Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 3Sefer Even ShelemaPart 96Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:35Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Eבן שלמה, perek vav, ot bet. We're continuing in ot bet.0:05Last week, last time, which was last week,0:08we were speaking about ot bet,0:09which was talking about hitting,0:12and we spoke about the concept of hitting0:13and how it applies in our days,0:15because like we said, the mitzvah is not the hitting itself.0:18The mitzvah is making sure the kids are in line.0:21And we said, if it's not working,0:23don't keep on trying it,0:25and we have to do things that work.0:26So now we'll get to the Eben Shlema itself.0:30I mean, excuse me, we'll get to the Gra himself,0:32and we'll see what it says.0:34But as we explained last week,0:35I want to0:36reemphasize is that the hitting that we're talking about over here,0:38like we said, is disciplining over here.0:41If you live in a society that you're listening to this0:44where hitting is acceptable0:46and it disciplines a child, no problem.0:48I mean, we're not telling you that0:49the hitting itself is an aveirah nowadays.0:51We're telling you that in the societies that we live0:54in, America, in Eretz Yisrael,0:56the gedolim have already told us.0:58I'm not talking about just the mechanchim,1:01which already is good enough.1:02I'm not telling you that therapists who don't want to get in trouble1:04because of the government.1:05I'm telling you gedolim, Gedolei Yisrael,1:07Rav Steinman,1:10alav hashalom, zichrono livrachah, and all the other gedolim who spoke about this,1:12they said hitting is not—it's not working.1:15It's not like it was.1:16And trust me, they also grew up with hitting.1:18But we have to, like we said,1:21we have to see what works.1:22We have to do things that work,1:24not just to do things blindly without thinking.1:27So the pasuk says in1:31Mishlei, Chosech shivto sonei beno. Famous, famous pasuk.1:33A person who holds back his stick,1:35he hates his son.1:37Ve'ohavo shicharo musar, and one who loves his son1:40will make sure—shicharo, like the word1:42shachar, which is the1:43morning—will make sure he's always on top of him1:45with musar, directing him in the right way.1:47He says, the Gra over here says,1:51Mishum hani'a shivto haraui lehakoto b'shevet. A person who holds back his stick...1:53From a son who deserves to be hit with a stick,1:58umechapeh alav, and he covers for him.2:01Ve'nomi yetzel oto beshivto, and he covers for him.2:03You know, when, let's say,2:05his school calls up2:07and the2:08teachers tell him, Your son,2:08you know, he doesn't sit in class,2:10he's always running out of class.2:11Oh, chazit, he needs a little bit of a break.2:13Okay, maybe he does,2:14but he always covers for him,2:16right?2:16You're always covering for your son.2:17You're always defending your2:18son. Every time somebody tells you2:20something wrong with your child,2:21you always get on the defensive2:23and you're always coming for him.2:25Hu soneh beno. That person really hates his son.2:28Why?2:30Because at the end,2:32what's coming out of you?2:33What's going to happen to your son?2:34What's going to happen to your child2:36when you're always covering for him2:37and you're always avoiding to disciplining him?2:40He's going to grow up to be2:42what we call a spoiled brat.2:43Why?2:43Because he knows that he can get away with it.2:46I don't want to just use2:47terminologies that people just say.2:48I want to explain how it works.2:50And what happens when a child gets away?2:52Children are very smart.2:54All humans are smart,2:55but children, when they're young2:56and their minds are not3:01so, you know, stuffed with so much garbage yet,3:03they're still fresh,3:04they're actually very, very sharp,3:05and they know how things work.3:07Look at an infant.3:08An infant will cry and cry and cry.3:10And why do they put up tantrums?3:12Because they know it works.3:13When an infant puts up a tantrum3:15and the parents3:17will run, No, no, no, no, no! You'll notice in most people's families,3:20the first and oldest child3:21is usually the most spoiled3:23or the youngest.3:24Why?3:25Why is that?3:25Because the first child,3:26parents still don't know what to do.3:28Most parents,3:28again, there's exceptions,3:30but most parents still don't know what to do,3:31and the kid cries3:32and everybody runs to satisfy him.3:34They don't understand that this is part of it.3:36Let him cry.3:36It's3:37okay. He'll get used to it.3:38Or the youngest,3:39when they're already tired of raising3:41seven, eight, nine kids,3:42whatever it is,3:42five kids even,3:43and the youngest, okay,3:44they let him get away with things3:45because they're already got older.3:47They don't want to put up with it.3:47So if he cries,3:48Oh, he's so cute.3:49We give him what he wants.3:51And what happens is that—3:53That type of raising,3:56that type of child raising,3:57what we call3:58chinuch—we use this word a lot now4:00instead of child raising,4:01we say4:02chinuch—that kind of upbringing for the child over here4:05is not beneficial to the child,4:07because he sees4:08that if I want something,4:10I got to make enough noise,4:12I got to make enough trouble, and I'll get it.4:13Wow, that's a horrible thing in life,4:16no? That the person grows up with this attitude:4:19whenever I want something4:20and I don't get it,4:21I don't have to improve myself;4:23I just have to make them suffer more,4:24and then I'll get it.4:26That's a horrible way of raising children4:29and mechanech anybody.4:33That's why it says,4:34One who holds back4:37shivto—don't say4:38shevet, a stick; it says4:39his own4:40stick—which means that it deserves to be used.4:42One who really loves his son,4:47not only is it enough4:48that he makes sure4:50that he disciplines him4:51when he deserves it,4:55but he tries to perfect him.4:58He makes sure that even,5:00you know, he goes up on higher and small levels.5:06Like, take a mashal5:07to a woman who is looking in the mirror.5:16What does she do?5:17A woman who's looking in the mirror5:18and she's putting on makeup,5:20she sees a small little imperfection in her face.5:24She's going to get, you know, those mirrors5:26that turn to the other side5:27and then it magnifies it,5:29right? So it's going to magnify the mirror5:32to see that small thing,5:34to see it big,5:34so she can, you know, work on it.5:37It's kind of5:37like—we'll give the mashal in our5:39days—you work on your computer5:40and you're checking a certain picture5:41that you need to put on Amazon,5:43and, you know, you have to5:44have pictures very good on Amazon,5:45otherwise they could throw you off.5:47Then you see a little speck5:48that's not good,5:49so you zoom in on the picture.5:51All5:51of a sudden that little speck becomes a big thing5:52so you can edit it,5:54right?5:54So he says the same thing over here.6:00Why does a6:01woman, why does she enlarge the mirror6:05to see her blemish that should be bigger?6:07Why do we enlarge the picture6:09in order to see— The dot6:12that's wrong in our picture,6:15and the answer is6:16because when we remove those things,6:17we make it more beautiful.6:20When a person who is trying to perfect something6:23will go even the details.6:26Ken ha-ahavah, so too if you really love your son,6:28you don't want your son to just be average.6:33You check up on him on the small things6:35because you want him to go higher and higher.6:39They shouldn't do even the small things.6:41So I'll give you an example.6:42Some parents are happy that their kids get6:4470s, they pass,6:46Baruch Hashem. I know a teacher,6:46and I call up a lot of parents, right?6:49And you see different parents,6:50and they have different expectations.7:00So look, sometimes the kids are sitting in the class way above them, and for them to just pass, they're happy with it, and that's great. And then some parents that are not happy with just passing.7:03I think my kid,7:04he should do an 80,7:05right?7:05But the worst is when you see that parents are happy7:08when the kid could do 90s and7:12100, and he's doing7:1270s, Oh, he's passing,7:13it's okay.7:14No, it's not okay.7:15This child should be getting7:16hundreds, and most of us are like that.7:18A kid comes home,7:19Oh, I got an 85.7:2085?7:21Why?7:22You should be getting7:24hundreds, right?7:24Or some other kids,7:25100 plus.7:27Anything less than 100 plus is not acceptable.7:29Whoa, leave the kid alone,7:32chazit. Why are you being so tough on him?7:34Got 100.7:34You know, sometimes I see also with the students themselves,7:37one kid will come to me,7:38Why, Rabbi,7:39why did I get 94?7:40Come on,7:41why did you mark me wrong in this one?7:43Another kid says,7:44You're crying7:45you got a 94?7:45I got a 54,7:47right?7:48So,7:49you know, like, and the answer is,7:51for the guy who got the 94,7:52he feels that he should have gotten a 98.7:54It's the same thing as this guy who got a 547:56that wants to get a 65 to7:58pass, right?8:00For him, yeah, he wants to go higher. It's great. It's wonderful, and it's as8:06a point. לכן אמרו מסכת... He says that's the Gemara tells you exactly.8:11אפילו גמיר ונמי מצווה כביד כמשמעו. When you hit your son, even if he's a learned person, what does that mean?8:14Not the hitting is a mitzvah, but to discipline him, to make sure that he perfects himself.8:20So if we do it with tests, why don't we do it with other mitzvot, right?8:24So the kid says, I can't do Shacharit, Dad, this whole week. Great.8:27Of course, give him the validation and give him the pride, חזק וברוך. But after a while, if he just says, I can't do Shacharit, excuse me,8:35it's like, did you learn before? Right? We want him to perfect.8:38Did you come to Shacharit on time? You prayed the whole tefillah? You made sure you didn't talk in tefillah,8:42right? We want to go higher and higher and higher.8:44Now, if we ourselves are not doing it, by the way, we don't expect that we should do it.8:48We should expect our children to have it, because we don't even know what to tell them.8:51So obviously we're talking about that we're cleansing more and more.8:57There's two more pieces over here from the Gra. There's two more pieces from the Gra over here, and I would like to do them also,9:04but I don't know how much I could do because of the time.9:07Let's just do the last piece,9:14okay? מוסר השם בני אל תמאס, ואל תקוץ בתוכחתו. פסוק, a famous pasuk. Why is it famous? Because I think Yaakov Shwekey came out with a song. Anyway,9:17there's a pasuk over here in Mishlei, it says,9:25מוסר השם בני אל תמאס, ואל תקוץ בתוכחתו. The מוסר, Hashem, my son, Shlomo Hamelech is saying, don't hate it,9:29and don't be disgusted by His tochachah, by His reproof,9:36כי את אשר יאהב ה' יוכיח, וכאב את בן ירצה, because whoever Hashem loves, that's the one He reproves.9:40That's like a father who wants his son, right, to perfect himself.9:53Says the Gra, כי אין דרך להוכיח רק לאוהב אשר לבו דואג על רעתו, ורואה שהולך בדרך אשר אין טוב לו, הוא מוכיחו. Because you don't reprove, you don't correct. A person, unless you like him,9:59and you care for him, and you worry about him that he might go in the bad way,10:03and when you see that he's not doing something right, then you correct him.10:07I remember personally one time, one time in my life, that I actually yelled on top of my lungs to somebody.10:13You know, working, I guess, for many years, even when I didn't know it was called kiruv,10:18I was actually doing kiruv for many years.10:20Basically, people don't go to class, I try to bring them to classes.10:24People not keeping... It's one of my things I love, you know, teaching.10:26This is why I got involved in this whole thing,10:29right? And always take the soft approach10:31and hi, they'll love you,10:32and when I do see certain people that are tough, I barely, barely, very, very rarely, like will yell.10:38And one time I remember yelling like crazy on somebody.10:41He was mechalel Shabbat. He was doing something not 100%10:45Shabbos. He was justified, basically. He was allowing his store to open on Shabbat.10:48He was taking money on Shabbat,10:50and I explained to him, and he was...10:52One time it was, I was still single. I was driving, I still remember this.10:56It was in the middle of summer night. It was like 12 o'clock at night,10:59and it happened to be I saw him outside.11:02So he got into the car.11:02He gets into the car, and I locked the doors,11:05and I went crazy on him.11:07You want to go to11:09Gehenna? You know, and I really, really,11:11right? And that person I really cared about. I really, really cared about.11:13I didn't yell at him because I'm upset that he's not listening to me,11:17and that's why I try to avoid yelling at other people,11:20because sometimes I ask myself,11:22why am I yelling at11:23him? Because he's not listening to me, or because it's really good for him,11:26right? And sometimes I know that it's good for him,11:28but if I yell at him, he's not going to understand I'm yelling because I think it's good for him.11:31He's going to think that I'm yelling at him because I'm upset at him.11:34I'm not upset at him.11:35I'm upset, but not at him.11:36I'm upset that he's doing these things,11:38he doesn't understand it.11:39In this person, I knew that we cared about each other very much.11:42I could yell at him, and he'll take it the right way,11:43and that's exactly what I did. I yelled at him,11:45and I gave him a real...11:47I never yelled at somebody like that,11:48not before, not afterwards,11:50about something that has to do with religion.11:53Baruch Hashem, it worked. We talked it, and it's today11:55very happily married, whatever.11:56It's been many, many years. Anyway,11:57but my point of saying it is that...12:00Like he's saying over here,12:01only if you really care about somebody, you yell.12:03So now, that's why we yell at our kids,12:05but like I said two classes ago,12:07when we yell at our kids,12:08but they don't understand,12:10we really care about12:12them. And if they don't understand,12:13and they're not taking the yelling the way they're supposed to take it,12:15it doesn't work.12:16It's not recommended.12:18It's not going to work that way.12:19When you know that your son knows that you're yelling,12:23it's for his own good,12:25then.12:26And the proof that our kids don't understand12:29it is that when we yell at them, they get upset.12:31I was in sports teams,12:33and when I was in high school,12:34I was on a hockey team,12:36I was on a baseball team,12:37and I followed a lot of sports.12:39And not only just watch the games.12:41I actually used to be very...12:43I would watch their,12:44you know, they have on TV all these different kinds of,12:46like, their practices, and they go inside.12:48And12:49I'll tell you something about sports teams.12:50There's a coach there12:52that's always yelling at you.12:55You know, you run practice,12:56You're not running fast enough.12:58Get to the side.12:58What kind of...12:59You play the game, you make a small mistake,13:00He yells like crazy.13:02What are you crazy?13:03That's such a dumb move.13:05Sit there,13:06you know, and they embarrass you in front of everybody.13:08Never ever, right,13:10did any of the players feel like,13:12Oh my gosh, he hates us.13:14No.13:14We understood that there's a game, we have to win.13:17I obviously messed up,13:18and he's yelling at me for the good,13:20right?13:22But13:22if you do the same yelling,13:24imagine in13:25a shul or in a class, you yell at somebody,13:27right?13:28They get offended,13:28they won't come back to13:29shul. What happened?13:31Obviously,13:32they don't feel that I'm yelling at them,13:33or yelling at them works.13:35So our children are unfortunately13:36like the second type,13:37not the first type.13:38They don't understand if you yell at them.13:40So obviously,13:40we can't use that tactic.13:41It's not working.13:42So he's telling you13:46over here, Same thing, if you see Hashem,13:47you do something,13:49you do something not good,13:50and you see Hashem,13:50boom,13:51you get hit somewhere.13:52Your business gets hit.13:53Your car gets hit.13:54You're this,13:55you start not feeling well.13:56Things are not going so well.13:58You should know that Hashem loves you,13:59because if He doesn't love14:00you, He'd just go.14:05Also,14:06you don't see anybody that really14:08disciplines, you14:09know, like let's say you see kids making noise,14:11so you tell them,14:11Hey guys, quiet enough in the14:14shul. Right?14:14So imagine there's 70 kids are all playing,14:16making a lot of noise,14:18okay? And14:19then everybody keeps quiet, quiet.14:20They're quiet for a second,14:21then they go back to making noise.14:21All of a sudden,14:22you see one guy goes to the group.14:24He goes to one kid14:24and slaps him in the face.14:26Who's that guy?14:27Who's that guy14:28that just slapped the kid in the face?14:30Everybody will answer,14:30that guy who slapped one of the kids14:31is the father.14:33You don't go and slap somebody else's kid.14:36If you're slapping somebody14:37and you want to pick somebody,14:38you're slapping your father.14:39So too,14:40when we see that from all the nations,14:43the one nation that always gets slapped14:45in the face14:46are the Jewish people.14:47It's because Hashem loves us.14:49Hashem cares about us,14:50right?14:50And same thing also,14:52but our kids have to understand14:53that message also.14:54If we're disciplining them14:56because we care about them.14:57Now, hitting doesn't work,14:58yelling maybe doesn't work,15:00but disciplining,15:00which means setting certain rules15:02and enforcing those rules,15:04which means what we call15:04quote-unquote punishments, right?15:06Taking away a privilege that they have,15:08right?15:08They have a privilege, for example,15:10of going out with friends.15:11Now they're not going to go out with friends.15:12They have a privilege15:13of getting a certain amount of money a week,15:15what's called an allowance,15:15and now they don't get that allowance.15:17They have a privilege of15:18we're going to take them on a trip.15:19Now we're not going to take them on a trip,15:20right?15:21That shows that,15:22no, I care about you15:23and I need you to go in the right way.15:24And eventually they will learn it.15:25But again,15:26we have to use tactics15:27that work15:28that our kids can understand.15:29We're already over time.15:30Hashem, tomorrow15:31we'll go to the next piece.15:32There's a lot to talk about.