Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 5, Lesson 8Sefer Even ShelemaPart 91Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:15Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:07אבן שלמה, פרק ה', אות ז'. מי שיש לו מידות טובות ואינו עושה מצוות. A person who has good middot, he has good character traits.0:10He's polite. He's easygoing. He's nice. Doesn't get angry. He helps people.0:17But he doesn't do0:22mitzvot, hu k'nezem zahav b'af chazir. It's like putting jewelry on a pig.0:26You take a gold ring or a gold nose ring and you put it on a pig.0:32So the ring itself is expensive, but where is it on,0:38right? שמטנף אותו בהשפעה. And the pig, what is he doing?0:40He's taking this beautiful ring, and as we know, pigs eat in the garbage,0:44and they're going to dirty it.0:49כי כאשר מעשיו רעים, אז הוא מהפך גם המידות והתורה להרע. When your actions are no good, you have good middot, you're polite, you're sweet,0:55but you go against Hashem.0:57The guy is0:58mechalel Shabbat. The guy doesn't keep the Torah and1:01mitzvot. The guy doesn't keep the halachot in Shulchan Aruch.1:03So he has beautiful middot and it impresses a lot of people.1:07He's so kind, so helpful.1:09He does a lot of tzedakah, but he doesn't keep1:12mitzvot. He's1:14mechalel Shabbat. He's angering Hashem.1:15He eats whatever he wants.1:17Oh, you should see what he does1:20in—I don't want to say vacations, but I said it,1:24right?1:24So that's what the Gra is saying.1:27Where is it coming from?1:28So look inside over here on the bottom,1:36אות ט'. מי שיש לו מידות טובות. פסוק in Mishlei, it says it mefurash: נזם זהב באף חזיר. A gold nose ring on the nose of a pig is אשה יפה וסרת טעם. It's a beautiful woman which has no taste.1:51Before I get to the next statement,1:54just I remember one of my rabbis once pointing it out.1:56In American culture, there's a concept called a blonde.2:01What does that mean?2:03There's a, again, this is not to say this way,2:05all my kids are blonde almost, except for the oldest one,2:10right? So I'm not, clearly I have nothing against blondes,2:12right? But the idea of a blonde is that blondes are not smart.2:15Did you ever hear that?2:16There's a lot of jokes about blondes.2:18Oh, she's a blonde,2:19you know, okay. Like the famous joke: a blonde decides that one day she's gonna, you know, put on a2:24wig and she's gonna wear black hair so nobody could figure out that she's a blonde.2:28She walks into the store,2:29she says, Can I have a cheese sandwich?2:31And the store owner says, You must be blonde.2:33She says, How'd you know?2:34She's wearing a black wig.2:36He says, This is a hardware store.2:40Right?2:42So anyway, those are jokes2:44are all, you know, it's in American culture.2:47Again, I don't, you know, I don't have anything against blondes,2:49but I'm just telling you why is it that way.2:50But he said a nice idea.2:52Why is it that way?2:52The answer is because when you see something beautiful on the outside,2:56you expect that it should be beautiful all the way through and through,3:00right?3:00So if you see this beautiful, beautiful car,3:03take, I don't know, the BMW or the Ferraris, you know, the fancy cars,3:08right? Imagine you get into it and it breaks down.3:11Would you view it the same way as when you have an old 1998 Toyota Corolla, you know, breaking down?3:20No.3:21A Toyota Corolla of 1998 breaking down is very different when you have a Ferrari 2019 breaking down,3:27right?3:28Why?3:28Because you expect that if it's beautiful on the outside,3:31it should be also beautiful on the inside,3:32right?3:33It's a Toyota Corolla. It's a Toyota Corolla, 1998,3:35right?3:36So it should be through and through.3:37He said that's the concept also of a blonde.3:41It's an ishah yafah but3:44saratam. And she's not, you know, it's not a full package.3:47It's just only one part,3:48so it's a little bit deceiving.3:49And that's really, if you look at this pasuk, look what he's saying:3:54Ishah yefat toar v'sadat taam. I didn't even get to the פירוש of the Gra, but we could all understand that.3:57What he's saying is that only a beautiful woman, but she's rude, she's nasty,4:03so the package is not good.4:05So he says also, the Gra, he says, שלמה המלך is coming to represent4:10over—he's not only talking about beautiful women.4:12What שלמה המלך is coming to tell you is character traits4:17and avodat Hashem, שמידותיהם מהנפש דבקה לגוף. The middot are part of the soul4:22that we know, that nefesh, which is the lowest part of the five souls, which is attached to the body.4:31כאשר יש לה גם נפש שכלית שהיא מן התורה, אז היא יפה. And when that nefesh is also a nefesh that's doing the Torah,4:36that's based on the Torah,4:39so it's called the4:42yefat. כמראה של אדם תלוי בלב. Listen to the amazing thing:4:44the way a person looks depends on a person's heart.4:50לכן מי שיש לו מידות טובות הוא נקרא יפה מראה. That's why a person who has good middot, he's called4:56yafeh mareh. It's amazing.4:57We think that when we read the Torah, we understand what we're reading.5:00We read about how in Mahot were beautiful,5:03read about Esther was beautiful,5:05right?5:05And we think they were really beautiful,5:08and Chazal tell us they are really beautiful.5:10But the Gra is coming to tell us that's not only beautiful.5:13The Torah is not interested in telling you about their physical appearance5:17when you don't even know what they look like.5:19There's no picture of them,5:20and even if there was, who cares?5:22But he's telling you, when it says in5:25Yeshayahu, שיר השירים, מגילת אסתר, that there's5:27יפת מראה, right,5:28about Esther,5:29כי יפת מראה היא, שיר השירים, when he keeps on talking about that she's so beautiful,5:34יפת רעייתי, right?5:36That means that you have good5:39midot. Ah, however, just having good midot is also not good enough.5:43So the pasuk says,5:44Ishayah, talking about a person with good5:47midot. It's talking about any person that has good5:50midot, but still,5:53Haikar hu hamaaseh. The main thing is not the5:56midot. Even though midot will help you,5:58we spoke a lot about midot will help you,6:01but midot will only help you.6:02Midot is a step.6:03It's a tool.6:04So you have the best tools,6:06but you don't use it to fix the house.6:10So what benefit did you get from the6:12tools? We gain nothing from the tools,6:15right? So he says,6:18Haikar hu hamaaseh, ve'elo shosha: Torah,6:19mitzvot, umidot, hem6:23tov, arev, umo'il, kemo shekatuv bYeshayah. And these three things:6:25your learning of the Torah6:27and believing the truth of the Torah,6:31not just the Torah6:33shebichtav, but all what Chazal tell us,6:35living our lives based on the way Chazal tell us;6:38mitzvot, keeping, or the commands of the Torah,6:42like the way it's dictated to us in the Shulchan Aruch6:45and all the books of6:47halacha; and good6:48midot are the three terminologies we're going to see right now6:51in the pasuk in Yeshayah,6:52which are tov, which means good;6:55arev means pleasant,6:57or tasteful, or pleasurable;7:00and mo'il, beneficial.7:02Look at the pasuk in Yeshayah,7:04famous pasuk.7:07Says Yeshayah,7:09Woe to the people who say about what's evil,7:11they call it good,7:12and on what's good, they call it evil.7:14Samim7:17choshech la'or ve'or lachoshech. They make the light into darkness7:21and the darkness into light.7:22Samim mar lamatok7:24umatok lamar.7:26They make what's bitter sweet7:27and what's sweet bitter.7:30Ki hamitzvot hen tov. The mitzvot are7:33tov, as it says in the pasuk,7:34Im ru tzaddik7:36ki tov, umatok, and what's sweet,7:42hu neged hamidot shemetiku deMalka. Sweet represents over here7:43the good7:45middot. As we know,7:46a person who has good7:48middot, he's sweet, he's pleasant,7:49he's enjoyable,7:50and that's the word of7:54arev, hu neged ahavah v'arev. And or represents the Torah,7:56kemo shekatuv, v'Torah or, and that's—8:00That's mo'ilah, as we all know. Light is what you benefit from.8:04Something that's pleasurable, something that's good.8:07You don't necessarily benefit from it; you enjoy maybe looking at it,8:09but to benefit really from it is you benefit from the light.8:12And now,8:16he says, Now we come back and bring everything together.8:19When a person really does the right things,8:23that means he acts the way he's supposed to8:25act, he keeps the mitzvot, he is tov as8:32hu ishayafa, u'mate et hataam hakol letov. Then she's an8:34ishayafa. Then all the taam, the8:36taam rashei teivot tov, mo'il and arev,8:39right? And now everything is good.8:43Everything is good, everything is wonderful.8:45When you do everything else, now ishayafa, you have good middot8:48and you have good8:51taam, tov, arev, and8:53mo'il, those three things, which are middot, Torah,8:58mitzvot. But when a person's actions are bad,9:03אז הוא מהפך גם המידות לטוב לרע. Then even the little bit of middot that you have,9:06right, or the little Torah that you have, it all becomes evil,9:10right? Because you're pleasant and you're nice, but it means nothing.9:15You know, it's like the basic things,9:18and that's what Adam was criticized on,9:20is that he was9:22kofer b'tov, a basic thing. You know, everybody should be grateful.9:25You do something good for somebody.9:27Imagine somebody, he raises his son.9:29He works so hard for him.9:31He pays so much money.9:32He spends time. He invests in his son,9:35and they're always talking everything else,9:37and the son gets into business,9:39and he knocks his father out of business,9:42opens up a store right across the9:44street to make sure his father's out of business9:46because he wants all his customers.9:50What is hakarat hatov? What is hakarat hatov? His father's a ani, it's good,9:52no competition now,9:53right? That's crazy thing, no?9:55So, and that hakarat hatov is really,9:59when we keep mitzvot, it's out of10:02hakarat hatov. Is that what?10:03Hashem gave us life.10:05Hashem gives us everything.10:07At least we could do is keep what He wants.10:10Forget about everything else,10:11that way we should keep10:12mitzvot. At least the basics.10:13He says when you don't have that,10:15then all your good middot are nothing.10:17You be nice to everybody else,10:18but you're not nice to your Creator.10:20Where are you, right?10:20It's like that guy knocking his father out of business.10:22Would you say he has good10:23middot? He's nice to everybody.10:24He gives tremendous10:26tzedakah, right?10:27He's a guy, you're gonna call him good10:32middot? V'zehu ishayfa v'saratam. This is what it means over here:10:36Nezem zahav b'af chazir, ishah yafah v'saratam. When you put a gold nose ring on a pig,10:39no, right?10:40The nose ring is beautiful,10:41but it's a pig at the end of the day.10:44He says the same thing over here.10:45Ishah yafah, a guy who has good10:47middot, v'saratam. He takes the taam, which are tov,10:50representing the good10:52middot, the ayin, the arev,10:55representing the,10:59what's somebody, the, what's it called, the mitzvot, and the11:00mo'il, the mem, which represents11:01mo'il, which is the Torah,11:03and11:03sarah. He makes them all go off the11:06di. You know,11:07saratam means he turns them all11:09lera. And that's why the pasuk says, V'omrim la-tov ra.