Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 4Sefer Even ShelemaPart 97Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0017:21Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Even Shelema, perek vav, ot gimel. So we're talking about the chinuch, raising our children.0:07So the Even Shelema brings down over here from the Gra, in ot gimel,0:12Gam et habanot tzarich lehadrich tamid.0:15Since till now we spoke about the importance of raising our children0:19al pi haTorah, learning Torah, because you'll get tremendous benefit from it.0:23So you might think that maybe girls are a little different. Girls don't have the obligation of learning0:27Torah. Now, he says over here that girls are also—you have an obligation also to תורה girls.0:33Let me just pause for a second. And I have to give you a little bit of background.0:39It's very, very important. I read recently the introduction to the Birkei Yosef.0:44The Birkei Yosef is the book, one of the many, many books of the0:48Chida, Rabbi Chaim Yosef David Azulai, one of the greatest Sephardic Acharonim in the 1700s,0:52who most of us go with the rulings of the0:55Chida, a lot of Kelalim, a lot of the rules that we follow in psak as Sephardim, we follow the1:01Chida. So in the introduction to the Birkei Yosef, it was, I don't think it was written by the Chida himself,1:07but whoever wrote that wrote something very, very important.1:10He says, it's so important in the introduction for the author of a book to not just write what the book is about,1:16which is very important, right? Tell me how the book works and whatever,1:19but also the book should tell us the background in which he was living in,1:23because we get to learn a lot about the time and place of how these psakim really came in,1:29or whatever is in the book, you know, how they applied.1:32And you see mamash that depending on the time, you see a lot of different things were written in a certain way.1:36For example, he writes in that introduction, he says, look at the1:41Abarbanel. The Abarbanel, he spoke so much about what was going on in the time when he lived1:45during the time of the Jews being kicked out of Spain, right?1:48The Spanish Inquisition. He got a big picture of what's going on in those times.1:52The Rambam in his teshuvot, you could understand a lot of things that were going on1:55where the Almohads, which were the Muslims who were conquering Spain,1:59which was really a Christian country, and the Almohads, the Muslims, came and took over2:02and became a Muslim country at a certain point in Spain, right?2:06And a lot of the questions that came, people who were obligated to convert and everything else.2:13So if the teshuva was only written in a halachic point of view without talking about the times,2:16you wouldn't really even understand the halachic point of it, right?2:20But so this is just small examples.2:22A more modern example is if you look in the Hatam Sofer's2:26teshuvot, he had to deal with reform,2:29tremendous amount of pressure from the Haskalah, from the Enlightenment movement,2:32which people were Jews who went to yeshivot and were just to go learn how to uproot the Torah.2:38And they were using,2:39so a lot of things that they did, a lot of takanot, a lot of extra chumrot, you could say,2:43was because of that reform movement, which was drastically changing European Jewry,2:48and they were very successful.2:49So there's a lot of things that they had to go against.2:52So you need to know the background.2:54So, Avi, I believe also we have to understand a little bit of a background how girls were raised,2:58very, very different from our days,2:59very different.3:00I mean, we know just the whole world and how do we look at women and how women are in society changed,3:06and it's even changing in our days that, you know, if we don't speak how it's changing maybe in our days,3:12someone will come later on and will not know how it was really.3:15And maybe in a few years,3:17you know, I saw a clip, a very funny clip of parents, you know, what's it called, parents dealing with their children in 2050,3:28right? And basically a father comes to wake up his son, a teenager, to go to, what's it called, to go to school.3:36He says, you know, Good morning.3:38Hi, how are you? You know, if you—3:40and he's, like, very careful to be so politically correct.3:43He's like, you know, Let's go,3:45you have to go up,3:46you know, and he referred to him as a male.3:48He says, That's very offending.3:51You can't call me a male.3:53I could be whatever I want to be.3:54He's like, Okay.3:55He's like, Okay, you can feel how you feel.3:58Don't tell, you know, I could, you know, you can't tell me how I feel.4:01You know, I mean, yeah, like everything is offending.4:02Whatever you say is offending.4:03It's like, it's making fun of our whole society,4:07how we can't even, you know. There was Fox News once had— so another clip4:11had a, you know, they're very good.4:12Fox News is very, I mean, very real,4:13you know, and they go crazy from this craziness in our world,4:16about one lady that said that it's very, very offending,4:20all these terminologies that have men in it.4:23We shouldn't call it a4:26mailman. That's sexist.4:28You call it, it should be a male person.4:31So you shouldn't, you know, and she went on,4:33it should not be a fireman.4:34It should be a fire person, a police person,4:36not policemen,4:38because there's a lot of women that work in the police department,4:40and there's a lot of women that are male men,4:42and they're not.4:43So he tells her, so, you know,4:45what are you going to say about Manchester?4:48You know, the city of Manchester.4:49He's like, You're right,4:50that's also offending.4:51It should not be Manchester.4:53It should be changed.4:54He's like,4:55Aha. So you don't think that maybe the people who are getting offended5:00are really abusing the majority of the people5:03that are not getting offended,5:04and they're forcing us to change?5:05No.5:07That's a crazy world that we live in,5:09right? So really, when we talk about men and women,5:11we also have to say that in a few years,5:13maybe you're listening to this in a few years,5:15it might be just optional,5:17right?5:18There's some places that you have the option of writing,5:20when you have a boy or a girl that's born to you,5:23you could choose not to write anything5:25and let the person decide what he wants to be5:28or she wants to be when they get older,5:30right?5:31That's a crazy world we're living in.5:32So if we don't talk about these things,5:34so later on when they come and they don't know,5:36hey, you know, why were these psakim,5:39or why were these rabbis speaking in a special way in those days?5:43So we have to understand how girls were beforehand.5:48Girls did not play an active role in society.5:51You know, today for a guy to say,5:53My wife works, it's not a5:55chidush. Not a5:56chidush. It's very normal.5:58Back then, for a guy to say,6:00My wife works,6:01wow, what is going on over here?6:04There must be like deep poverty or something.6:06And even then, it's only the guy who,6:08you know, even the poorest of the6:09poor, it's only the guy had to figure out how to bring in6:12parnasa. A woman was a housewife,6:13and her role was, as the pasuk says,6:16Kol kevudah bat melech penima,6:17right?6:18So because of that, the girls also,6:20their education was not needed so much.6:22Most of the things she picked up in her family.6:25In the 1800s,6:28when there was a lady, Sarah Schneer,6:30it's not late 1800s, early 1900s,6:33when she saw that society is not,6:36you know, we used to look outside to society,6:38you know, and we grew up the way our society grows up, right?6:41So when she saw that looking to society6:44to raise our children is not an option anymore,6:47she opened up6:48the—she made the Beis Yaakov movement,6:50which is girls' schools,6:52to raise girls6:54al pi taharat6:56hakodesh, al pi haTorah. But in the times of the Gaon, in the 1700s,6:58this was not around.6:59Girls were raised by their mothers,7:01and the mother knew what the mesorah was7:04and the tradition was,7:05and she passed it on to her daughters.7:06She says even to your daughters,7:08you always have to direct them the right way as well.7:10For example,7:12like what?7:17Because, you7:18know, one of the7:19kochot, one of the powers that's given to women,7:20as the Gemara says,7:21is the power of speech.7:23You see girls, when they are7:26younger—excuse me, girls that are7:28infants—the girls speak before boys speak.7:30They have that power of speech.7:31A girl could talk on her phone to her friend all day,7:34and she could talk to herself all day.7:36You know, she's talking, right?7:37It's that koach of dibur.7:39Because of that,7:40it could also be used in a negative way.7:42So therefore, he says,7:43you got to be careful with your daughters7:44that they shouldn't be cursing,7:46they shouldn't be making swears,7:48lying,7:48or creating tension and fights in the house,7:51lashon hara7:53and rechilut. You have to be on top of that,7:54just as a girl should be on top of all mitzvot.8:02And the girls don't listen, you have to discipline them.8:05And like we said in the last couple of classes, how hitting applies in our days,8:10so you have to, which is disciplining, a form of disciplining, disciplining has to be done to girls as well.8:18And also, they have to learn Torah. On Shabbat, instead of reading,8:22if you go look at all the sifrei poskim about, unfortunately, what's a girl supposed to do in her time on Shabbat?8:30Men go to learn. They have finally off, they could go learn. Back then, what did the girl do?8:34So there were, believe it or not, books that were not appropriate.8:38There were things that were published by the goyim which were very not appropriate,8:42and girls would read that. So he says instead of that, give them sifrei musar, let them read that.8:46So nowadays, it's even more so. Unfortunately, even, you know, the yetzer hara of a phone to keep a person busy,8:53even in religious circles on Shabbat, people have a very, very hard time staying away from it. So8:58there's a lot over here to talk about and how it applies in our days, very, very practical,9:04and we have to be on top of our girls as well to make sure.9:09One of the things also, like, you know, sometimes you have, like in my case, one girl and many boys,9:16right? And they're always fighting with each other because she has no friends in the house.9:21You know, she's one standing against four, and it can create a lot of tension.9:25And girls have a mouth like Hashem yerachem, right?9:28You know, in every deal with shalom bayit, and yes, husbands could yell and they could get angry and things,9:35but if a woman opens her mouth, wow, she could wipe the floors with the guy,9:41right? She knows how to take the guy and wipe the9:43floors. Women have this koach of speech,9:46and they could, you know, I once dealt with a couple, they were fighting,9:50and the guy hit his wife. He says, He's a bully, she tells me.9:53And I said, you know, forgive me, but you're also a bully.9:57Because, she got, what do you mean?9:59I said, well, he's a bully because what's a bully?10:03He's using his power that he has over you, right,10:06against, you know, over you. He's stronger than you to put you down.10:09So he's physically stronger than you. He's hitting you because you can't fight back.10:14Well, you're much—you're ten times stronger than him in speech.10:17When you open your mouth, you make him feel like garbage.10:21You destroy him all the way. You're bullying him in words.10:26You're much stronger than him in words, and you know he can't catch up with you in words.10:30Forget about fighting you. He can't even catch up to you,10:33and you destroy him. So the only way he can respond back is by hitting you back.10:36I'm not telling you he's allowed to. I'm not telling you he's10:39allowed to. But I'm telling you that you're doing the same thing.10:42So girls have that koach. It's not just that lady. It's a lot of girls, right?10:47You know, as a teacher dealing with parents,10:50you don't want to get on the mother's bad side.10:53The father is always more quiet. Okay, listen, you know, quickly,10:57yeah, like give it to me, you know. When I send a PTA, the father is about 25 seconds.11:01A woman is like, you know, they get five minutes, they want another five11:04minutes, you know, they have what to say, because that's the koach of a woman.11:07It's not a bad thing. It's a koach that she has,11:09and because of that, it has to be directed in a good way, right?11:13So let's see now from the Gra.11:16Famous letter the Gra left over for his family before he passed away,11:20as giving them commands, you know, on how to run the house.11:23He says like this:11:27Look at the expressions that he's using.11:30And I came to request for you a big, big, big, big request:11:38direct your daughters that make sure that they shouldn't speak words of either curses or swears and lies,11:52and machloket, like hakoves shalom, ve'ahavah ve'chayim. All her words should be words of peace, of love, of togetherness and calmness,12:00and have a few books of12:02Musar. Let your daughters read them, let the girls read them.12:07And also on Shabbat Kodesh, there should only be osek with12:19sifrei Musar. And make sure12:29the girls are12:32only drinking if they make berachot, berachah rishonah and berachah acharonah, b'kavanah. And the main thing is that12:35don't let them go around roaming and hanging out outside. Also, other things, gossip,12:38and people like to, you know, always tell you about the news.12:40She's like, Oh, you heard what this lady bought?12:42Oh, I heard that she really doesn't... right?12:48And make sure the girls are only drinking if they make12:56berachot, berachah rishonah and berachah acharonah, b'kavanah. And the main thing is that don't let them go around roaming and hanging out outside.13:04And also that they should listen to you.13:07He's telling his wife, the guy is telling his wife,13:08and they should give you kavod.13:10Yes, parents have to insist on their kavod.13:13It's a big thing we're missing in our days.13:14We don't insist on our kavod. We let it go.13:16No, I'm your parent. You don't talk to me that way.13:19I'm not your friend.13:20Tell your kids that,13:22without yelling.13:22Very calmly. Yelling, you lose your power, believe it or not.13:25When you yell, it shows weakness.13:26It shows, Ah! You don't talk to me that way!13:28No. You stop,13:30but very calmly, but very firm.13:32You don't bend down.13:33You stay standing up and you look down to your child. You say,13:36I am your parent.13:37I'm not your friend.13:39Yes, I'll be nice to you.13:41I'll take you out to places13:44where... and I want you to come to me,13:45and we want to share deep things.13:47But keep in mind, I'm still your father.13:49I'm still your mother.13:50You don't talk to me this way.13:51Not yelling and threatening,13:53if you talk to me very straight.13:55No, no option.13:56When you threaten, it's like you're giving a person an option.13:58Here's a threat, ready?14:00And if you don't talk to me this way,14:02I'm going to send you to your room.14:04So the kid, that means you're telling the kid,14:06you have the option. If you want,14:08you can go to your room and not talk to me that way,14:10right? Think about it.14:11If you really need to get someone, you can't find parking,14:14there's no standing, you'll say,14:16You know what? It might be worth $115 to get here.14:19It's worth it, right?14:21So a threat is really an option.14:25Don't give a threat,14:26because we're not giving an option here.14:28You don't talk to your father that way.14:30You don't talk to your mother that way.14:32This is the way you talk to me.14:34But like we said on Shabbat,14:35don't just say the problem, also say the solution.14:38This is how you address me.14:40You don't call me by my first name.14:42You say Daddy. You say Mommy.14:44You say Abba.14:45When I walk into the room, you stand up.14:47Yes, train your children that way.14:49They should hear from you,14:51firm, without yelling, but firm.14:53But they have to hear it.14:54They have to be mechabed you.14:56It's a14:57mitzvah de'oraita. Do you train your children to say berachot?15:00Berachot15:02are de'rabbanan. Say a beracha before you eat.15:04Only birkat hamazon, if you're full, is15:06de'oraita. All other berachot are15:07de'rabbanan. But we all train our kids with this15:09very, very special mitzvah of15:11de'rabbanan. Kibud va'av va'em is15:13de'oraita. Now, it's got to be age appropriate,15:15right? If you know that if I press them now,15:17they're going to resent it later on.15:19But this is how you do it.15:21Very simple. Watch.15:22Not when you walk in,15:23but when your wife walks15:25in—I'm talking to men right15:27now—you tell your kid, Oh, Mommy's here. We stand up.15:30And mommies who are listening to this,15:32you should do the same thing.15:34Ah, daddy is here, we stand up.15:36This is how, and you stand up with them.15:39The kids are not in remote control.15:40You press the remote control,15:41you make them stand up.15:42We stand up together.15:43You don't have to stand up for your wife.15:44Trust me, I know.15:45But for the mitzvah of15:48chinuch yeladecha, you standing up is worth a hundred speeches.15:53Mommy walks in, we stand up.15:54When your parents walk in,15:57that means the dido and the grandparents are walking in.16:00And you stand up, and you say when Jiddo or when Grandpa and Grandma walk in, we stand up for them.16:06And even if it's your in-laws, you have given a speech worth 200, given halacha l'maaseh worth 200 speeches.16:15That's a practical way of training our kids. This way doesn't work the following way.16:21Stand up, laktofya, wala, and you take out your shachat. That will almost for sure not work. It may work immediately, but for sure not work in the long term,16:29because it's done with anger, and the kid now associates hate, anger, and tension with this mitzvah.16:37He didn't really accomplish much. For the moment he did, that's worth nothing, right?16:41Or especially the ones who grab them by the ear, What if, you know, stand up and they pull them up. That's for sure doesn't work.16:47Stand up, you yourself, you model for the kids. This is how we do it. Stand up, oh, father walks in,16:52and don't do the fake standing up. Stand up and sit down. But that's it. You showed respect.16:56Believe it or not, that standing and sitting down, what Chazal tell us we have to do, does a lot in17:01kibud av va'em. You have to stand up because they know in school they have to stand up for the rabbis,17:05right? And the rabbis, you know, at least most of the time, you don't talk that way.17:09So therefore, they will eventually realize that they can't speak to you that way either.17:13So that's a very important thing in training them in the mitzvah d'oraita of17:17kibud av va'em. We're way over time, so I'm going to stop over here.