Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 5, Lesson 6Sefer Even ShelemaPart 89Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:23Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:03Perek hei, ot hei, in0:08the Even Shlema. Yirat ha'ones mevi'ah lidei chokhmah.0:11Unbelievable statement, no?0:12People who are scared of punishment,0:15even if you do things because you're scared of punishment,0:18it will eventually lead you to wisdom.0:20Vachokhmah, but now that you gain this level of wisdom, understanding of Torah,0:27mevi'ah lidei yirat haromemut, will lead you to a higher level of0:29yirah, and that is0:32yirat haromemut. What does it mean,0:34yirat ha'ones, yirat haromemut? I would like to take a little bit of time out for a second0:38just to clarify these terminologies.0:40The Beit HaLevi, not our shul, but the Beit0:46HaLevi, Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, the father of the Brisker Rav,0:50and he says that there are three levels of0:54yirah. We find fear, fear, fear.0:55We talk about yirat Hashem, yirat shamayim, right?0:59Fear. We always translate it as fear in English.1:01Really, personally, I don't like that translation1:03because I don't believe it really defines what it is.1:07Fear is not only what it is.1:08Yes, by definition, yirah is fear,1:10but he explained there are three levels of1:13yirah. There's something called the lowest level.1:14We can go from the lowest to the highest level.1:16There's something called1:20yirat ha'onesh. There's something called1:24yirat hachet, and the third level is called1:27yirat haromemut, which is really what yirat shamayim really is all about.1:31Let's define what they are.1:33Yirat ha'onesh is kipshuto. You're scared of punishment.1:36Why don't you eat1:37treif? I'm scared of1:39Gehinom. I'm scared my mazal is going to go down.1:41I'm scared I'm not going to be successful in my marriage,1:45or I'm working on a dayah. If I eat this thing that's1:48treif, Hashem is going to punish me.1:49I'm going to get zapped, basically, right?1:52The flip side of yirat ha'onesh is1:54I'm doing a mitzvah because I want reward in this world.2:00I want reward in2:02Olam Haba. It's the same idea.2:03It's a very low level.2:04Baruch Hashem, you're still doing it, right?2:06Nobody should think that that's a low level,2:08oh, it's not good.2:09As one person told me,2:10one rabbi in Kollel told me,2:11he says2:12the proof that, you know,2:14halavai we should get to that level,2:15because the fact that we do do2:18aveirot means we're not even on that level, right?2:20We're not even scared of the onesh.2:21So that is2:23yirat ha'onesh. That's the lowest level.2:25But again, it's a great level.2:26You keep the mitzvot at the end.2:27The next level above that is something called2:30yirat hachet. I'm not scared of the punishment,2:33but I'm scared of that the sin is gonna break,2:36ruin the relationship between me and2:39HaKadosh Baruch Hu. So I like to always compare it to a husband and wife relationship.2:44A person has a good shalom bayit2:45and he gets along with his wife wonderfully,2:48and he's away in China on a trip,2:50and all of a sudden he's, you know,2:53offered a certain temptation that nobody will know.2:58Nobody in the world will know.3:00Nobody in the world will know.3:01Yeah, he could do something.3:02It's a different country, different world,3:03and nobody will know.3:05But still, he knows that it will affect his relationship with his wife.3:08He can't look at his kids the same way.3:10He can't look at his wife the same way.3:11So that's called3:13yatza chet. I'm scared to do this3:15aveirah. I don't care about the punishment so much.3:16I'm not gonna get punished for it.3:18Of course Hashem knows, but I'm not gonna get punished.3:20But how can I come and open up a siddur after I went3:25and I'm eating taref,3:26and I'm using the same mouth?3:30Peh she'achal neveilot u'treifot is gonna be the same mouth that's gonna say,3:32'Elokai, sefatai3:35tiftach, ufi yagid tehilatecha.' So it's not about punishment.3:37Again, it's not that I'm scared my prayer will not get answered,3:40but how3:42can I—I've maintained such a good relationship with Hashem,3:44and that could be, you know, a lot of people could have that.3:47Again, I was saying that it's not all or nothing.3:50It could be on many levels, right,3:52from many different areas.3:53So a person, let's say, has worked very hard on his kashrut.3:58Somebody tells him, 'Come eat something that's not according to your kosher level,'4:01or it's not, you know. But all these years I've been keeping this level of kashrut.4:05I'm not gonna go down now.4:08Why? I'm gonna get punished?4:09Not be punished,4:11because I've developed a certain relationship.4:13And then there's4:15yirat haromemut, and that's what we said. Yirat shamayim, that's the highest level.4:17What's4:18yirat haromemut? I love the way one of my rabbis explained it.4:20It was beautiful,4:21and he says like this.4:23Imagine you find yourself, you get on the plane, you're taking a plane by yourself.4:27You get on an airplane,4:29and there's an empty seat next to you,4:32and, you know, nobody's sitting in it yet.4:33And all of a sudden, you know, they say,4:35Okay, sorry, the last passenger is getting on.4:37The last passenger gets on, and he sits right next to you.4:40I don't care if you're in first class or in a more sophisticated seat in the4:44coach, whatever it is, but that person gets on.4:47You look, you can't believe your eyes.4:49This is a person that you truly, truly admire.4:52You really look up to,4:54like, and for a long time been following him.4:56Today you could say that without actually getting arrested for it, right?5:00You've been following him on Twitter, whatever it is.5:02This is a person that you truly, truly admire.5:04It could be you're in first class and, you know, you happen to got a great ticket,5:08and right next to you is this guy.5:11And not a person that you, that's famous necessarily,5:15because people, yeah, do see famous people and they're like,5:17you know, but you really admire this person. You look up to him.5:21How would you approach him? How would you speak to him?5:23You'd probably get nervous. Most people probably get nervous,5:25like, I don't want to sound, like, silly and, like, you know, stupid.5:28Now, for me talking, I don't know, a lot of people have different people in their heads, right?5:31For me talking, I would say somebody like a gadol, right?5:36Imagine I'm on an airplane and hacham Ovadia gets on and he sits right next to you.5:42Start talking to him and learning, you sound like an am haaretz. I really don't know, right?5:45But somebody that you really, really admire, somebody that you really look up to, right?5:48Imagine I had a seat next to5:50Benny. Now I saw a sign in one of the elevators in school.5:54It says, If you would get stuck in an elevator with someone, who would that someone be?5:57Who would you want that someone to be? It's an interesting question, right?6:00But sometimes if someone is so great, you get nervous, you don't know what to say.6:03So in any case, this is your6:07yirat haromemut. You understand what Hashem is all about.6:10You can never really, really understand Hashem.6:12If you really, really understand Hashem, you can't really open your mouth.6:16If you really have—if you really know that you're talking to Hashem,6:18it's very, very, very hard to open your mouth and really talk.6:21That's why we have to ask Him, Hashem, sefatai tiftach, open my mouth,6:25because it's really—that's a highest level. That's called6:28yirah. So let's come back now to the6:30emes shelema, summarizing the words of the Gra. You can appreciate it a little bit more.6:32What does it say? It says,6:36Yirat ha'ones meviah lidei chochmah. Fear of just the punishment—I'm not doing aveirah because I'm scared of6:40punishment—will lead you to wisdom.6:42And the wisdom will lead you to6:45yirat haromemut, which is even the highest level of6:48yirah. Let's see the source in the words of the6:51Gra from Mishlei, perek tet-vav, pasuk6:55lamed-gimmel: Yirat Hashem musar chochmah, velifnei kavod anavah.6:59The yirat Hashem is musar7:01chochmah, and in front of kavod is humility.7:05Says the Gra, Kemo shekatuv, Im ein7:09chochmah, ein yirah. Famous7:10Mishnah, Pirkei Avot: If there's no wisdom, there's no fear.7:14Ve'im ein7:17yirah, ein chochmah. And the same Mishnah, literally the next line says,7:20And if there's no fear, there is no wisdom.7:24So what does that mean?7:26Yirat ha'ones, she says, miviah lidei chochmah. Yirat ha'ones will bring a person to wisdom,7:29right?7:30As the famous words of the Mishnah says,7:35Kol sheyirato kodemet lechochmato, chochmato mitkayemet. If you have yirat Shamayim before you learn,7:39right,7:40your Torah mitkayemet. We pointed this out many, many times when we learn7:43and we become—especially come to7:44halachot—and sometimes I go on a whole monologue,7:47and this has been off the record,7:49but now will be a little bit on record, right?7:51And it's something that really, really aggravates me a lot,7:54is that a person can be knowledgeable in wisdom of7:58Torah, in chochmah...8:01Halacha, a lot of things, but if there's no yirat shamayim, you end up being matir all different kinds of8:07issurim, right? As there was—this is one, it was not a case that brought up to me, but there was once a person that had a question:8:12could a person see his wife nidah in a bathing suit,8:17right? So that was the question that was, you know, I was brought up to certain types of rabbis,8:22all telling him different heterim and derech, not derech.8:27It's a big sugya. I'm not coming to answer anything here right now.8:29He went to a person who—he went to another rabbi that had8:33yirat shamayim, and I know this person personally.8:35This rabbi person, I know he really has—he's a real person, he has real8:39yirat shamayim, right? So much so that I know that he doesn't drink tea on Shabbat anymore.8:43Why? Because one time, by accident, he put a tea bag in the first cup, not in the second cup.8:48Ever since then, he says, I don't want to get into that,8:49and he stayed away from it.8:51And he's not a guy who doesn't know halacha. He knows his halacha well, he knows everything,8:54but that's called yirat shamayim, right?8:56A little bit of yirat shamayim. So this question was—this person came and asked him this question.9:02So he obviously wanted to know, why would he want to know the halacha?9:06So, yeah, we're going on vacation. Wife is going to go, you know, on the beach.9:09The question is, is it okay for me to look at her or not?9:11He says, Could you think about what you're asking for a second?9:14You want to know, right? This is what's bothering you, right?9:18Your wife's going to be undressed in front of everybody. That's okay.9:21You're wondering, yachol nidah, can I look at her, right? What's going on over here?9:26And the other rabbi is like, How come they're not bothered saying this,9:31right? With yirat shamayim, like, you can't look. Is the lung kosher or not kosher, rabbi?9:35But you're talking about a lung of a pig.9:38What are you doing? What are we dealing with?9:43Koshi d'ato kodemet lechochmato. It's a9:46mefurash Chazal. Chochmato mitkayemet, because really it looks very silly.9:50What are you, you know, and I'm saying this as a very quick thing, but there's a famous story about a lady, a girl who was very, very sick.9:55She was in sakana, and she wouldn't eat.10:00You know, a doctor prescribed her, in olden days, 200 years ago,10:02a doctor prescribed her that she has to eat pig.10:04She wouldn't eat it. I don't care. She said, You're going to die.10:07You need to eat this pig. It has a certain thing that it's going to heal you.10:09She wouldn't eat it.10:11Finally, the rabbi spoke to her; it didn't work.10:13Finally, a big rebbe came to town, and he came to the girl10:17and he convinced her that you have to eat it because sakana,10:19and you're not doing a mitzvah by not eating it;10:20you're doing a big10:21aveirah. She finally said, Okay, I'll eat it, but on condition:10:23I need the shochet to do shechitah on the pig.10:25He says, Okay, fine.10:27The rabbi left the town.10:28They bring the shochet, they bring the pig.10:30Okay, he does shechitah on the pig.10:32Okay, good, you happy? He says, No.10:33Do check his lungs.10:35Okay, the shochet puts his hand in his lungs;10:37he feels something. He feels something weird,10:39you know. He's not sure it's treifah, not10:41treifah. They bring it to the rabbi of the city,10:43big talmid chacham. He says, Listen, I don't know what to tell you. You10:46know, I'm feeling it.10:47If it was a cow, okay, but this is a pig.10:49What do you want me to say,10:50kosher on the pig?10:51What do you want me to do?10:52I'm dealing with a pig at the end of the day,10:54right? A lot of times questions are like that.10:56And when the rabbi is sitting there making lomdus about the pig,11:00if it's kosher, the lung is11:02kosher, just forget the pig, rabbi.11:03Talk about the lungs.11:05It sounds very11:06foolish. Yir'at leads to11:08chochmah. Im ein yir'ah, kodemet11:12lachochmah, chochmah lo mitkayemet, because if you think about it, it sounds very foolish,11:15you know. And I'm sure, you know, people who are, like,11:19they're trying to be very machmir in certain areas,11:21and meanwhile they're doing all different types of11:23aveirot, they look like fools in front of goyim.11:25Goyim say, You consider a religious man and you're doing this?11:28No, no, no, no, no.11:29This is, this shitah. You look like a fool,11:32because there's no11:34yir'at Shamayim. Yir'ato kodemet11:36lechochmah, chochmah lo mitkayemet. So you've got to look at the whole picture together,11:38and that's what the Gra is saying over here:11:42chochmah mi'al yedei yir'ah to nimtza, right?11:43If you have yir'ah... You understand chokhmah in the right way.11:46When you understand chokhmah in the right way,11:47you come to real11:50yirat, which is what we've been saying till now,11:51that all these things are given to you as a gift.11:57V'zehu yirat shemusar. Zehu yirat ha'onesh, v'lo yirat dechokhmah. This is the meaning of11:58pasuk. Go back to the pasuk now.11:59Yirat Hashem is12:01musar. We know musar is strict and things and punishment.12:04That's what it means.12:05When you have12:07yirat ha'onesh, that level, it leads you to chokhmah12:10lifnei anavah. And before you get to12:12anavah, what does that mean?12:13Ki12:14yirat haremumut hi anavah. Hayesod is really12:16anavah. When you really understand what Hashem is,12:18you become very humble12:19because you understand,12:21whoa, what an honor,12:22what a privilege I'm standing here.12:24You know, the rich guy always thinks,12:26so big, I'm so big.12:27All of a sudden he's given a tour12:29to one of those princes in Saudi Arabia12:31where they have literally warehouses of gold12:36and jewelry hanging from the ceilings12:38and everywhere else,12:39literally boxes and boxes of gold.12:41He realizes he's nobody.12:43We think we're so great,12:44we stay. When we truly understand who Hashem is,12:46we become humble12:48automatically. We realize who Hashem is12:49and who we are in comparison to Him.12:50That's what12:55he says.12:56Okay, skip all that.13:04It says, again, he repeats the same thing,13:06proving it from a different point,13:07but we got the point in,13:10and that's what we wanted to emphasize.13:12You work with what you could accomplish13:14in your own level,13:15and then you build yourself up13:16and higher and higher and higher.