Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 5, Lesson 4Sefer Even ShelemaPart 87Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:33Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Even shelema perek hei, ot0:03gimmel. I just want to mention something about ot0:06beit. Yesterday we did it in the0:09Even Shelema, and he says in the Even Shelema that a person who does mitzvot,0:12even if he does a lot of mitzvot,0:14but he's—it's not based or founded on Torah and0:18yirat shamayim, Hashem says, What do I need0:21... However, the source that he brought,0:22when we read it inside from the0:25Gra, was very, very difficult to see the connection.0:27And in fact, it's not only that;0:29even the son of the0:31Even Shelema, he himself also asked the same question:0:33I don't see the source in the0:35Gra. Now, if everything is coming from the0:37Gra, so we still don't have a source for such a concept,0:39and therefore it's good to see0:42that something—you know, this is the importance.0:43We learned at least another lesson today.0:45It's always good to see the idea in their sources.0:49That means if we're saying that this is what the Gra says,0:52let's open up the0:53Gra. We open up the Gra and we saw0:54he didn't say such a0:55thing. He did say that people will learn Torah0:57not for the right reason,1:00how it can be problematic,1:01and Hashem says, I don't want that type of Torah.1:03But a person who does mitzvot1:05but it's not based on Torah,1:06I don't see how he understood it from there.1:08We could squeeze it,1:09but it's really very difficult1:10to say that that's really what the Gra meant.1:13So I just wanted to point that out,1:15and also take out a lesson from it1:17of the importance of looking things in the sources.1:22In ot gimmel today,1:24we move on to a new concept.1:26It's again, it's all the same category,1:28but it's a new piece.1:30He says,1:34Torah u'mitzvot yesh b'yad ha'adam lehasigan. Torah and mitzvot, a person has the ability to fulfill them,1:38to either understand the Torah1:39or to keep the mitzvot.1:44However, true inner fear and love of Hashem1:47is not fully in the hands of a person.1:52V'hu matat Elokim. It's a present from Hashem.1:55So if it's a present from Hashem,1:56how are we1:58commanded, V'ahavta et Hashem Elokecha? How are we2:01commanded, Et Hashem Elokecha tira, and how are we expected to do everything?2:03And not only that,2:04it seems to contradict the famous2:06Chazal. Chazal tell us,2:10Hakol bidei shamayim chutz miyirat shamayim. Ela, what it means is as follows:2:12K'she'adam oseh et shelo—well, you have to do what you have to do.2:15You have to put in as much as you can,2:17your effort,2:17as Hashem2:20lo yimna hatov l'holchim b'tamim. will give it to you.2:22So it's kind of like the—2:24so basically,2:25we could understand and now clear2:26what he means to say is that2:30the attainment2:31or accomplishment2:32or reaching that level of2:34yirat, true2:36yirat, ahavah, is there's no such a thing as2:38reaching it on your own.2:39You could put the effort2:41and then it will come to you.2:42It's kind of like parnassah.2:43Many people think that they earn money.2:45Chazal tell us clearly,2:46we don't earn money;2:47Hashem gives it.2:48The clearest proof is that2:52if, you know,2:53we said beforehand,2:54if something can be copied,2:55then it's not luck,2:57right?2:57If there's a system,2:58if I— if I could,3:00what's it called,3:00if I know how to—3:02if I'm successful,3:03I should be able to create a certain system3:05that will always be successful.3:07But you see,3:07sometimes people do follow a system3:09and they're not successful,3:10so it's not the system;3:11it's rather3:12HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Now there's a certain minimum.3:14We all agree there's a certain minimum.3:15For example,3:16farming.3:17There's a system3:18that you have to put the seeds in the ground3:20and then it'll grow.3:21And so too in business also,3:22there's a minimum of3:23you put in a certain effort3:25or you open up your store3:26and you sell certain merchandise3:27and you could grow.3:29But the higher success,3:31I guess,3:32if you call the millionaires3:33or the people who are very successful,3:35that really comes—3:36it's matat Hashem.3:37It's really a present from3:38HaKadosh Baruch Hu. And sometimes even poverty3:40is something that's given from Hashem,3:42or Hashem makes somebody who's poor,3:46where, you know,3:47even they do the regular system3:48and it's supposed to work,3:49it doesn't come to them.3:51And kind of like3:52what he's saying, basically3:53the Gra is over here saying the same thing3:55when it comes to the3:57yirah and3:59ahavah. Let's see the words of the4:02Gra, and as you see in our book,4:03whenever the words turn into this font,4:06it means we're bringing something very, very deep,4:09and it's not4:11pashut pshat. It's kind of like a deeper thing that the4:12Gra is. We know4:13the Gra wrote on everything,4:16and his ideas were also on many, many levels.4:19Some were al pi pshat,4:20as we saw a lot of them,4:22and some were on4:23drash, and a lot of it was also al pi sod,4:26based on Kabbalah.4:27This seems to be something with the last category,4:30on sod, al pi sod.4:31He explains like this.4:33The pasuk says,4:35Bayit vahon4:39nachalat avot. U'meHashem ishah maskelet. Famous, famous4:41pasuk. House and wealth4:43is something that's inherited from the fathers,4:47but from Hashem,4:48a person has an4:51ishah, a wife4:52that's4:53maskelet, that's clever4:54or basically,4:55you know,4:57has taskil or successful.4:59And this simple pshat needs,5:01you know, also explanation,5:02which means we could spend a lot of time on it5:05and get musar5:06and whatever.5:07But even,5:09but that's not our time right now.5:10That's not our, you know, what he's coming to do.5:12He's going to come and explain it5:13on a deeper level of what it means over here.5:16Ve'inyan, comes the Gra and says,5:18bayit. What's the idea of here in the5:19pasuk when it talks about5:20bayit? What is it referring to,5:21the bayit over here?5:22Hu5:25mitzvot aseh u'mitzvot lo ta'aseh. Bayit represents the5:27mitzvot that we have to do,5:28what we call the positive commandments,5:31the ones that we have to fulfill,5:33and the5:35mitzvot lo ta'aseh are mitzvot that we have to stay away from,5:36what God commanded us to stay away from.5:39Kemo shekatuv, why is that called bayit?5:42The pasuk says in Mishlei somewhere else,5:44Bechochmah yibaneh bayit,5:47u'vitvunah yikonen, as a famous song is right now, right?5:49Bechochmah yibaneh bayit.5:52Okay, bechochmah yibaneh bayit.5:53With wisdom,5:55a house is built,5:56right?5:57What's that wisdom?5:59What does it mean?5:59The chochmah haTorah,6:00that's how you build your house.6:01When you,6:02as the famous words of6:04Pirkei Avot, Ein am haaretz6:07chasid, ve'lo bur6:09yerei chet, right?6:09You can't be— Chasid v'yam haaretz.6:13And if you are a bur,6:15means a person who is empty of Torah,6:17you can't be fearful of sin.6:18You don't know which sin to stay away from.6:20So the guy says,6:22Yirei Shamayim. Yirei Shamayim, you don't know what Shamayim is.6:23You don't know anything about Torah,6:24Hashem commanded.6:26How could you be6:27yirei Shamayim? So, b'chochmah, with the wisdom of Torah,6:29yibaneh bayit.6:30What6:30do you mean, a house?6:31No.6:31It means6:33you build your spiritual house.6:34You build your bayit6:36in Olam Haba by the wisdom of Torah,6:37because you keep the6:39mitzvot aseh and you stay away from the6:41mitzvot lo ta'aseh. So that's what bayit represents6:42in this pasuk.6:43Bayit represents6:44mitzvot. We proved it.6:45Next,6:46hon. Hon is wealth.6:47What does hon represent?6:49What wealth are we talking about?6:50Hu Torah.6:51This is the wealth of Torah,6:52as the pasuk says,6:56Uvda'at chadarim yimale'u kol hon6:58yakar vena'im. And with the knowledge of the rooms,7:00you fill up all wealth.7:02What knowledge7:03do you fill all the rooms?7:04What wealth is filled up in these rooms?7:07That's the wealth of Torah.7:09As we know,7:10people are ashirim in monetary things;7:11we know what they have.7:12And there are people who are ashirim in Torah.7:14Ooh, what they have.7:15Some are ashirim in Mikra,7:17and some are very wealthy in7:19Mishnayot, some are very wealthy in Shas,7:21some are wealthy in7:23Halacha, and some are wealthy in Musar,7:27and there's no end.7:28Some are wealthy in Sod.7:30V'zeh shene'emar. Now we come back,7:32we plug everything together.7:35Bayit v'hon nachalat avot, u'me'Hashem ish. What does that mean?7:40K'lomar, sheya'aseh ma'asim tovim al yedei sechel, v'hu sheya'asim al yado b'chol derechav. A person7:41who's going to do his good deeds7:43has to be7:44al yedei sechel, has to be done with intellect,7:47and he should always7:49put—you know,7:50he should always be on top of it.7:51He should not be a robot just doing things.7:53He's always got to be thinking7:55and, like we mentioned in the past,7:56to always look to improve. V'zeh shene'emar.8:02And there's another famous pasuk: In all your ways you must know God. What does that mean?8:07Da'ehu means da lechaber hei u-vav. The word da'ehu is split up into two: da, hei, and vav.8:16You should know the hei and the vav.8:20Oof, hei and vav, we're getting a little bit Kabbalistic, so let me just pause for a second to clarify what it means over here.8:26Da, the word da'at means connection. Where do we see that from?8:32The pasuk tells us by Adam and Chava, Parashat8:35Bereishit, Vayeda Adam et Chava, and they had a son.8:39What does it mean, he knew his wife? Everybody knows his wife, or at least he thinks he knows his wife,8:45right? Okay, so the answer is the Torah is talking in lashon8:47nekiyah. It's telling us about a chibur, a connection, a connection between a husband and wife which produced a child.8:57But the Torah is talking in lashon8:59nekiyah. Why does it use the word vayeda, vayishkav, or whatever?9:02Because the word da'at is complete connection. Adam and Chava had unbelievable connection because they were the first two people in the world.9:09Da'at means to connect. Da'ehu means to connect, but connect what? The hei and vav.9:15Hei and vav represent different things.9:18Hei represents Torah. As you know, the Torah ends with the hei;9:22it's mitzvah. Hei represents, we said, things of9:26Olam Hazeh. The Torah guides us in9:28Olam Hazeh, and vav represents9:31neshama. Those are two letters of HaKadosh Baruch Hu,9:33right? And the vav is a hook.9:35You ever see the letter vav, how it's spelled in the Torah, how it's written in the Torah?9:39If you step back a bit, look how it looks like a hook,9:42especially if you put it on the side, right?9:44And in fact, the word vav itself, the letter vav, there's also a word called9:51vav. Vavei ha'amudim, Parashat Terumah, talks about the hooks. Of the amudim,9:56right? And we know that the letter vav itself connects two words together.10:01For example, if I want to say me and Abraham, so I say ani10:08ve'Abraham. The letter vav, again, connects.10:10So the vav in the letter of Hashem's name represents connection.10:16So vav, he says over here, represents10:19the shema, because that's what connects me to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:22When I'm learning the Torah, with the vav, how am I connecting with the vav?10:27It means I'm doing it lishma, right? That's10:31da'ehu. That's how I make my connection with HaKadosh Baruch Hu,10:35and I can understand the10:35Gemara. But the Torah says, Kudsha Berich Hu v'Orayta v'Yisrael chad hu. Hashem, the Torah, and the Jewish people are one.10:41We are connected to Hashem through the Torah.10:45Okay, now that's10:51da'ehu. Ratzon lomar, כמו שכתוב, השכל וידוע אותי. ואמרו, הרוצה להחכים ידרים. What does it mean also?10:54Ratzon lomar שיעשה לשמה. What it means over here is that when you're learning your Torah,10:57when you're doing anything, do11:01it l'shem Shamayim. דעבד חסד קונו ואז יחכים. And that's the chesed you can do with Hashem.11:02It doesn't mean that Hashem needs our chesed.11:04It means there's nothing that we can really11:08do—or, there's nothing, in better words, there's nothing that we can really give Hashem11:12except for our trust and our ability to do the mitzvot of HaKadosh Baruch Hu,11:18because that's where Hashem doesn't, כביכול, have control over us, right?11:21He can command us, and He can reward us and punish us11:24for our ability to be able to do it without Him forcing us.11:29Otherwise, He can force us to do anything.11:31Otherwise, we can't get any reward, I mean.11:34So that's the chesed that you do with HaKadosh Baruch Hu means11:37the mitzvot that we do, if we do it in this concept,11:40l'shem Shamayim, ואז יחכים, the Torah says,11:44right? Then you be machkim, as Rabbi Meir tells us,11:46כל העוסק בתורה לשמה, right?11:49What happens when you are osek b'Torah l'shem Shamayim again,11:52where you connect to HaKadosh Baruch Hu?11:53It brings a lot of things.11:55One of them is,11:57נעשה כמעיין מתגבר. You become just greater and greater and11:59greater. What does it mean you become greater?12:04ונגד נון רש נר של אדם, the neshama of Adam.12:07But דרגא שישית, מה השם ישמש. Now this is on the first level.12:09So that's12:12Bayit v'Hon, נחלת אבות. The house, which is the Torah, keeping the mitzvot;12:15the hon, which is the Torah.12:17When we do them with the proper12:19kavanah for l'shem shamayim,12:20that's something that we can make for ourselves12:22that could be an inheritance.12:24But the pasuk continues, it says12:25there's a third thing over here,12:28ish ha-maskil. We have to see what this ish ha-maskil represents,12:32and it says over here that comes from Hashem.12:35So he says over here,12:37... ish ha-maskil, ze12:39ein b'yad ha-adam. Klal says from Hashem.12:41This is a fifth level.12:42It's not in your hands.12:43It's from Hashem.12:44And the idea is,12:47v'derech chayim tochachot musar. What we were talking about till now,12:48that third aspect,12:50we said that there is what?12:52There's ner Hashem nishmat adam,12:55chofeis kol chadrei vaten. No, excuse me.12:57Ki ner mitzvah v'Torah or.13:00There's a mitzvah,13:01which is represented by a ner,13:02and the or, which represents13:04Torah, and then we said13:06v'derech chayim tochachot musar. And there's a third level, which is13:08musar, and that's the ish ha-maskil over here.13:10That musar, that13:13derech chayim, is the fear and the love of HaKadosh Baruch Hu13:15that's13:17penimi. What does it mean,13:18penimi? It means the deeper one,13:20the connection through fear and love,13:22the internal one,13:23not the one that we inspire ourselves to keep,13:28that, you know, we inspire ourselves to be fearful13:30to love HaKadosh Baruch Hu.13:31That's external.13:32The one that's deeper,13:34meHashem. That comes from matat13:35Elokim. That comes from HaKadosh Baruch Hu.13:37But so the question is,13:38if it comes from Hashem,13:39so should I just wait till Hashem gives it to me?13:40And the answer is no.13:43When you do your bit and hon,13:45when you work on keeping the mitzvot13:47and you work on your13:48Torah, then HaKadosh Baruch Hu will give you the rest,13:51as it says in the pasuk,13:53v'Hu yasher orchotecha. You have to do your hishtadlut,13:55your effort.13:56Put in as much as you can13:58to keep the Torah and mitzvot l'shem shamayim,14:00and then you'll be14:02blessed with that true yirah and14:05ahavah. It's an unbelievable idea,14:07is that people sometimes may feel like,14:09Ah, how can I attain such high levels?14:11And the answer is,14:13you work in the way you could work.14:16You put your effort where you could put your effort,14:18and that is in keeping the mitzvot,14:20learning14:22Torah, and both of them doing it l'shem shamayim,14:24and you'll see eventually it'll come.14:27See, when it comes to other areas14:29where we can measure success,14:31let's say,14:32l'mashal, the guy is working on keeping kashrut on a high standard,14:35but right now he's eating14:36taref. So over there you can measure success by seeing,14:39did I get to that level of being14:41machmir on every chumrah in14:44Yoreh Deah, in Shulchan Aruch?14:45Am I keeping every stringency in the14:47book? And I can see, I have a checklist.14:50I'm keeping this14:50chumrah, I'm keeping that14:51chumrah, you know, some of the more common ones that people say,14:53you know,14:55kemach yashan and chalav Yisrael,14:56and of course then there's14:58bishul akum on a highest level.14:59There's levels and levels.15:01You can measure it,15:02right?15:02And you can see, I'm holding,15:03I'm not holding,15:04you know, and you can see I'm getting there,15:06I'm getting closer and closer.15:08When it comes to15:10yirat and ahavah, you may not see it right away,15:12and you may say,15:13hey, when is this going to come ever?15:15And I'm not seeing anything.15:16The answer is because it's matanah kadosh baruch hu.15:19You keep on working,15:19you'll see it'll just come in eventually.15:21But you have to do your effort15:23in the other areas where you could measure.15:25We'll stop over here,15:27be'ezrat Hashem, and move on to dalet next week.