Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 2Sefer Even ShelemaPart 95Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:16Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Even Shelema, Perek Vav, Ot Bet.0:03So yesterday we said that we're going to go to the Gra today.0:07Meaning to say, as we know, that Even Shelema is the collection of the Gra's words,0:11but a summary in his own words,0:13and he brings as a source on the side where he got it from, from the0:18Gra. Now, we are—I'm looking at the Gra, and there's not really much that he adds.0:25We pretty much said everything,0:26so we're going to move on to Ot Bet today.0:30Mi shemonea—okay, before I get to it, I just want you to know, though, that we're going to read it.0:35We're going to literally translate it,0:37and like we said yesterday, and that's a very important introduction,0:40if you haven't heard yesterday's class, which was an introduction,0:43we have to come back and, you know, we have to explain it how it fits in our days,0:49like we said yesterday. That means that when we hear these ideas,0:53because the strategies, right, the0:56concepts—this is what the Gra is going to teach0:58us—is the concepts are there, but the strategies, how to do it,1:02we have to apply, you know, we have to make sure it matches in every generation.1:06Let's see.1:10Mi shemonea melayeser ulakot et beno al davar shera'ui leyasero. A person who holds back from punishing, I guess,1:15or we'll call it in better words, disciplining1:18and hitting his son on something1:20shera'ui leyasero, where he deserves that he should be disciplined on,1:23umchapeh alav, and he feels bad for him.1:26The word hapeh is from the word cover,1:28the means the word cover. He covers for him,1:30like the word chuppah. Or the word in1:34Avic haf, which is a cover that we use,1:36mechapeh alav. He covers for him.1:39How does this soneh et beno? In reality, he really hates his child.1:42Why?1:44Because at the end he ends up going1:46to—he ends up being, you know,1:49having bad manners,1:51and he's going to be raised improperly.1:55A person who really loves his son,2:00lo dai shemeyaser oto alav, not only does he discipline him2:02when he deserves to be disciplined,2:07ela shedoresh alav pen ya'aseh nidnud kal u'meyaser alav. But he's always fine-tuning him,2:10and he's always even checking for the small little details2:13to make sure he aligns him properly.2:16He2:17adjusts him. Lachen amru, that's why Chazal tell us,2:21afilu gamir, mitzvah shemakeh oto. Chazal tell us2:22there's a mitzvah2:24for a father to hit his son.2:26Again, hitting in our days,2:28we're going to call it disciplining.2:30There's a mitzvah for a father to hit his son.2:33So the Gemara says,2:33Yeah, but that's talking about,2:34you know, maybe a kid who's not good.2:35What if a kid is a very good boy?2:38The Gemara says,2:38Still there's a mitzvah.2:39How could that be?2:40How could that be?2:41How could there be a mitzvah to hit him2:42just for no reason?2:43The Gemara answers,2:48v'hainu shelo yeheh bo nidnud rak klal. What it means is that2:49there shouldn't be even a dot of bad.2:52You want to perfect him.2:53You want to make sure that even this,2:55that you fine-tune it.2:58And anybody who loves his son more3:01will reprove his3:02son or discipline his son more.3:05Now, there's a lot to talk about here.3:07The idea,3:08we could summarize in our own words,3:10and that is that3:13disciplining shows care3:16because putting things in order.3:18But we have to clarify a lot of points3:20because we don't want to be misunderstood,3:24and we want to make sure3:26to make it also practical,3:28right?3:28So let's start with,3:30I think, grade A.3:31Let's start with level one.3:32Let's tell you what's called disciplining3:34and what's not called disciplining.3:36People yell in their house.3:37People yell at their kids.3:38Some people even hit their kids,3:40not in a dangerous way3:41where they actually, you3:43know, like they beat them mercilessly,3:44but they hit them when they get frustrated.3:47That may not be what the Gra says,3:50לייסר את בנו. That's definitely not what3:52Shlomo HaMelech means also,3:55חושך שבטו שונא בנו. A person who holds back from his stick,3:57he hates his son,3:58which is where the Gra brings it from.4:00But we're going to get to that in a second,4:02you know, in the pasuk,4:03but I just want to point out something.4:05Just because you actually do this,4:07you actually yell at your kids4:09and you tell them what's wrong,4:10doesn't mean you're actually doing4:12what it says in the4:13halacha. I'll give you—well, I'll tell you why.4:16A lot of times, and I would say 80% of the times,4:20the yelling that we do is uncalled for.4:23It's not productive.4:24It doesn't produce the results that we want.4:29It doesn't, and therefore, because it doesn't produce4:32the, what's it called, the results that are needed,4:35it's called not necessary,4:38and because it's not necessary,4:39so it becomes actually an4:41aveirah and not a mitzvah.4:42I'll explain what that means,4:45okay? If I am a rabbi of a shul,4:47which happens to me,4:47I think I am a rabbi of a shul,4:49okay?4:49But if I'm a rabbi of a shul4:51and I see there's a guy4:53who walked into my shul,4:56he's clearly not religious.4:59You're going to ask me,4:59how do I know?5:00Well, he's got a mohawk.5:01You know, the mohawk5:02where they shave the sides of the head5:04and the middle is like the standing up,5:06you know, it's about five inches tall,5:08right?5:09And his hair is colored pink and blue,5:11and he's got this earring,5:13and he's wearing ripped jeans,5:15and he's being led by one of the5:16guys in my shul5:17that I know loves to do kiruv.5:20And clearly this guy who's walking in5:22is lost,5:23right?5:23He's this guy who is way off,5:25right?5:26He walks into my shul5:27and he sits down.5:29He's given an English siddur,5:30and I'm watching this.5:32And then I see in the middle of5:34tefillah, or5:35Chazarah — Chazarah is a good one, right?5:37— in the middle of5:38Chazarah, of the repetition of5:40the Amidah by the chazzan, this guy with the mohawk5:42turns to another person next to him5:44and he says something,5:45and he laughs.5:47Okay? Now, he's clearly not asking a halacha.5:49He's clearly saying a joke,5:50right?5:51He got the other guy also to laugh.5:52So what do I do?5:53I go over to him5:55and I yell at him.5:56So what are you doing?5:57You come into shul to talk?5:58This is a shul,6:00the house of God.6:01It's a house where Hashem6:03is. Where's your respect to God?6:05This is how you do?6:06This is how you act?6:08Now,6:08did I just do according to halacha?6:11If you look in Shulchan Aruch,6:12the Shulchan Aruch says6:14that whoever speaks in6:20Chazarat HaShatz, right, gadol avono mineso, vegoarin bo. You have to yell at him.6:22You have to put him in place.6:24Now, I did according to halacha,6:26right?6:27Now everybody's going to agree6:28that's crazy.6:29What did I accomplish in that?6:31What did I accomplish in that?6:32This is where I'm putting my foot on.6:34I'm putting my foot up against what?6:35Against this guy.6:36Hazit, he just walked in.6:37It's probably his first Jewish experience,6:39and you yelled at him.6:40Where do you think he'd get to6:42with the guy? Do you think this guy has hope in your shul?6:44Forget about your shul;6:45he has no hope anywhere.6:46But I did6:46it, says in halacha.6:47I yelled at him.6:49Everybody with6:50a sechel, with a brain,6:52understands that6:54it's not the yelling that's a mitzvah.6:56Shulchan Aruch says,6:57goarin bo. You have to yell at him.6:59That's not what he means.7:00It means you have to make sure he doesn't talk.7:02So back then,7:03where everybody's religious,7:04everybody understands7:05that when the rabbi yells,7:06it means to put you in place.7:07So when he says,7:08goarin bo, he'll understand he's doing something wrong.7:09He's going to fix himself.7:10And nowadays,7:11he's not going to understand when you yell at him,7:12because he's going to say,7:13Oh, you're yelling at me.7:14Wow, these crazy black-hat fanatics.7:16What did I do7:17for? He's going to walk out.7:18So it's not the act;7:19the result of the act.7:21The act itself is not mitzvah.7:24So let's take this now7:25and apply it on kids.7:27I told him he's had a crazy day.7:29By the way, notice7:31whenever you are yelling at your kids,7:33it's usually because you had a very hard day.7:36On top of that,7:37your wife said,7:37Your son is driving me nuts.7:40Okay? Keep that in mind, by the way.7:42So the wife adds that pressure.7:45And, chas v'shalom, it's not always the wife's fault.7:46Sometimes the wife gets the pressure7:47from everybody else.7:49Either the school called her,7:50the neighbors are complaining,7:51or the other kids are complaining7:53about that child.7:54So there's an—8:00The added pressure that's going to our lives, and everything builds up.8:04What do we do? We come and we start yelling at the kid,8:07What's wrong with you? Where's your brain? Do something!8:11And I don't know, all different types of nice lines.8:14What do you think that happens?8:16Now, because whoever is listening to me is an adult,8:19I want you to understand that just like that guy with the mohawk,8:24when he gets yelled at, when he gets yelled at from the rabbi,8:30and he, you know, he has no clue what the rabbi is talking about.8:34He has no clue. Why is he flipping out? What's the big deal?8:37Because he wasn't taught.8:40I would say the same thing 80% of the time with our kids.8:43Not 20%, but 80% of the time.8:4580% of the time, our children were not taught the right way, and we just yell them.8:51And you can say, What do you mean? I said in my house a lot of8:52times. So again, I repeat, our children were not taught.8:58You making an announcement in your house,9:01you making a declaration and making a constitution in your house9:06doesn't mean you taught your children the right way.9:08When I say to my kids, Why don't you clean up?9:12Yeah, that doesn't mean I taught them,9:15and therefore when they didn't clean up, I could yell at them.9:17No, I didn't teach them.9:18I made a declaration. I made an announcement.9:23You must clean up.9:24What do the kids know about cleaning up?9:27There's a great story that I always remember,9:29and I know I'm going a lot on this9:32because I believe it's very important. I have to do two parts,9:35okay? Now, there's a great story that I remember hearing from one of my rabbis.9:38I think it's a mashal, but it's cute.9:40A kid comes home to his mother and he says,9:42Mom, I learned today in school something very important.9:44She said, Oh yeah? What's so important, my little9:47six-year-old? He says, I learned that we must have breakfast.9:52Breakfast is the most important part of the day.9:54It's the most important meal of the day.9:56When you have breakfast, you can do everything.9:59You can learn better. You can be healthier.10:02You'll grow up to be tall. You'll be a great ball player,10:05and you'll be able to...10:06Wow, he kept on in. That's great.10:08Okay, so he tells her, From now on, I want to have breakfast.10:12Sure. What would you like for breakfast?10:14Would you like cereal and10:15milk? He says, No, mommy. We need to have breakfast.10:18He says, Oh, okay, maybe some eggs,10:20some hard-boiled eggs with some bread and some cheese.10:23He says, No, mommy, you need breakfast.10:25Oh, so you want waffles and syrup?10:27No, mommy, we need breakfast.10:29So you mean French toast?10:30No, no, mommy, we need breakfast.10:32So you want maybe a bagel with cream cheese and, you know, what's it called, an10:40omelet? No, mommy, we need breakfast.10:44Now, mommy stops for a second.10:47She was a smart mommy.10:49I'll tell you why she was a smart mommy in a second.10:51And she says, My six-year-old sweetheart, what is breakfast?10:56I don't know. Never thought about that.10:59I know breakfast is important, but I never thought what breakfast is.11:02Aha, right?11:03Now, why did I say this mother is smart?11:05Because when we yell at our kids and we say, Clean up,11:08we never stop and we never wonder and we never ask,11:11Did I teach them how to clean up?11:13Did I go through the whole procedure?11:14What do you mean I have to go through the procedure?11:15They see me doing it every day.11:16No.11:17If you never actually went through the actual procedure11:19and you went through each detail,11:21don't expect your kids to know.11:23And if they don't know, they were never taught.11:26You can't yell at them.11:28You cannot yell at them.11:30And in the crazy halacha, the halacha says that11:32when a person does an aveirah, he has to be warned,11:34and he has to do that in order to be punished11:36for whatever aveirah it is.11:37He has to be warned by two witnesses.11:41They have to quote him the source in the Torah,11:43and they have to tell him exactly what he's doing is wrong.11:45And the person who's committing the aveirah has to do it11:48within a second or two from the warning.11:50If he does it five minutes later after the warning,11:52you cannot punish him.11:53Why?11:53Because maybe he forgot about the warning.11:56Because you want to hit somebody,11:57you got to make sure.11:58You want to discipline somebody,11:59you got to make sure12:00that he really actually did it on purpose, intentional.12:03And if we never taught our kids the right way,12:06what are we expecting from them?12:07So that's why I came back to what I said originally:12:1080% of the time that we yell at our kids,12:13it's not called for.12:13One, it's not effective.12:15Why is it not effective?12:17We know why. Well, the proof that it's not effective,12:18because all parents complain to me12:20and they say, You know how many times I12:21yell, it doesn't work.12:22So clearly we're doing something wrong.12:24There's something wrong with our system.12:26The yelling will only work if they were taught12:28what they're supposed to do,12:29and they know that what they're doing is not wrong,12:31and then I could discipline them.12:33So if it's not effective, we can't use it.12:37If I yell at the guy with the, with the, with the, what's it called, with the earrings12:41and the colored hair in my12:44shul, and it doesn't work,12:45then I shouldn't be doing it,12:47right?12:48So we come back over here,12:49and it's a very important introduction to when we see12:52when Chazal tell us,12:53or the Torah tells us,12:54or excuse me,12:55or someone tells us,12:56that you have to hit your son,12:58hitting, yelling, all these things,13:00if they don't work,13:01then there's no mitzvah in doing them.13:05We're obviously doing something wrong13:06that it's not working.13:07So we got to figure out what should be our system13:09in order for it to work.13:11Now what's that system?13:12Be'ezrat Hashem, next time we'll continue.