Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 6, Lesson 1Sefer Even ShelemaPart 94Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:48Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Perek vav in Eben Shlema, ot aleph. We're beginning a new perek. This perek deals with raising one's children according to the Torah and how to give tochachah to people.0:14Now, raising children in our days, the practical way of doing it may not necessarily be mentioned over here. I'll try to mention it, but I want to point out from the0:25beginning, a lot of things that we will learn over here is more of what happens as a result of our efforts in raising our children, or lack of effort in raising our children.0:37That's something. A lot of times people see, and I always say this to a lot of people, there's a Shulchan Aruch that we have to keep.0:45Shulchan Aruch is very, very big. It has four halakim and halachot that we have to keep. Some people have challenges with certain halachot more than others.0:52Shulchan Aruch doesn't tell you each person in his situation has to keep it. You have to figure out how to do that.0:58L'mashal, I'll give you a very, very common case that happens by a lot of people.1:02A person, the Shulchan Aruch writes in Yoreh Deah, siman tof kaf, the dinim of dipping kelim. You have to take a kli and dip them in a mikveh. Good, that's a1:14halacha. Now, a guy gets married, he gets so many gifts, and he gets expensive stuff and everything else, and now nothing has been dipped.1:21Oh, he says so much, how am I supposed to dip everything? Shulchan Aruch says you have to dip it. Go figure it out now.1:27You might have to hire a moving company. You might have to get a few yeshiva guys. You might have to use1:34plastic tole. I don't know what to tell you, but the halacha says you have to dip it, and you got to figure out the steps that you need to go dip it.1:41Take the same halacha to a different person. I dip my kelim, I'm very good, but I'm eating by my mother-in-law, and I'm eating by my parents, I'm eating by my siblings, and they don't dip their1:54kelim. I'm not talking about me personally, right? This is a question we get all the time, right? What do I do then?1:59Again, halacha says you cannot eat from kelim that were not dipped. That's a2:04halacha. Now, you want your local rabbi, who knows your situation very well, and he knows your family, knows how to deal with it, could tell you a way to keep this2:11halacha. If he tells you a way to break this halacha, that's a big problem, right? But he could tell you a way to keep this2:17halacha. So, but the halacha is there. You have to figure it out now, how to do it.2:21You're bringing that tzvikaation time, or at least towards the end of vacation time, people go away on vacation.2:27I have only to buy minyan. Halacha says a person who prays without a minyan, his tefillah is very hard to be mitkabel, especially that we're not mechaven nowadays, right?2:34If you pray minyan, the tefillah is mitkabelet. You got to figure it out.2:37What do I do without kosher? Halacha says you have to eat kosher. You got to figure out now how you eat kosher.2:41You might have to eat vegetables for the next couple of weeks. Maybe you should take meat frozen and go buy yourself a grill, or just the top of it. There's ways to get it, right?2:49But everything is like that. So with that, I want to come to2:54chinuch ha'yaladim. When it comes to halachot, sometimes people don't know how to deal with halachot. They hear the halacha and they flip out.3:01Has to be dipped, he ends up at his in-laws' house. He doesn't care about their feelings. He doesn't care about their kavod because he doesn't know them, right?3:08And he doesn't think that it should mean anything. He comes to his, you know, in his house maybe when he yelled, he got his way around3:14because his parents didn't know how to raise him, didn't teach him good derech eretz, good manners.3:17But when he comes to now his in-laws' house, he starts yelling also, You guys are a bunch of resha'im. What are you guys doing here?3:23So it doesn't work that way, because his father-in-law is very tough, right?3:28And he's going to put him in his place, and we're going to have fights and all these things, so it doesn't work.3:33And some people go, What do you mean? The3:36halacha, halacha, halacha. Whoa, there's a big... Shulchan Aruch is very big also.3:39You only know the halacha of siman kuf chaf. I don't even know if you know it inside.3:43All you learned is that you have to dip your keilim, but did you learn the halachot of3:47derech eretz? Did you learn the halachot of kibud av va'em, which also apply to your mother-in-law and father-in-law? Did you know that?3:51Right?3:56That kibed et and kibed et imecha, that a bot also, hamicha vhamodcha. You stand up when your father walks into the house, into the room.3:59You stand up when your father-in-law or your mother-in-law walk into the room.4:01And if you haven't done it yet, you better start doing it. That's4:05halacha Shulchan Aruch. So there's a big Shulchan Aruch, right?4:07There's a lot of different areas in halacha. You have to keep all of it. You can't just keep some of it4:12and consider yourself a tzaddik, right?4:14Don't use one halacha to trample over another4:17halacha. So, rabotai, we bring you also the chinuch yeladim also.4:20That's a very important introduction in general.4:22But for chinuch yeladim, it's an area that I feel a lot of people are lost.4:27I'll tell you why they're lost in a second.4:29They're lost, they're confused, and they're really, you know, sometimes you want to throw in the towel a little bit.4:36And the reason for that is for a simple reason,4:40because it's an amazing, amazing thing of how the generations,4:44how times are changing so fast. The world is changing so fast.4:49Maybe, not maybe, I could honestly say4:53anybody who is a parent today was raised differently from the way they're raising their own children.4:59Now, it's always like that.5:00No, it wasn't always like that.5:03I could also comfortably say that 150 years ago,5:07150 years ago, not 100 years ago, but 150 years ago,5:10you were raised the same way that your parents were raised,5:14and therefore you raised your children the same way, and it worked,5:17because the world didn't change.5:20A certain amount of fear of parents, a certain amount of discipline,5:23or a certain amount of freedom that the children had without us being worried,5:27where are they going, what's happening, right, could be done.5:30But nowadays, where children could be exposed to the worst things in society5:35just with a mere telephone, right?5:37If any kid has a cell phone, they're exposed to the whole entire world.5:41And somehow we want to kind of like take them around the whole world5:45or give them the access to the whole world5:47and at the same time protect them from everything else, right?5:50Besides that, the whole society looks down on authority, right?5:54We live in a country that has freedom of speech,5:56and you can say whatever you want to whoever you want,5:59and it could be the president of the United States,6:01and you could throw a shoe at him.6:03And everybody will praise you, and they'll sell the shul in an auction for fifty, seventy thousand dollars, right?6:08And you could be, what's it called?6:11So in Syria, for those of us who do remember, I grew up in Syria,6:14and I remember one time I was a kid, and I said something as a joke as a kid,6:19and I said about Hafez al-Assad, who, the father of Bashar6:22al-Assad, I said as a joke. Oh my gosh, I was, like, taken into a corner:6:27Don't you ever say that again. You don't know where you're gonna end up.6:30I never, ever in my life did I ever say it again.6:33And then he died. I can't say about him anymore.6:35That's it. But even now, when I would say something on the government,6:39my father, who actually lived through those kind of things,6:42and he was accused of a lot of things that he didn't even say,6:45and he went through the tzar, he would give me a look in the middle of my class and tell me,6:48anything that I say about the Arab world, he gets very nervous6:51because he knows what it's like till today, right?6:54But we live in a freedom, a world of freedom of expression and freedom of6:58speech, and therefore statements as follows, right, from your children is not unheard of:7:05You're an idiot. I never saw such dumb people in my life.7:09I wish I wasn't your kid. I wish I wasn't part of your family.7:12You're the worst parents in the world. You don't give us anything.7:15I wish that you... right? You're—excuse me, is that what you're calling your parents?7:21And I'm not talking about kids that grew up on the street7:23and they're watching TV and they're watching the7:25worst, the worst, for sure. Forget it. I hear even worse things that I can't even say over here.7:30There's a lot of deeps I have to say, right, when I've heard kids literally in front of me,7:34that's the way they talk to their parents.7:35But even kids that grew up in good yeshivot, in good places,7:39they—the society is such they could say whatever comes to mind.7:44There's no—that the self-control is not exercised and it's not practiced, right?7:51And I'm entitled, that entitlement, that feeling. Could we change?8:00In society, very difficult. Can we control it? Can we use it to our benefit? We could.8:06So therefore, we have to be very careful in knowing that when we learn a lot of stuff,8:10we can say, Oh my...8:11Sometimes, if you just take the, you know, like let's come back to the halacha of dipping8:17kelim. Halacha, you have to dip kelim. A husband, she wrote today on the chiyuv of dipping8:21kelim, and I'm going to make sure these kelim that we don't eat by my8:24in-laws have something. I make sure that they should understand8:27that we're doing a bunch of reshaim; they're not keeping the halacha, right?8:30Anybody who knows halacha doesn't keep his... No, I'm going to make sure they get it.8:34Now, the tactic of how you keeping halacha is wrong.8:39There's ways of how to do it,8:40and if you try to do it in this way, you're going to end up with more problems than regular.8:43Now, if my wife sides with them,8:46I'll divorce her. I need to live with such a8:50rasha? Well, I'm being a little extreme, but usually I just took a story of ten years,8:54I made it into one line.8:56That's what really happened.8:57This led to that, to that, to that, to8:59that, and then we have all these problems.9:01So, with that, with that, let's come back to9:05chinuch eladim. What we learn here, you know, as one of our favorite guys in the class says,9:10Don't shake your body, right?9:12That when you learn over here, understand that this is how it is,9:16but you have to know that the way to get to it,9:19you need a rabbi that knows how to guide you,9:21or you need sometimes maybe some counseling9:24and some—because counseling is needed when we can't keep the same system we grew up with,9:29right?9:29And being the system that we grew up with doesn't work in our days.9:33It just doesn't work.9:34Why?9:35Because, like I told you, when society changes, you have to adjust,9:38you know, you have to adjust your plan also,9:40just like you do in business.9:41You don't say, This is the same shoe I've been selling all my life.9:45I'm going to sell the same shoe.9:46It's a shoe. You need to walk.9:50A style has changed. If you don't get the bottom white thing, you know, today you're not gonna sell.9:54That's it. What do you mean? I'm selling the shoe.9:56Okay, good.9:57And I don't care about internet.9:59I sell in the store.10:01Customers are not walking in.10:02What happened?10:03Amazon took over.10:03If you don't start going online,10:04the world is changing.10:06You have to adapt to it.10:07Why, when it comes to our10:09chinuch yeladim, we don't have the same concept, and we say,10:12That's the way I grew up.10:14I got beat up and it's gonna work,10:15and I don't understand.10:17Till today, I still talk to parents that still have that mindset that the way it worked for me is gonna work.10:23And I ask them in the store, How do10:25you sell the same merchandise?10:26No, you update.10:27Oh, for that you update.10:28You get the10:292.0. And if you get a phone, an iPhone, you know, 10, whatever, up to 11,10:34you know you can't use the iOS, you know, the 4,10:37right? You have to use the updated one.10:38Why?10:39It doesn't work.10:41I believe it's the same thing over here.10:42You need to update also.10:43So these concepts are emet because they are what the Chazal tell us.10:47But again, I'm warning very, very much,10:50and really I barely started, because when you come to listen to it,10:53I'm not gonna say it again and again.10:54I might mention here and there,10:56but in how to apply it, you need guidance on how to apply it.11:00Good.11:01Let's just read the ... today.11:05Me'od tzarich adam l'hashgiach al nafsho sheyelchu בדרכי ה'. A person has to be very, very much on top of his children11:09to make sure that they go in the ways of Hashem.11:12L'hashgiach, like any mashgiach in the yeshiva or mashgiach in the kitchen,11:15you don't actually have to cook.11:16You have to be on the lookout,11:18right? You have to be on top of it.11:20You can't let your kids just go and, you know, let them figure it out,11:24unless you have a plan,11:26which means your plan means they're gonna figure it out.11:29But you have to be on top of your children.11:33כי חס ושלום ... אב ואם מאוד. You might say, What do I care?11:35Let them, let them, you know, that's their life.11:39They can do whatever they want in their lives.11:40And my parents say, some people, especially young people, say,11:43My kids can do whatever they want.11:44Today, some people take that to the extreme.11:47My kid could choose if he wants to be a boy or a girl.11:49You know, it's his choice. I can't force it upon him.11:51It doesn't work like that, because if the kids mess up,11:54even parents get punished.11:55I want to read you a Midrash that's brought down11:58in the Shevet Chochma. It says as follows.12:00The Chavetz Chaim also brings it down in Shemirat HaLashon.12:03It says,12:05Malach Chabalah Chamishi. The fifth one,12:09makeh et aviv v'imo. He hits a person's parents.12:14And he tells them,12:15Why didn't you put your children in the right places12:18where they should learn Torah,12:22k'dei sheya'asu mitzvot u'ma'asim tovim? Because if he studies Torah,12:23you know that he's going to end up doing12:26mitzvot and ma'asim tovim. And by learning Torah and keeping12:30mitzvot, it'll keep him away from bad12:35aveirot. Then they give the malach permission12:37to hit the person's parents.12:42And if the kid did go l'talmud Torah,12:45the parents did send him to yeshiva.12:47They did what they have to do.12:48They bring the child and they hit the child12:50in the eyes of the parents.12:52The parents have to see the suffering12:53of their own child in front of them.12:55That's a scary thing, right?12:56So he's telling you,12:58you can't just say,13:00Oh, you know, my kids can do whatever they want.13:01No such a thing.13:02Parents should be very happy13:04and excited that their children are learning Torah.13:06And if a child says,13:06I want to go to Israel,13:07I want to go to yeshiva to learn,13:09parents should be elated.13:11Wow,13:12Baruch Hashem, this is your benefit,13:14not only his benefit.13:15First of all, he's happy.13:16I don't understand that.13:18If the child is telling,13:19I want to make this choice in my life,13:20No, you're not.13:21You're going to go to work.13:22The kid is doing the13:23right—he's not doing, he's not13:24thinking, I want to be a13:25pimp, you know what I'm saying?13:26He's not13:27telling you, I want to be a gangster.13:30He wants to go learn Torah,13:31and that's the choice he wants to make in his life.13:33No, you're going to be a doctor.13:34He doesn't want to be a doctor.13:35No, you're going to be a lawyer.13:36He doesn't want.13:37He wants to be this.13:38Let the kid do the choice in his life.13:40That's number one.13:41But more than that,13:42we're telling you,13:43it's your own benefit.13:44You end up gaining more13:45that your kid is a13:47talmid chacham. You gain more than anybody else.13:49Oh,13:50okay, we'll talk about that13:51later. Even the father is a tzaddik himself.14:01If he has a son that's a rasha, ... He didn't direct his child properly.14:04What does it mean that he's a tzaddik?14:06A tzaddik, that means he made it to Gan Eden.14:08When his son dies and he gets to14:11Gehinam, they bring the father from Gan Eden to see.14:13Well, tzaar that is.14:14The father's not getting punished by his pain,14:17by he's watching his son getting punished.14:20Look at the other ot over here14:22that's brought down on the bottom.14:24He says, when he means to say,14:28he says,14:29Tzaddik hainu shema'af lo asah et ha-mutal alav, az nash me'od kibo al ha'el, ve'af im asah et ha-mutal alav lechanech beno, ve'im ken eno נענש. Even if you did what you have to do14:35and you're not going to get punished,14:41mikol makom ro'eh beno kibo amemidrash, hanashim makin oto bifneihem, that you, unfortunately, you see14:43you did what you're supposed to be doing,14:45but your child didn't go that way,14:49and unfortunately ends up14:51that the father has to see14:52his son suffering.14:54It's kind of like, imagine,14:56lo aleinu, of children making the wrong choices14:58in their parents' lifetime,15:01right? And the parents have to go through15:02the embarrassment and the suffering15:04of such a thing,15:06right? So we have to be careful from the way in the beginning.15:08One last paragraph,15:10or one last line over here,15:12and it says,15:15Aval keshem yesader beno baderecho. When you discipline your son15:18and you direct him in the right ways,15:22as podeh haben et aviv miGehinnam vegam meol Gan Eden. So much so does it work out for you15:24to the point that15:25even if you ended up in15:28Gehinam, your son could pull you out of15:30Gehinam, and not only pull you out of15:32Gehinam, he could even put you in Gan15:36Eden. For that, be'ezrat Hashem we'll see15:37the words of the Gra tomorrow.15:39We just learned a very big introduction today,15:42and we're way over time.15:43And Hashem will continue tomorrow.