faster than 25 miles per hour on Ocean Parkway.5:08Okay.5:08They put up cameras. Oh boy, now you see that they're holding to it,5:12right?5:12And when you find out that the camera will only clock you at 35 and above,5:17okay, so now, at least when you drive by the5:20camera—everywhere else—at least when you drive by the camera, you will not.5:23There are stricter in cell phone policies.5:27Okay, people are still using their cell phones.5:29Oh, once you get that ticket, oh boy, you see this is serious.5:33There's points and everything else. Oh boy.5:35So then you got a little bit more5:37machmir. And again, you might push it again, but if you got caught again,5:40you see that this is not going to work.5:42So this is what the Gra is saying over here,5:45that derech hana'ar, the way of children,5:48is that if you don't meyaser him, it doesn't mean, again, that you punish5:52him. I'm using the word discipline.5:54In their days it was with a stick.5:56In their days, if you want—you know, in our days, when we were younger in Syria,5:59I told somebody, I said, You want to know how it was?6:01This is how it was.6:02In the middle of me, the teacher is reading, he stops,6:06says, Hey, Nahum, next word.6:10And if I didn't get the next word, I come up, boom.6:12I got hit in front of everybody in the class,6:17right?6:17So everybody sees now, oh boy, if you don't have the finger on the spot,6:20I'm going to be on the spot,6:21and everybody's on the spot afterwards.6:24Why? Because he does it random enough6:25that you're going to make sure you always follow6:27me. So that's everybody.6:30All of them are that way.6:32So I just want to point that out.6:34I know it's really part of6:36dalet, but I wanted to point that6:38out—I mean part of6:38gimel—I wanted to point that out,6:39and we spent half the time,6:40but I think it was a very important thing to understand in6:43chinuch. So therefore, the practical advice now is as follows:6:48for parents, for6:50teachers, you must have a structure6:52that works with reality with the child.6:55You can't be also a Nazi,6:57you know what I'm saying?6:58You got to be realistic.7:00Whatever works.7:00You need them to go to bed on time.7:02It's age appropriate7:03that they should be in bed at that time.7:05You make a rule.7:06You make a rule with a consequence.7:08The7:09consequence—you must give the consequence.7:10If you're nice7:12and you're not7:13go'erbo, as the Gra brings over here,7:15and you don't follow your rule,7:17you lost it.7:18I still remember when I was in Israel,7:21to learn in yeshiva,7:22it was the year 2000,7:23and Intifada number two started,7:25okay?7:26And I still remember the Prime Minister Ehud Barak.7:29There were soldiers that were kidnapped7:31by Hamas, or whoever it was,7:32I don't remember.7:33I think it was Hamas, whatever.7:34They were kidnapped by the Palestinians.7:36And he comes out on national television,7:38he says,7:39If those soldiers are not returned7:42within 24 or 487:43hours—I forgot what he said,7:44let's say 487:45hours—if these soldiers are not returned within 48 hours,7:47Israel will not be quiet.7:49We're going to retaliate.7:50We're going to show you.7:5148 hours,7:52they did not return the soldiers.7:54He comes out on national television.8:00I'm extending it another 24 hours. If you don't return the soldiers, that's it.8:06That was—he was ousted. The government broke up. He didn't even finish a year. Why?8:11What kind of leader is that? I'm extending the deadline?8:15That shows weakness, that I'm really scared. You know, I'm giving you another—because I'm really scared8:19to. You made a consequence. If you feel that you should not be 48 hours, don't say 48 hours.8:24Say give them 72 from the beginning, right?8:26But if you said 48, you stick to your word.8:29Same thing. You told your children something, you do it,8:33because if you don't do it, you break it.8:34The message to the child is, there's no real rules over here.8:39I do whatever I want, I can get away with it afterwards.8:41You must follow up. You must follow up.8:45And when you feel bad, you're actually, like we said, you're not feeling—you're ruining it. You're doing it worse.8:50So let's go to that. It's a little bit8:52shorter, so we spend enough time on gimel. Let's go to8:59that. כשמכה את בנו או את תלמידו, מכה אותם דרך כעס, על העבר, חס ושלום. When a person even is hitting, right?9:01And we said the disciplining in their days, hitting was okay.9:05So even when you're hitting your child, never ever allow to hit him9:09a hit like a person who hates somebody,9:11because you're upset on something that happened in the past.9:15רק כוונתך כעת יהיה להצילם לעתיד. So this is also very important.9:17All those that say hitting works,9:19that's how we were raised.9:20Hitting, hitting, we got to hit the kids again,9:22right?9:23Even when you hit, like I told you,9:25being that we don't know how to hit, that's why we don't hit.9:28The hitting has to be that you're saving from something he should do in the future,9:33that he should not do anything wrong in the future again.9:38ולכן להכותו הרבה בפעם אחת. That's why when you're hitting him, don't do too much.9:43רק מעט מעט, לפי היכולת, הנה לא. You do a little bit, because remember,9:46it's a message that we need to give across to the child.9:48So if I hit him and I don't get the message across,9:50so what do I do?9:52I just hurt my child for no reason.9:58כשהרואה שרבה המטה עליו להכותו, כלל לא. Unbelievable line.10:00I want to read it slowly and translate it.10:05Ukshe'roeh sherabacha mato alav. When you realize that you're so upset at your child,10:13lo yakeh oto klal bayad. Then that's a siman that you're not allowed to hit10:15him. Isn't that the opposite of what parents do?10:18They only hit when they're so upset,10:21right?10:22It's the exact opposite.10:24We're actually, we're clearly not hitting for the purpose of being10:27mechanech. We're hitting because we're angry,10:29and that's not the way to raise a10:31child. Children are not supposed to be silly.10:33Children are gonna be disrespectful,10:35not because they're supposed to be, but that's how they are.10:38Children may not even know they're disrespectful.10:40You know, it's amazing when you have so many different ages of children in the house,10:44you can see the difference.10:45Take a child, right?10:47I have my baby.10:49He's two years old,10:50very, very cute,10:51right? He can do anything in the world, get away with it.10:53So he tells me he learned from his siblings,10:57You're iwi and you're10:58yummy. So he knows iwi is bad and yummy is no good.11:02So whenever something like, you know, like let's say I'll tell him,11:04No, you can't have that toy,11:05so he'll get upset and say,11:06Oh, Abba, you're iwi,11:08right?11:09So now, if I get offended and I hit him for that,11:13does that mean I have sechel in my head?11:16Does that mean I have brains in my head?11:17He's a baby. He doesn't know what he's saying.11:19He goes around to everything.11:21He tells the toys, You're iwi, you're11:24yummy, right?11:24It's his way of saying, I like something, I don't like something.11:27But if an adult comes to me and says, You're iwi,11:31oh, that's embarrassing me,11:32you understand?11:33It all depends.11:35So when children say things that sound disrespectful,11:38understand that it could be the kids don't even know.11:40Like we give them a Shabbos by breakfast,11:42kid doesn't even know what he's saying.11:44So you can't expect that when the child says something,11:47Oh, don't treat him like an adult.11:49He's not an adult.11:51A child is a child.11:52They'll say things that are very, very upset,11:54and even teenagers, they'll say things, but they don't even realize.11:59Say, I hate you. I can't stand you,12:02da-da-da. They will say those things.12:04They don't really hate you.12:05And when they say, I wish I'm not part of this family,12:07they don't really mean it.12:10They're just, their way—this is how they express their anger.12:12So when you discipline them,12:14and especially if you hit them,12:15you're clearly not understanding them.12:17So how do you expect to really send over the message to the child,12:20I really care for you, and I want you to stop doing this because it's not good for you.12:23The kid doesn't understand that you just hate me.12:25You don't understand my feelings.12:26So that's why this is a great proof over here.12:29You're upset, you don't hit, because your hitting12:31is clearly not sending the right message.12:34The kid who's saying, you know, those disrespectful lines,12:37so when you're calm, you pull over the kid and you explain to him,12:41I understand you're upset,12:42but the way you're expressing your anger with those words12:45are very hurtful to the adults around you,12:47to your teachers, to your principal, to your parents, to your siblings.12:51When you say, I'm going to kill you, I'm going to chop off your head,12:54kids say that.12:55I've heard it from all types of kids,12:56religious, not religious.12:57Just they're angry, they're going to say those kind of lines13:00when they're not13:02b'sha'at kaas. But when13:03you're calm, it's when you go over and you explain,13:05do we use those kind of words?13:07What's the problem when we use those kind of words?13:09It's a discussion,13:10and we explain,13:11yeah, but I'm upset.13:12You know how many times you get that?13:13I'm upset.13:15Okay, but just because you're upset,13:17we don't speak like that when we're upset.13:18We're upset, say,13:19Ah, I'm very upset,13:20and practice with the child.13:21That's really—you got to practice with the child.13:23That's a practical way of this.13:25Really, really,13:26I think it's a powerful, powerful line,13:29especially for that mentality of hitting.13:30This is something maybe we should have done before.13:33You know, we spoke about hitting,13:34but anyway, we did it anyway.13:35... tomorrow we'll move on to13:37hey and continue.