Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 11Sefer Even ShelemaPart 104Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0016:00Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Eben Shlema, perek vav, ot chet. This is the last piece in Chinuch HaYeladim, and it's been a very, very interesting perek so far.0:07We spoke a lot of concepts, and like we said, raising children is never an easy thing,0:13and nowadays even much more so. But we brought a lot of fundamental ideas.0:18Let's see the last part over here.0:23Nimtza im shenei minei mochichim. Says Eben Shlema, it comes out that there are two people, there are two styles of people when they come to correcting others.0:33One style is a person who, when he wants to correct somebody, he uses hard, harsh words.0:39He embarrasses them. He knocks them.0:43And that's why usually these kind of people, their words are not accepted.0:46A person who is wise comes with good things.0:53He comes with nichumim. He comes with words of consolation, and he brings them close to Torah,0:59like Moshe amru b'Aharon, like says about Aharon HaKohen.1:02What does it say about Aharon, famous Mishnah Avot? Hillel omer: Hevei mitalmidav shel Aharon. Be of the students of Aharon.1:13Ohev shalom, v'rodef shalom, ohev et habriyot umekarvan laTorah. Look at the whole statement.1:17By the way, something I know by heart, it says on the bottom over here. Look at the words of the Mishnah completely. Look what does it1:20say. It says, Love peace and love people, and then you bring them to the Torah.1:26You have to love them to be able to bring them to the1:29Torah, something that we spoke about yesterday.1:34And even then, even though you can love people, right, the resha'im, the people who are1:42resha'im, are only for a moment's time, they listen and they won't actually follow through.1:50Okay, now there's so much to talk about. We will come back to it.1:52We just want to finish the, you know, the piece.1:55The next paragraph says,2:00Also, a lot of people will tell you problems.2:03We mentioned this in one of the speeches2:06on my parashat, I think, so we mentioned this.2:10A lot of people complain. Sounds like complaining. What does that mean? A lot of people will tell you what the issues are,2:15but they don't tell you how to fix them,2:18right?2:18But the person who's smart, who's wise, doesn't just tell you the problems,2:27but he tells you how to fix the problems, how to heal the sickness.2:32Now, people who express themselves like the stabs of the sword,2:41but the language of the chachamim heals people.2:46And this is also, it needs discussion by itself,2:49but it's so, so important to know this concept.2:53There are people, a lot of people tell you the problems.2:55If you pay attention, it's so sad.2:57A lot of times you hear people that say problems,2:59but they don't tell you how to fix it.3:01And I'm guilty of that sometimes myself.3:04A few weeks ago I spoke about a big issue,3:06and somebody came to me and very sincere says,3:09Chacham, you're telling us the issue, but you're not telling us what to do about it.3:11And I said, You're right.3:13That's not fair3:14of me. And it happens to be, the reason why I didn't say the answer is3:17I have about an hour and a half prepared of how to solve that particular issue.3:22I can even say3:24it's the issue of internet and how to deal with the internet3:27and children, our children raising our children in this modern age where technology is all over,3:32and how do you deal with it.3:34I have an hour and a half of solutions.3:36The problem is that when I speak on3:40Seudah Shlishit, I only have 15 to 20 minutes to speak.3:44How much can I say?3:45I can at least only present a little bit of the problem.3:49So, be'ezrat Hashem, I would like to make a3:52course—what do you call it,3:54this course? A workshop, basically. I'd like to call it basically3:58three classes on this idea, and we'll see.4:01We're going to work on it in the near future.4:03Meanwhile, I'm working with schools on this.4:05But why am I mentioning this?4:07Because you can't just say problems without solutions.4:10And again, I am guilty of it sometimes also.4:13But you have to know, we all have to know,4:16that when we point out issues, we have to be ready for a4:21solution. The chochmah of Yitro,4:23and I believe one of the reasons why Yitro, the Torah4:27gives a special parashah,4:29gives him the— you know, the parashah is named after him—4:31is because throughout all the Torah,4:33we find people that complained and they brought out the problems4:35that were existent or relevant in the time,4:38but nobody came with a solution.4:40Nobody came with a solution.4:41Everybody just said the problem.4:43Yitro was the only one who came and he told Moshe,4:45Here's the problem. You're sitting by yourself judging the whole entire nation,4:48and here's the solution.4:49You make a system exactly like this to the bottom detail,4:52and he came and prescribed it for him.4:56We saw somebody has a problem,4:58we have to tell him the solution with it.5:00What's a problem that we see?5:01We see people that are what?5:03They're not going to shul,5:04and they're not waking up5:05for Shacharit. Well, you're not going to shul.5:08Okay, helpless guy. How are you going to help this guy?5:10How are we helping him?5:11We just— okay, we know the problem.5:12How are we helping him?5:14Are we providing him maybe a ride?5:16Are we finding out what really his problem is,5:18right?5:19So we picked up this symptom: he's not going to shul.5:22We speak to him.5:22How can he not go to shul?5:23I have a hard time waking up.5:25Why? What time do you go to sleep?5:27That's my issue.5:28I have a very hard time sleeping.5:30Well, you got to sleep early.5:31What's this?5:32Shul is important,5:33and how do you not go?5:36What's that? You're not helping the guy.5:37He knows it's5:38a problem. He's telling you what this problem is.5:39At least, Baruch Hashem, you figure it out.5:42So, okay, we're going to work on this together.5:43We're going to get you vitamin that helps you go to sleep earlier.5:46Whatever it is,5:47you5:48get your full sleep. I'll come pick you5:49up. Whatever it is,5:50but come up with a solution.5:52It doesn't have to be you helping him,5:53but you have to give him a solution as well.5:55Go back to the first idea,5:57and that is the two types of6:00mochechim. There are two types of people that, when they correct6:04others, there's ones who speak very strongly6:06and they bash, basically,6:07they knock,6:09and there's others that speak, you know, in a soft way.6:11And he's telling you the derech of Aharon, the way he won over people is that the one who spoke softly.6:18And now, it seems to me there's a lot of speakers out there that seem to show us that the right way is to knock,6:25the right way is to speak harsh,6:27the right way is to, you know, sometimes even speak a little bit insulting,6:31because you have to tell the people the truth6:32and you have to give it to them straight,6:34and that's the way,6:35and that's—and they're preaching,6:37they go around6:37preaching—that's the right way that works,6:39not the other way.6:39So what's going on? The Gra is saying over here that the soft way is what works.6:44So I put out that video on purpose, you know, like in the chat—not in the chat,6:49I don't like to call it,6:50it's not a chat,6:50it's only me talking and only me sending the things.6:52So I put out that video based on the class we gave recently.6:56It's about that teacher that welcomes the students with the handshakes,7:01and the other teacher that whips everybody, right?7:04So that's the same idea with disciplining,7:07that people who speak harsh, the people correct,7:10and there are people who speak softly.7:13Just like the case of the whipping,7:14we said the whipping works immediately,7:18but the problem with it is that it only works for that time,7:21it doesn't work for later on.7:22So too, because it's like, you know, the famous saying in English,7:26Easy come... Easy go.7:28So that's the same thing over here when it comes to the way people speak.7:33The people who speak harsh and they made an instant effect,7:38easy come, easy go.7:39If you convince somebody by scaring him7:41and you spend five minutes and you instill fear in him,7:45then easy come, easy go.7:47Because later on that fear eventually wears out,7:49especially in our generation7:50when there's so many things that, you know, take away that fear,7:54right?7:54So people you could have, you're really affecting.7:56I don't know how many people you're really, really affecting, but if—8:00You spoke to the person, right, b'derchei noam, and you explained to him, and you clarified for him, and you8:05showed him what the Torah is about. It might have to take you longer to explain to him,8:09but that will usually have a bigger effect.8:12Nobody's telling you to hide the truth.8:14Nobody's telling you to avoid the truth.8:15No, you say the truth,8:17but the way you say it, the way you come out, that's the difference.8:21Let's see where it comes from.8:23The Gra, in his commentary to Mishlei, has a big piece over here. We'll do part of it8:28today.8:29No, I think we can do all of it today. Let's see.8:31Pasuk says in8:33Mishlei, Kesef nivchar lashon tzaddik,8:38lev resha'im kim'at. Kesef nivchar, silver, the choicest of silver, we call today sterling silver, is lashon tzaddik.8:46Is the tongue of a tzaddik,8:48and the heart of the resha'im is kemat, is very tiny.8:51What does that mean?8:52Says the Gra, there's a pasuk that says,9:01הַמַּשְׂכִּלִים יַזְהִרוּ כְּזֹהַר הָרָקִיעַ, וּמַצְדִּיקֵי הָרַבִּים כַּכּוֹכָבִים לְעוֹלָם וָעֶד. The wise people will shine in the future when Mashiach comes like the shine of the sky.9:06You know, the sky in the middle of the day when there's no clouds, how it shines.9:10And the matzdikei rabim, people who cause others to do good, they'll also be like the9:17stars forever and ever.9:18He says,9:20יש שני ענייני צדיקים. There are two types of tzaddikim.9:23היינו משכילים, מצדיקים. You see the pasuk referring to two types of tzaddikim.9:25One is called the maskilim, one is called9:28matzdikim. And9:33חזל tells us in מסכת סוטה, רבי חייא בר אבא בדרש מתאתא, ורבי אבהו בדרש אגדתא. Hadatahas Rabbi Chiya bar Abba was once teaching a9:38shiur halacha, and Rabbi Abahu was giving a shiur in9:43aggadata, which is like basically stories and mashalim and different things.9:49ואותם הדורשים מלמדים לעם שמעתתא הם נקראים משכילים. The ones who teach halachot, they're called9:52maskilim. Why?9:56Because they're educating the people in the right way,9:58making sure that they become knowledgeable in halachot and knowing what to do,10:02and eventually they become talmidei chachamim. They know how to open a10:04sefer, they know how to learn Gemara, they know how to open up a10:09Tur. ואותם הדורשים אגדתא הם נקראים מצדיקים. And the ones who teach Torah10:13that is more like stories and mashalim that draw to people's heart,10:16they're called10:21matzdikim. Why? לפי שהם מושכים לבן של בני אדם לתורה שמדרך. Because they pull them.10:22It's much more attractive, right?10:23It's much easier to listen to a class on stories and10:28mashalim than it is to listen to a class on, you10:31know, concepts of Torah that are deeper, like in halacha and machlokot and different things.10:40וכנגדם בעולם הם זהב וכסף. Now this is the two types of tzaddikim,10:41and in the world we find two types of people also.10:44There are people—excuse me—in the world we find two types of precious stones.10:48There's gold and there's silver.10:51Zahav10:54eino nitan lashimsh, shekonim בהם דברים יקרים. Gold, you don't really need gold.10:56Who needs gold?10:57The ashirim, the ones on a higher level, they need the gold,11:00because they use it to buy precious things.11:02But the aniyim11:05shekonim, they bring it, the aniyim, ... but the aniyim, all they need is silver,11:07which is primarily the ingredient that's used for coins,11:10even though today it's changed to metal.11:14That's why silver and money is called kesef.11:18Why? From the word nichsaf, which is11:20draws. Everybody's drawn to it.11:22... because everybody can use it.11:23Everybody can use money,11:27dineros. Shegam ashirim ... and ashirim also,11:28they don't only use gold;11:29they also use,11:30and they use the regular money to buy small things.11:35And the same idea also when it comes to correcting people.11:38Like it says in the Gemara,11:40... all the people, when they came to hear the shiurei Torah,11:43they didn't go to11:47Rav Chiya bar Abba, because he was teaching11:48halachot; it was too hard for them.11:49They went to Abahu, who was teaching the stories and everything else.11:55Uvekesef, יש גם כן שני דברים. In the silver, there's also two types.12:00There's matbe'a ... יש מטבע ... There's a cheaper material, which not everybody accepts,12:04because it's not made from the finest material.12:12Everybody tries to avoid it.12:13It's like using pesos.12:15Pesos works, but only works in selected countries.12:19Vasheni, and ... like the dollar,12:21right? It's made where it's accepted everywhere.12:24Everybody accepts the dollar.12:24V'kol bocharimot, everybody wants to use it,12:27right? So he says also by12:30mochichim, there are two types of people when they correct others.12:33He says, like the Gemara says,12:34Tamei ani, yesh ba-dor hazeh12:37mi sheyodea lehochiach. The Gemara says,12:39Masechet Arachin, that one of the rabbis says,12:41I wonder if there's anybody who really knows how to correct others.12:45We mentioned this yesterday.12:46I said12:47the Chazon Ish says it. It looks like it's a Gemara.12:49Penei shemochiach bidvarim kashim bazeh, ve'omrim, Penei, ma ata oseh12:54kach? U'macharifo. Because there are people, when they come to correct,12:56they start yelling.12:57They embarrass the guy,12:59right?13:00He doesn't accept it. He doesn't really accept it.13:01He'll just agree to you in front of you,13:03but he doesn't really accept it.13:07Ach ha-tzadik sheyodea... ba-dvarim tovim u'vinuchim. The tzaddik who knows how to correct, he comes with good words,13:11comes with soft words.13:14Karev oto laTorah bishvil sheyishma elav. He brings him closer to Torah.13:16He brings him closer to himself.13:18He makes a relationship with13:19him because he knows later on he'll listen to him.13:24V'kol nechsafim elav kemo Aharon. And everybody is drawn to him,13:26like the way Aharon, everybody was drawn to him13:27because Aharon loved peace,13:29and he pursued peace,13:31and he loved the people,13:32and that's why he's able to bring them closer to Torah.13:35V'zeh kesef13:36nehar. That's the meaning of kesef13:39nehar. Let's go back to the pasuk.13:40What does it mean, kesef13:41nehar? The choices of the silver.13:43Remember, silver is something that draws everybody.13:46Everybody needs silver,13:48but remember, we said that everybody accepts all types of silver.13:51So what's the choice? Silver.13:53What's the dollar?13:54What's the commodity like the dollar13:55everybody accepts?13:57What is that?13:58He says that's the lashon of the14:00tzaddik. That's the one who corrects them14:02with nachat, like Aharon14:03HaKohen, who draws them closer,14:08okay? And the ones—but we see it doesn't work on everybody.14:11You see, it doesn't work on everybody.14:12You see a lot of people that are in kiruv14:14and they try, and it doesn't work on everybody.14:15He says, you know why?14:20After shemo divrei tzaddik, eino machmatesor shedivrei tzaddik. It's not the problem of the14:22tzaddik, the people14:28who will not חוזר בתשובה, אך הוא מחמת שלבם של רשעים הוא רך ואינו נכנע אל השם מועטת. That's because these14:30reshaim, they want to be, they want to do bad.14:32They don't want to correct themselves,14:34and therefore they only do for14:36a temporary time,14:37and then it goes back to be like it used to be.14:41And that's why the Gemara says,14:43Masechet14:46Taanit, כל תלמיד חכם שאינו קשה כברזל אינו תלמיד חכם. A talmid chacham who is not as hard14:48as steel is not14:55a talmid chacham. כי בזה קשה לעשותו נקב, אך אם עשו בו נקב אינו נסתם הנקב. Metal,14:56iron, is very, very14:57hard to make a hole in it, but once you make a hole, it's very hard to15:00fix it. Why?15:02Because it's a hard material.15:05מה שאין כן אם נעשה נקב בדבר רך, if you made a hole in something that's soft,15:11תכף אחר נקב נסתם וחוזר להיות כבתחילה, then it becomes very easy to fix.15:15He says, we find by15:16the Jewish people, they're called15:17עם קשה עורף, they're very stubborn.15:19What does that mean?15:22Because15:23reshaim, they're only for the moment, the time15:25they make that hole, that incision in them,15:27they make the impact on them.15:31Afterwards they come back and everything is sealed.15:34But the Jewish people are,15:35compared to עם קשה עורף, they're stubborn,15:37they're hard. But when you15:39finally succeed to make a hole in them,15:41you finally succeed to influence them a little bit,15:43let's say, you could be set for sure15:45that they're going to15:47do the right thing.15:49I think we went off time. I went a little bit over time.15:51We covered almost everything, pretty much.15:53We're going to move on to perek zayin tomorrow.